Ottawa may reverse CRTC's Internet ruling

Can someone please explain what this is about?

As I understand it, the fact is that people are moving over to getting their TV off the internet, and dropping their cable etc payments to Rogers and Bell. And, if you do that, you only pay Rogers for internet, and you stop paying them for cable TV as well.

So Rogers, seeing the way the wind is blowing, say they wanna put a meter on our internet usage.

That way, of course we'll wind up paying more for intenet-with-TV than we used to pay for internet in addition to cable TV. The CRTC agreed with Rogers and Bell that they could go ahead with metering the internet -- how else, agreed the CRTC, are Rogers and Bell gonna continue the revenue stream to which they have become accustomed?

Clements/Harper now say no, the internet has always been unlimited (as has cable TV). Metering is bad. It is not the CRTC's job to provide income for distributors.

The way I see it, of course the program providers and stations have a right to be paid. But I don't see that the distributors have a god-given right to be paid. Certainly not at the rates they are going to be able to screw out of us if metering goes ahead.

If Rogers and Bell now find themselves with a shrinking market, they must come to terms with that, just as so many other industries before them have had to do.
 
Can someone please explain what this is about?

As I understand it, the fact is that people are moving over to getting their TV off the internet, and dropping their cable etc payments to Rogers and Bell. And, if you do that, you only pay Rogers for internet, and you stop paying them for cable TV as well.

So Rogers, seeing the way the wind is blowing, say they wanna put a meter on our internet usage.

That way, of course we'll wind up paying more for intenet-with-TV than we used to pay for internet in addition to cable TV. The CRTC agreed with Rogers and Bell that they could go ahead with metering the internet -- how else, agreed the CRTC, are Rogers and Bell gonna continue the revenue stream to which they have become accustomed?

Clements/Harper now say no, the internet has always been unlimited (as has cable TV). Metering is bad. It is not the CRTC's job to provide income for distributors.

The way I see it, of course the program providers and stations have a right to be paid. But I don't see that the distributors have a god-given right to be paid. Certainly not at the rates they are going to be able to screw out of us if metering goes ahead.

If Rogers and Bell now find themselves with a shrinking market, they must come to terms with that, just as so many other industries before them have had to do.

You seem to understand it pretty well. ;)

Bell and Rogers want to prevent other content providers from even getting a foothold here. Netflix is the most often cited because they just started up here recently, but I think the truly scarey competitors for Bell and Rogers are Google and Apple. With their t.v. services, those providers could really steal a lot of business Bell and Rogers. Google and Apple want to allow consumers to pay for only what they purchase. Their models will in all likelihood do to t.v. what competition did for long distance calling--allow people to buy only what they want and pay much less. That's what Bell and Rogers want to prevent and that's why EVERYONE, not just "heavy users" of the internet should be riled by what Bell and Rogers (and their puppet the CRTC), are trying to pull here.
 
The way I see it, of course the program providers and stations have a right to be paid. But I don't see that the distributors have a god-given right to be paid. Certainly not at the rates they are going to be able to screw out of us if metering goes ahead.

I suppose one can make the same argument for any service where a distributor is involved. Why should we pay Enbridge for distributing gaz and why should we pay Toronto Hydro for distributing electricity?
 
I suppose one can make the same argument for any service where a distributor is involved. Why should we pay Enbridge for distributing gaz and why should we pay Toronto Hydro for distributing electricity?

If a cheaper way of delivering the desired product becomes possible, where we don't have to pay the distributors what they've gotten used to, then yes, that's the way we've gotta go. The regulators must act first in the public interest, not in the interests of preserving revenue streams.
 
It isn't that distributors don't have a right to be paid. They do. But the analogy is a faulty one. A better one would be if Bell and Rogers were selling milk, but bought all the cows, pasture and dairy trucks, then told you not only how much your were going to pay for milk, but also how much cheese and cream you'd have to buy from them to get your milk.
 
A better one would be if Bell and Rogers were selling milk, but bought all the cows, pasture and dairy trucks, then told you not only how much your were going to pay for milk, but also how much cheese and cream you'd have to buy from them to get your milk.

Man, this is getting more complicated than first meets the eye. Aren't Bell and Rogers REGULATED monopolies and their revenue rates are set by the government or a government agency?
 
Man, this is getting more complicated than first meets the eye. Aren't Bell and Rogers REGULATED monopolies and their revenue rates are set by the government or a government agency?

You're having me on now? ;)

The fact they both sell internet, tv and phone services should be enough to tell you there is no monopoly here. They are subject to regulations that the CRTC can impose, but many believe (me included), that they've got the CRTC in their pocket. Just today the Chairman of the CRTC blithely admitted that the idea of the 15% deduction for third party ISPs (which the CRTC tried to impose in their most recent ruling), came from Bell!!

The shame is that this is not a complicated situation, but most of the public has been acting like sheep being led to the Bell and Rogers slaughterhouse buying the bullshit line that the duopoly simply wants customers to pay for what they use. If they want to introduce true UBB, I'd be fine with that, but they must reveal what it costs them to provide consumers with a gb of data transmission. Then we can figure out a fair price, and I'd be willing to pay for exactly what I use. But they'd never want to do that.

The CRTC should revise their position by increasing, not lessening competition. Then the government should take longer term action. The truth is that there is no lack of bandwidth in Canada right now. But if everyone suddenly wanted to begin using 300 gb a month, that would change. We should do as other countries have done, make major infrastructure investments now, (Australia is spending 45 Billion), and then open up the network to private providers and let them compete for privilege of delivering the service.
 
Glad to see government getting involved and saying they will overturn the CRTC. I don't like metering. That said, I don't usually use more than 50 GB a month anyway, but I think everyone will be using more as the technology of entertainment-delivery changes.

It seems the CRTC is in Bell's pocket, and the CRTC has no accountability to voters. Government is accountable to a degree, and this issue is one that costs the government little to nothing while making politicians seem on the side of the people. No wonder the Liberals and NDP quickly said they supported consumers, and the Conservatives quickly got on board too. So good, it shows how our democracy works. In Egypt they take to the streets with pitchforks and torches; here we sign online petitions and the government appeases us.
 
The fact they both sell internet, tv and phone services should be enough to tell you there is no monopoly here.

One thing I know for sure. Only Rogers is allowed to sell cable TV in my area, nobody else. In return for this monopoly, the rate that Rogers is allowed to charge is set by government (probably the CRTC).

There are lots of regulated monopolies in Canada. Here are some examples: Enbridge, Toronto Hydro, TransCanada Pipelines, etc.
 
Yup, so far the response has been encouraging. I think Bell and Rogers were clumsy with their greed and underestimated how pissed people would be. It wasn't enough for them to have 95% of the market and crazy profits, they have to try and close off any possible future competition. The public will have to maintain the political pressure and be vigilant, or they'll find another way to realize their evil goals. ;)
 
One thing I know for sure. Only Rogers is allowed to sell cable TV in my area, nobody else. In return for this monopoly, the rate that Rogers is allowed to charge is set by government (probably the CRTC).

There are lots of regulated monopolies in Canada. Here are some examples: Enbridge, Toronto Hydro, TransCanada Pipelines, etc.

Right.
 
Glad to see government getting involved and saying they will overturn the CRTC. I don't like metering.

But that raises the broader question. Why do we have metering for my water, electricity, gaz, etc.? Why can't I just pay $10 a month for all the electricity I want? Can we start an online petition for no meter electricity?
 
Rockslinger, if you want to take an intelligent part in this discussion, read the article by Geist that I posted above. That may help you to understand why water and electricity are not good comparisons to the internet situation in Canada.
 
But if everyone suddenly wanted to begin using 300 gb a month, that would change. We should do as other countries have done, make major infrastructure investments now, (Australia is spending 45 Billion), and then open up the network to private providers and let them compete for privilege of delivering the service.

+1. The time will come when everyone will want 300 GB a month, so best to start infastructure improvements now.

My monthly unlimited plan usage record was 1.3 TB, but I can get by with 50 GB most months. However, I think the Internet will move to be the backbone of home delivery of entertainment. One reason is people feel gouged by Rogers and Bell on entertainment fees and see the internet as an affordable alteranative to save money. Just as fewer by album CD's for $20 and more download songs at a dollar each from itunes. If you only like 2 songs on the album, you get what you want for $2. If you only watch 2 TV shows a week, why pay a high monthly fee to watch everything - just but the 2 shows you like a la carte. Unlimited internet downloads for a set reasonable monthly fee are the path to moving entertainment to this model. Of course Bell and Roger's don't like it, Bell would rather you paid a flat fee for your sat dish monthly service. If more competition comes in via the net, Bell and Rogers can still compete, they just have to adjust prices to do so and make less profit, which they don't like. If competeion is allowed, sure, Bell can charge whatever it likes and set limits on use - but they will see a huge number (half?) of their customers jump ship to the competition. This won't happen as they will lower prices to compete and still make handsome profits.
 
Exactly. Bell and Rogers want to have their cake and eat it too. They want to charge exhorbitant fees (relative to the service they provide) and dictate to customers how they can use their internet service and how they get their video content. I'm surprised more people haven't pointed out how Bell and Rogers don't count their video on demand services towards your internet usage, but if you get your video from youtube or Netflix, suddenly they are very concerned about the bandwidth.

If Apple and or Google succeed in negotiating good content deals (and I think they eventually will), then the jig will be up for Rogers and Bell. If Canadians look south of the border and see that folks down there can pay 99 cents for a t.v. show and four bucks for a movie--paying just for what they want--and not locked into bloated "package" deals, they will holler for the same up here.
 
Yes, people's need for bandwidth will continue to go up. Rogers says it grows at 40% a year.

I remember back in 1984 I went in to The Bay at Bloor & Yonge to the IBM computer boutique they had in store. The salesman was trying to sell me a brand new just released IBM AT PC ("286"). It had a hard drive. Forget about 5.25 floppy discs with this baby, he said. I asked what the hard drive capacity was, and he beamed that it was a huge 20 MB in size. Is that big enough? I asked. Oh yes, he said, it is big enough to store every letter one has ever written in life - who could want or need a bigger hard drive than that. The XT had a 10 MB hard drive, but this new one is twice the size and more than one could ever need.

Now 27 years later I have multiple 1 TB hard drives (3) in my PC clone (IBM doesn't even make PCs anymore, so not really a clone lol). I use them all. Digital photos (didn't exist in a consumer form in 1984) are often jpegs of 4 MB each in size, so that old hard drive would hold what - 4 pictures lol. Technology changes. Back in 1984 most people used a home PC for personal finances and writing letters instead of using a typewriter (remember dot matrix printers). Today we do so much more that most people in 1984 didn't even dream of. If I told that salesman I wanted 3 TB of hard drive storage space internally in my PC he would have been floored lol, TB? TB?!

Point is, things change. Internet use will skyrocket over the next 10 years, unless Bell gets its way of course. I wonder, what if the hard drive manufacturers in 1984 had tried to cap hard drive storage space at 20 MB to prevent having to spend money to develop bigger hard drives? BTW my computer with 3TB cost 1/4 as much 2 years ago as that IBM AT cost with its 20 MB drive in 1984 - and that is using 1$ in 1984 = 1$ in 2009 at par, not taking into account the higher buying power of a dollar in 1984 vs 2009. If that was worked in the new one would have cost much less than 25% the price of the other one.
 
didn't bill gates say 640k ought to be enough for anybody? ;)

Bell and Rogers can't keep the demand from happening. They're just trying to hold off the day when they'll have to actually compete for their profits. What's damning is that they're perfectly willing to retard internet use and development in Canada to do so.
 
I don't think that's true. The electorate has also shown a strong interest in low taxes, and generally has been intelligent enough to worry reasonably about the deficit as well. So I think the electorate is a bit more sophisticated than you're giving credit for.

you would be talking about the electorate that elected our darling Dalton not once but twice (you know the guy who doesn't increace our taxes)........i'm not so sure about that sophisticated part????