No More Free Speech?

"Our organizational culture reflects diversity and inclusiveness," the statement goes on. "We welcome contributions from everyone regardless of age, culture, ethnicity, gender, gender-identity, language, race, sexual orientation, geographical location and religious views. Mozilla supports equality for all." But the company is plainly taking the position that it won't employ, in leadership positions, anyone who publicly holds orthodox Christian or Muslim views on gay marriage.
Source:http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...e-litmus-test-violates-liberal-values/360156/

Exactly, that's their organizational culture, that's their "opinion", and Eich, as the CEO, didn't put that opinion forward. So even if he had been fired, which he wasn't, it would've been perfectly legitimate for them to do so because his opinion was not the company's opinion and as CEO that's the opinion he is required to have.

They aren't saying anything about leadership positions. They had no problem having Eich in other leadership positions. They just can't have him as CEO if his opinion isn't going to reflect theirs and his conduct is going to damage their reputation and their marketshare.
 
Well no, not "every right".

The "rights", here, do not favour the shareholders of a corporation. The CEO, being an employee of the corporation is, like every other employee, not subject to being fired by shareholders.

Of course, the CEO can be fired (e.g for incompetence, or for acting against the corp's interests) -- just not by the shareholders.

There is no statute that says an employee cannot be fired (although some work-contracts have that effect.) The statute gives employees the right to receive money compensation if they are discriminated against on one of the forbidden grounds.


The Ontario Human Rights Code contains these provisions (presumably, cal. has similar.)
Employment
5. (1) Every person has a right to equal treatment with respect to employment without discrimination because of sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability.
Harassment in employment
(2) Every person who is an employee has a right to freedom from harassment in the workplace by the employer or agent of the employer or by another employee because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability.

Announced intention to discriminate
13. (1) A right under Part I is infringed by a person who publishes or displays before the public . any notice, sign, symbol, emblem, or other similar representation that indicates the intention of the person to infringe a right under Part I or that is intended by the person to incite the infringement of a right under Part I.
Opinion
(2) Subsection (1) shall not interfere with freedom of expression of opinion.


So, if a CEO of a corporation articulates publicly that he is against gay marriage, an employee of the corp who is, or is looking to become, a gay spouse, just might possibly have a cause of action against the corp, on the grounds that he (the employee) is likely to be discriminated against by the corp -- but, presumably, not unless the CEO goes beyond merely saying he is against it, and says he will ding any employee of his corp that enters a gay-marriage. Merely stating an opinion does not generally amount to announcement of an intention to follow that opinion up with hostile action. It's just an expression of opinion.

The remedies for breach of the Ontario HRC employment safeguards are in the form of money damages to be paid by the employer (the corp) to the discriminated-against employee. So, in effect, a corp is free to discriminate against an employee on the forbidden grounds, provided they are prepared to pay compensation to the employee. In fact, well-heeled bigoted employers do this all the time.

Of course, the employee need not actually be fired by the corp. If the corp allows the employee to be subjected to harassment, whereupon he leaves voluntarily, that can amount to constructive dismissal, and the corp is just as liable for damages as if they had fired him. This is true for the CEO, as for any employee.

Except that in Eich's case, there were several people in the company that did complain about his position and stance. Forget about his donation to prop 8 for a moment, if you're CEO and you have a not insignificant part of the people underneath you unwilling to work for you because of how you conduct yourself, would you not agree you're failing at being a CEO? That was the position Eich found himself in. The ONLY reason this is a debate is because "gay rights" isn't guaranteed yet and society is split on whether it's right or wrong to withhold equal rights from them. Like I've said before in this thread, if he had been donating to re-introduce racial segregation, for example, no one would have a problem with his being fired (if he had been fired, which he wasn't).

Because of actions he took, by his own choice, he was rendered ineffective as CEO. He couldn't do the job. Instead of making an issue of it, he quit. Frankly, I respect the man for that. He stood up and made the tough call based on what was better for the company he created, putting his own wants aside. That's a brave move. If he hadn't, however, I would see no problem, and I don't think any law would either, would him being fired. A company can't fire a CEO for holding an opinion, that's true. But they can fire them for not having the faith and backing of the shareholders, or the employees. They can fire them if their personal actions have affected the company's marketshare. And Eich's opinions absolutely did all those things. He was wholly unable to fulfill the particulars of his contract because of his opinion. So while he can't be fired simply for having the opinion, he can be for failing to perform even if the reason he isn't able to perform is because of his opinion.
 
From what I hear, this guy is a superstar. His departure will hurt the company a lot more than if he had stayed. Reminds me of the time when Apple fired Steve Jobs because a few people thought Jobs was arrogant. Apple nearly went bust.
 
From what I hear, this guy is a superstar. His departure will hurt the company a lot more than if he had stayed. Reminds me of the time when Apple fired Steve Jobs because a few people thought Jobs was arrogant. Apple nearly went bust.

Eich is a superstar. He'll have no problem finding work. I'll be very surprised if it's as CEO though. Not for a while.

Jobs was arrogant. Apple was struggling before he was fired. Jobs threatened to do something that would've catapulted Apple into bankruptcy even faster. When he was called on it, he didn't care - he was too arrogant. The board sided with Sculley and Jobs got canned. Everyone, including Jobs himself, admits he was a terrible executive at the time and deserved to be fired. Jobs left, tried his hands at some other things, and came back a different man.

You see, what you're failing to realize is that just because Jobs was a visionary doesn't mean the world was ready for him, and just because Eich is a mad genius when it comes to coding doesn't mean he's in a position to make a great CEO. I'm sure the future will hold many great things for Eich. But one thing is for certain - the company he represented was being boycotted and a not insignificant number of the people under him didn't have faith in him. No matter how great an asset he is in various ways, he wasn't a good fit for CEO.

In 20 years will Eich return to Mozilla and catapult it to greatness? Possibly. But even if he does, that doesn't mean his leaving wasn't the best thing for Eich and the best thing for Mozilla.
 
From what I hear, this guy is a superstar. His departure will hurt the company a lot more than if he had stayed. Reminds me of the time when Apple fired Steve Jobs because a few people thought Jobs was arrogant. Apple nearly went bust.
A well chosen example of another 'firing' for not playing well with others. Actually Jobs recruited his 'successor', and moved on—however unhappily—by mutual agreement, however that was obtained.

As with the Eich, to make your case you have to have a participant denying they agreed, claiming they were forced and trying to do something about it—and all that as a result of what he said. Sour grapes because your rants pissed people off and they reacted doesn't make them censorious bigots, suppressing free speech. Nor does it make you a martyr to it.
 
Last edited:
Mozilla announced Chris Beard as the interim CEO. Let's hope he or she is "gay friendly" because gays expect nobody to ever disagree with anything they do or say.
 
Mozilla announced Chris Beard as the interim CEO. Let's hope he or she is "gay friendly" because gays expect nobody to ever disagree with anything they do or say.
Well there's a clear example of how stupid voicing your prejudice can make you sound. Of course all guys who like guys think as one <sarcasm alert>. 'Isn't it too bad they look just like the rest of us. But once they disagree…, their orientation becomes obvious.' Question: When someone expects no one will disagree with what they do or say, does that make them gay? Do straight guys—you, me and AK47, may be—never lose it when faced with disgreement?
 
Last edited:
Mozilla announced Chris Beard as the interim CEO. Let's hope he or she is "gay friendly" because gays expect nobody to ever disagree with anything they do or say.

Yes, because all gays have the same opinions on all subject. Seriously, you've got to be trolling at this point.

Gays aren't protesting their opinions on music or fashion, this is a civil rights movement. You sound the way I picture my grandfather did in the 60's with those pesky blacks. You're absolutely entitled to have the opinion that civil rights under the law shouldn't equally apply to everyone, but you also have to accept that those oppressed by your opinion are going to be upset by it. Besides, I've never met a gay person that was upset by people who didn't like them (though I'm sure they exist). I've found, however, that most gays get pretty upset when you try to tell them they aren't equal. If you extrapolate that to "they persecute anyone that disagrees with anything they do or say", that's your business. But it's not only pretty wrong, it makes you look pretty inane.
 
Yes, because all gays have the same opinions on all subject. Seriously, you've got to be trolling at this point.

Gays aren't protesting their opinions on music or fashion, this is a civil rights movement. You sound the way I picture my grandfather did in the 60's with those pesky blacks. You're absolutely entitled to have the opinion that civil rights under the law shouldn't equally apply to everyone, but you also have to accept that those oppressed by your opinion are going to be upset by it. Besides, I've never met a gay person that was upset by people who didn't like them (though I'm sure they exist). I've found, however, that most gays get pretty upset when you try to tell them they aren't equal. If you extrapolate that to "they persecute anyone that disagrees with anything they do or say", that's your business. But it's not only pretty wrong, it makes you look pretty inane.

For the record, I never said I was pro or anti gay marriage. The issue is why was Erich fired? If Mozilla believes in "openness", then it should welcome diverse and even conflicting opinions on social matters.

http://www.bizpacreview.com/2014/04...t-over-mozilla-ceos-forced-resignation-110647

http://theblacksphere.net/2014/4/mozilla-loses-in-end
 
For the record, I never said I was pro or anti gay marriage. The issue is why was Erich fired? If Mozilla believes in "openness", then it should welcome diverse and even conflicting opinions on social matters.

http://www.bizpacreview.com/2014/04...t-over-mozilla-ceos-forced-resignation-110647

http://theblacksphere.net/2014/4/mozilla-loses-in-end

I never said I'm a man, and yet I'm pretty sure it's obvious. You don't have to give your opinion explicitly for it to show. I don't know if you're for or against gay marriage specifically, but I do know you have a problem with the civil rights movement the LGBT community is undertaking right now. Your frequent use of terms like "a gay" and "the gays" also makes it pretty clear you don't have much exposure to them and have an attitude that's not particularly modern.

The issue isn't why Eich was fired...because he wasn't fired. The issue is that Mozilla believes in openness and Eich did not, made it clear he did not, and as CEO, that made him ineffective to the point that he resigned.

I'm sure Mozilla has many employees of various diverse backgrounds and opinions, and I'm sure they wouldn't fire people for it if the are able to effectively do their job. But a CEO that doesn't share the company's core values is not able to do his job. You keep saying the same things, but you have never addressed that point. If Eich was a worker bee, or even a mid-level exec, he could probably get away with being his own man. But as CEO he can't. No CEO can. That's what the CEO job means. It doesn't matter if the company says, "We value everyone's opinion!" That doesn't mean the CEO can say "I think you're all morons and I'm the only one that's right" because the CEO needs to reflect the company's values.

EDIT: Interesting choice of articles. Two sites more biased and extreme right-wing than Fox News. What's next? Are you going to quote the Heritage Foundation or the Madison Project? Again, you don't have to state your opinion if this is the type of media you follow - your general political leanings are made quite clear if that's the case.
 
[TABLE="align: center"]
[TR]
[TD][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
http://gaymarriage.procon.org/#Background

The history and pros and cons of gay marriage. Regardless of whether one is pro or con, one should be able to express one's opinion without losing one's job.

Unless one is a CEO or other person whose public statements are understood to represent the organization.
 
BlueLaser;4895808 Interesting choice of articles. [/QUOTE said:
Sir, feel free to post your own articles. Isn't that the nature of free speech?

Surveys show that about half the American population support and half don't support gay marriage. Does that make 175 million Americans anti-gay?
 
Ok, shall we go on a witchhunt and root out all the CEO's who don't explicity support gay marriage?

No.

But if a company suggest a CEO resign, or outright fires them, for not sharing the company's values, that's perfectly acceptable at the CEO level, because a CEO is expected to represent the company's opinion. For example, the company might support the view that gay marriage is abhorrent, like Christian Mingle for example. Why should they terminate a CEO for an opinion that is part of the company's core values?
 
Sir, feel free to post your own articles. Isn't that the nature of free speech?

Surveys show that about half the American population support and half don't support gay marriage. Does that make 175 million Americans anti-gay?

It makes them anti-gay-marriage, and therefore not a surprise that the organizations that support said agenda will have a huge readership that shares their views and post articles that support it. But before you rush to the "average American" to defend your views, consider this:

More than half of Americans blame Obama for raising their taxes... even though he has cut taxes across the board.
More than half of Americans discount the theory of evolution.
Almost half of Americans believe the Earth is less than 10,000 years old.
Roughly 25% of Americans think the Sun revolves around the Earth.

Does sound like group that's educated, has an understanding of the issues and approaches things with an open mind before making rash decisions, or a group that believes what the talking heads tell them and drink any Kool-Aid you throw at them?
 
Unless one is a CEO or other person whose public statements are understood to represent the organization.

Don't forget to add his public statements and actions are in direct contradiction the organizations already stated stance on the matter.
 
"Our organizational culture reflects diversity and inclusiveness," the statement goes on. "We welcome contributions from everyone regardless of age, culture, ethnicity, gender, gender-identity, language, race, sexual orientation, geographical location and religious views. Mozilla supports equality for all." But the company is plainly taking the position that it won't employ, in leadership positions, anyone who publicly holds orthodox Christian or Muslim views on gay marriage.
Source:http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...e-litmus-test-violates-liberal-values/360156/

Good article