Ontario, Greece

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
I've been watching BNN the past couple of days. Drummond Report and all that. It has been said at least a couple of times that Ontario is on the same track as Greece:Eek: but 10 years behind.
 
its nice catchy expression but what facts back that up?
 
Oops, just noticed there is already a thread on the Drummond Report in the Political Forum. Why is this subject in the Political Forum?

Anyway, the guests on BNN said that the debt and deficit in Ontario must be brought under control starting now before it overwhelms us.
 
they need to be brought under control- but its hardly a greek tragedy just yet.
 
I've been watching BNN the past couple of days. Drummond Report and all that. It has been said at least a couple of times that Ontario is on the same track as Greece:Eek: but 10 years behind.

Greece is the new Hitler. Anytime you mention it you lose. Greece has become right wing code for 'don't raise taxes but gut services'. Does Ontario need a program review? Yes. Should it restrain wage and spending growth? Yes. Should there be a tax review? YES, and that should include the possibility of reasonable increases. Should the feds take their global industrial race to the bottom glasses off, look at oh say Germany, and try to do something for Ontario and Quebec? YES. And should we be getting out slice of the equalization pie? YES, we've certainly given it for long enough.

The whole report was a cagey Liberal move. They whipped out this guy to put the scare in us, so then they can use it as leverage to do far more balanced reforms. (That even this NDPer says are needed in a number of areas.)
 
Should it restrain wage and spending growth? Yes. Should there be a tax review? YES, and that should include the possibility of reasonable increases.

Tax payers are already giving up more than half their income to taxes, and you want more? You are ok with tax increases, i.e., taxpayers having less money to spend and racing taxpayers to the bottom, but you don’t want any cutbacks in the public service on numbers, wages & benefits, just slower growth?

Ontario is on the same track as Greece:Eek: but 10 years behind.

I heard 2-3 years before Ontario starts to hit some walls. People are going to start questioning whether they will get their principle back when they buy Ontario bonds, and if it is worth risking their principle on a 2% or less return after taxes.
 
Tax payers are already giving up more than have their income to taxes, and you want more? You are ok with tax increases

I wouldn't say I want tax increases... I like my money just as much as you, thanks. But given that or deep cuts I'm willing to the sticker price for living in a civilized society. I also didn't say income taxes specifically. Some select, not bottom focused rollbacks of recent cooperate cuts may be needed, along with some fee hikes and new fees, and maybe some examination of the top end of the tax spectrum. And? The alternative isn't Greece but California.

But you don’t want any cutbacks in the public service on numbers, wages & benefits, just slower growth?

Not if they can be reasonably avoided for front line core services. If you can find reasonable efficiencies, find them (a let who needs letting go, go). If you can restrain wage growth in programs and wages over the medium term, well, that might be necessary. If a program is past it's shelf life, axe it. If you need to look at bumping and seniority rules, do it (I'm a socialist for meritocracy, when meritocracy isn't just code for 'find someone cheaper'.).

But that gravy can be hard to find, and people are more compassionate than Conservatives give them credit for.

But slashing and burning out of an ideological hate of government is counterproductive over the long term.
 
Check out the cartoon for today, Feb. 16.

Yeah, I saw that. Hence, the title of this thread is "Ontario, Greece". If nothing is done starting now, the Ontario deficit will hit $30 billion in 5 years. Old Irish proverb: "Pay me now or pay me much more later".
 
You can't spend more than you have.
Most governments will not accept this,but you can't do this ponzi forever!
Hudac had SO much ammunition and he went awal during the election.
The people on Ontario re-elected this A-HOLE premier having experienced 8 years of his socialist WASTE.
I guess you do get what we deserve. Bankruptcy for all.
 
IIRC in 1984 Greece had the same debt to GDP ratio as Ontario [ignoring the federal component]. It does not take long to enter a world of shit and then there you are sitting on the crapper with an M-14 muzzle in your mouth and a full load of 7.62 full metal jacket rounds in the clip.

Sad thing is that if the various governments or more to the point if the various countries had electorates that acted like adults and not children, if they started in 1984 the European countries could have easily paid off their debt by 2008 and had lots of fiscal room to deal with the current situation and a zombie invasion combined. There were many good years there.
 
IIRC in 1984 Greece had the same debt to GDP ratio as Ontario [ignoring the federal component].

That is why Ontario has to act NOW. Ontario has lost its manufacturing base and now has an aging population with little prospect for economic growth. If Ontario tries to tax the 1% any further, they will simply head for Calgary and then Ontario will have the 100% and no more 1%.
 
Those with a Government job have nothing to worry about, Canada is not Greece, absolutely nothing is going to happen to their dream pensions/benefits/salaries.
 
its nice catchy expression but what facts back that up?

Yes, see Drummond Report :frown: Not near Greece yet but give it ten years if we don't change something.
 
Buddies

Those with a Government job have nothing to worry about, Canada is not Greece, absolutely nothing is going to happen to their dream pensions/benefits/salaries.

Mc wimpy's favorite employees, thats who got him elected, NOT you average working stiff.

FAST
 
Those with a Government job have nothing to worry about, Canada is not Greece, absolutely nothing is going to happen to their dream pensions/benefits/salaries.

Heard that the teachers pension plan is underwater (record low interest rates don't help). Teachers can retire on full pension at age 54 and they often live to 135 years old.
 
That is why Ontario has to act NOW. Ontario has lost its manufacturing base and now has an aging population with little prospect for economic growth. If Ontario tries to tax the 1% any further, they will simply head for Calgary and then Ontario will have the 100% and no more 1%.

Fearmongering.
Show me the proof that rich people move when tax rates change.
 
Show me the proof that rich people move when tax rates change.

Then why don't we raise the tax rate to 100%? Money is mobile and so are most humans. If the rich leave and take their money with them we are left with the 200,000 people living in subsidized housing. Show me proof that money is not mobile.
 
true, why would anyone rich live in a frozen shit infested city like toronto? because their business or how they make money is there so these can't simply move away.

Fearmongering.
Show me the proof that rich people move when tax rates change.