Ottawa may reverse CRTC's Internet ruling

"We are convinced that Internet services are no different than other public utilities, and the vast majority of Internet users should not be asked to subsidize a small minority of heavy users," he told a parliamentary committee.


What and astonishingly clueless moron this guy is. The marginal cost of bandwidth is FALLING LIKE A ROCK and has been for decades. Also, don't electricity resellers buy power and resell it? Why does Internet have to be any different. As far as I know, the resellers buy capacity in bulk and resell it. Ther offer extra capacity by aggregating users and buying more volume.
 
A few things:

- As I said before, to say that the Internet is like most other public utilities is bullshit. With most other public utilities like water and electricity there is a built-in desire and public good to *SAVE* on usage. These are scarce resources. Charging by usage makes complete sense because the less I use, the more I conserve. It is simple.

- There is no such scarcity in Bandwidth.

- They keep saying that light users should not have to subsidize heavy ones - well, will my monthly rate DROP as a result of UBB if I am a light user? Hell no it won't, so why would I want to support it?

- As for electricity suppliers, they do not buy excess capacity or excess production as electricity cannot be stored. For electricity, a reseller generally has to be an electricity producer and pump electricity into the grid. What they do is pump-in the amount of electricity that their customers use. Someone could correct me on this if I'm wrong, but that's the impression I have.

Well, electricity is traded on a market, but moving it is costly and capacity constrained. The infrastructure cost to move and transmit electricity is not dropping the same way bandwidth is dropping, technology is driving down the cost of bandwidth exponentially. It was also quite amusing how Rogers and Bell were crowing about Toronto Hydro building a wireless network. I say Toronto Hydro should jump right in there. Add another competitor to the mix. Also the GOVT should license a specific spectrum for 4G, with Bell and Rogers NOT BEING ALLOWED TO BID. Initially in the metro areas for data only.
 
Nominated for the most Sarcastic Post of the Year Award.

I fixed your post. Let's face it. If governments rule by popularity polls, we would all have free Internet, cellphones, water, electricity, gaz, housing, women, etc. Human nature is human nature.
 
But that raises the broader question. Why do we have metering for my water, electricity, gaz, etc.? Why can't I just pay $10 a month for all the electricity I want? Can we start an online petition for no meter electricity?

Sure you can, you just won't get any because $10 is drastically below the cost of providing it. The surcharges Bell and Rogers charge are billed at a gross margin of about 2700%... are you really that stupid or are you just trolling?
 
a gross margin of about 2700%...

Where did the 2700% come from? I heard that some people are using the "incremental" cost in their argument. Sort of like saying the incremental cost of driving your car one kilometre is 10cent. In MBA school they taught us to use the "fully loaded" cost as the true cost of a product or service.
 
Isn't it interesting that they all raise their
prices to the same amount...so there's no competition on price.

It is in the nature of Canadians to whine about gas prices, bank charges, telephone bills, cable, etc. Ever notice that similar houses in the Beach (I still like to call it the Beaches) are all basically priced the same? Where is the competition?
 
It is in the nature of Canadians to whine about gas prices, bank charges, telephone bills, cable, etc. Ever notice that similar houses in the Beach (I still like to call it the Beaches) are all basically priced the same? Where is the competition?

If one wants the money fast, there is competiton in real estate. My friend lived in north Toronto in a nice area. The houses there were selling for 1,750,000 in that area at the time on average. They were usually on the market a few weeks to a couple of months befoee finding a buyer. One guy on the street for some reason wanted money to split town fast - he listed his house for 1,000,000. immediate occupancy - money paid right now with no waiting for mortage approvals. It sold the first day it was listed, by 1pm. I saw the agent put up the for sale sign on the lawn at 9am with an open house as well, and then the agent put a 'sold' up on the sign at 12:45pm.
 
If one wants the money fast, there is competiton in real estate.

Actually, the best competition for real estate is in U.S. foreclosed houses or so I heard. They actually hold open auctions.

Advice: Be careful about buying a house from someone who is in a hurry to sell at a deep discount to market. Make sure you put up big signs saying the previous owner is gone and this house is under NEW ownership.
 
But not by popularity polls. Decisions should be based on principles, not politics. Of course, virtually everybody wants free Internet.

There is no evidence whatsoever that this CRTC decision was based on principles of any sort.

It was based on the complete and utter failure of the CRTC to differentiate between wholesale and retail tarrifs: because of a regulatory decision regarding wholesale bandwidth charges, the CRTC chose to impose a cap on retail bandwidth offerings. Utterly ridiculous and devoid of any principle.