New Governor General

Toronto is not really the best place to judge national support for the Monarchy.

Toronto has a wide variety of opinions on the monarchy, from total to zero support. We know what plays in the rest of Canada as well, we're not as isolated and self centred as other regions might think.
If you think Canadians can't see the big picture and look at the country as a whole, then there isn't a good place to judge national support. Thus we stick with doing nothing, which now sadly seems to define Canada.
 
If she continues to go along with proroguing Parliament for a minority Prime Minister, it will be easier to sell ditching the GG to Canadians.
The GG and the monarchy are useful if you like pissing off Quebec and enjoy being under the rule of another country, so nothing will change.

First of all, we are not strictly speaking under the rule of another country, as the Queen of the UK does not have any power whatsoever to affect the institutions or governance of Canada (in fact, she does not have any power or influence to affect the institutions of the UK itself, except perhaps under the most extraordinary of circumstances, say under a minority government like we have in Canada, and even in this circumstance it's not entirely clear if the Queen has any authority in this). In Canada, the Governor General, to my understanding, also has no power except under very specific circumstances, such as the decision of proroguing Parliament (which is actually initiated by the Prime Minister, and she merely agrees to it for a limited duration).

If we in Canada decide to scrap the role of Governor General, then the natural replacement would be to have a directly elected President along with a Prime Minister who represents the leader of the party with the most number of MPs in Parliament (an arrangement similar to what is currently available in many European countries and in India and Israel). One of the things that needs to be worked out is whether the role of President is primarily ceremonial or whether specific powers are assigned to the President.

A potentially complex process, to be sure. Whether it is all worth it is up to Canadians to decide (again, I have no strong opinions myself on this issue).
 
If we in Canada decide to scrap the role of Governor General, then the natural replacement would be to have a directly elected President along with a Prime Minister who represents the leader of the party with the most number of MPs in Parliament (an arrangement similar to what is currently available in many European countries and in India and Israel).

Oh no, not a president! That is so American. I would rather have an elected Senate but that requires the consent of 82 provinces that represent over 60% of the population. Impossible numbers to achieve in a democracy.
 
Oh no, not a president! That is so American. I would rather have an elected Senate but that requires the consent of 82 provinces that represent over 60% of the population. Impossible numbers to achieve in a democracy.

Rockslinger, there is nothing uniquely American about having a president -- for example, the scenario I outlined above is the system of government as currently exists in Ireland, France, Austria, Germany, Israel, and India, to name just a few. I have not doubt that if Australia decides to scrap the system of the Governor General (there was I believe either a motion in the Australian Parliament or a referendum to do just that, which was narrowly defeated) then this would be the system implemented.

Personally, rather than scrapping the Governor General's office, I would much rather scrap the Senate in Canada altogether, which as far as I can see is a useless institution in our democracy, catered to the patronage of whatever party happens to be in power. The Senate (a hold-over of the House of Lords in the UK) does not propose or alter existing legislation to any great extent in Canada, so scrapping it will not cause any major changes in the nature of governance here in Canada, and could just save taxpayer's money, as well.
 
Last edited:
The senate does a lot of unpublicized work cleaning up bills to fix up errors and omissions, generally trying to avoid changing its meaning or intent while making it better law. If the senate were eliminated that function would have to be replaced.

The GG's most important function is to serve as the final arbiter on the power of a Prime Minister, and reign in a dictatorial one. She is the final check to balance an authoritarian PM.
 
The senate does a lot of unpublicized work cleaning up bills to fix up errors and omissions, generally trying to avoid changing its meaning or intent while making it better law. If the senate were eliminated that function would have to be replaced.

The GG's most important function is to serve as the final arbiter on the power of a Prime Minister, and reign in a dictatorial one. She is the final check to balance an authoritarian PM.[/QUOTE]

I concur that the Governor General's primary role is to serve as the final check on the PM's power. However, a directly-elected President in a parliamentary democracy as I described earlier can fulfill that same function, while avoiding any association with monarchy, nor any association with the leader who is appointing or selecting the Governor General (since it is the PM who appoints the GG).

As for the Senate, the members of that illustrious body in Canada are appointed by the PM (the leader of the majority party at any given time), so one could easily imagine a situation of a PM wanting to stack the Senate with members who are more likely to favour the political views of the PM or his/her party. As for correcting any omissions, a committee made up of members of the House of Commons (with representation from all major political parties to avoid bias) can fulfill the same responsibilities you assign to the Senate.
 
As for the Senate, the members of that illustrious body in Canada are appointed by the PM (the leader of the majority party at any given time), so one could easily imagine a situation of a PM wanting to stack the Senate with members who are more likely to favour the political views of the PM or his/her party. As for correcting any omissions, a committee made up of members of the House of Commons (with representation from all major political parties to avoid bias) can fulfill the same responsibilities you assign to the Senate.

I'm not sure whether a house committee could perform the cleaning function: The senate is generally aware that the House has the legislative mandate from voters and as a result it tends to steer clear of partisan debate. This allows it to focus on the nitty gritty details of bills in a way that the House does not. It is in fact an ideal job for a bunch of well respected appointees.

A House committee would, I think, wind up being yet another opportunity for the respective parties to grand stand their political views, they would try and turn the job into electioneering, and would fail to get down to the nitty gritty and clean up the small details in law.

I am sure there are other solutions to that problem, but it is a key function performed by the Senate that is often ignored and can't be replaced by a bit of hand waving.
 
Just get rid of this stupid monarchy shit already.
 
Personally, rather than scrapping the Governor General's office, I would much rather scrap the Senate in Canada altogether, which as far as I can see is a useless institution in our democracy, catered to the patronage of whatever party happens to be in power. The Senate (a hold-over of the House of Lords in the UK) does not propose or alter existing legislation to any great extent in Canada, so scrapping it will not cause any major changes in the nature of governance here in Canada, and could just save taxpayer's money, as well.
Although this is wandering off topic, the problem is that there is a great deal of institutional oppostion in the House of Commons to making the Senate a popularly elected body, that could serve as a real check on the power of the House of Commons.

For whatever reason this does seem a theme in Canada. It is interesting that Canada has the largest number of and longest standing unicameral legislatures, of any in the British/American tradition.
 
As for correcting any omissions, a committee made up of members of the House of Commons (with representation from all major political parties to avoid bias) can fulfill the same responsibilities you assign to the Senate.

Really? Are you familiar with the legislative process? I only ask since House committees are already charged with examining legislation, yet still errors and omissions need to be corrected by the Senate. The Senate serves as a useful check on the elected House.
 
Really? Are you familiar with the legislative process? I only ask since House committees are already charged with examining legislation, yet still errors and omissions need to be corrected by the Senate. The Senate serves as a useful check on the elected House.

I admit that I am not an expert on the legislative process here in Canada -- perhaps some of the TERB members here may be more knowledgeable here -- any politicians amongst ye?

All of the quotes that have been mentioned in defense of the Senate seems to imply that there are frequent errors and omissions in legislation or bills that gets sent through the House of Commons. My first question is whether that is really the case. Since it is the responsibility of the House of Commons to examine and bring forward legislation, shouldn't they be the ones to ensure that they get it right? (btw, we are talking about errors and omissions, not about the key purposes of the legislation, which opposing parties can and often do oppose). Thus my suggestion of a House committee devoted to this task.

Second question is if it is determined that the House is simply not capable of self-correcting their errors (as seems to be suggested by some of you), then does it make sense for an unelected Senate to take on this responsibility, accountable to no one but the PM, selected under the sole discretion of the PM? IMHO, I would argue not.

I would argue for one of the two: (1) either we have an elected Senate or (2) eliminate the Senate completely. My preference would be for (2).
 
All of the quotes that have been mentioned in defense of the Senate seems to imply that there are frequent errors and omissions in legislation or bills that gets sent through the House of Commons. My first question is whether that is really the case.

That is often the case. The Senate does considerable work tightening up the language of the legislation, removing ambiguities, closing loopholes, and so on. It is generally all non-controversial grunt work. It is fairly rare for a Senate change to modify the general intent of the law in a way that would upset the authors of the bill. Instead usually the Senate concentrates on debating the finer points and how it will be interpreted by a court, making minor changes to clean it up and make it better legislation.

The House Committees on the other hand tend to spend their time debating larger issues, and making modifications to the bill that change its meaning, toughen it up, water it down, and so on.

In other words, the House tends to engage in the political debates around the merits of the bill, while the Senate tends to get into the legalistic nitty gritty.

does it make sense for an unelected Senate to take on this responsibility, accountable to no one but the PM, selected under the sole discretion of the PM? IMHO, I would argue not.

I would say yes. The reason being that since the Senators aren't going to be fighting an election, and since they know they don't represent the will of voters, and since they are comprised of well respected, highly knowledgable, and trusted individuals, that they are ideal to the task of doing the non-political grunt work, leaving the House free to debate the politics of the law.

If we had an elected senate then instead of knuckling down to get the job done, the Senators would, like the House, view every opportunity to inspect a bill as an opportunity to campaign for re-election, and highlight only the issues that catch the media's attention, rather than work on the finer points which are irrelevant to elections but highly relevant to judges and lawyers.

If we eliminated the Senate I think we would have to replace it with some other body of appointed non-partisan unelected individuals who would perform the same function.

Note that the Senate's work is confirmed by Parliament--the changes made by the Senate are submitted back to the House for a final vote. These are generally rubber stamp type votes as generally nobody objects to the minor improvements the Senate has made to the bill.
 
Fuji,

You do raise some valid points above. Perhaps my negative views of the Senate come from the impression that this part of the legislative body exists solely for patronage (i.e. the PM rewarding his friends with a cushy government job at taxpayers expense).