Nuclear Plant struck????

someone up there compared pickering to chernobyl, as I understand it, the difference between the two plants is that chernobyl's reaction process once started, has to be slowed down to prevent melt down where pickering's natural state is "off" and the reaction has to be basically forced to work. Any malfuntion and the process stops.

When chernobyl blew the reaction went wild and continued for a long time after the melt down. I actually saw a special on 60 minutes where a robot went in and looked at the melted core and it was still glowing (10 yrs later). One of the reasons pickering was built where it is is due to the unlimited access to massive amounts of cooling water. WHile it would be a polluted mess, the melt down would be contained and limited.

The dirty bombs that everyone is speaking of is spent uranium or plutonium and exploded conventionally. There wouldn't be a nuclear reaction but it would spread the radioactive material over a wide area. This is a pure terrorist tactic as those infected (affected?) may not realize it for years until cancers start appearing. They could probably predict with a computer model who received what dose. There are measures that could be used to clean up the site but all porous materials surrounding the explosion would have to be removed and buried as they would remain dangerously radio active for 100's of years afterwards. Of course this all depends on the length and amount of exposure.

Why was the reactor built so close to Toronto? As mentioned ease of the power distribution and Toronto is the province's largest consumer of electrical power. Now if they built it on the leslie street spit, now that would be a little TOO close though they could have done it.

Nuclear produced energy is relatively cheap, relatively safe, and relatively clean (not counting for the waster that remains dangerously radioactive for 10,000 yrs).

Anyhow, we shouldn't worry about being attacked by terrorists, hell, we are their safe haven!!!! why would they want to shit where they eat? Christ we almost go as far as to HELP them get here and then set them up with healthcare, welfare, grants and an education!
 
There are many differences - Chernobyl uses graphite as a moderator inseatd of heavy water, and graphite burns at high (heavy water doesn't burn!). Chernobly was used for power AND for plutonium production (unlike a CANDU). The Chernobyl folks purposely ignored the safety systems (actually turned one off to stop the alarming) and ran the reactor in a manner than was known to be unsafe. And yes, Pickering and Darlington are designed to default to a safe condtion.
CANDU's are expensive, but they are undeniably the safest reactors in the world. Compare their risk to the health effects faced every year by producing power at the coal plants in Ontario!
 
Galt is right..

The Candu System is very safe. All reactions will stop as soon as the doping happens by dropping the Boron rods into the reactor. The containment building for the reactor has 28" of re-enforced concrete and can withstand the impact of a loaded 747. Actually, it can withstand a nuclear bomb at its front steps for the same reason.

Unlike the Three mile Island reactors, the Candu fuel bundles are made up of natural uranium and will never achieve critical mass even in the event of a fuel melt down.

It is of course possible for the operators to do some things very foolishly and resulting in pressure build-up. Again, the vacuum building volume equal to one reactors worth should contain that. There is also a pool of water at the top of the containment building available for emergency cooling.

And, for those who wants to think about taking over the station, let them think again because Security is tough on site. Again, driving a truck of explosive into the building will do absolutely nothing for reasons mentioned earlier.

How do I know ? Let's say I worked in this industry at one time.
 
Winston said:
A buddy of mine is a nuke operator. The buildings are indeed over engineered to withstand a 747 or better "accident".

When 747's and other large planes are decommissioned, I think that they should be used to test the structure, at least once a year.
 
One thing people are forgeting is the balck out last summer.

Winston, if your buddy is an operator, then he/she can verify the fact that a downed powerline in Ohio ought not have been able to devistate the entire East coast.

Reality is the fail safes already in place would have to be down at all facilities for that to happen.
 
bbking said:
I would have to agree with you here - but correct me if I am wrong isn't Pickering inactive due to equpment problems and as such is shut down - wouldn't be much of a threat then. As for Ebola being a problem - this is one bug we don't have to worry too much about - it is so fast moving in killing it's host that it is hard to spread - smallpox on the other hand could be devestating. The US has taken steps and vaccinated health care workers there, we have yet do anything.

You are wrong here because if a terrorist network decides to infect 500 suicide Ebola carriers and strategically places them throughout every large american city then the nations health care structure would collapse as we know it. Hospitals would be over run and the virus would spread like wild fire.
Smallpox vaccines look nice on paper but if Al Queda has mastered the art of viral mutation then any innoculation is completely futile.
In other words we are toast!!!
 
this thead is hard to read...

you guys need to get a grip, talk about paranoia, im with a bunch of intellectual nerds. Get laid boys, it will help...isnt Kiarra around that area, she looks hot and if the plant does go up and your with her...hell, you probably wouldn;t care !!
 
Listen up gabe, we're not paranoid we are just playing hypotheticals and I'm getting laid plenty thank you very much.

Bbking, you are wrong because Ebola is contagious well before the bleeding of every orifice happens, as a matter of fact its contagious when the first mild flu symptoms arrive.

Also it has not been completely proven that the virus isnt airborne and it can also mutate into one.
 
Last edited:
Environmental contamination and nuclear winter severity aside, the blackouts alone would cripple us. Remember August 18th? The Northern half of the Eastern Seaboard became basket cases overnight.
 
WhaWhaWha said:
Environmental contamination and nuclear winter severity aside, the blackouts alone would cripple us. Remember August 18th? The Northern half of the Eastern Seaboard became basket cases overnight.

Basketcases??.. I think it brought neighbours closer together.. It was a huge nieghbourhood party all night where I was living
 
The idea of a terrorist group genetically engineering viruses and infecting the population would be devastating and is the stuff movies are made of. But the reality is that it is much easier, almost effortless, for someone to walk into a crowded train or nightclub and blow it up. You just need the people willing to do it. Thankfully these people are not that common.
 
Re: this thead is hard to read...

gabe-reardon said:
you guys need to get a grip, talk about paranoia, im with a bunch of intellectual nerds. Get laid boys, it will help...isnt Kiarra around that area, she looks hot and if the plant does go up and your with her...hell, you probably wouldn;t care !!

Gee Gabe, sorry if we overtaxed your limitted mental capacity and made this thread too "hard to read" for you. If you have something value add to contribute we'd be happy to hear it but if the thread bothers you so much stop reading it. Better to be an intellctual nerd than a closed minded twit.

Now...On to the topic at hand. Most biological agents are quite difficult to deliver in the form of a weapon. BBKing is right in that Ebola is not really an effective weapon. This is true for a number of reasons. First, to get a sample of the virus is difficult enough but to have a lab that can culture it and build a delivery mechanism is much tougher. Secondly, even if you infected a human host to deliver it one would have to put that host on a plane to get them to where they needed to go. The incubation period of Ebola is so fast that the host would, in all likelihood be violently ill before that plane landed so much so that the plane would be quarantined. (Now, admittedly I am making the assumption that the plane is coming from some terrorist haven type corner of the world and not the terrorist haven Canada in which we all live). To move the virus in any other form would be very difficult. Hemoragic fevers like Ebola are viruses that are their own worst enemy because their symptoms are so violent, devestating and fast acting that the viruses tend to burn themselves out rather quickly.

We need to consider that terrorists are not necessarily interested in complex plots to anihalate a population. Terrorists are more interested in psychological warfare. They want to create an environment that makes people question if they are safe in their day to day activities. Even the 9/11 hijackers could have created far more devestation had they simply crashed the planes into Madison Ave or Wall Street instead of the WTC. Just the amount of cars on the street and people on the sidewalk that would have been killed would have equalled far more than the wtc but the WTC was a statement. Apart from the carnage that it caused the WTC made a huge visual impact and it rocked the financial markets because the WTC was a symbol of financial power.

It is far more effective for terroists to keep their plots simple and cause as much devestation as quickly possible in a place that makes people scared to go out of their houses. People in Spain will now be thinking twice before setting foot on a train as will most other people in Europe. Given that the entire continent relies on various public train systems imagine what this will do to how the economies of Europe function. That is the true target of terrorism...it is not our actual lives but our minds and how we live our lives.
 
instead of flying a plane into a nuclear plant or inflicting mass hysteria by infecting thousands in a large metropolitan... would it not be much easier to blow up a few toxic and volatile pressurized chemical tanker rail cars (chlorine, bromine, toluene or amonia) on a train in a populated area??... look at the mass evacuation in Mississauga when the train derailed about 20 years ago.. i am pretty sure that was chlorine

this would be a very simple, inexpensive operation which could have mass casualites... and a scenario that I would have more fear of actually taking place than an attack on a Candu nuclear reactor.
 
But Galt, an Ebola attack WOULD cause psychological panic in the population even if it didnt spread quickly like you say (something I disagree with BTW). People arent gonna sleep better when Rumsfeld comes on TV and says: "We have the Ebola and Smallpox outbreak under control people, only 800 victims will die and thats it, we promise you".
Boy, I can just see the americans believing that one.
 
WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
instead of flying a plane into a nuclear plant or inflicting mass hysteria by infecting thousands in a large metropolitan... would it not be much easier to blow up a few toxic and volatile pressurized chemical tanker rail cars (chlorine, bromine, toluene or amonia) on a train in a populated area??... look at the mass evacuation in Mississauga when the train derailed about 20 years ago.. i am pretty sure that was chlorine

this would be a very simple, inexpensive operation which could have mass casualites... and a scenario that I would have more fear of actually taking place than an attack on a Candu nuclear reactor.

You are right, Daddy. There are things possible that we havent even thought of yet. How about a sarin nerve gas attack on the TTC and SIMULTANEOUS carbombing of every hospital in downtown T.O. With the hospitals in ashes there is noone to look after the subway victims.
 
bbking said:
This family of virus has no history of being airborne. There are lots of virus that never become airborne

You cannot tell me that in somewhere in the world right now, at some research lab that there is not research going on to manufacture weaponized aerosol versions of these viruses (ebola, smallpox and other deadly hemorrhagic fevers)
 
WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
You cannot tell me that in somewhere in the world right now, at some research lab that there is not research going on to manufacture weaponized aerosol versions of these viruses (ebola, smallpox and other deadly hemorrhagic fevers)

Actually, according to the CDC, in research conditions it's already been demonstrated that all strains of the Ebola virus can be transmitted by aerosols, although they also point out that no such cases have been documented in real world conditions. It would probably take a mutated form of the present virus for terrorists to be able to use it this way, but certainally not beyond the realm of possibilities.