Outplaying vs. Winning

Goober Mcfly said:
Fine. The Senators lost as a team, and the Leafs won as a team. But the actual play, independant of the score, was performed much better by the Senators as a whole.

ok, I'm gonna jump in here. I haven't read all the posts but...

But I do see where Ranger is coming from and what he is trying to say. Belfour is part of the team. So how can you say that the Senators lost as a team and the Leafs won as a team but then say that the Sens played better overall if Befour's brillance equates into the team performance?

I'm gonna make up numbers but lets say there was some formula that determined which team won:

Ottawa:
Forwards (7) + Defence (6) + Goaltending (5) = 18

Toronto:
Forwards (4) + Defense (5) +Goaltending (9.5) = 18.5

So even though the Sens skaters were outplaying Leafs skaters, it was Toronto's goaltending contribution to the team total that put them over the top.

Now we can say that Ottawa had better balance of contributers while Toronto relied on one guy much more for their teams performance. But overall Toronto's goaltending did pull the TEAM over the top.

When the Chicago Bulls were winning championship after championship in the 90's were people saying "Well we outplayed most of your players and the only reason you won is because you had Michael Jordan on your team. Without him bailing you out we would have beat you guys. Your other guys did squat. We outperformed you guys as a whole and we're a better team even though we lost" ? No, Jordan was the star of the Chicago Bulls and made the Bulls a better team than the others. His contributions pulled his teams to outperform over the opposition. The 72-10 Bulls are considered one of the best teams off all times. Michael Jordan was just a really really big part of the team. There is no asterisk next to that record that says they are only 72-10 and have the best record in NBA history because of Michael Jordan.
 
superquad1968 said:
Why the Mudslinging?

I get your argument and in fact i can read. I just don't wish to split hairs or atoms and argue anything that divorces itself from common sense. Though I doubt that you understand common sense. That is my one and only discussion point.

*gone to join the Doctor on the 401. CAR!!!!!*

Why the mudslinging?!
Uh, sorry, it seemed like: you implied that I was giving you a headache; I didn't have an ounce of common sense; I should get over it; and that I like arguing with myself.

Hey, if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.

Thanks for your incredibly lame contribution, though.
 
Cnd-Guy said:
*sigh* Here we go again.
Marleau is part of the TEAM, San Jose won, therefore San Jose outplayed Colorado

Hey, I think you're finally getting it Cnd-Guy!

Oh, never mind - it's unlikely.
 
Don said:
ok, I'm gonna jump in here. I haven't read all the posts but...

Holy crap! Someone actually undertstands what I'm talking about! It's a miracle! LOL

You are EXACTLY right on, Don.

I want to thank the Academy, God, and my mother! You like me! You really really like me!

;)

Yeah, nobody ever said "Jordan stole one".
 
Ranger: I get you argument (and Don put into words and a much more descriptive analogy) and I do see where you are coming from. You argument makes perfect sense IF as someone has already stated, you want to ignore the ability to disect the whole then you are perfectly right.

My position is that to ignore the parts is to have a meaningless, or at the very least a short discussion. In your argument the parts are irrelevant therefore the only thing we can debate is the final score.

It is a team game, there is no "I" in team, etc. blah, blah, blah.

Don's point about the Bulls is true given that over time we forget the details and focus on the general. Jordan at that time carried the Bulls with the help of Pippen, Kucoc, Rodman, etc. But it is hard to "steal" a basketball game in the same way that only a goalie can "steal" a hockey game. Goalies are that dominant to the success of a team. The only two basketball players I can think of who possibly can are Iverson pre-injury and Shaq.

And hey thanks for being the smartest person on the board. Apparantly you are right and most everyone else is wrong.

SQ
 
guys.....the series was over 5 days ago....the leafs won...the senators lost. We can try to analyze this and offer our opinions on who outplayed who but the outcome won't change.

In the end does it really matter...what is obvious is that certain Sens fans feel one way and certain Leaf fans feel the other way and nothing is going to change that.

Can't we all just get along
 
superquad1968 said:
Ranger: I get you argument (and Don put into words and a much more descriptive analogy) and I do see where you are coming from. You argument makes perfect sense IF as someone has already stated, you want to ignore the ability to disect the whole then you are perfectly right.

Utter nonsense. I've already responded to this. Dissect the team all you like. But then you're no longer talking about the team "as a whole", which is what this discussion is about.

Is there something you want to discuss about *individual components* of the team? Go ahead. Who's stopping you?

superquad1968 said:
And hey thanks for being the smartest person on the board. Apparantly you are right and most everyone else is wrong.

SQ

I can't help it if you're wrong. You could learn to listen to reason. Or just learn to read. Sorry.
 
galt said:
guys.....the series was over 5 days ago....the leafs won...the senators lost. We can try to analyze this and offer our opinions on who outplayed who but the outcome won't change.

In the end does it really matter...what is obvious is that certain Sens fans feel one way and certain Leaf fans feel the other way and nothing is going to change that.

Can't we all just get along

I can get along with everyone who doesn't insult me because they don't understand my argument.
:)
And my argument isn't just about this one series - it's about all series where a goaltender is the best player on the ice.
 
superquad1968 said:
But it is hard to "steal" a basketball game in the same way that only a goalie can "steal" a hockey game. Goalies are that dominant to the success of a team.

Yeah in team sports very little individuals can have such a dominant effect on a team like a hot goalie in hockey. The only thing I can think of where an individual can have more of an impact in a team sport is a dominating pitcher in baseball.

Anyway I think everyone here agrees that like Jordan sometimes had to bail his teammates out when they are having a crap games, Eddie totally bailed the Leafs out that whole series and the Leafs were lucky that Belfour was above and beyond his game.
 
For the 3rd time. I understand, and have read believe it or not, your argument. If you want to narrow it down to simply a score then go ahead. I prefer to delve a little bit deeper and try to understand what led a team to victory or defeat. Most of this section does do that. That's what makes it fun to be a fan.

Simply because someone does not agree with your hypothesis does it make them wrong. Just a difference of opinion.

SQ
 
Don said:
Yeah in team sports very little individuals can have such a dominant effect on a team like a hot goalie in hockey. The only thing I can think of where an individual can have more of an impact in a team sport is a dominating pitcher in baseball.


Perhaps in a single game a pitcher can have a more dominant effect but in a playoff series there is no player in professional sports that can have more of an effect than a hot goaltender. A goaltender can play every second of a playoff series and win four straight for their team. How many pitchers can you name who have played 9 innings in four straight games to single-handedly win a series. A single hot pitcher isn't going to win a championship in baseball.
 
It is impossible to dispute that the goalie is part of the team. The real statement to argue is if the "score" is the true indicator of which team played better.

If the score is a valid test of the better team and the goalie is indisputably part of the team then the better team won, i.e. they outplayed the other team as indicated by the score.

The only way you can debate that is if you say the better team did not win, which means you are saying the score is not a true indicator of which team outplayed the other, not who's part of the team and who's not.

Since Ranger said outplaying relates to winning (the score) "almost" all the time then it really is hard to dispute his statement. By qualifying his statement he's acknowledging what superquad said about the game being more than the score. I think everybody understands everybody else's points (they're not that difficult) but you seem to be arguing different issues.

Ranger says since the Leafs won the series, it means they (including Belfour) outplayed the Sens. The only part that can be refuted relates to your definition of outplaying. You would say that just because they won they did not necessarily outplay their opponent and that they can therefore say that, with or without Belfour, the Leafs were outplayed.

Now let's stop talking about this already and talk about some real sports like the dog shows or world's strongest man.
 
Don said:
Yeah in team sports very little individuals can have such a dominant effect on a team like a hot goalie in hockey. The only thing I can think of where an individual can have more of an impact in a team sport is a dominating pitcher in baseball.

Anyway I think everyone here agrees that like Jordan sometimes had to bail his teammates out when they are having a crap games, Eddie totally bailed the Leafs out that whole series and the Leafs were lucky that Belfour was above and beyond his game.

Yes, a goaltender has more influence in a hockey game than perhaps any other single individual in any team sport I can think of. Even a dominating pitcher in baseball only starts every four games, or, if a reliever, appears every other game for an inning and a bit, at most.

The rest of the Leafs certainly were lucky that Belfour was performing above even his standard in the first round.
 
superquad1968 said:
For the 3rd time. I understand, and have read believe it or not, your argument. If you want to narrow it down to simply a score then go ahead. I prefer to delve a little bit deeper and try to understand what led a team to victory or defeat. Most of this section does do that. That's what makes it fun to be a fan.

Simply because someone does not agree with your hypothesis does it make them wrong. Just a difference of opinion.

SQ

Once again, you fail to grasp an essential part of my argument.
I enjoy "delving" to "try to understand what led a team to victory or defeat", too, as much as anyone.

Look, I could do the same thing. Let's say you come to the conclusion that Belfour was the Leafs' best player in the first round. I could then accuse you of not delving enough - what MADE Belfour the best player? What components of his game were better or worse than Lalime's? Prusek's? Break it down game by game? .....

You can break down a game as much or as little as you like, and so can I, and everyone else.

MY POINT IS (to take a *specific example*):
When you don't break the games down AT ALL, in the first series, and just look at them as a final result - TORONTO OUTPLAYED OTTAWA.
Period.
Now, feel free to break it down all you like, and we can choose to agree or disagree.

Do you have a difference of opinion with my "hypothesis"?
 
shack said:
It is impossible to dispute that the goalie is part of the team. The real statement to argue is if the "score" is the true indicator of which team played better.

If the score is a valid test of the better team and the goalie is indisputably part of the team then the better team won, i.e. they outplayed the other team as indicated by the score.

The only way you can debate that is if you say the better team did not win, which means you are saying the score is not a true indicator of which team outplayed the other, not who's part of the team and who's not.

Since Ranger said outplaying relates to winning (the score) "almost" all the time then it really is hard to dispute his statement. By qualifying his statement he's acknowledging what superquad said about the game being more than the score. I think everybody understands everybody else's points (they're not that difficult) but you seem to be arguing different issues.

Ranger says since the Leafs won the series, it means they (including Belfour) outplayed the Sens. The only part that can be refuted relates to your definition of outplaying. You would say that just because they won they did not necessarily outplay their opponent and that they can therefore say that, with or without Belfour, the Leafs were outplayed.

Now let's stop talking about this already and talk about some real sports like the dog shows or world's strongest man.

Hear hear, shack. You've nailed it.
There really isn't any (much) disputing what I've said - the score is the score.

That having been said, let the analyses go on from there - WHY did the Leafs outplay the Senators, for instance? (Of course, the answer is obvious. ;) ...)

Oh, actually, my qualification was really NOT about how a game can be more than the score - it would be in the rare case where truly fluke occurrences happen, or the officiating is perhaps SO biased it surpasses belief. Games like this happen so rarely, you may as well NOT qualify my statement.

Just to make things clear.
 
shack said:
It is impossible to dispute that the goalie is part of the team. The real statement to argue is if the "score" is the true indicator of which team played better.

If the score is a valid test of the better team and the goalie is indisputably part of the team then the better team won, i.e. they outplayed the other team as indicated by the score.

The only way you can debate that is if you say the better team did not win, which means you are saying the score is not a true indicator of which team outplayed the other, not who's part of the team and who's not.

Since Ranger said outplaying relates to winning (the score) "almost" all the time then it really is hard to dispute his statement. By qualifying his statement he's acknowledging what superquad said about the game being more than the score. I think everybody understands everybody else's points (they're not that difficult) but you seem to be arguing different issues.

Ranger says since the Leafs won the series, it means they (including Belfour) outplayed the Sens. The only part that can be refuted relates to your definition of outplaying. You would say that just because they won they did not necessarily outplay their opponent and that they can therefore say that, with or without Belfour, the Leafs were outplayed.

Now let's stop talking about this already and talk about some real sports like the dog shows or world's strongest man.

A good and accurate post. I only hope Leaf fans remember this when ou team loses to Philly. No excuses........the better team wins!
 
Don said:
I'm gonna make up numbers but lets say there was some formula that determined which team won:

Ottawa:
Forwards (7) + Defence (6) + Goaltending (5) = 18

Toronto:
Forwards (4) + Defense (5) +Goaltending (9.5) = 18.5

So even though the Sens skaters were outplaying Leafs skaters, it was Toronto's goaltending contribution to the team total that put them over the top.

Now we can say that Ottawa had better balance of contributers while Toronto relied on one guy much more for their teams performance. But overall Toronto's goaltending did pull the TEAM over the top.
While we're pulling figures out of our collective asses, how about the following (my interpretation of the series):

Ottawa:
Forwards (8) + Defence (6) + Goaltending (5) = 19

Toronto:
Forwards (4) + Defense (4) +Goaltending (9.5) = 17.5

OH MY GOD! By Don's "formula", the Senators OUTPLAYED THE LEAFS!!!!!

</just disturbing shit, and making a point>

P.S. I think for most of the game yesterday, Toronto OUTPLAYED Philadelphia. But Toronto lost.
 
"Excuses".
Silly word.
Anyway
Yes, scubadoo, you may have finally grasped the concept:
whoever wins a series has outplayed the other team.
:)
Maybe it's time for YOU to finally admit it about the first round - or talk to some of your Sens fans friends about that fact.
 
Goober Mcfly said:
While we're pulling figures out of our collective asses, how about the following (my interpretation of the series):

Ottawa:
Forwards (8) + Defence (6) + Goaltending (5) = 19

Toronto:
Forwards (4) + Defense (4) +Goaltending (9.5) = 17.5

OH MY GOD! By Don's "formula", the Senators OUTPLAYED THE LEAFS!!!!!

</just disturbing shit, and making a point>

P.S. I think for most of the game yesterday, Toronto OUTPLAYED Philadelphia. But Toronto lost.

Well, Goober, I think you clearly don't understand much about what we're saying in here.
How is it possible that Toronto's team score, including goaltending, was less than Ottawa's team score, AND YET THE LEAFS WON?! LOL
You failed to make any point, except that you really don't understand anything.

And, you're wrong - for most of the game, Toronto was being outplayed (including goaltending). At the end of the game, we had been outplayed.
Again, you fail to properly, accurately qualify your statement - the Toronto SKATERS outplayed the Philly skaters for most of the game, but lost anyway.

You really should just give up.
;)