No More Free Speech?

You're analogy to to the KKK is a bit extreme, but I can see your point. Personally, I think people should only be fired for their work performance (or lack thereof), not for personal opinions they hold in their private time.

Also, the "gay mafia" isnt a term I came up with, it was Bill Maher: http://nydn.us/1kCzPIi
And all of you have avoided my question, so I'll ask again:

Lets say you attended a gay march that supported gays adopting kids. Would you be okay if I fired you over that because I, as your employer, dont agree with your political views??

No, you can't fire me for that. But as I said, Eich wasn't fired. They are completely separate issues. Essentially, my entire post is an answer to your question, which is why I quoted you. What part about my post do you feel wasn't an answer to this?

I also never said you coined the term "gay mafia", I simply said it's attempting to create an image that doesn't make sense. I don't really use Bill Maher as a signpost of anything.
 
I would equate that to, you can't fire someone for being gay, but we sure as hell can make him the outcast of the office, until he finds it so unbearable that the gay guy quits.

Same thing, different angle

Ok, let's try a different approach. Freedoms can't overrule rights. You have freedom of speech, but you also have the right to equality. You can't make someone an outcast in the office because they are black. Your "freedom" to call him whatever you want, thereby harassing and discriminating against him until he leaves, is a violation of his charter RIGHT, and his RIGHT is more important than your freedom. The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that section 15, the right of equality, includes sexual orientation.

It doesn't matter why you don't like someone, if it's because they're black or chinese, male or female, muslim or atheist, straight or gay, they have the right to equality and being treated with respect and not to be singled out because of who they are. You can argue being gay is a choice and not a state of being if that's why you feel this way, but unfortunately for you the Supreme Court of Canada has disagreed with that viewpoint. The law is pretty clear here - sexual orientation is on par with gender, ethnicity and religion insofar as protection from persecution and discrimination go. You can dislike or hate gays if you want to, but if you're too vocal about it, you just might be drifting into hate speech.
 
Thankfully down here we have the First amendment...It allows ALL Speech.

That means the ugly and vile bile that certain fringe groups spew.

See we don't have so-called Human Rights Committee's because someone has their panties in a knot.

Unfortunately The Leftist "Thought-Police" are still on Campus shouting down opposing views.

"Congree shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof , or abridging the freedom of speech,or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the goverenment for a redress of grievances"

Take Note Canada...This IS what REAL Free Speech Is.

Yes, let's all look to America as an example of how a legal and penal system should be run.
 
Considering gays adopting kids is supported by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms... yes, you would lose a suit for termination without cause
So is freedom of speech. Should NOT be cause for termination

Actually no you can't. You would rightfully be hit for workplace harassment if by individuals and massive lawsuits if condoned by the company. Being gay is protected by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Right, but its OK to fire someone for a measly $1,000 donation they gave 5 years ago.

Ironically, around that same time Obama had publicly stated he was against gay marriage. And then later flipflopped


No, you can't fire me for that. But as I said, Eich wasn't fired
He was either fired or asked to quit. To me (and anyone with half a brain) thats the same thing

Ok, let's try a different approach. Freedoms can't overrule rights. You have freedom of speech, but you also have the right to equality. You can't make someone an outcast in the office because they are black. Your "freedom" to call him whatever you want, thereby harassing and discriminating against him until he leaves, is a violation of his charter RIGHT, and his RIGHT is more important than your freedom. The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that section 15, the right of equality, includes sexual orientation
Excellent. Now lets extend to freedom of speech, and we can agree

It doesn't matter why you don't like someone, if it's because they're black or chinese, male or female, muslim or atheist, straight or gay, they have the right to equality and being treated with respect and not to be singled out because of who they are
And people should have the right to express their opinion, and not be singled out for it

Just a little FYI, supposedly there are gay groups who scour through FOI records to see which people have been giving donations to anti gay marriage causes. They then put pressure on companies to fire these people.

This is going to far for him, because it stifles freedom of speech.

And just so we're clear, I have no problem with gays, nor do I have a problem with gays getting married.
I do have a HUGE problem when they try to undermine freedom of speech
 
SkyRider said:
Coming to an employer near you, every employee will be asked the following question: "Do you support gay marriage?" Answer correctly and you keep your job and maybe even get promoted. Answer incorrectly and you will be fired or forced to resignSpot on!!

And guess what, the opposite was condemned not too long ago. Some NFL club got in trouble for asking the question whether prospects "liked girls or not": http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/football/nfl-teams-crossed-gay-line-combine-article-1.1275386
How is that different from promoting or firing people based on their attitudes to 'straight' marriage (or religion, or politics) which is something we've long done. Not that the point (so-called) in either post really has anything to do with free speech. But they sure have a lot do do with prejudices and preconceptions. No one has the right to force an answer for such offensively prying and personal questions.

If you cannot see the wisdom of, or room for discretion in such personal matters, then you have the protection of your right to speak freely if you are compelled to disclose. As in all cases where that last resort is invoked, you too will pay some price, but as the NFL team discovered they will face sanctions, not for asking, but for punishing the reply they extorted.

It's absurd to imagine free speech means speech without consequences.
 
Sure whats next, do we fire people because they will vote for Republicans next election??

Eich made a $1000 contribution to a political candidate who was for proposition 8, which passed in Calfornia but I believe was struck down by some judge:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_8_(2008)
 
Sure whats next, do we fire people because they will vote for Republicans next election??

Eich made a $1000 contribution to a political candidate who was for proposition 8, which passed in Calfornia but I believe was struck down by some judge:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_8_%282008%29

He did more than make a contribution, he made a bunch of public statements about it. Do you think employees, customers, and partners should be forced to do business with him against their will? What sort of freedom would that be?
 
It's absurd to imagine free speech means speech without consequences.
Then what is the point of having referendums or freedom of speech if a vocal minority with a different POV pressures your company to fire you?

What is your position on abortion, assisted suicide, Quebec independence, death penalty, prostitution, marijuana, women in combat role, bike lanes, black only schools, dogfighting, masturbation, etc.? Whatever is your position on these and other issues, I can virtually assure you there will be other people who will disagree with you. Is it acceptable for these other people to try and get you fired?

BTW: There is now a petition to get Michael Vick fired because he used to support dogfighting. The guy went through due process and served his time. Shouldn't people leave him alone now?
 
He did more than make a contribution, he made a bunch of public statements about it. Do you think employees, customers, and partners should be forced to do business with him against their will? What sort of freedom would that be?
Okay, so I know from previous posts you're an avid gun owner, would it be okay for me to fire you because I'm a gun-control supporter??

And I'm just playing devils advocate, I support right of gun ownership myself.
But answer the question anyways, please
 
wedfqwecdqwecdqwedf
 
Indeed it does. In ways you wouldnt even begin to understand

Of course which doesn't even answer the question put to you.

CAMH has been there for years, something like 150 years in one form or another as one of TO's predominate medical facilities. There are even regular commercials on media about what it does. That you don't recognize it speaks volumes how much time you don't spend involved in your community
I was right not to hold my breath
 
So is freedom of speech. Should NOT be cause for termination


Right, but its OK to fire someone for a measly $1,000 donation they gave 5 years ago.

Ironically, around that same time Obama had publicly stated he was against gay marriage. And then later flipflopped



He was either fired or asked to quit. To me (and anyone with half a brain) thats the same thing


Excellent. Now lets extend to freedom of speech, and we can agree


And people should have the right to express their opinion, and not be singled out for it

Just a little FYI, supposedly there are gay groups who scour through FOI records to see which people have been giving donations to anti gay marriage causes. They then put pressure on companies to fire these people.

This is going to far for him, because it stifles freedom of speech.

And just so we're clear, I have no problem with gays, nor do I have a problem with gays getting married.
I do have a HUGE problem when they try to undermine freedom of speech

Perhaps all those people need to get a whole brain then. I've been "asked" to leave a job before. I said no. I'm pretty sure when you're fired, you can't say no. Those are very different things. If I ask you to give me your car and you say sure, I didn't steal it. Unless Mozilla put a gun in his face or he was under duress in some way, being asked to leave is not the same as being fired. And it's not "either". Every report available says he resigned. So he "chose" to leave.

The only problem with the theory that people shouldn't be singled out for speaking their mind no matter what is that you create a paradox. I can't single you out for speaking your mind, but what if you speaking your mind singles me out? Why are you protected and not me? What makes your "freedom" to speak more important than my "right" to equality? Furthermore, you miss a key point in this entire situation. Eich wasn't some drone in the operations room. He was the CEO. Whether explicitly implied in his contract or not, a CEO is required to act in a manner that represents the company he's in charge of. If he owns it, that means he can do whatever he wants. If there are other stakeholders, however, they have the right to an opinion.

You see, if I'm a drone working in a factory assembly computers, and my requirement is to assemble a minimum of 50 computers a week, I can attend any rallies I want and financially support any cause I believe provided I show up to work on time and meet my goal. My "opinions" don't affect the company. But if I'm CEO and my attending of rallies or financing of political groups causes the company to lose money, then I am having an impact on the company. My actions are hurting the company's financial situation. And by your own admission, someone's work performance WOULD be grounds for termination. So even if he had been fired, which he wasn't, his performance was hurting the company. And while one might argue it didn't take place on company time, one would be missing the fact that as CEO he's on salary, a rather large one at that, in addition to being the figurehead of the company, he is always on company time.
 
Sure whats next, do we fire people because they will vote for Republicans next election??

Eich made a $1000 contribution to a political candidate who was for proposition 8, which passed in Calfornia but I believe was struck down by some judge:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_8_(2008)

"Some judge" found the law violated the Constitution with "no rational basis". "Some judge"'s opinion was also upheld by the Supreme Court. Why didn't you bother to read the article you linked? You went to all the trouble to find the article, then didn't even look at it? You wouldn't have to believe anything, you could've just read it.

But no, you can't "fire" people based on who they vote for. You keep making up situations that are nowhere near what actually happened. Why are you trying to extrapolate this as if it was some gateway incident that's now going to lead to people being fired for any reason under the sun? Eich gave public support to something which has a strong lobby against it, the Board asked him to resign on the basis that it affected the company, he agreed. In what way does that lead to people being terminated based on who they vote for?

Unless these "people" are CEOs or some other official representative, unless "fire" means ask to step down and unless "vote" means donate to and publicly support a cause, you're making a huge leap and connecting dots that don't connect.
 
Okay, so I know from previous posts you're an avid gun owner, would it be okay for me to fire you because I'm a gun-control supporter??

And I'm just playing devils advocate, I support right of gun ownership myself.
But answer the question anyways, please

I think people have a right to boycott. He was not some minor employee, people were boycotting the company, costing it business.
 
"Some judge" found the law violated the Constitution with "no rational basis". "Some judge"'s opinion was also upheld by the Supreme Court. Why didn't you bother to read the article you linked? You went to all the trouble to find the article, then didn't even look at it? You wouldn't have to believe anything, you could've just read it
No dude, I'm busy at work. Not much time to read entire wiki pages. My post was correct though, a judge overruled a democratically voted upon proposition which didnt want gay marriage.

I'll get to your other post later
 
Yet you posted it as 'proof'? Why is that not surprising?
Because I just read the part where the vote was overturned by a judge. Which it was.

Was there anything about my post that wasnt true??
 
I think people have a right to boycott. He was not some minor employee, people were boycotting the company, costing it business
If I were your boss and fired you for attending a pro-gun rally you'd scream bloody murder, fuji.
You know its true.

Leave politics the fuck out of the workplace I say
 
Perhaps all those people need to get a whole brain then. I've been "asked" to leave a job before. I said no. I'm pretty sure when you're fired, you can't say no. Those are very different things. If I ask you to give me your car and you say sure, I didn't steal it. Unless Mozilla put a gun in his face or he was under duress in some way, being asked to leave is not the same as being fired. And it's not "either". Every report available says he resigned. So he "chose" to leave
You're incredibly stupid if you dont see whats going on here. Eich is generally respected in software community because he started Java-whatever. He was politely asked to quit so he could save face.

If he had refused he wouldve been fired.
To me, and anyone else with half a brain, thats exactly the same thing as being fired