Olympics: Perdita Felician

Kev

Crap
Jul 29, 2003
549
0
0
Vancouver
Do i ever feel sorry for this women. She had so much pressure from the media and others to capture the gold that in the end she screwed it up. I feel if everybody would have just just left her alone she probably have the gold medal. --- Kev
 
It’s a major bummer. I’m sure it was nerves.

I know Perdita. I was dating her cousin about 4 years ago and I watched her race when she was trying for the Canadian Olympic team for Sydney. I knew that I’d be reading about her in the news someday.

We haven’t heard the last of her. She’s a fierce competitor and she’ll be back in 2008.
 
yes what a shame :( but I'm sure she will be back to grab the gold in China!
 
Kev said:
I just saw that Canada's Angela Whyte did manage a 6th place finish in the hurdles. So thats positive. --- Kev
Oh yeah .. in a field of 6 :(
 
No, I disagree with the " choke " part. In hurdles , these things sometimes happen and to the best. You hit the top bar with your foot and down it goes and in this case, Perdita went down too.The person I feel really sorry for , is the Russian hurdler who was knocked out of the race by Perdita 's crashing into her. I heard on CBC that the Russian s cuold protest and if the refereee agrees , then the race could be re run , but without Perdita , opf course , who was the cause of this crash. Anyway, I agree. Perdita will get another chance in China in 4 years. She's young yet and she'll get better !
 
n_v said:
Oh yeah .. in a field of 6

When the last time you finished 6th against the world n_v? Thats what i thought.;) You still have to beat other tough competitors to get to the finals. I think its a good result. --- Kev
 
sun said:
The person I feel really sorry for , is the Russian hurdler who was knocked out of the race by Perdita 's crashing into her. I heard on CBC that the Russian s cuold protest and if the refereee agrees , then the race could be re run

I agree. Irina Shevchenko had a chance to medal and that chance was taken away. They should rerun it. But then we can say that wouldn't be fair for the competitors who finished. I wonder whats fair in this situation? Rerun or just let it stand?

They never did have the medal ceremonies so there is a chance that the race could be rerun. --- Kev
 
Kev said:
I agree. Irina Shevchenko had a chance to medal and that chance was taken away. They should rerun it. But then we can say that wouldn't be fair for the competitors who finished. I wonder whats fair in this situation? Rerun or just let it stand?

They never did have the medal ceremonies so there is a chance that the race could be rerun. --- Kev

They shouldn't re-run the race. It's unfair but crashes can happen like they do in speed-skating.... ok that is an exaggeration but still they shouldn't re-run.

I do feel bad for the Russian. It's one thing to screw up and lose but it is another matter to lose because of someone else's screw up.
 
no. it wouldn't be fair to have her race the clock... when training alone, some runners score higher, while others run slower times... and because everyone else had to compete on a 'fair' playing ground, she would have to also...

they probably should re-run the race for the simple fact of what's fair after what occurred. however, the crash aspect is a risk associated with hurdles and oftentimes a crash doesn't necessitate a re-race.
 
While i feel sorry for the russian, the incident is just a part of the race. it happens in cycling and other races as well, if one competitor crashes and inadvertently causes another rider to crash it is just an unfortunate circumstance.

To re-run the race and possibly take away a medal from another athlete would not be fair either.
 
Kathleen said:
The true sad story is for Shevchenko. I have no idea why they wouldn't allow her a chance at a medal. You don't need a re-run for everyone. Just let Shevchenko have a solo run a few minutes later. She would be racing a clock only. If she beat any of the top three runners, she gets a medal.
This is the Olympics, not beat-the-clock. Sorry, but what you posted is ridiculous.
 
ToronToto said:
This is the Olympics, not beat-the-clock. Sorry, but what you posted is ridiculous.

Kathleen was just making a suggestion, no need to call her post "ridiculous"
 
Kev said:
When the last time you finished 6th against the world n_v? Thats what i thought.;) You still have to beat other tough competitors to get to the finals. I think its a good result. --- Kev
Kev, you made it sound as if within the final she accomplished something. Yes taken into context of all the runners in the even that is good, but she still finished last in the final race. Her making it and being in the final was old news.
 
gladheateher said:
Kathleen was just making a suggestion, no need to call her post "ridiculous"
And ToronToto was stating his opinion. You know there were a few posts made in another thread about guys running to the defense of SP's for no apparent reason other than to suck up to them. Grow a spine gladheateher. If Kathleen has a problem with ToronToto's post , then I am sure she is a big enough girl to defend herself.
 
What happened to the Russian girl simply goes with the territory. Going into a hurdles race you are aware of the pitfalls.

Same in cycling, someone might crash in front, which takes out the favorite, it's the nature of the beast.

Sorry Russian girl, but it was not intentional, and it cost our girl and Canada a chance at another medal.

Geoff
 
Geoff's right. Re-running the race would be unfair to the gold medallist, who ran the race of her life.

Here's an interesting question: Had Perdita not fallen, do you think she would have won? Her personal best is slower than the winning time from yesterday's race...
 
Re-running the race is not without precident. It's been done before and is at the discretion of the on field officials. I'm not aware of the conditions that warrant a re-run but I would imagine that if it were the other way around where the favourite(s) are taken out, not of their own doing like Perdita, but because of a pile up or if a certain percentage of the field is wiped out then you re-run.

It's all part of the game...sometimes you're the bug, sometimes you're the windsheild.