Captain Fantastic said:
1. You get what you can while you can. (Basic economics and human nature.)
Sure, but shouldn't that apply to taxpayers too? Shouldn't we be trying to maximize our value, and get the most we can for the taxes we pay?
When we overpay for services then necessarily we get less for our tax dollars. Fewer daycares, fewer swimming pools, inferior libraries, poorer roads, fewer police, and inferior healthcare system. When we overpay it is a simple fact we can't buy as much as we could if we paid a fair rate.
2. Our society NEEDS a middle class that can earn enough money (including the benefits) to pay mortgages, support their families, etc. With manufacturing jobs disappearing, government jobs are one of the few ways people can still make a good living, spend money and contribute to the growth of society.
We can't fake it. It's not sustainable to create fake high wage jobs. You can't take a skilled job where the wage was high due to valid supply and demand effects and then take some unskilled job and overpay and say you have solved the problem.
At the end of the day it is not really the "high wage" that we need, it is the "high productivity". That factory worker was churning out a lot of stuff that we were trading overseas to other people. Forget about money for a moment and realize that what we need are more goods and more services and you will see that you can't just fake it--you can't just overpay someone and say you have a middle class.
What we need are SUSTAINABLE high wages, and that means people who are well paid because they produce valuable goods and services, not just because we arbitrarily decided to overpay them.
As for private garbage collection, I'd really have to see the numbers in Etobicoke: amount and type of garbage collected, cost per household, amount of waste diverted, etc.
The numbers were posted up-thread. I have read a fairly convincing article though that it is not that private is better than public, but that competition is better than a monopoly.
In other words you get good value and fair wages out of public employee unions when they are forced into competition with the private sector. So, say every 5 or 10 years the city puts out a tender and allows BOTH private sector firms AND the public unions to bid on the contract.
It turns out that under those circumstances often the public sector union can win the contract with a competitive wage and deliver good value for money.
What is happening now with CUPE in Toronto is that they effectively have a monopoly on picking up garbage. The city has made it illegal for anyone else to pick up garbage, and now they are holding us all hostage demanding to exort more money out of us.
That's what ALL monopolies do, so it shouldn't be surprising.
Break the monopoly and you'll find that you save 20-30% and might even still have CUPE picking up the trash--but only after they were forced to submit a competitive bid against Turtle Island or whoever else. Or maybe Turtle Island would win, either way, it's the competition that makes it efficient, not just because it's private.