Karl Rove and co. didn't exactly do their thing in a vacuum; at least one American pollster already saw the split coming in the early 1960s, and the Dem's- as they are now beginning to acknowledge- brought it on themselves. The Dem's of old were first and foremost champions of the working class at a time when most people worked at industrial jobs. By the end of the 60s, the Dem's and/or the Left more generally abandoned the working-class cause in favour of more trendy issues like civil rights, feminism, abortion, environment, affirmative action, etc. The old focus had been primarily economic; the new one raised culture and lifestyle issues to the fore, and it was here that things began to unravel. It turned out that the "little guy" in America is, in many ways, a rather conservative fellow who flies a flag, wants to see criminals severely punished, and favours at least some social standards of modesty. This same individual distrusts Big Government as much or more than he does Big Business, and insists on his freedom to drive fast cars, to smoke, to raise his kids as he sees fit, and above all, to keep and bear arms (one of the biggest mistakes the postmodern Dem's made was to attempt to trespass upon the latter).
Furthermore, as many of the little guys moved up into the middle classes, Republican tax cuts became more and more appealing; where the Dem's saw in tax cuts only an excuse for the rich to get richer at the expense of the little guy, the little guy himself saw an opportunity to become more independent- and in this respect stopped seeing Big Business as his natural enemy, but rather as an ally in the fight against the nanny-State (another central nail in the Dem coffin).
With increasing individualism and economic independence, the elitist and patrician style of the Dem's became more and more intolerable. The Dem's had inherited an old aristocratic tradition whereby they just sort of saw themselves as the natural spokesmen and protectors of the Commons, appointing themselves as the leadership of constituencies from which they expected obedience and allegiance as their rightful due (something that is still true with respect to Blacks). This was a lot easier back when most people belonged to unions and lived under machine politics (especially in urban areas and the South), and obedience could be secured with patronage or even the threat of violence. Along with declining union membership and less corrupt municipal politics came greater individualism, under which people are both less likely to vote the way local bosses tell them to and to believe they need someone to protect them from being exploited by the rich.
Aggravating the situation even further is that, following the Civil Rights movement, urban liberals from the North came to view working-class, rural, and/or Southern Whites with undisguised contempt as "Archie Bunker slobs", "rednecks", "trailer park trash", etc. This had the effect of turning traditional anti-elitism away from resentment of the rich and towards resentment of "cultural elites" and "East Coast Liberals", who were hated not for their wealth, but for their attitudes. In the South in particular, this cost the Dem's what were once hereditary seats, and comprised the final nail in the party's coffin.
Right now, the insane campaign being waged by ACLU-types (indelibly associated with the Dem's in the public mind) to outlaw public expression of religious faith, the baffling, truly incomprehensible refusal of the party to give ground on 2nd Amendment issues, and the tendency of many outspoken Dem supporters to despise their opponents as intellectually and even genetically inferior barbarians and usurpers- among others- all end up doing Karl Rove's job for him. He could base Republican press releases and speeches on stuff he plagiarized from restaurant place-mats and baseball cards, and the Rep's would still come out on top.