No Coloured Man

Thus defeating the entire underlying argument behind the current case on its way to the SCC.

Nonsense. Both cases turn on the same point: Women have a right to security of person, and anything that violates that right is illegal and unconstitutional. Forcing women to work in unsafe conditions violates that right. Forcing women to have sex with someone against their will violates that right.

It is you who fail to understand the blatantly obvious. I have noticed how this happens to you--you wrap yourself up in irrelevant intricacies, you get your nose deep down into the details of some side-point, and completely, totally miss the obvious.
 
But if, as a service, I am consenting to be violated in exchange more money, I must provide equal access to all to violate me.

Absolutely dead wrong, fuji is right on this point in his post #285 above. Each sex act must be consented to by the lady, even if you wanted MSOG!!!!! Just because you got your rocks off once doesn't mean you can go for a second shot if she doesn't want to or else it's rape.

Read this:
"Yes. When a woman says “no,” it means no – it doesn’t matter if she is a prostituted woman or not. Even if she agrees to do one sexual act, if the john forces her to do a different sexual act against her will, that is still rape."
http://www.womenslaw.org/simple.php?sitemap_id=148
 
In other words, yes lady, you must be raped or you will be in contravention of the human rights code. That's just nuts.

Do you believe that the human rights of a John should trump the rape of an escort?

Would you also say it was assualt to force a barber to cut a black man's hair?

And, as has been stated a number of times, the tribunal does not force people to carry out any acts. They simply fine and educate. Is it a fine you think is a rape or being sent to a course?

The reality is that this industry was never considered when the legislation was drafted. But if we are going to allow for the legal commditisation of sex, we either need to change the act, or live with the consequences.
 
Would you also say it was assualt to force a barber to cut a black man's hair?

This is one of the most retarded things you have ever posted. You've dropped to groggy level of stupidity here.

Do you REALLY think taking a cock up your ass is no more of a violation of your security of person, than having to cut someone's hair?

we either need to change the act, or live with the consequences.

No we don't. No Act of Parliament has the force to compel the rape of a woman. Any Act of Parliament that would imply that is null and void. There is no need to change the act. The fundamental right to security of person is recognized as being superior to any act Parliament can pass--leaving aside certain exceptions in the case of criminal penalties, and medical procedures of course.
 
And by the way, I can assure you that, "An Act to amend the constitution of Canada to allow the compulsory rape of women" would not get many votes.
 
And by the way, I can assure you that, "An Act to amend the constitution of Canada to allow the compulsory rape of women" would not get many votes.

You are right about that. But since there would be no need for it, it is just your fantasy.
 
This is one of the most retarded things you have ever posted. You've dropped to groggy level of stupidity here.

Do you REALLY think taking a cock up your ass is no more of a violation of your security of person, than having to cut someone's hair?



No we don't. No Act of Parliament has the force to compel the rape of a woman. Any Act of Parliament that would imply that is null and void. There is no need to change the act. The fundamental right to security of person is recognized as being superior to any act Parliament can pass--leaving aside certain exceptions in the case of criminal penalties, and medical procedures of course.

A fine or being sent to a course is not a rape. Except perhaps in Fuji world.

Is being mandated to provide plumbing services to people of all races equally the same as being sent to a work camp?

It is you who are acting like a child here. But carry on, it is your typical MO.
 
A fine or being sent to a course is not a rape.

It certainly is coercion.

Is being mandated to provide plumbing services to people of all races equally the same as being sent to a work camp?

I don't know what you are on about, neither of those cases have anything to do with security of person, and so both are irrelevant to the question at hand.
 
I don't know what you are on about, neither of those cases have anything to do with security of person, and so both are irrelevant to the question at hand.

So you don't think that if I sent people to a forced labour camp to perform plumbing work that it would not violate security of the person?

You clearly don't understand what security of the person means.
 
Absolutely dead wrong, fuji is right on this point in his post #285 above. Each sex act must be consented to by the lady, even if you wanted MSOG!!!!! Just because you got your rocks off once doesn't mean you can go for a second shot if she doesn't want to or else it's rape.

Read this:
"Yes. When a woman says “no,” it means no – it doesn’t matter if she is a prostituted woman or not. Even if she agrees to do one sexual act, if the john forces her to do a different sexual act against her will, that is still rape."
http://www.womenslaw.org/simple.php?sitemap_id=148

A client's forcing an sp to have sex with him is wrong and illegal...so what?

If a black man goes to a restaurant and is refused service based on his race, the restaurant owner is violating that man's human rights.

If, however, the black man responds violently, pulls a gun out, takes a waitress hostage, and demands that the restaurant serve him a meal, he has then committed a crime for which he will be punished.

His complaint was valid...his response was wrong and illegal. Had he simply complained to the Ontario Human Rights Commission he would have been successful.

If the sp agreed to have sex with the john and then changed her mind, she should give back the money or risk civil/criminal action.
 
So you don't think that if I sent people to a forced labour camp to perform plumbing work that it would not violate security of the person?

If you sent people to a forced labour camp it would certainly be a violation of their security of person. If a court did it as part of a criminal sentence, well I would disagree with that, but as I wrote up thread, "The fundamental right to security of person is recognized as being superior to any act Parliament can pass--leaving aside certain exceptions in the case of criminal penalties, and medical procedures of course."

You clearly don't understand what security of the person means.

It's certainly violated if someone shoves a cock up your ass against your will!
 
If you sent people to a forced labour camp it would certainly be a violation of their security of person. If a court did it as part of a criminal sentence, well I would disagree with that, but as I wrote up thread, "The fundamental right to security of person is recognized as being superior to any act Parliament can pass--leaving aside certain exceptions in the case of criminal penalties, and medical procedures of course."



It's certainly violated if someone shoves a cock up your ass against your will!

Your problem is that you have not yet established that a fine, or being sent to a course is a violation of the security of person.

Your interpretation of the current legislation would mean the board could never fine or send anyone to a course, because being forced to cut a black man's hair (which the board cannot actually do) would be the same as an assault, a logically bankrupt position.

And if there was a Charter analysis, which really none is required or would even happen, you seem to think there is no place for s. 15.

You are out in space on this one.

What we have is a clear case of unintended consequences, no real Charter issue in sight.

You could use the regulation of say sex toys as exactly the same example, and your logic would lead to the same irrational conclusions.
 
Your problem is that you have not yet established that a fine, or being sent to a course is a violation of the security of person.

State interference with bodily integrity and serious state-imposed psychological stress constitutes a breach of security of the person. Forcing a woman, by threat of criminal sanction, or fine, or any other state imposed sanction, to have sex against her will is a profound interference with a woman's body and thus an infringement of security of the person. The psychological harm to the woman inflicted by rape represents an additional infringement of her security of person.
 
State interference with bodily integrity and serious state-imposed psychological stress constitutes a breach of security of the person. Forcing a woman, by threat of criminal sanction, or fine, or any other state imposed sanction, to have sex against her will is a profound interference with a woman's body and thus an infringement of security of the person. The psychological harm to the woman inflicted by rape represents an additional infringement of her security of person.

So if a physician does not wish to treat black patients but the Ontario Human Rights Commission "forces" him to do so, is his integrity of person being violated by forcing him to stick his fingers in a black man's ass and give him a prostate exam?


No?


Didn't think so.

Fuji: you have failed.

Now:
GTFO_HOUSE_225083.png
 
State interference with bodily integrity and serious state-imposed psychological stress constitutes a breach of security of the person. Forcing a woman, by threat of criminal sanction, or fine, or any other state imposed sanction, to have sex against her will is a profound interference with a woman's body and thus an infringement of security of the person. The psychological harm to the woman inflicted by rape represents an additional infringement of her security of person.

No rape involved.

She has the right to take her product or service off the market, or pay the fines and do the courses, if she is dead set on not serving men of certain ethnic groups. Just like the plumber can stop charging for his services, or just pay the fines as a cost of doing business, if he doesn't want to repair asian people's toilets.

Nice of you to stand up for the KKK approach to human rights though.

You have blown this one just so badly. I know your ego is far too immense to admit how bad your analysis is, but this happens to you every time you try to discuss legal issues. I guess you just don't learn well.
 
015.jpg
 
This thread was full retard the moment anyone suggested that the human rights code could be used to coerce a woman to have sex with a guy against her will.
this thread went full retard when you and the peanut gallery equated equal rights to rape.
 
Ok, time for dinner break. Fireworks to continue after dinner.