Neo-cons vs Neo-libs?

WoodPeckr said:
FYI: the late Pope John Paul II, had it all over W on both of the above counts.

Except that the Pope commands no armed force, and can't enforce his edicts. In any case, when Bush talks, people listen; hatred is the surest sign of attentiveness...

Blessed are the peacemakers for they shall be called the children of God.
Matthew 5:9
...Thanks for the quote Blitz.

"He that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one"

-Luke 22:35
 
Truncador said:
"He that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one"

-Luke 22:35

He will judge between many peoples and will settle disputes for strong nations far and wide. They will beat their swords into plowshares and their spears into pruning hooks. Nation will not take up sword against nation, nor will they train for war anymore.

Micah 4:3
 
Truncador said:
In this respect, the revival of the medieval, theocratic notion of a "just war" (shorn of the theological reference) on the part of the anti-Bush anti-war activists is highly suggestive. Indeed, neither the concept of "international law" nor "human rights" even make sense outside of a theological, Judeo-Christian frame of reference. Explicit references to God may drop out, but remain in the background as an unstated assumption- one which can remain unstated precisely to the extent that it is utterly foundational, e.g. can simply be taken as a given.

A bulk of Bush supporters would fit your description even more perfectly, without any need to drop explicit references to God. Yes, the intellectal lineage of the concept of "just war" does indeed trace back to the Judeo-Christian tradition. But surely, you must agree that today's conception of jus ad bellum, at least as conceived in the West, is light years removed from that of Thomas Aquinas: it is essentially a modernist concept that has long outgrown theological speculations about the revealed God, and thoroughly immersed in secular, humanistic values. While these values may be as foundational as religious dogma, they are products of Enlightenment that stopped turning to priests and sacred texts long ago.

Of course, the same cannot be said of fanatic Islamists, whose concept of just war rests on yet another, different sacred text, but the US itself is not entirely devoid of a virulent strain of fundamentalism that not only appeals to a higher, supernatural authority for moral justification, but also interprets human history based on the revealed text. I don't have to remind you of Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson who interpreted 9/11 as God's punishment for American moral decay, blaming gays, feminists, ACLU, and the rest of the ungodly (which no doubt includes all of us here just for browsing through this board), and going as far as to say that God had handed Americans over to their enemies to give what they deserved. Many, I mean many Christians in the US actually share their views, and however bizzare it may seem, their idea of a just war falls along the line of Anne Coulter: convert the heathen to Christianity. Now, that is a concept of just war that truly resonates with the Judeo-Christian mindset.
 
I find it interesting that opposing sides can find passages from the bible to further their own ideas. Dangerous, but interesting.
The D's of the old are gone, they have chosen to abandon their core values, and have decided their future is in socialism.
IMHO this was a bad move.
The foundation of America was based in religous freedom, self reliance and an utter distaste for a central goverment.
The current D's plattform stands for the exact opposite, unless they go back to their roots, they are in danger of loosing even more ground.
 
bbking said:
What are you talking about - the Roosevelt D's were far more socialist than today's moderate D.

This is actually true. Beyond universal health care and a few vague words about protectionism in the face of outsourcing, there doesn't seem to be much concrete social policy in the economic field at all on the Dem plate these days. It's probably a sign that the age of economic socialism is well behind us
 
LifeSucks said:
Yes, the intellectal lineage of the concept of "just war" does indeed trace back to the Judeo-Christian tradition. But surely, you must agree that today's conception of jus ad bellum, at least as conceived in the West, is light years removed from that of Thomas Aquinas: it is essentially a modernist concept that has long outgrown theological speculations about the revealed God, and thoroughly immersed in secular, humanistic values. While these values may be as foundational as religious dogma, they are products of Enlightenment that stopped turning to priests and sacred texts long ago.

Modernized would probably be a more precise way of putting it. This or that war isn't just, or is- but says who exactly, and on whose authority ? Why doesn't might make right ? How can a law possibly be binding on the State in light of the brute fact that the State is the highest authority on Earth ? For that matter, why shouldn't the President proclaim himself a God ? There's no answering any of these questions without a minimum of theological speculation, to wit: There exists a supra-human sovereign of sovereigns, who alone can identify his might with right and his will with law and the sacred more generally, who makes his laws known to humans, and invests some of them with competence to judge the actions of earthly rulers on his behalf. The recent case of the late Rachel Corrie, who not only galavanted around without legal authorization in a warzone of a country she wasn't a citizen of, but tried ordering military vehicles to stop- expecting them, in all apparent seriousness, to actually do so :rolleyes: is a particularly clear-cut example of how this theology doesn't need to be made explicit to put itself into practice.
 
There seems to be two major tendencies within the camp of the Dem's, and related parties in other countries these days:

a) One that is properly referred to as "neo-liberal". This camp is above all interested in economics, and has attempted to seriously engage with the criticisms levelled against unreconstructed social democracy, especially in the area of fiscal restraint. Paul Martin, in his role as Finance Minister, was probably the most exemplary representative of this phenomenon. In Europe, PM Tony Blair and others have began to take free-market theory seriously and view the market mechanism as a problem-solving tool instead of a problem in itself to be buried in regulation.

b) The second, represented above all by intellectuals, student-types, and people who frequent fashionable bohemian cocktail parties and lounges, is indifferent to economics. Peeping Tom has justly drawn attention to the religious origins of this group's views (notwithstanding the extravagant and downright decadent lifestyles of many of its members), which amount to little more than a moral criticism of capitalism, in strident exhortations lifted straight out of Old Testament prophecy (whether consciously or not). Where public policy is concerned, this group focuses above all on lifestyle, civil rights, and other non-economic issues: abortion, ecology, sex-ed, gay marriage and opposition to traditional religion in general, etc. Recently, of course, Bush-bashing has become an obsessive pre-occupation of this group.

It seems to me that, in American public life, this frivolous, second camp overwhelmingly dominates the more sober and serious first camp, at least in terms of public profile; witness the last American election, carried out as a politics of negativity against a symbol of Evil.

It would be easy to say that the first camp should split from the second in order to make the party conservative on non-economic issues and moderately socialistic on economic issues, but that would alienate a lot of their urban supporters, and not necessarily do much to impress others for whom laissez-faire has become synonymous with freedom. The Dem's are hanging onto to a shitrope: the harder they try to hold on, the faster they slide down.
 
bbking said:
What are you talking about - the Roosevelt D's were far more socialist than today's moderate D.



bbk

I disagree.
The D's in the past had a much deeper connection to American values, than the ones today.
Faith, hard work, self reliance and morale values were much more part of the D's agenda then today.
I don't believe the current success has so much to do with "conservative values". I think is more about longing for the loss of the "American values" of the past.
The R's have taken advantage of this, buy identifiying themselves wit those core believes.
For example, the push by some for "Gay marriage" is shattering some core believes, the same goes for abortion and the "cheapening " of the value of life.
In the past, even the most staunch Democrat, would have opposed these issues.
Roosevelt's "great deal' was born out of faith. The faith that everyone has the responsibility to help his fellow men. On the basic level this is heartly a notion that anyone can be against. In their hearts very few people are.
The excess of this basic idea and some of the questionable degrading of moral values, is what makes people move towards the Republicans.
IMHO.
 
Neo-Cons?

Let's just call them: WRECKERS OF THE ECONOMY

The numbers below are for 2000-2004.

The Financial markets

S&P 500 -15%
NASDAQ -36%
Dow Jones -5.3%

Consumer income and expenses and Standard of Living

Price of a Gallon of Gas +46%
Real Value of the Minimum Wage -7%
Median Household Income -4%
Average cost of 4-year public college +24%
Poverty Rate +11%
Americans filing for Bankruptcy +33%
Annual Increase in Prescription Drug Prices (from 4.1% t0 6.8%) +68%
Number of Americans without Health insurance +18%

Federal Finances

Federal Debt +39%
Monthly Trade Deficit +75%
Annual Trade Deficit +53%

The dollar

Dollar versus Euro -30%
Dollar versus Yen -11%

Consumer Debt

Home Mortgage Borrowing +100%
Total Outstanding Consumer Debt +28%
Household Debt as a Percentage of Assets: 20%
Household Debt as a Percentage of GDP +21%

Whatever happened to the Republicans of old: fiscally conservative, sensible, kept out of your bedroom, conservers of the environment, believers in the Constitution, etc?

They sold their souls out of a pure lust for power, allowing the fundamentalists to have their nuts in a vise.

You apologists and liars! The Bushies have betrayed everything the Republican party once stood for, and instead you have the Rush Limbaughs, Janes Dobsons, Pat Robertsons, Ann Coulters, Sean Hannitys, and Bill O'Reillys of the world to suck up to. False videos masquerading as news, gay whores patrolling the halls of the White House, lies about why we went to war with Iraq, ignoring the threat of Korea, not going to ONE single funeral of a soldier killed in Iraq, Terry SChiavo, cutting veterans benefits, Condi the Russian language expert (NOT!), Gonzalez the torture apologist, a whitewash of a 911 report, My Pet Goat, and so on and so on.

Your response, no doubt: 911 changed everything! Unfortunately, you read that one out of Frank Luntz' talking points playbook.

No, wait, wiat ... it is all Clinton's fault.
 
TOVisitor said:
Let's just call them: WRECKERS OF THE ECONOMY

The numbers below are for 2000-2004.[...]

It seems that Bush has such God-like powers that he was not only able to induce all these transformations through his evil will alone, but to do it before he even took office...


Whatever happened to the Republicans of old: fiscally conservative, sensible, kept out of your bedroom, conservers of the environment, believers in the Constitution, etc?

What exact Republican of the past kept out of your bedroom as a matter of principle ? Moreover, what Republican of today seriously wants to meddle therein ? As to the Constitution, the Bush administration is on record for wanting to extend Constitutional rights for the law-abiding...

They sold their souls out of a pure lust for power, allowing the fundamentalists to have their nuts in a vise.

Given that they've done exactly nothing for the fundamentalists, it seems that they have the fundies' nuts in a vice...

My Pet Goat.

The President reading story-books to schoolchildren ? Oh, the humanity...

Your response, no doubt: 911 changed everything! Unfortunately, you read that one out of Frank Luntz' talking points playbook.

Who or what on Earth is a Frank Luntz :confused:

No, wait, wiat ... it is all Clinton's fault.

No, it isn't.
 
Ha, ha, ha ...

Truncador said:
It seems that Bush has such God-like powers that he was not only able to induce all these transformations through his evil will alone, but to do it before he even took office... .

What on earth are you talking about? I said 2000 – 2004. I think W was Pres in that period.


Truncador said:
What exact Republican of the past kept out of your bedroom as a matter of principle ? .

Oh, we can start with Barry Goldwater.


Truncador said:
Moreover, what Republican of today seriously wants to meddle therein ? .

Oh where shall I begin? Santorum, Dobson, Frist, Colburn, Robertson, Scalia ... the hits go on and on.

Truncador said:
As to the Constitution, the Bush administration is on record for wanting to extend Constitutional rights for the law-abiding... .

Oh sure, like the people who have been tortured at Gitmo or Abu Ghraib, or who have been the targets of extraordinary renditions, or the American citizens who were held without bail or notice that they were being held. Did you notice that NONE of these folks were charged with a crime? Yup, that’s our administration at work – those law-abiding constitutional guys.


Truncador said:
Given that they've done exactly nothing for the fundamentalists, it seems that they have the fundies' nuts in a vice... .

Ha, ha, ha … spit take. You mean Doctor Dobson and friends won’t be wanting their pound of flesh very, very soon? You are surely deluded.



Truncador said:
The President reading story-books to schoolchildren ? Oh, the humanity... .

From what he has himself said, that’s about the only thing he reads. But surely, if it were Clinton who had sat there reading a book while the US was under attack, you would have been oh-so-graceful and forgiving of his behavior.

Truncador said:
Who or what on Earth is a Frank Luntz :confused: .
You really ARE ignorant, you just don’t only act that way. Google him.

BTW, nice job of ignoring the facts that I presented. If the facts are against you, argue the law. If the law is against you, argue the facts. If neither are with you, say that 911 changed everything.
 
TOVisitor said:
Let's just call them: WRECKERS OF THE ECONOMY

The numbers below are for 2000-2004.

The Financial markets

S&P 500 -15%
NASDAQ -36%
Dow Jones -5.3%

Consumer income and expenses and Standard of Living

Price of a Gallon of Gas +46%
Real Value of the Minimum Wage -7%
Median Household Income -4%
Average cost of 4-year public college +24%
Poverty Rate +11%
Americans filing for Bankruptcy +33%
Annual Increase in Prescription Drug Prices (from 4.1% t0 6.8%) +68%
Number of Americans without Health insurance +18%

Federal Finances

Federal Debt +39%
Monthly Trade Deficit +75%
Annual Trade Deficit +53%

The dollar

Dollar versus Euro -30%
Dollar versus Yen -11%

Consumer Debt

Home Mortgage Borrowing +100%
Total Outstanding Consumer Debt +28%
Household Debt as a Percentage of Assets: 20%
Household Debt as a Percentage of GDP +21%

Whatever happened to the Republicans of old: fiscally conservative, sensible, kept out of your bedroom, conservers of the environment, believers in the Constitution, etc?

They sold their souls out of a pure lust for power, allowing the fundamentalists to have their nuts in a vise.

You apologists and liars! The Bushies have betrayed everything the Republican party once stood for, and instead you have the Rush Limbaughs, Janes Dobsons, Pat Robertsons, Ann Coulters, Sean Hannitys, and Bill O'Reillys of the world to suck up to. False videos masquerading as news, gay whores patrolling the halls of the White House, lies about why we went to war with Iraq, ignoring the threat of Korea, not going to ONE single funeral of a soldier killed in Iraq, Terry SChiavo, cutting veterans benefits, Condi the Russian language expert (NOT!), Gonzalez the torture apologist, a whitewash of a 911 report, My Pet Goat, and so on and so on.

Your response, no doubt: 911 changed everything! Unfortunately, you read that one out of Frank Luntz' talking points playbook.

No, wait, wiat ... it is all Clinton's fault.


SOROS is it you???Oh, maybe its MM?
The argument could be made(if somebody was stupid enough to believe it), that the stock market decline began under Clinton's watch. Believe me I know, because I lost my shirt as part of the NASDAQ bubble.

You lefties and your ever present desire, that the goverment is responsible for your failure or for your well being. You poor soul, waiting all his life for the "big brother" to take him out of his misery.Still waitng and getting angry in the process, because the help doesn't come.Oh..my.

In any case, while you sit there and cry about the "evil George" being responsible for all the woes of the US economy.
I suggest you take off your blinders and look to the rest of the world, especially Europe and Japan, and find out how their economy did or is doing inthe same cycle??
True that the Euro is the currency "du jour", but will ultimately fail in the long run.
The "housing bubble" has created an economy of it's own, just think about all the jobs are being created, and the money spend in connection with it.

The US economy i by far the most resillient and strongest in the world. The threat of China has added to the pressure, no doubt.
I can assure you, that before the US economy will fall, there is a long line of economies in front of us, that will fall first.
3-4% growth in the last quarter!! Name one European country, that can show the same, well maybe Ireland and Spain, but those are emerging economies.What was the last number in Japan?
I suggest, don't waste your time, by waiting for the "evil empire" to fall. Instead round up your energy, stop waiting for the goverment and make something of yourself. Whining and complaining is not going to get you there.
Cheers,
 
bbking said:
All in all Lange - once again you had an opportunity to talk in a rational manner but instead you decided to us the time honoured method of all conservatives and bash liberals for the sake of bashing.
bbk

You are right..I was over the top, and I shouldn't let myself get down to this level.
I just got tired of the constant negativism. However two worngs don't make a right...point taken..
 
Perfect Storm That Could Drown the Economy

langeweile said:
...The US economy i by far the most resillient and strongest in the world. The threat of China has added to the pressure, no doubt.
I can assure you, that before the US economy will fall, there is a long line of economies in front of us, that will fall first.

How might a perfect storm be created? It would likely gather overseas, and wouldn't necessarily take the form of a terrorist strike or oil shock. The United States finances its spendthrift ways by selling dollars and dollar-denominated securities (like Treasury bills) to foreign creditors, mostly to central banks in Asia. To sustain growth, the United States needs foreign creditors to continue to add to their piles every day.

Any signs to the contrary are worrisome. In February, when the Korean government suggested that the Bank of Korea might diversify its foreign exchange holdings, "this seemingly innocuous statement set off a small panic in our stocks and bond markets," said James Grant, editor of Grant's Interest Rate Observer.

If the Bank of China, which has been accumulating dollars at the rate of $200 billion a year, decides to cut back on new purchases, either to diversify or to let its currency appreciate, the United States would quickly have to offer sharply higher interest rates to retain existing investors and entice new ones. Nouriel Roubini, an economics professor at New York University's Stern School of Business, estimates that if China cut its rate of accumulation by half, long-term interest rates in the United States could rise by 200 basis points over a few months and the value of the dollar would fall.

Such a rising tide - the yield on the 10-year bond shooting from 4.25 to 6.25, the average 30-year mortgage rising from 6 percent to 8 percent - would mean instantly higher borrowing costs for the government, businesses and consumers. It would drench Wall Street, soaking the stocks of giant interest-rate-sensitive blue chips like Citigroup and making life difficult for speculative, debt-ridden companies. Some highly leveraged hedge funds or investment banks caught on the wrong side of trades would incur significant losses.....

link:
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/08/w...64944640&ex=1273204800&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss
 
TOVisitor said:
What on earth are you talking about? I said 2000 – 2004. I think W was Pres in that period.

He didn't take office until 2001.

Oh, we can start with Barry Goldwater.

In his day, the biggest perceived moral dangers were comic books, the haircuts of the Beatles, maybe even Playboy magazine. The sexuality issues that get debated today would have simply been inconceivable then; even the most brazen libertines weren't talking about the likes of gay marriage.


Oh where shall I begin? Santorum, Dobson, Frist, Colburn, Robertson, Scalia ... the hits go on and on. [...] You mean Doctor Dobson and friends won’t be wanting their pound of flesh very, very soon? You are surely deluded.

The Federal government in America doesn't have the legislative competence to give them a pound of flesh or much of anything else. Many religious people today appear to be embarassed by the Moral Majority-type antics of the 80s and have disavowed the project of forcing people to be moral through legislation, focusing instead on the family and above all parenting. Meanwhile, at the level of the State, Pres. Bush doesn't strike me as a paragon of Christian virtue; the Neo-Cons are far too preoccupied with foreign policy to worry about anything else; and the First Lady boasts about going to see male strippers with Lynne Cheney and Condi.


Oh sure, like the people who have been tortured at Gitmo or Abu Ghraib, or who have been the targets of extraordinary renditions, or the American citizens who were held without bail or notice that they were being held. Did you notice that NONE of these folks were charged with a crime? Yup, that’s our administration at work – those law-abiding constitutional guys.

9-11 changed everything...In any other country, post-911 would have seen- at minimum- a state of martial law, under which everyone's rights and immunities would have been suspended, accompanied by mass preventative detention of everyone the police even suspected of being a sympathizer. Google October Crisis, if you're not from Canada. The Administration's policy of selectively removing enemy combatants from the sphere of Constitutional protection altogether, leaving the Constitution itself intact, is exemplary.

But surely, if it were Clinton who had sat there reading a book while the US was under attack, you would have been oh-so-graceful and forgiving of his behavior.

Yes, I would, since there's nothing to forgive any leader for in that particular case, where security personnel were standing at the back of the classroom with a big sign advising the President not to leave the room (for fear there may have been terrorists in the building).


BTW, nice job of ignoring the facts that I presented

You presented a jumble of economic factoids without any clear logical connection to each other or any concrete government policy, and then presented a jumble of one-liner character asassinations. You then attempted to pre-emptively disqualify any discussion of the terror problem as somehow frivolous, or as evidence of manipulation by party propagandists. In the study of propaganda, they call this "inoculation" or something. Whose talking-points manual are you following ?
 
Truncador said:
In any other country, post-911 would have seen- at minimum- a state of martial law, under which everyone's rights and immunities would have been suspended, accompanied by mass preventative detention of everyone the police even suspected of being a sympathizer.

Oh, please. Every other country in the world would have reacted this way, huh? You don't help your argument by exaggerating to ridiculous extremes.
 
bbking said:
I really don't see this doomsday scenario that some people do and I really believe that no one has lost money betting on the US economy
bbk

These doomsday scenarios come out every couple years and usually make for a good read if they are reasoned out well. We can only hope they don't come to pass, however present deficit spending is not sustainable over the long term. The whole world economy becomes a house of cards when everyone starts doing it.
 
bbking said:
Your right the economy was going south before W took office but perhaps that turn was because of the fact he was going to take office. Actually the timing could be attributed both administrations, the fact is the slow down was a normal economic cycle and to argue who's responsible is silly.
bbl

Don't forget the main reason for 'the economy going south before W took office' was due to Alan Greenspan jacking up interest rates almost every chance Alan could! The GOP then applauded and encouraged these rate hikes saying they were necessary to 'slow down' Clinton's red hot economy! Greenspan said his main reason for this was due to fears of 'inflation' that never materialized back then. Others felt Greenspan's main reason was more politically motivated, namely a desire to reign in Bill Clinton's rip-roaring economy which was doing so nicely then.

Now it is comical to see that when those many Greenspan interest rate increases did finally kick in and slow down the economy, as designed by the GOP, the GOP try to blame Clinton for this slowdown that the GOP caused in the first place........ :p

Another comical point back then was when the GOP used to say Alan Greenspan was the man behind Clinton's boom. They would argue that Greenspan deserved all credit for the 90's economic boom and controlled it from the Fed with Clinton merely benefiting from Alan's expert policy moves at the Fed.

To this I used to answer if Alan made Clinton look so good in the 90's, then why is Alan making W look so bad after 2001? It almost made it look as if Alan was a stealth Dem out to 'git' W......
 
Asterix said:
Oh, please. Every other country in the world would have reacted this way, huh? You don't help your argument by exaggerating to ridiculous extremes.

Well, my country reacted exactly that way in the face of a terror crisis in which the Quebec Liberation Front (FLQ) kidnapped a government minister and an ambassador in 1970, murdering one of them. Emergency powers were invoked, Montreal placed under military occupation (complete with soldiers in battle gear armed with assault rifles patrolling the streets alongside tanks), hundreds of people- mostly hippie-type, Left-wing activists with no connection to the terror group- were arrested without charge and held incommunicado for weeks, and a whole heap of warrantless search-and-seizures were carried out at the whim of the police.

This happened in a country where civil rights are protected just a little less strictly than in the USA and respect for the rule of law and the rights of the subject far more embedded than just about any other country on Earth outside the Anglosphere.

Even though the action was very effective and arguably necessary (many experts conclude that it prevented the FLQ from becoming institutionalized the way the IRA did in the UK), it revealed a troubling side of State power, one that is potentially present in any modern country. That this dark side of power wasn't, post-911, manifested on the interior of Amercan society is remarkable, almost astonishing, when you think about it.
 
Politicians will always claim if the economy is good, that it was all their doing. They will always try to blame someone else, if it goes wrong. See Bush Sr.!
Unfortunately most people believe this hype, pending on which side of the fence they sit.
Personally I believe,that politicians only can influence the climate of an economy. The less they do, the better. We all know what happens to economies, where the goverment is trying to control it. :mad:

This is more so true today, when economies are more connected on a global level.