O'Leary boat accident...

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,804
5,488
113
I am no fan of that blowhard, but the other boat had no lights on a pitch dark lake and was parked stationary. If it was moving you could possibly hear the engine or see the wake. On top of this the boat that was struck had a dark silvery grey hull. There is no FUCKING WAY you can really be expected to see a boat like that with no lights. If the wife had a drink or 3 is irrelevant IMHO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchual
I am no fan of that blowhard, but the other boat had no lights on a pitch dark lake and was parked stationary. If it was moving you could possibly hear the engine or see the wake. On top of this the boat that was struck had a dark silvery grey hull. There is no FUCKING WAY you can really be expected to see a boat like that with no lights. If the wife had a drink or 3 is irrelevant IMHO.
Actually as the police will not reveal the investigation this is just hearsay - o r one version of the events by the defense. The family apparently is being stone walled by the police. As Leary is an ex tory leader candidate this is not surprising.
 
I am no fan of that blowhard, but the other boat had no lights on a pitch dark lake and was parked stationary. If it was moving you could possibly hear the engine or see the wake. On top of this the boat that was struck had a dark silvery grey hull. There is no FUCKING WAY you can really be expected to see a boat like that with no lights. If the wife had a drink or 3 is irrelevant IMHO.

I agreed with everything you said until you said driving a boat while under the influence is irrelevant.
I hope you or your love ones are never harmed by someone under the influence....but I guess if they were that would be ok by you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchual and Jenesis
I agreed with everything you said until you said driving a boat while under the influence is irrelevant.
I hope you or your love ones are never harmed by someone under the influence....but I guess if they were that would be ok by you.

It is not likely to have contributed to the accident. if you go to lake in the dark, with a dark coloured boat, and park with your lights off, you are asking for it. That is a lake with a lot of boating. I do not endorse boating under the influence, I am just saying it was not a contributory factor. Kinda like having 3 drinks on the highway and another drunk driving the wrong way smashes into you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchual
I'm not a big fan of Leah McLaren

But this is a pretty good overview of the boating incident in Toronto Life.


Apparently there is evidence they switched off the nav lights, none that they switched them back on before the collision, but I agree nav lights close to shore or with background of cottages can be missed.
 
It is not likely to have contributed to the accident. if you go to lake in the dark, with a dark coloured boat, and park with your lights off, you are asking for it. That is a lake with a lot of boating. I do not endorse boating under the influence, I am just saying it was not a contributory factor. Kinda like having 3 drinks on the highway and another drunk driving the wrong way smashes into you.
Assuming the lights were turned off - 75% liability to the owner-operator of the pontoon boat; 25% liability to Mrs O' Leary for the high rate of speed which meant that ANY chance she had of spotting the darkened pontoon in time was negated and for the blood alcohol level ditto.
 
I am no fan of that blowhard, but the other boat had no lights on a pitch dark lake and was parked stationary. If it was moving you could possibly hear the engine or see the wake. On top of this the boat that was struck had a dark silvery grey hull. There is no FUCKING WAY you can really be expected to see a boat like that with no lights. If the wife had a drink or 3 is irrelevant IMHO.

I thought the wife had the drinks after she got to shore
 
I thought the wife had the drinks after she got to shore

Before and after. Her lawyer may have advised her to have a drink before the police came, so nobody could say her blood alcohol level being too high was due to drinks she had before the accident.
 
Before and after. Her lawyer may have advised her to have a drink before the police came, so nobody could say her blood alcohol level being too high was due to drinks she had before the accident.

Can a lawyer testify under oath if called by the plaintive? Can a lawyer loose his license to suggest that to a client? (sorry my knowledge of the law is not that good when lawyer suggest something so sketchy...)
 
Can a lawyer testify under oath if called by the plaintive? Can a lawyer loose his license to suggest that to a client? (sorry my knowledge of the law is not that good when lawyer suggest something so sketchy...)
yes -prove it - no, over 100 cases had cops proven to lie under oath- in one year alone in ontario
 
Can a lawyer testify under oath if called by the plaintive? Can a lawyer loose his license to suggest that to a client? (sorry my knowledge of the law is not that good when lawyer suggest something so sketchy...)
No. Lawyer cannot answer questions about legal advice or legal conversations with a client in private. Solicitor-client privilege.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roadhog
No. Lawyer cannot answer questions about legal advice or legal conversations with a client in private. Solicitor-client privilege.

Ok thanks. But when you write "legal advice" it should read here... "illegal advice" ;)

Cheers,
 
Ok thanks. But when you write "legal advice" it should read here... "illegal advice" ;)

Cheers,
But it's illegal to ask the lawyer if the advice was illegal..... So no one will ever know.
 
yes -prove it - no, over 100 cases had cops proven to lie under oath- in one year alone in ontario
Ohhh fuck, the cops lie - at least a little - in every case. Old lawyer joke: - "How do you tell if a cop is lying?" - Answer: "His / her lips are moving."
 
Assuming the lights were turned off - 75% liability to the owner-operator of the pontoon boat; 25% liability to Mrs O' Leary for the high rate of speed which meant that ANY chance she had of spotting the darkened pontoon in time was negated and for the blood alcohol level ditto.
60/40. She is docked points for being married to a cunt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerbear15