Outplaying vs. Winning

Goober Mcfly said:
Yes they were. It would be like me saying that "the Senators, with the exception of Patrick Lalime, outplayed the Leafs in the first round."

But that's not what I've been arguing.

My point is that the Leafs wouldn't have advanced (probably) had it not been for the stellar play of Ed Belfour. So, yes, Belfour outplayed the Senators. But the Senators skaters out-hit, out-shot, out-muscled, out-played the Leafs (generally).

Therefore, on the whole, the Senators team (90% of the roster) outplayed the Leafs.

WHOA! We're arguing whether or not "the Leafs outplayed the Senators in the first round". That's what I said, and what you CONTINUALLY say is not true, and that I'll never convince you of it!

I notice that you're now using "on the whole" rather than "as a whole". I'd agree with the statement "on the whole, the Senators outplayed the Leafs". This means that MOST Senators players outplayed most Leaf players.
What's NOT true is that "AS A WHOLE" the Senators outplayed the Leafs. That would imply that, taking all things into account, the Senators were a better TEAM. They weren't. They lost. To judge a team is to judge its accomplishments AS A WHOLE, not to break it down into individual analyses.

AS A WHOLE ENTITY, the Leafs outplayed the Sens.

You agree that Belfour outplayed the Senators, but that the team, overall, wasn't outplayed? Clearly, you mean that MOST of the players weren't outplayed. THE TEAM WAS! What you're saying is like saying "More people live in Toronto than the entire US, but more people live in the US than in Canada."
?!?!
Toronto is PART of Canada. Belfour is PART of the Leafs.
 
Dude - Ranger - you're giving me a freaking headache. You're arguing semantics here, man. When people say the Sens outplayed the Leafs, they're generalizing for the sake of conversation, and most people are sharp enough to understand what they mean. On the whole, the Sens outplayed the Leafs. More shots, more scoring chances, they looked better, sharper, faster, and tougher. Obviously, however, the Leafs played better as a whole, because ultimately they won the farking series. Quit splitting hairs. We all understand what you're saying - we're not slow, and we're not missing it. It just doesn't matter. When people say a team outplayed another despite losing, we all understand that generally means they did everything better than the other team but just couldn't get it in the fucking net. As a Red Wings fan I'm quite familiar with this phenomenon.

DW
 
DW: That sums it absolutely. Thank you for making my point that I wish I had have made pages ago. But you know I don't think it will make any difference to Ranger. He has backed himself into a corner with his argument and would take a really strong person to admit the truth in your argument.

Thanks,

SQ
 
DenWa said:
Obviously, however, the Leafs played better as a whole, because ultimately they won the farking series.

Goober disagrees with this statement, Den Wa.
THAT'S the point of this discussion.
Yes, it's semantics - but Goober doesn't think so. I think that most people *could* follow my argument, as you've demonstrated, and as I've said several times regarding the "authority figures".

Goober either can't or won't understand, but vociferously disagrees with me when I make this point. I brought it "off-line" to continue the debate for those who care.

You're not obliged to read this thread.
 
Uh, superquad? I agree with what Den Wa said.
In what way have I not?
I haven't backed myself into a corner - as Den Wa makes perfectly clear, it's GOOBER who refuses to listen to reason.
And yourself, perhaps.
And yet you agree with Den Wa?!
LOL
Read carefully, dude.

I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING DEN WA SAID. It perfectly sums up my argument.

Goober disagrees - with both of you, I guess.
 
DenWa said:
Dude - Ranger - you're giving me a freaking headache. You're arguing semantics here, man. .................Quit splitting hairs. We all understand what you're saying - we're not slow, and we're not missing it. It just doesn't matter. ...........
DW

Exactly!!!!........wow! wish I could have said that it in french.....Ranger, what you say overall makes a lot of sense......but Denwa hit it right on....you're splitting hairs........we could analyze the whole thing forever.......Denwa's right....it just doesn't matter.
 
I'm glad you agree.
Tell Goober, and we can put this whole thing to rest.
So, what I'm saying "overall" makes a lot of sense, but .... what, exactly? I'm splitting hairs? Not really - Goober disagrees with one "split hair" but not the other. Semantics? Goober doesn't think so - he's arguing the IDEA, not the words.
Which is what we're debating.
Clear?
Good.
 
Well said DenWa. I totally agree.

Ranger68: Take a look at the thread that started all this nonsense ->https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=52866

Goober Mcfly said:
Nuts.

As the third period was dying away last night, I felt a mixture of emotions...from sadness to anger to respect to hope.

I`m sad the Sens couldn`t make it past the Leafs again. I`m sad that they actually played mostly up to their potential but ran into an ultra-hot goaltender. I`m sad that I needed to log onto TERB the next day and listen to asshats like Johnnyhandsome rant and rave about how the Sens suck.

Which brings out the anger. I`m sick of people saying the Sens have no heart, no grit, no determination. I think they`ve proved otherwise. They won most of the battles, but lost the war. And not by much either. Last night was not the blow out of a few years ago, the final score withstanding. And as I listen to the echoing "woo-hoo!"`s emenating from the hallways and offices around me, I get pissed that the Leaf fans around here actually think that the result of this series makes it okay to chant "Sens suck" and belittle the team I love.

However, there were players on the Leafs team that deserve my respect. First and foremost, Eddie Belfour. This guy took the entire team and hopes of the entire Leaf Nation on his shoulder pads and still made save after glorious save. For that he deserves everyone`s respect. I also respect and admire Joe Nieuwendyk, Brian McCabe and Gary Roberts for playing their hearts out in the series. These four are the only Leafs deserving of my respect and admiration. I tip my hat to most of the Senator team though. With the exception of Bonk (where the fark was he?) and a few others, the fact that the Sens out-shot, out-chanced, out-hit, out-hustled and out-most everything else except out-scoring is admirable.

Which leads me to where I am now. With a sense of hope. I hope the Leafs are eliminated in four. I hope that Calgary or Montreal wins the Cup. I hope that there will be hockey next year. And I live in the hope that the Senators are a young(er) team with many good years left in them.

Well done Toronto.
Since then you have been arguing that solely because Belfour played awesome, the entire team played awesome. That is simply not true.

I have admitted before that the Leafs won the series, obviously. I have admitted that because they won the series, they *by definition* outscored the Senators. But the game of hockey is more than the final score. Plain and simple. Therefore, I can say that the Senators outplayed the Leafs, but lost the games because they were either a) outscored or b) didn`t score enough themselves.

Originally posted by DenWa
When people say a team outplayed another despite losing, we all understand that generally means they did everything better than the other team but just couldn`t get it in the fucking net.

You have argued that a team can not lose if they aren`t outplayed. Semantics.

Happy?
 
Goober Mcfly said:
Since then you have been arguing that solely because Belfour played awesome, the entire team played awesome. That is simply not true.

I've never argued this. ?!?! I've argued that, as a whole, the Leafs played better than the Sens. At the same time, I've said that TONS of components of the Leaf team were outplayed - starting with most of the skaters. Honestly, Goob, are you missing half of my posts, or what?! Nice straw man, though.
:rolleyes:

Goober Mcfly said:
I have admitted before that the Leafs won the series, obviously. I have admitted that because they won the series, they *by definition* outscored the Senators. But the game of hockey is more than the final score. Plain and simple. Therefore, I can say that the Senators outplayed the Leafs, but lost the games because they were either a) outscored or b) didn't score enough themselves.

Then, what do you mean by "outplayed"?!?! Everything EXCEPT goaltending, I guess, which is a point I've made many times - you're saying that the Sens *skaters* outplayed the Leafs *skaters*, which I agree with - which I've ALWAYS agreed with.
As a team, including goaltending - that is, FACTORING IN GOALTENDING - the Leafs outplayed the Senators. Agree or disagree? If, factoring in goaltending - that is, taking the team as a whole - the Leafs were outplayed, how come they won?

Goober Mcfly said:
You have argued that a team can not lose if they aren't outplayed. Semantics.

Happy?

Yes - the team that wins has "outplayed" the other, hasn't it?? Isn't that the point of the team playing?! To win?!?!
I'll be happy when you concede that the Leafs outplayed the Senators, when you factor in goaltending (which IS, after all, part of the game).

Oh, and you DON'T "totally agree" with Den Wa!!!!
"Obviously, however, the Leafs played better as a whole, because ultimately they won the farking series."
THIS IS THE WHOLE ARGUMENT WE'RE HAVING!
Sheesh.
Do you, now, suddenly, AGREE with Den Wa's statement?!?! If so, we can move on. Otherwise, I guess this is one more point you're just pulling out of thin air - agreement with the rest of the "TERBites".
 
Ranger68 said:
Do you, now, suddenly, AGREE with Den Wa's statement?!?! If so, we can move on.
Yes, I agree with DenWa's statement insofar as he means that the Leafs outplayed the Senators in actually putting the puck in the net.

My point is, was, and forever shall be that the Sens out-shot, out-chanced, out-hit, out-hustled and out-most everything else except out-scored the Leafs. Myself and many others condense this to "out-played".

We're arguing semantics.
 
We're still debating the topic.
The end-game is in sight.
 
Let's take the debatable term "out-played" out of the equation.

Can you agree with the following statements?

1. The Senators out-shot, out-chanced, out-hit, out-hustled and out-most everything else except out-scored the Leafs.

and

2. The Leafs out-scored the Senators.

If you can, we are in total agreement. And we can tbill this thread.
 
Goober Mcfly said:
Yes, I agree with DenWa's statement insofar as he means that the Leafs outplayed the Senators in actually putting the puck in the net.

My point is, was, and forever shall be that the Sens out-shot, out-chanced, out-hit, out-hustled and out-most everything else except out-scored the Leafs. Myself and many others condense this to "out-played".

We're arguing semantics.

Did they outdraw them? Outcoach them? Outskate them? Outspit them? Outdive them? Out them?? You're just arbitrarily picking things to define as "outplay", and saying that since they did all those things better, they outplayed them. Fine.

As long as it's clear what *I* mean - when I say "outplay", I mean taking the team performance as a whole - factoring in everything, including goaltending, in the proper proportions - the ones that actually MEAN something when you put them all together - the final score.

The Leafs outplayed the Sens. As a whole. Including EVERYTHING, not just what *you've* chosen to consider.

Your definition of "outplay" is a much less accurate reflection of reality, since mine reflects ... well, reality - that the Leafs won.

As I said - I grant the commentators, newspaper analysts, and coaches this conceit - it's obvious why they're saying what they're saying, and, indeed, what they mean. They mean everything *outside of goaltending*.

I choose to take the team as a whole, including goaltending.

INCLUDING GOALTENDING, the Leafs outplayed the Senators.

Earlier, you disagreed with this statement. Now, it's clear that it makes no sense in *your* definition, since goaltending isn't a part of "outplay". You could have just said that, instead of arguing with *my* statement and maintaining, in the face of my argument, that I was wrong - failing to grasp what I was talking about, in the end.

I'd say that others clearly grasp what I'm talking about better than you.

Semantics? Fine.

Your statement is drastically less precise, and consequently less accurate, than mine.

Done?
 
Goober Mcfly said:
Let's take the debatable term "out-played" out of the equation.

Can you agree with the following statements?

1. The Senators out-shot, out-chanced, out-hit, out-hustled and out-most everything else except out-scored the Leafs.

and

2. The Leafs out-scored the Senators.

If you can, we are in total agreement. And we can tbill this thread.

I've always agreed with point one, to a degree - I'd agree with it almost completely if you modified it to say "everything else except *out-goaltended* and out-scored". You see? This is my point - you're trying to make it sound like the Senators outplayed the Leafs IN EVERY COMPONENT OF THE GAME, but somehow, miraculously, I suppose, the Leafs won. The Leafs out-goaltended the Senators. This is, in fact, why they won.

Point two is a fact, not something to agree or disagree with.
 
Aha!

Ranger68 said:
As long as it's clear what *I* mean - when I say "outplay", I mean taking the team performance as a whole - factoring in everything, including goaltending, in the proper proportions - the ones that actually MEAN something when you put them all together - the final score.
I think it's fair to say that not everyone places the same emphasis on goaltending as you do. If you are looking at the team as a whole, you can't then breakdown the components and have a weighted distribution of values. Personally I believe scoring is more important than goaltending becasue if you can't score, you're going to loose eventually. Unless of course you are planning on the lucky bounce off someone's ass that you already stated you can't plan for.
As I said - I grant the commentators, newspaper analysts, and coaches this conceit - it's obvious why they're saying what they're saying, and, indeed, what they mean. They mean everything *outside of goaltending*.
Unfortunately you are not in any more of a position to interpret what they say than I am and if I do the same thing you've done, I take them at face value and believe they mean *including goaltending*

Your statement is drastically less precise, and consequently less accurate, than mine.

That is your opinion and unfortunately that does not make your pojnt correct and Goober's wrong.


Note:Please read my comments carefully and notice that they are statements of my opinion and therefore do not imply any interest or intention to argue "outplaying vs. winning". This board is about freely expressing your opinions and although you have a differing opinion and are willing to argue it ad nauseum does not make it any more correct. That's just my opion of course.
 
Goober Mcfly said:
I'm done. My point has been made.

No, not really.

A semantic argument is one where the two sides differ only on language interpretation.
You disagree with my fundamental analysis of the argument.
Once again, taking your things and going home.
And that's why:
the Leafs outplayed the Senators.
:)