Next leaf captain?

wazup

Well-known member
Jun 12, 2010
4,276
584
113
Are they waiting for Matthews like the oilers did. I don't think Reilly is a choice, and prolly not nylander. They should have given it to pollack this year, does he play every game, can't watch every game.
 
Mirko Frycer!
 
Greg Terrion better choice.
 
I'm surprised JVR isn't even an alternate captain he's had one of the longest tenures of any current Leaf player.
 
At least in Toronto, the captain (and coach) don't necessarily have to be able to speak French.
 
Max Pacioretty does not speak French.
He's not even Canadian. I think there have been one or more captains in recent years who don't speak French. To increase their French content the Canadiens acquired Rene Bourque only to discover he doesn't speak French.
"The Alberta-born Bourque is of Metis heritage but cannot speak French."

I think Tessa Bonhomme also didn't speak French until recently.
 
He's not even Canadian. I think there have been one or more captains in recent years who don't speak French. To increase their French content the Canadiens acquired Rene Bourque only to discover he doesn't speak French.
"The Alberta-born Bourque is of Metis heritage but cannot speak French."

I think Tessa Bonhomme also didn't speak French until recently.

Is there anything that you state as fact... actuallly fact?

The Canadiens have not had a French speaking captain for over 17 years!!!.

In the last 30 years the following 7 players have been captains:
Max Pacioretty
Brion Gionta
Saku Koivu
Mike Keane
Kirk Muller
Chrios Chelios
Bob Gainey

The Canadians have only had an exclusive French Captain in 8 of the last 30 years.

And your comment on the Rene Bourque trade was equally ridiculous.
#1 Mike Cammaleri wanted out
#2 Bourque had 27 goals the two prior years, and was on pace for the same
#3 Bourque added size to a squad of dwarfs.

But yes it was all about the French content...
.
 
Sorry for taking the discussion off the topic of the thread, but sometimes things need to be corrected.


To me it's either a longstanding vet or nobody for this year. Giving it to a young vet could create an awkward situation down the road if you decide you want to give it to somebody else like Matthews at some point.
 
IIts a team currently having an 82 game pre season, a leader will have to rise above the rest as they all develop.

With a group this young and diverse, I think we will see someone step up and take a leadership role over the course of this season. When it occurs naturally, it just makes sense and there is no questioning from within the ranks.

If someone does not step up, then management needs to question the character of people they have brought to the organization.
 
With a group this young and diverse, I think we will see someone step up and take a leadership role over the course of this season. When it occurs naturally, it just makes sense and there is no questioning from within the ranks.
Agree, and it won't cause any controversy if he doesn't speak French.

BTW: Max Pacioretty has learned or is learning to speak French.

"Pacioretty read a prepared statement all in French before taking questions."

"When asked about the importance of learning to speak French as captain of the Canadiens, Pacioretty said: “This is my home now. Me and my family take it very seriously."

http://montrealgazette.com/sports/hockey/nhl/montreal-canadiens/pacioretty-named-canadiens-captain
 
Is he a team guy though? I like him as a player, and feel he has great talent.
But many nights wonder how he could motivate others, when he cant motivate himself. I liked the passion Lupul played with, but you cant lead from the press box.

Its a team currently having an 82 game pre season, a leader will have to rise above the rest as they all develop.



Joffrey Lupul is likely will be gone from the leafs soon, he a injury prone player. He has been injuried a number of times with leafs. I don't seeing being back at the team at all. The leafs are not ready to name the next Captain. This team is nowhere ready to be back in the playoffs at all. This current leafs team has a number of young players are just 19 or 20 years of age. In my opinion the leafs next Captain will be likely be Auston Matthews or William Nylander or even Mitchell Marner. These three young kids are great young players for this team and there are only 19 and 20 years of age. There are not ready to be Captain yet, I would give them 3 or 4 years to be ready to take on responsibility of being a captain.
 
Joffrey Lupul is likely will be gone from the leafs soon, he a injury prone player. He has been injuried a number of times with leafs. I don't seeing being back at the team at all. The leafs are not ready to name the next Captain. This team is nowhere ready to be back in the playoffs at all. This current leafs team has a number of young players are just 19 or 20 years of age. In my opinion the leafs next Captain will be likely be Auston Matthews or William Nylander or even Mitchell Marner. These three young kids are great young players for this team and there are only 19 and 20 years of age. There are not ready to be Captain yet, I would give them 3 or 4 years to be ready to take on responsibility of being a captain.

I'm thinking the same, it could 3 or 4 years before the Leafs have a new captain.
 
Is there anything that you state as fact... actuallly fact?

I'm sure it's happened at some point, but extremely rarely, like Halley's Comet rarely.
 
I'm sure it's happened at some point, but extremely rarely, like Halley's Comet rarely.

With one particular member, it is necessary to explain something 2-3-4 or more times and even then he might still fail to comprehend. Appointing a captain of the Montreal Canadiens who doesn't speak French is controversial.


" Max Pacioretty has learned or is learning to speak French."

"Pacioretty read a prepared statement all in French before taking questions."

"When asked about the importance of learning to speak French as captain of the Canadiens, Pacioretty said: “This is my home now. Me and my family take it very seriously."

http://montrealgazette.com/sports/ho...adiens-captain

http://vigile.quebec/Language-and-the-Habs

"Keane outraged the team's French-speaking fans"
"Keane was a leader in every sense of the word, but had little star quality about him. The press again grumbled that he was another english only captain. Keane, when questioned about his willingness to learn french, sidestepped the issue altogether by stating that the dressing room language was english. The french media, of course, jumped all over the quote and misappropriated it, making their relations with Keane in regards to post game interviews somewhat tense and uncomfortable.


 
Is he a team guy though? I like him as a player, and feel he has great talent.
But many nights wonder how he could motivate others, when he cant motivate himself. I liked the passion Lupul played with, but you cant lead from the press box.

Its a team currently having an 82 game pre season, a leader will have to rise above the rest as they all develop.

I don't know I'm not in the locker room. He is inconsistent in his play I'll give you that. Lupul is done which is too bad because he had a good all around game when he was healthy. I don't see Kadri being captain type maybe it will go to Reilly eventually. He's really stepping up his presence, deals well with the media. He just needs to cut down on the bonehead defensive errors.
 
It will most likely be mathews, although it won't be this year. I think it will play out like McDavid. See how consistent he is this year. I haven't seen many games this year other than the first and we all saw what he did that game, I haven't monitored the Leafs much since.