New 2019-20 Maple Leafs thread

I'd take a couple guys like Carolina's Warren Foegele any day.

Which might come close to being equal to one William Nylander.
 
Which might come close to being equal to one William Nylander.

They even showed his goal on Pardon the Interruption. However being American and typically ignorant regarding hockey, they made no mention of floating or perimeter or soft or garbage. It was cringeworthy.
 
Hey Wicky, 9 times out of 10? Where do you come up with these stats? In Make Be Leaf land?
Remember the OT winner scored off of own New Jersey stick? Turnover created by Nylander using slick stick skills. Say that 3 times fast.
It's called using a smart hockey mind.

Hey 'twinkle', anyone who ever played even house league hockey knows you are taught as a basic to body guys off the puck, and not just reach for a stick check because it virtually never works, especially along the boards. DUH! Clearly you were never anything more than a street hockey player banging tennis balls around in the slush or you'd know that.
 
Which might come close to being equal to one William Nylander.

Hahaha! They two are nothing alike at all. Foegele eats pussy, Free Willy is a pussy! See the difference?
 
anyone who ever played even house league hockey knows you are taught as a basic to body guys off the puck, and not just reach for a stick check because it virtually never works,
The best method to separate the enemy from his puck is to hit his body. Using stick checks is for wimps. I've played against guys who were magicians with the puck. The only option was to take their body (if you can) off the puck.

The problem with Nylander (and Marner) is that he isn't big enough to muscle most guys off their puck. Plus, he rarely if ever attack the enemy's net when he doesn't have the puck to create chaos/screen. See how little guys like Gallagher and Domi attack the opposition's net.

BTW: https://nesn.com/2020/01/jake-debrusk-is-using-new-stick-that-has-hole-in-the-blade-and-its-weird/

I saw one of these sticks up close. If allowed, I would make the hole just a bit bigger so I can "cradle" the puck. Talk about puck on a stick, it is literally in the stick. Great for stickhandling.
 
They even showed his goal on Pardon the Interruption. However being American and typically ignorant regarding hockey, they made no mention of floating or perimeter or soft or garbage. It was cringeworthy.

Yes, very ignorant regarding hockey.
Because normally, when you show a highlight reel worthy play, you should always follow up with the negative aspects of the player's game,
that's normal right?

I've learned so much about hockey on this site, especially that you can understand a player's value simply by watching a
video of 20 goals by that player, however mundane most of those goals are.
I think the Bruins are going to pursue Nylander in the offseason, you score a goal like that,
there's absolutely nothing more you could ask from a hockey player.
 
See how little guys like Gallagher and Domi attack the opposition's net.

Domi 192 lb
Nylander 190 lb
Gallagher 184 lb
 
I think the Bruins are going to pursue Nylander in the offseason....

He's pretty fast, they'll have a tough time catching him, offseason or not.
 
The best method to separate the enemy from his puck is to hit his body. Using stick checks is for wimps. I've played against guys who were magicians with the puck. The only option was to take their body (if you can) off the puck.

The problem with Nylander (and Marner) is that he isn't big enough to muscle most guys off their puck. Plus, he rarely if ever attack the enemy's net when he doesn't have the puck to create chaos/screen. See how little guys like Gallagher and Domi attack the opposition's net.

BTW: https://nesn.com/2020/01/jake-debrusk-is-using-new-stick-that-has-hole-in-the-blade-and-its-weird/

I saw one of these sticks up close. If allowed, I would make the hole just a bit bigger so I can "cradle" the puck. Talk about puck on a stick, it is literally in the stick. Great for stickhandling.
No, the problem with Nylander is that he IS big enough and he IS talented enough, but won't even take a bump to make a play.
Oh wait, he had a very good game last night, that means everything we've seen until yesterday doesn't count for anything.
 
Yes, very ignorant regarding hockey.
Because normally, when you show a highlight reel worthy play, you should always follow up with the negative aspects of the player's game,
As opposed to TERB where normal is talking about the negative aspects of a player's game and not acknowledging the skills that player possesses and the results that they've produced or not even giving credit for an undeniably spectacular goal.

BTW, as much as I enjoy their show, the only sport that those guys know less about than hockey is soccer.
 
As opposed to TERB where normal is talking about the negative aspects of a player's game and not acknowledging the skills that player possesses and the results that they've produced or not even giving credit for an undeniably spectacular goal.

BTW, as much as I enjoy their show, the only sport that those guys know less about than hockey is soccer.
That's as untrue a thing as I've read here.
It has been acknowledged, his skills have always been respected, I've said it on numerous times.
Criticism of Nylander is based on the fact that he is skilled.
You guys want to wash away deficiencies, that he has control over, based on a couple of trick goals.
It's acknowledged way beyond this board that he's highly skilled and has no heart.
What, a goal between his legs changes that all of a sudden?
 
I’ve been one of Nylander’s worse critics and I’ve said enough about what I don’t like about the way he plays. So it’s only fair that I should acknowledge what I’ve seen as improvements in his game. He doing really well this year in scoring goals and I’ve seen he’s at least shown a little more effort in the defensive end. Especially in the last game he’s shown how much more impactful he could be by engaging more physically.

He is, however, who he is. He’s been playing the “non contact” style all his life and it would be unfair to expect him to turn into a Bob Gainey or Mark Messier. I think most critics like myself want to see a little more desire in winning one on one battles by engaging physically than just stick checking. The same can be said about Matthews and Marner who are imo have shown more grit and desire than Willy but there are still rooms to improve.
 
That's as untrue a thing as I've read here.
It has been acknowledged, his skills have always been respected, I've said it on numerous times.
TBH, I didn't check your posting history in particular, but all I seem to hear from the naysayers is trade him for anything, no heart, floater, not as good as so and so etc. etc non-stop with next to no acknowledgement that his high skill level combined with good offensive results is a potent counter to his liabilities. It is overwhelmingly negative. It is not even close. He has elite skills and, as smuddan pointed out, he has made significant strides in trying to play more of an overall game. He just needs more consistency in that regard but one can see the maturity of his game improving.

What, a goal between his legs changes that all of a sudden?
No, but that comment proves my earlier point that the negatives are emphasized but the good results go unmentioned for the most part.
 
Taking the body to create turnovers is not the only way to do it. First goal yesterday Leafs win the faceoff. Sandin to Lily who directs the puck towards Kapanen along the boards expecting to get hit he chips it in an attempt to get it out of the zone. Set play. But Hedman used his brains instead of trying to plaster Kapanen and take himself out of the play which would have allowed that Leafs play to work. He sees what Kapanen is doing and stops. Gloves the puck and turnover created. Passes to Stamkos and now two on one on Sandin since the other 2 forwards have already left the zone. Stamkos to Kucherov shot goal.

Nylander turnover on Kucherov was the right play. The puck was sitting right there. Nylander uses his strength to hold up Kucherov's stick as his body is leaving the zone. Nylander has the leverage and eventually Kucherov skating towards up ice loses the puck. The dumb play would have been to try to plaster Kucherov into the boards. Kucherov would have been long gone by then since he already had a step.
 
No, but that comment proves my earlier point that the negatives are emphasized but the good results go unmentioned for the most part.

That comment proves nothing.
That comment was in response to all the silly comments that tried to wash away his rep because of that goal,
in other words trick goal does not equal a soft player.
Your buddies are children at best.
 
That comment was in response to all the silly comments that tried to wash away his rep because of that goal,
.
I don't think that anybody would seriously think that. It seems to be an overinterpretation of somebody simply saying it was a very good goal. And it was not a one-off in terms of consistent scoring this year.
 
Stamkos, Kucherov, and Point are not paid to bang bodies. They're paid to make plays and score goals and they do that very well. Not saying a team doesn't need bangers. That's why TB went out and got Maroon and company. Augment the skill. Leafs recognize that. Hence resigning Muzzin and trading for Clifford. They should replace Gauthier with more grit as well.

Once Soupman comes back he'll take out Malgin.
 
Toronto Maple Leafs
SCORING GP G A P +/-
1 Matthews, Auston C
64 43 31 74 16
2 Marner, Mitchell RW
53 15 47 62 0
3 Nylander, William RW
62 28 28 56 0
3 Tavares, John C
57 26 30 56 -6

Plus/Minus
Mathews (+16), Nylander and Marner 0, Tavares (-6)
 
The apologists for slippery Willy aren't legion, not even on this board. Most IRL know what he is and call it out regularly. No one lets him off the hook for his deficiencies, not the sports media, and especially his own coaches. On this board, there are really only three people who can't seem to accept that he's a soft, one-dimensional, overpaid player who still isn't close to playing a complete, well rounded, two-way game.

Those three can continue to sing his virtues, but it won't change the reality of what anyone who actually knows hockey knows to be true. Just makes you look stupid the more you protest and insist on pumping his tires.