Oscar Pistouris Trial

he's laying it on pretty thick hey?
sobbing, vomiting...

My thoughts exactly.

From what I've read about the guy, he seemed like a loose cannon.

I find it real hard to believe his story. Real hard. (As do her parents it seems.)
 
The guy is going down...for one simple reason.

He contends that an intruder had entered his washroom through a window and he had to deal with it.

HOWEVER...simple fact is, the girlfriend went in to sit down and use the facilities.

She took three rounds....the fourth one missed...likely because she fell off the toilet.

Now...logically....if I think someone is coming in THROUGH MY WINDOW..I shoot into bathroom AT THE WINDOW. STRAIGHT INTO THE ROOM AT CHEST HEIGHT.

BUT NO.....he directed his shots directly at the victim seated and off to the side in a low position.

Only he knew where she was seated and where to shoot.

The guy is toast.
 
I don't think he has a leg to stand on. Okay, someone was going to say it. :D

Pretty girl, what a waste.

article-reeva-fhm2-0214.jpg
 
The guy is going down...for one simple reason.

He contends that an intruder had entered his washroom through a window and he had to deal with it.

HOWEVER...simple fact is, the girlfriend went in to sit down and use the facilities.

She took three rounds....the fourth one missed...likely because she fell off the toilet.

Now...logically....if I think someone is coming in THROUGH MY WINDOW..I shoot into bathroom AT THE WINDOW. STRAIGHT INTO THE ROOM AT CHEST HEIGHT.

BUT NO.....he directed his shots directly at the victim seated and off to the side in a low position.

Only he knew where she was seated and where to shoot.

The guy is toast.
Seeing as she went in to the bathroom to get away from him during an argument as opposed to having to perform bodily functions, your theory has more holes in it than the bathroom door.

I agree he's guilty as shit.
 
Seeing as she went in to the bathroom to get away from him during an argument as opposed to having to perform bodily functions, your theory has more holes in it than the bathroom door.

I agree he's guilty as shit.

I hope the judge will do well.
 
Seeing as she went in to the bathroom to get away from him during an argument as opposed to having to perform bodily functions, your theory has more holes in it than the bathroom door.

I agree he's guilty as shit.

Yes, she was wearing a top and shorts - how many girls get dressed to go to the bathroom ? She was trapped - unable to leave and he shot her.

Add my vote to the Guilty column.
 
I wouldn't deliberate for more than a minute as I find his scenario very hard to believe. What's the maximum penalty?
 
Yes, she was wearing a top and shorts - how many girls get dressed to go to the bathroom ? She was trapped - unable to leave and he shot her.

Add my vote to the Guilty column.

You are spot on. Who locks the door when they go to the bathroom in the middle of the night?
 
Also, according to his version, he stated he yelled at whomever was in the washroom before he shot...now wouldn't she have said "it's just me?"... Guilty and I hope he enjoys his new life in prison.
 
My thoughts exactly.

From what I've read about the guy, he seemed like a loose cannon.

I find it real hard to believe his story. Real hard. (As do her parents it seems.)

I agree

These antics tip me towards guilty
 
Think about it, GRAPHIC AUTOPSY evidence of someone you love....I'd be I'll too!

How about GRAPHIC AUTOPSY of anyone you knew ?? He didn't have a stomach problem when witnesses saw after the shooting beside the body.

He is a hot headed cowardly spoiled brat who let fame go to his head. Think Bieber as a double amputee.
 
Reports I heard from the neighbour/doctor who on the scene moments later said he was crying and shaking, holding her head, and praying for her to survive!

Don't know where you getting the "cowardly" part. All these public figures are prima Dona's.

Understandibly he was sorry he killed her. He realized that he would be locked up for life.

Why would you shoot through the bathroom door, if you have a powerful gun? Why not Point the gun at the door and see who comes out. Does not make sense.

What makes sense is that the girl dressed and wanted to get away from him and locked herself in the bathroom.
 
Don't know where you getting the "cowardly" part.

You are holding a gun at someone hiding in a locked bathroom. The door isn't opening, (forgetting that Pistouris was most likely aware from the shouting who was in there) would you not ask who was there before firing ? You wouldn't care if you were a coward - you would just start shooting.
 
Understandibly he was sorry he killed her. He realized that he would be locked up for life.

Why would you shoot through the bathroom door, if you have a powerful gun? Why not Point the gun at the door and see who comes out. Does not make sense.

What makes sense is that the girl dressed and wanted to get away from him and locked herself in the bathroom.
I just don't know, and thank God I'm not in a position where I have to analyze either what he has said or his legal argument!
 
vomiting and crying, pooooor little baby. What an "Oscar" performance! He deserves an award...............................GUILTY! Off with his head.
 
More like "smart".
It's not like TV or the movies: Where everybody who holds a gun becomes an instant cool hand and expert shot.
Every person you confront when you hold a gun doesn't automatically quake in fear because you have a gun, throw down their gun and accede to your every demand when you threaten them.
And calling through a closed door could get you gunned down right through it by some creep with an AK47!

He thought he'd left her in the bedroom, heard a noise that sounded like someone breaking in through the bathroom window, shot, heard her screams presuming they were from the bedroom and that she was being assaulted there so fired to finish off the guy in the can and go rescue her. The story seems fully plausible to me and the evidence against is pretty paltry supposition from neighbours as to what they heard and over-extrapolated as to what they "think" it means.

It's amazing he hasn't knocked off a few paperboys and girl scouts selling cookies because you don't know who maybe ringing the doorbell.

I suppose the story is plausible if he is a sniveling little coward who screams like a like a girl and puts a few bullets into a closed bathroom not knowing if there was a girl, guy, or 12 year old terrified autograph collector. I wouldn't shoot and I am not a gun enthusiast with experience in firing in public places when in a rage. If a guy has an AK-47 which he intends on firing - why the fuck would he lock himself in the bathroom ????? As sniper nests go - the view and maneuverable area wouldn't make a locked bathroom a prime choice unless the guy breaking in was as much a gutless coward as Pistouris is. The other interesting little caveat to Pistouris's highly plausible scenario is that with the bathroom entrance covered and one intruder shrewdly locking himself into the bathroom (maybe he needed to take a dump) - his partner gets by Pistouris and ignores him to busy himself attacking the girlfriend. :confused:

As for the 'paltry' supposition from three independent neighbours who without flinching from their story under intense cross examination - all heard two distinct voices male & female arguing before the shooting .... I have heard couples argue and this is not a leap of faith to recognize it. It is much easier to accept when three different witnesses come forward. And it is much, much easier to accept their version than the absolutely ludicrous story that Pistouris dreamed up to explain his deadly behaviour.

Ladies & gentlemen - the prosecution rests. When the jury returns - I'll be in the hardware store buying a length of rope.