Tkachuk certainly is a dirty S.O.B., but similarly to Brad Marchand, he is also a very skilled player. He’s the kind of guy you hate when he’s on another team, but love when he’s on your side. Tkachuk did score the nicest goal in the past few seasons with that between the legs O.T. winner with no time left on the clock.
Leafs need Tkachuk, since trading Kadri, the Leafs lacking a pest. And when players like Matthews doesn't have to worry about Tkachuk, it's a bonus.

