Ovechkin Overrated.

BallzDeep

New member
Feb 12, 2007
2,265
5
0
This is the first time I've watched him regularily for entire games and not just on highlight reels and think he's extremely overrated. He's terrible defensively, shifts are way too long, often tries to beat 3-4 guys by himself, very selfish player.

Of course he'll score 60 goals a year when he plays every power play and shoots all the time. They hardly beat a very average Ranger team and he was hardly noticeable in game 7, I think Semin is a lot better.

He's a good player but way overrated IMO, I think Pittsburgh will handle them easily.
 
Did not watch the series but I've seen him play a few times. He is amazing to watch, a hog and selfish at times but he produces. Defensively he gets stuck up high too many times. But to call him overrated I will disagree big time.

He is a wizard with the puck and has the sixth sense to go with it.
 
BallzDeep said:
This is the first time I've watched him regularily for entire games and not just on highlight reels and think he's extremely overrated. He's terrible defensively, shifts are way too long, often tries to beat 3-4 guys by himself, very selfish player.

Of course he'll score 60 goals a year when he plays every power play and shoots all the time. They hardly beat a very average Ranger team and he was hardly noticeable in game 7, I think Semin is a lot better.

He's a good player but way overrated IMO, I think Pittsburgh will handle them easily.

You watch a few games and you can sum up your expert analysis of Ovechkin. Overrated? Get real. I guess you left out the part that not only is he the most exciting player in the league today but he is also in the top 10 in hits. He might be a bit of a puck hog but the guy has a knack for scoring. He is not there to play defence hence the reason he scores many goals. His defensive game isn't nearly is bad as you say either.

IMHO, I think Washington needs to shore up their game and Pittsburgh will be tough. Pittsburgh will be a tough test for them. Not sure about handling them easily but the Penguins have been playing pretty well as of late.
 
So far he's a regular season phenom, that's it, let's see how far he takes his team, that's the true test, he looked very average last night, when he should have shone.

He has to beat Pittsburgh and be dominant to justify his prolly 2 league MVP's, I realize he's young but Malkin and Crosby are doing it.

He stays out 50 seconds longer than his linemates, that'll work against NY but not against the better teams.

Federov looked great.
 
BallzDeep said:
So far he's a regular season phenom, that's it, let's see how far he takes his team, that's the true test, he looked very average last night, when he should have shone.

He has to beat Pittsburgh and be dominant to justify his prolly 2 league MVP's, I realize he's young but Malkin and Crosby are doing it.

Federov looked great.

Ovechkin has been on a shit team for a few years now. Ovechkin has brought this team to some prominence.

Fedorov has a good game and we should bow down to him right? I'm not saying he didn't play well but you're judging one fucking game.

BTW, I like Malkin and Crosby. Two superstars against one. Should be interesting.
 
you could say he's over rated but i still rate him above everyone else.
 
It's the first time i've seen him for an extended period of time and wasn't overly impressed, surprised how much he loafed. In the highlights he's going high speed all the time.

I predict he'll do very little the rest of the playoffs, we'll see.
 
Bob Loblaw said:
I would say calling him overrated might be harsh, but I wouldn't completley discount that notion. He's the most exciting player easily, but people are in awe at what a prolific scorer he is (56 goals): he put 528 shots on goal in the regular season! That's 156 more than the second highest guy, Eric Staal.

If you look at the top 50 scorers this season, Ovechkin ranks 48th in goals-scored percentage! Broken down further, Ovechkin scored one goal for every 9.43 shots he fired on net; Dallas' Loui Eriksson's percentage was 20.2% over 178 shots on goal, meaning he scored at a clip of 1 goal per 4.94 shots on goal. If Ovechkin -- at his rate -- fired only 178 shots on goal, he scores 19, and is hardly considered the superstar that he is.

Jeff Carter was second in goals scored, if he put 528 shots at his pace, he would've scored 71 goals; Kovalchuk would have had 83; Vanek would have had 100; Eriksson pots 107!!

I know numbers don't tell the whole story, I'm just saying there is evidence to suggest that Ovechkin could be overrated. There is some merit in that accusation.

By the way, when Wayne Gretzky score 92 goals in 1981/82, he put a career-high 369 shots on goal. If he had put 528, that's a projected 132 goals.

Wow.


So I guess Louis Ericksson is really keeping defenders on edge and drawing a bunch of penalties like Ovechkin then?. There's a reason guys have 100 shots and some have 300... there not good enough to generate more scoring opportunities, or put themselves in position to get a decent shot away.

Ovechkin coming down the wing is almost always guaranteed to at least be able to get a decent quality shot on net - so he takes the shot.... that is hardly the case for anybody else in the NHL, who might only be able to take a longer distance rlower % shot as they do not have the one on one puck skills or shooting skills to be able to get a harder or close shot away. If Louis Ericksson is only capable of banging in rebounds, or being set up for close in opportunities, that all of a sudden makes him a better sniper?

And before you criticize Ovechkin shooting % you might want to look at the league avg. Why would he only shoot 178 times. WTF?
 
Ovechkin is a puck hog, he doesn't use his teammates like Crosby does. Yes he take too many long shifts. He plays physical and he will ware down in the playoffs. Pittsburg will find a way to shut him down and Washington will have to rely on the depth of their second, third and fourth lines to get some scoring. Pittsburg has more depth than Washington and should win this series while Ovechkin looks for highlight reel goals to be on youtube.
 
You know the Montreal Canadiens said the same thing about Mike Bossy when they passed him over in th draft. My recollection was that the Canadiens drafted a very good defensive player ahead of Bossy. Very good defensive players come along every year, natural goal scorers like Bossy and Ovie come along once every generation. (Of course, the perfect hockey players like Howe and Orr come along once in a lifetime.)
 
The writer was probably biased but there was a Toronto Star article that made it sound like Ovechkin would love to play in Toronto; he loves the spotlight and as we know, it's the biggest hockey market in North America. Yes, I would love to see Ovie in a Leafs jersey.

Having said that, there's nothing better than a rivalry between elite players. I like both Ovechkin and Crosby and this rivalry is good for the nhl. Going to be a great series.
 
well you will have an answer to our question in a couple of weeks.
the wash/pitt series i think will be a great series. if AO is the player everyone says he is, he will rise to the occasion and carry the caps thru to the next round. this will be he first major "test" in his career
 
BallzDeep said:
It's the first time i've seen him for an extended period of time and wasn't overly impressed, surprised how much he loafed. In the highlights he's going high speed all the time.

I predict he'll do very little the rest of the playoffs, we'll see.

I have seen him live twice, granted it's against the Leafs, but to even a casual observer he was head and shoulders the best player on the ice. Honestly, if I had a player as creative as him, defence would be the least of my worries. Also, I don't remeber Gretzky or Lemeiux killing themselves in their own end.
 
Production = Results.

that's all you need to know.
 
Sorry buddy.....u r dead wrong!!

http://thehockeywriters.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/crosbythecrybaby1-300x225.jpg
BallzDeep said:
This is the first time I've watched him regularily for entire games and not just on highlight reels and think he's extremely overrated. He's terrible defensively, shifts are way too long, often tries to beat 3-4 guys by himself, very selfish player.

Of course he'll score 60 goals a year when he plays every power play and shoots all the time. They hardly beat a very average Ranger team and he was hardly noticeable in game 7, I think Semin is a lot better.

He's a good player but way overrated IMO, I think Pittsburgh will handle them easily.

Ovechkin has more heart than sid the kid.....I can't stand Crosby. Caps in 6 games over Pitt.

http://www.bpwtf.org/files/page0_blog_entry1_3.gif
 
I thought he was average to below average for the whole series, wasn't noticable in games 5 & 7, he's paid to win games. In game 6 he scored the highlight goal and everybody is mesmorized.

Those 1:30 sec. shifts won't work when the pace picks up even more, let's see what he does in the top eight teams.
 
if i was starting a team right now, crosby would be the guy i would build around. he makes everybody around him a better player. and he,s always astep or two ahead of everybody else.imho, he has it all. excellant hockey player.
 
BallzDeep said:
Of course he'll score 60 goals a year when he plays every power play and shoots all the time.
LOL yes, these kind of players are a dime a dozen. Who can't score 60 meazly goals when you play every power play. :D
 
Ovechkin hasn't been at the top of his game yet he still has 3 goals, 4 assists and 49 shots in 7 playoff games. He is the most talented player in the league so I disagree with your assertion he is over rated.

Still I'd rather have Crosby just because he has the intangibles I think it takes to win when it counts. But I love watching Ovechkin play, you can just see how much he loves the game. He doesn't take a shift off, his energy level and conditioning is incredible.

Should be a great series and one I'm looking forward to seeing.