If they're going to ban paying for sex, they have to define what sex is, and what paying for sex is. If they try to capture as much as possible, they start encroaching onto everyday behaviour. In a MP, if the attendant gives a HJ as a freebie but the massage fee is higher, is that paying for sex; is a HJ sex, or is it only intercourse? What if the guy is allowed to masturbate himself, is that paying for sex? Who determines what is a reasonable price for a massage? What if a MP charges a normal rate, but gives HJ's as a freebie to attract business? Like in the case of a one night stand, would the guy who gives the woman taxi fare so she can get home be guilty of paying for sex? Or a single mother on welfare picks up a guy in a bar, brings him home and after sex, asks the guy for some cash to feed the kid because she's run out of cash for the month. Or a short relationship, after sex, the guy gives the woman a gift like earrings or even flowers; is that paying for sex? What if it's not money that's being exchanged but a Canadian Tire purchasing voucher? I know this is getting silliy and a cop is not going to stalk women hanging around bars, but the law itself has to be clear and not vague. I think they are getting bogged down with the sillyness of defining what sex for money is, and this is why MacKay's deadline for a spring Bill is slipping.