Pay for garbage collectors

For the record, many of the guys that get in as garbage collectors (or to work for the City in general) do so through influence. In other words, they're related to the bigwigs at City Hall more often than not!!!

I wonder if the media is in cohouts with with the City. I often also wonder whether the Union is in cohouts with the City Hall bigwigs… in any event, these jobs are all very well paying but there’s no equal opportunity… the blatant nepotism is simply overlooked and never exposed.

My ex-gf worked for the City in a mgmt position and left for greener pastures (and also because she wanted more of a challenge)… the things she told me were absolutely mind-boggling and atrocious for a progressive City like Toronto with respect to their recruitment and selection of staff!
 
It doesn't matter if the contractor is unionized or not, providing the city gets a couple of key conditions put into the contract agreement:

1. If the contractor is unable to provide services, say because of a strike, the city is entitled to turn to a different contractor to provide the service

I agree the problem is that there are not the number of big players to not have a monopoly since an investment in equipment etc. is large and a barrier for entry for many.

2. To submit a bid a contractor must show that it has reached an agreement with its union that covers the duration of the contract with the city

The problem is that that contract can go on for years past what the contract is for their employees. City of Mississauge had this happen. Also think of the power you put in the union hands when they know the company has to resolve the contract to get the bid.

That is essentially what Etobicoke does with its contractor, who is unionized. The city does not have to worry about a strike because the labour agreement between the contractor and its union covers the life of the deal.

What doesn't happen is over site on excessive charges, yes this is a city problem but then you need to hire staff to oversee the private contractor. There was claims going private would save Etobicoke 10 million dollars however when I asked them to validate this and asked where the 10 million dollars of savings went they never wanted to return my calls or emails. I contacted the local counsellor who avoided my direct questions on this. If you are claiming a savings great but don't BS me wa are going to save money but can't back up those claims. I wanted to see the claimed 10 million returned to the taxpayers but they couldn't even show there was a savings at all. I didn't want the propoganda I wanted to see what we saved, it appears we didn't.

By the time that contract expires the city will have received new bids from the same or other contractors, also demonstrating that they have an agreement with their unions.

Moreover though this is about competition--unions are fine, when they are not a monopoly. When the union has to compete with other unions or other companies its generally becomes more competitive, wages come down, and workers become more productive (less lazy).

Yes and the current mix of city garbage collectors and private collectors is exactly competition since the private contractor has to keep in line with city collectors rates or better them. I don't have a problem going private but not a private monopoly. Not much competition for companies to invest millions of dollars in equipment for a 5 year contract unless the returns are rewarding enough. So the barrier to entry for larger competition is the large upfront investment. Also as we have seen with "competition" in the gas prices they all keep in line without dramatic savings.

Nothing wrong with union workers so long as they feel a little fire under their asses to get the job done at a fair price.

I agree and I think the city managers who make over 100K plus cola plus pay for performance which equals 6% per year recently, should get off their asses and lite that fire. In regards to the fair price it may start off low but the privates will increase rates and do questionable practices to add on fees.

I don't buy into the notion that if we go private we are going to be better off nor do I buy the idea that city collectors cannot be improved. I just hate using my tax dollars to support a philosiphy without evidence you are saving dollars with all elements taken into consideration.
 
addicted2whiskey said:
For the record, many of the guys that get in as garbage collectors (or to work for the City in general) do so through influence. In other words, they're related to the bigwigs at City Hall more often than not!!!

I wonder if the media is in cohouts with with the City. I often also wonder whether the Union is in cohouts with the City Hall bigwigs… in any event, these jobs are all very well paying but there’s no equal opportunity… the blatant nepotism is simply overlooked and never exposed.

My ex-gf worked for the City in a mgmt position and left for greener pastures (and also because she wanted more of a challenge)… the things she told me were absolutely mind-boggling and atrocious for a progressive City like Toronto with respect to their recruitment and selection of staff!
I agree since mangers have been caught many times giving freinds and family jobs. Nothing happens to these managers even when it is discovered since they all do it. Lots of stories on this a few years back but nothing changed. Remember the recent Toronto Star article that was written by a young female part time worker who gave her experience of a first time strike for her. If you read the article her dad was a City Manager, do you think having Daddy as a City Manager helps you get a job at the City of Toronto? Yea you won't see her writing about that topic.
 
my2cents said:
I agree the problem is that there are not the number of big players to not have a monopoly since an investment in equipment etc. is large and a barrier for entry for many.

The city owns the equipment and can sell or lease it if necessary, but it is not such a barrier to entry as you imagine--the cities who put garbage collection up for contract have NOT had trouble attracting bids.

The problem is that that contract can go on for years past what the contract is for their employees.

Well what I'm saying is that the city make it a CONDITION of the bidding process that the contractor show that its contract with employees lasts longer than the contract with the city.

Any contractor that wants to bid then has to negotiate with its union FIRST, and then together the contractor and the union submit a bid for the work.

Also think of the power you put in the union hands when they know the company has to resolve the contract to get the bid.

That pressure cuts both ways. If the company DOESN'T get the bid, then all those union workers are out of a job. The union and the company have a common interest in putting in a bid that will win the work and so they will have a strong incentive to co-operate and put together a deal that will satisfy the city.

What doesn't happen is over site on excessive charges

Either way the City has a staff of managers who either oversee the union, in the public case, or the contractors, in the private case. Nobody said the city has to abdicate its oversight responsibilities just because it contracted out!

Yes and the current mix of city garbage collectors and private collectors is exactly competition since the private contractor has to keep in line with city collectors rates or better them.

Sorry but that's not competition. There is nobody out there breathing down the city GC's necks hoping to steal the business. They have a monopoly on collecting garbage in Toronto, and as any monopoly does, they use their monopoly to extract higher than market prices from the city.

I don't have a problem going private but not a private monopoly.

There's no evidence of any private monopolies developing in garbage collection. In fact just the opposite--in areas where collection is private, such as other cities in Ontario, or pickup of commercial and industrial waste, there are many firms competing for the business.
 
fuji said:
The fair wage is the lowest wage at which qualified people would accept the job.
'Scuse me, but 'fair' to who? If another employer values the work more and pays higher is that 'unfair'? And if the employer's offer isn't accepted by anyone qualified, and she rejects the worker's higher asking price, what's the 'fair' price? Never mind why you pick the lowest an employer can get away with rather than the highest a worker could get. What sanctifies 'lowest' as fair?

And of course your definition pretty much defines any worker trying to advance his self-interest as unfair.

Trouble is, with all this stuff, value judgements, money lust and envy, and theoretical economics get all mixed up. Nobody gives a fig until they wake up one mornig and discover their ox was gored in the night and demand a villain, a hero and a quick fix. Where was the outrage at uppity garbage collectors—we're still talking about them and not doctors and lab techs—when the trash dissappeared every week.

But granting that pretty much all existing wages have been set unfairly—as you mentioned earlier, legal and other restrictions abound, and many employers are just too lazy to actually do the work to get the talent at the lowest wage—it still comes down to the dealmaking that establishes the number. Which is established by agreement between buyer and seller.

And that brings us to the union question: Why not? And if not, then how do you/we distinguish between bad group action—like some folks' idea of unions—and acceptable group action—like say all getting together in a group and setting one rate for trash collection, take it or leave it?
 
my2cents said:
I agree since mangers have been caught many times giving freinds and family jobs. Nothing happens to these managers even when it is discovered since they all do it. Lots of stories on this a few years back but nothing changed. Remember the recent Toronto Star article that was written by a young female part time worker who gave her experience of a first time strike for her. If you read the article her dad was a City Manager, do you think having Daddy as a City Manager helps you get a job at the City of Toronto? Yea you won't see her writing about that topic.

What's her name? I missed the article... There's one manager in particular that my ex-girlfriend spoke of. He hired family members directly under him (in all honesty 70% of the staff was not competent and related to him). When someone reported this to the fraud line and it was confirmed they just moved the staff out to different units and didn't bother to discipline the guy.

Sheesh! Our tax dollars hard at work!!!
 
oldjones said:
'Scuse me, but 'fair' to who? If another employer values the work more and pays higher is that 'unfair'? And if the employer's offer isn't accepted by anyone qualified, and she rejects the worker's higher asking price, what's the 'fair' price? Never mind why you pick the lowest an employer can get away with rather than the highest a worker could get. What sanctifies 'lowest' as fair?
One again, you show a complete misunderstanding of the issues. Fuji is undoubtedly referring to the competitive outcome where, at the margin, the last worker hired is just getting his reservation wage (e.g. “lowest wage at which qualified people would accept the job”). At the same time, the firms are paying the highest wages they are willing to pay for that marginal worker. Thus, it is both "lowest an employer can get away with" and "the highest a worker could get" at the margin. This outcome is Pareto Efficient. Intramarginal workers are getting rents. Any other wage results in unemployment where other workers would be willing to work if the wage was a lower and firms would be willing to hire the additional workers. I will not bother with the rest of your post as it just follows from this basic misunderstanding of yours. There is a much better way you could debate Fuji but I very much doubt you will hit on it as it likely would not be on the NDP website.
 
Last edited:
Mrbig1949 said:
Deserve to be able to make enough money to be able to buy a house take a decent vacation every year and sent their kids to college. You just can't do that unless you pay decent wages.

So I guess McJobs should pay a decent wage too? Fine if you want to pay $8.00 for a bigmac.

I guess by that argument assembly line workers should get $40.00 an hour too? Which is why we have lost our manufacturing base to china.

I guess a stock boy working nights at loblaws should get $20.00 an hour too? So don't bitch about high grocery costs

I guess gas jockeys should get $25.00 a hour too? Which is why gas stations are all self serve.

If you put all the low paying menial jobs into the high paying job category then businesses will find ways to eliminate those jobs. Then you have untrained, unskilled homeless people living on the streets or on welfare. Guess you like that huh?

Here's a good example for you: I worked in the trade show biz. I worked for 15 yrs learning all the skills I needed to manage $25M worth of business. I worked on average 80 hrs a week. My salary was $25.00 per hour. On an hourly basis I made $12.00 an hour. The training and skill level to be a GC can take as little as 30 minutes. Is THAT fair?
 
fuji said:
No they don't deserve that. If they want that go get some skills and some education and earn it.

I do not deserve to pay for your free shit.

I dunno about that. I believe that everyone deserves to live a comfortable life. However, education (i.e. University) should not be the only key to comfort. We need waste management as much as we need doctors (and more than lawyers, IMHO). However, we live in a capitalist society (check the sig), and as things stand, some civil servants are being paid quite well to do unskilled jobs. If they are make 50k+/year to start, then they have no right to strike. Different strokes for different folks, but if they are so offended by the contract which they are being offered, they can quit and head back to one of our fine educational institutions and retrain themselves (enrollment at York U is down this year). I'm not one to wave diplomas and degrees in people's faces, but let's be serious; if we're supposed to live in a meritocratic society then they are well off in comparison to the job in which they perform. It's required, but let's not kid ourselves into believing that 'anyone' can do it. Granted it will never happen, but I believe that it would be fair for everyone to earn a comfortable wage for whatever beneficial work they do. It just irks me to hear that a group of people (i.e. garbage collectors; York U TAs/part-time staff; TTC employees) who earn wages that are more than 'comfortable' (80k??) and they continue to want more. If they want sick days, at the wages they earn, they can afford to take a day off without pay. Just my opinion.
 
tboy said:
So I guess McJobs should pay a decent wage too? Fine if you want to pay $8.00 for a bigmac.

I guess by that argument assembly line workers should get $40.00 an hour too? Which is why we have lost our manufacturing base to china.

I guess a stock boy working nights at loblaws should get $20.00 an hour too? So don't bitch about high grocery costs

I guess gas jockeys should get $25.00 a hour too? Which is why gas stations are all self serve.

If you put all the low paying menial jobs into the high paying job category then businesses will find ways to eliminate those jobs. Then you have untrained, unskilled homeless people living on the streets or on welfare. Guess you like that huh?

Here's a good example for you: I worked in the trade show biz. I worked for 15 yrs learning all the skills I needed to manage $25M worth of business. I worked on average 80 hrs a week. My salary was $25.00 per hour. On an hourly basis I made $12.00 an hour. The training and skill level to be a GC can take as little as 30 minutes. Is THAT fair?

No. However, for the amount of money McDonald's/grocery stores make they could afford to pay their employees better. It's difficult to pin-point what is fair, but let's remember that certain jobs are tailored to certain people (i.e. teenagers). Those jobs aren't really meant to be careers (although they can lead to them). It's career-like jobs that should pay enough to live decent.
Years ago I was offered a job as a restaurant manager. I have the experience and know-how, but was offered well below 50k to start. After doing it for a couple of months, I had no choice but to leave. Not because I didn't like the job, but because I could barely cover basic expenses (car, rent, insurance, FOOD); and I'm not lavish. I argue for both sides. How can an employer offer someone a job that won't cover basics? How can someone who is being paid a more than fair wage complain? This is why I feel that unions are dated. They had a function, but that function has been compromised. For the most part they have driven up the cost of living in order to 'over-pay' their members. Rather than fair wages, we have a situation in which parity doesn't exist.
 
Toke said:
No. However, for the amount of money McDonald's/grocery stores make they could afford to pay their employees better. It's difficult to pin-point what is fair, but let's remember that certain jobs are tailored to certain people (i.e. teenagers). Those jobs aren't really meant to be careers (although they can lead to them). It's career-like jobs that should pay enough to live decent.
Years ago I was offered a job as a restaurant manager. I have the experience and know-how, but was offered well below 50k to start. After doing it for a couple of months, I had no choice but to leave. Not because I didn't like the job, but because I could barely cover basic expenses (car, rent, insurance, FOOD); and I'm not lavish. I argue for both sides. How can an employer offer someone a job that won't cover basics? How can someone who is being paid a more than fair wage complain? This is why I feel that unions are dated. They had a function, but that function has been compromised. For the most part they have driven up the cost of living in order to 'over-pay' their members. Rather than fair wages, we have a situation in which parity doesn't exist.

If an employer does not pay enough he will have difficulty maintaining good hard working people
You yourself left a job because from your point of view it did not pay enough
Your foamer employer will notice if all his good people leave for higher paying jobs & he will adjust the pay level (if he can without losing money) to prevent this from happening in the future.

Grocers work on very thin margins , so your assumption they can pay well is not necessarily true
 
oldjones said:
But granting that pretty much all existing wages have been set unfairly—as you mentioned earlier, legal and other restrictions abound, and many employers are just too lazy to actually do the work to get the talent at the lowest wage—it still comes down to the dealmaking that establishes the number. Which is established by agreement between buyer and seller.

And that brings us to the union question: Why not? And if not, then how do you/we distinguish between bad group action—like some folks' idea of unions—and acceptable group action—like say all getting together in a group and setting one rate for trash collection, take it or leave it?

Bad action groups are ones who strike when their compensation is already in excess of their maket value.
Bad action groups disrupt commerce.
Bad action groups
Bad action groups place their precieved entitlement about the needs of thier customers
Bad action groups place their precieved entitlement about the needs of other employees (tourism industry)
Bad action groups do all of these things in the name of a union

Trash collectors is a prime example
 
JohnLarue said:
If an employer does not pay enough he will have difficulty maintaining good hard working people
You yourself left a job because from your point of view it did not pay enough
Your foamer employer will notice if all his good people leave for higher paying jobs & he will adjust the pay level (if he can without losing money) to prevent this from happening in the future.

Grocers work on very thin margins , so your assumption they can pay well is not necessarily true

True. The position I took was one that they were looking to fill for over a year. Your assumption was what I told them when I left (as nice as possible). They were looking to fill a 50+hr/week position by offering peanuts. It's actually quite common in the restaurant industry today. Another place that I had worked at did the same thing, but worse. Low pay; no benefits; and a carousel of management coming in and out. It was quite remarkable to watch. They even tried a headhunter and he basically laughed at the compensation package being offered (not to mention that they didn't even cover parking).
The point that I was trying to make is that today it is becoming more difficult to simply 'provide' for oneself. Some industries are paying way below fair; while we have others where the employees are going overboard in their requests. Granted the city is trying to take back what they have given (this is where the problem began), but I believe that the current strikers are being paid 'fairly' for the work they do; sick days aside.
As a side note, when I did work in restaurants, I worked at a variety of types from 'fine' to 'family'. The one constant was that the waitstaff had the potential of making anywhere from $20-$40 per hour. Whenever they pulled the 'greater than thou' attitude, where they felt they were doing the restaurant or customers a favour, I'd remind them of what they are paid for the work they do. I'm not saying that serving is an unskilled job, but let's be serious... it does not require a whole lot of skill. Patience and organization, yes; education and specific skills, no. Not waving credentials, but it's not like they had to sacrifice time and money to have a job that compensates them quite well.
 
JohnLarue said:
Bad action groups are ones who strike when their compensation is already in excess of their maket value.
Bad action groups disrupt commerce.
Bad action groups
Bad action groups place their precieved entitlement about the needs of thier customers
Bad action groups place their precieved entitlement about the needs of other employees (tourism industry)
Bad action groups do all of these things in the name of a union
... and bad employees do all of these things with or without a union.
Trash collectors is a prime example

I agree. I wouldn't be as harsh, but you've summed things up quite nicely.
 
I'm probably in the minority here, but I don't begrudge what the union workers are making, for a few simple reasons:

1. You get what you can while you can. (Basic economics and human nature.)
2. Our society NEEDS a middle class that can earn enough money (including the benefits) to pay mortgages, support their families, etc. With manufacturing jobs disappearing, government jobs are one of the few ways people can still make a good living, spend money and contribute to the growth of society.

The pendulum is swinging toward greedy business owners who would be happy to have Canadians (and Americans/Europeans) be nothing but service-industry workers (with low pay and no benefits) or higher-end jobs, with nothing in between. All while leveraging as much public funding and perks as they can.

Both sides are missing the point in our overall social compact.

Don't get me wrong, I despise the way the union - and the city - has handled this strike. Neither side "gets it", considering the economic times. The city can't trot out the bad economy as an excuse while spending like drunken sailors and giving out raises to some. And to take a stand over something like banked sick days shows how truly out of touch the union is. It's bad enough that they take the job, pay and benefits for granted, but their lack of pride in their work and disdain for the city and residents is disappointing. Greed, arrogance and stupidity all around - a terrible combination.

As for private garbage collection, I'd really have to see the numbers in Etobicoke: amount and type of garbage collected, cost per household, amount of waste diverted, etc. I'm not saying that they're not doing a good job out there - I've just found over the years that the savings for privatized services are not always as great as we're led to believe and the quality of service is not nearly as good as purported.

Shame on both the city and the union for allowing this to happen - in the summertime in particular (health, economic and esthetic impacts.)
 
Toke said:
I believe that everyone deserves to live a comfortable life.

I don't. I believe as a society we need to ensure that no-one starves, that no-one winds up homeless, that every kid no matter who their parents get a fair shot at a good life, but those who are lazy and unwilling to work do not deserve to be comfortable.

However, education (i.e. University) should not be the only key to comfort.

I reject the notion that education means university. I would consider an electrician or a plumber or a car mechanic to have good skills and education as well.

We need waste management as much as we need doctors (and more than lawyers, IMHO).

Sure, but as taxpayers when we overpay for something we need, we get less services. Our tax dollars don't go as far, and EVERYONE is made worse off by that. Were we to pay a proper rate for waste management and day care we could have more frequent pickup, more daycares, or maybe put the money into something else--more swimming pools, or maybe just lower taxes.

If they are make 50k+/year to start, then they have no right to strike.

Well.. I would not want to dismantle the labour relations system. There is a point to having a union in some cases, but it is a fair point to say that management gets the union it deserves. The city has been a pushover and has allowed the unions to walk all over it.

A much tougher, harder nosed city would serve taxpayers better and, I believe, would result in fewer strikes--the union would learn to have a little more respect for the city if it got badly burned on an unreasonable strike.

If they want sick days, at the wages they earn, they can afford to take a day off without pay. Just my opinion.

This isn't even about sick days--the city's latest offer gives them six full months of sick days. They just can't bank them and cash them out. This is about cash.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
1. You get what you can while you can. (Basic economics and human nature.)

Sure, but shouldn't that apply to taxpayers too? Shouldn't we be trying to maximize our value, and get the most we can for the taxes we pay?

When we overpay for services then necessarily we get less for our tax dollars. Fewer daycares, fewer swimming pools, inferior libraries, poorer roads, fewer police, and inferior healthcare system. When we overpay it is a simple fact we can't buy as much as we could if we paid a fair rate.

2. Our society NEEDS a middle class that can earn enough money (including the benefits) to pay mortgages, support their families, etc. With manufacturing jobs disappearing, government jobs are one of the few ways people can still make a good living, spend money and contribute to the growth of society.

We can't fake it. It's not sustainable to create fake high wage jobs. You can't take a skilled job where the wage was high due to valid supply and demand effects and then take some unskilled job and overpay and say you have solved the problem.

At the end of the day it is not really the "high wage" that we need, it is the "high productivity". That factory worker was churning out a lot of stuff that we were trading overseas to other people. Forget about money for a moment and realize that what we need are more goods and more services and you will see that you can't just fake it--you can't just overpay someone and say you have a middle class.

What we need are SUSTAINABLE high wages, and that means people who are well paid because they produce valuable goods and services, not just because we arbitrarily decided to overpay them.

As for private garbage collection, I'd really have to see the numbers in Etobicoke: amount and type of garbage collected, cost per household, amount of waste diverted, etc.

The numbers were posted up-thread. I have read a fairly convincing article though that it is not that private is better than public, but that competition is better than a monopoly.

In other words you get good value and fair wages out of public employee unions when they are forced into competition with the private sector. So, say every 5 or 10 years the city puts out a tender and allows BOTH private sector firms AND the public unions to bid on the contract.

It turns out that under those circumstances often the public sector union can win the contract with a competitive wage and deliver good value for money.

What is happening now with CUPE in Toronto is that they effectively have a monopoly on picking up garbage. The city has made it illegal for anyone else to pick up garbage, and now they are holding us all hostage demanding to exort more money out of us.

That's what ALL monopolies do, so it shouldn't be surprising.

Break the monopoly and you'll find that you save 20-30% and might even still have CUPE picking up the trash--but only after they were forced to submit a competitive bid against Turtle Island or whoever else. Or maybe Turtle Island would win, either way, it's the competition that makes it efficient, not just because it's private.
 
Toke said:
I agree. I wouldn't be as harsh, but you've summed things up quite nicely.


Thanks
If I am harsh. it is because these union guys feel they deserve an ever increasing bite out of my paycheques (through taxes) .
I also do not like their tactics, but most importantly I do not like their self -righteous approach to extorting excess from the economy
 
fuji said:
I don't. I believe as a society we need to ensure that no-one starves, that no-one winds up homeless, that every kid no matter who their parents get a fair shot at a good life, but those who are lazy and unwilling to work do not deserve to be comfortable.

'Comfort' is not defined as excess. What you have outlined as what everyone deserves is similar to mine. Everything that you said as well as employment that doesn't leaving them wondering where there next meal will come from. That is comfort. Not yearly vacations. There is no reason for someone to horde capital while the next person has to work sixty hours per week just to get by.

fuji said:
I reject the notion that education means university. I would consider an electrician or a plumber or a car mechanic to have good skills and education as well.

Same here. I said university because that is the popular belief. Other forms of education (i.e. college, trades, etc.) are undervalued and that is part of the problem. We have successful tradesmen that preach 'university' to their children, rather than promoting the very work that they did/do. It's a societal paradox.

fuji said:
Sure, but as taxpayers when we overpay for something we need, we get less services. Our tax dollars don't go as far, and EVERYONE is made worse off by that. Were we to pay a proper rate for waste management and day care we could have more frequent pickup, more daycares, or maybe put the money into something else--more swimming pools, or maybe just lower taxes.

Exactly. Too much tax money is spent to over-pay for services. Not only waste management but many, many other public services. I can't remember exactly who, but around the turn of the century (early 1900's) an American socialist politician proposed lower income taxes in favour of higher death taxes.

fuji said:
Well.. I would not want to dismantle the labour relations system. There is a point to having a union in some cases, but it is a fair point to say that management gets the union it deserves. The city has been a pushover and has allowed the unions to walk all over it.

I dunno about that. To say that management gets what it deserves by striking, which sometimes leads to taking society hostage, is somewhat misleading. I like what the city is currently doing, but I'm still skeptical of the motive/outcome.

fuji said:
A much tougher, harder nosed city would serve taxpayers better and, I believe, would result in fewer strikes--the union would learn to have a little more respect for the city if it got badly burned on an unreasonable strike.

Or binding arbitration.

fuji said:
This isn't even about sick days--the city's latest offer gives them six full months of sick days. They just can't bank them and cash them out. This is about cash.

Then they have a sweet deal. More reason not to strike.
 
JohnLarue said:
Thanks
If I am harsh. it is because these union guys feel they deserve an ever increasing bite out of my paycheques (through taxes) .
I also do not like their tactics, but most importantly I do not like their self -righteous approach to extorting excess from the economy

Okay, I'll be harsh...
To the striking workers, "How much do you want to be paid to pick up trash?"