Ovechkin Overrated.

Bob Loblaw said:
Jeff Carter was second in goals scored, if he put 528 shots at his pace, he would've scored 71 goals; Kovalchuk would have had 83; Vanek would have had 100; Eriksson pots 107!!

QUOTE]

If ?

If my aunt had balls, she would be my uncle

Hockey is a whole lot more than putting 8.63 shots on goal & expecting a goal as statistical outcome.
You have to score to win , but what often separates the really good players are a lot of things that do not show up on a score sheet.
Like driving the net when your playing Pronger or Chara, wearing down a teams defensemen with the body & intense forchecking, drawing penaties, back checking & leading by example,

Those that criticise Ovechkin for being a puck hog , might wonder if his coach has encouraged him to shoot a lot & designed plays to get the puck to him.
Ovechkin has a whicked shot.

If I had to start a team from all the guys in the league, it would be a close call on the first guy I would take. But Ovechkin would probably get the nod over Pavel Datsyuk because he is more physical
Malkin would be third choice, Luongo fourth.
 
Last edited:
He is only 23 years old and no where near his prime. Let's judge him in a few years from now.
 
No need to judge. I guess if Alex was Canadian he would be dynamic and incredible. The guy shoots the puck because he can and his speed and strength get him to the net. I am really getting tired of the nitpicking on this guy. He has a great time playing the game, he is the most prolific goal scorer in the game today and hits anything that moves and still healthy. The only thing I didn't like was when he pulled that "hot stick" act when he potted his 50th goal of the season. Otherwise, I love watching this guy play. He gets paid to score and people are jumping on his back to pass more and that he needs to take his team to the promised land. It's a lot harder that people realize. There have been many great players that have not won the Stanley Cup (Crosby and Malkin included) and just enjoy the kid play. Just because he is different doesn't mean you have to dislike him. He truly enjoys playing and you can tell he wants to win more than anything.
 
Bob Loblaw said:
Unless there was another article that I'm unaware of, I wonder if you were thinking of the one in which they talk about Kovalchuk. This isn't the actual one I saw in which there were sources saying he would love to play in T.O., I just can't find it.

http://www.thestar.com/article/529055

Sorry for the late response - missed this one. It was an article during Ovechkin's rookie season. I would've posted the link but it was so long ago I doubt it's still available. At that time, the Caps were a futile team and there wasn't any indication it would get better. Ovechkin sought the spotlight even in his rookie season and seemed to understand the importance of hockey in Toronto. Now that they have a pretty good team, I'm not sure Ovechkin would want to leave.
 
Bob Loblaw said:
Jeff Carter was second in goals scored, if he put 528 shots at his pace, he would've scored 71 goals; Kovalchuk would have had 83; Vanek would have had 100; Eriksson pots 107!!

I know numbers don't tell the whole story, I'm just saying there is evidence to suggest that Ovechkin could be overrated. There is some merit in that accusation.

By the way, when Wayne Gretzky score 92 goals in 1981/82, he put a career-high 369 shots on goal. If he had put 528, that's a projected 132 goals.

I used to hear the same argument about Michael Jordan in basketball... that he scored a lot because he shot the ball so much and that anyone can score that much if they shot the ball as much as MJ.
 
Cindy Crosby

Puck hog or not, he still is better then Crosby!


lovelatinas said:
Ovechkin is a puck hog, he doesn't use his teammates like Crosby does. Yes he take too many long shifts. He plays physical and he will ware down in the playoffs. Pittsburg will find a way to shut him down and Washington will have to rely on the depth of their second, third and fourth lines to get some scoring. Pittsburg has more depth than Washington and should win this series while Ovechkin looks for highlight reel goals to be on youtube.
 
lovelatinas said:
If you are comparing Ovechkin to Cindy Crosby. I would say yes Alex is better than her.

Ovechkin's team one up on Crosby's. If he were Canadian, there would be no question who was better.
 
friendz4evr said:
Ovechkin's team one up on Crosby's. If he were Canadian, there would be no question who was better.

I think Crosby is great but overall Ovechkin is better. If he was Canadian he would get more adulation.
 
OK I may have been wrong on this one:D , feel bad for Crosby though, he's carrying the team and not crying, he's got absolutely no help, Staal hasn't developed much and Malkin is non existent.
 
On his second goal there should have been a tripping penalty off the draw.
 
And on Crosby's third, there should have been a penality for cross checking the goalie in the head.
 
wow, cannot believe i would ever see a thread bashing ovechkin, claiming he is overrated.

he plays with passion, and sometimes he may be a little too enthusiastic with his celebrations, but so what. he knows he is also in the business of entertaining, and that is what he does. does he take a ton of shots...hell yeah, but he puts himself in the position to be able to do so. he also makes everyone else around a little bit better. guys like semin and backstrom are good, no doubt, but ovie draws the other teams best defensive players, allowing his teammates to play against lesser guys. his physical play is a bonus, although one thing ovie has to watch out for, is disrespecting fellow players/teams with his antics sometimes.

the other thing i like about ovie, is he didnt bitch, whine and cry about getting drafted and having to play in washington. ovie played a few seasons with a bad caps team, but stayed quiet and patient, and is now reaping the rewards. is it not nice to see a guy go somewhere and help his team grow into a championship contender?

sidney crosby equally as good as ovie, but does not have the "wow" factor on display as much as ovie does. do not let it fool you though, as crosby has scored and displayed many awesome goals and moves. one thing i do not like though with sid, and many have noted it, is his tendency to whine. other than that, i am enjoying watching these two forge their careers, and look forward to may head-to-head battles between the two young superstars in the years to come. tonite's game was a prime example, hat-tricks for both of them.

i grew up watching gretzky his whole career, then lemieux, and use to listen to people constantly picking their games apart, instead of sitting back and realizing that they are watching history being made. i am not for one moment comparing ovie and sid with gretzky and lemieux, just the fact that people should enjoy their efforts instead of trying to pick them apart.

Plyrs99
 
plyrs99 said:
wow, cannot believe i would ever see a thread bashing ovechkin, claiming he is overrated.

It's because Crosby is everyone's golden boy and the Great 8 is taking away from his luster. The NHL wants Sid to be the star 'cause he's North American and thinks he is more marketable (speaks English, etc) than a Russian. As far as I'm concerned, I wouldn't care if Ovie couldn't say a word of English, he's as fun to watch as they come.
 
Don said:
And on Crosby's third, there should have been a penality for cross checking the goalie in the head.

Yep & Kuiniz maybe suspended for that.
 
I'm a huge Penguins fan and even I think Ovechkin is definitely NOT overrated. He is the games #1 most exciting player to watch bar none... He is near the top of the greatest natural goal scorers of all time and he is tough as nails and is one of the league's most feared hitters.

Props are definitely due, here.
 
lawyerman said:
I think Crosby is great but overall Ovechkin is better. If he was Canadian he would get more adulation.

I happened to be in Washington near the Verizon Wireless arena when they played game 1 and I saw fans everywhere wearing Ovechkin's number 8. They do love him here!
 
i wondered what happened to all the Kolzig sweaters, myself... though, I did see some Simon and Bondra sweaters from the ole Ron Wilson days there.
 
friendz4evr said:
I happened to be in Washington near the Verizon Wireless arena when they played game 1 and I saw fans everywhere wearing Ovechkin's number 8. They do love him here!

I think he meant nationally and especially in Canada.