Neo-cons vs Neo-libs?

langeweile

Banned
Sep 21, 2004
5,085
0
0
In a van down by the river
I am trying to read and finish David Mcculloughs biography of Truman.
By most standards today he would be considered a neo-con or a conservative, but he was a Democrat??
The term neo-con today is being almost used in demeaning way. If I compare Truman, to todays democratic party, the term neo-lib would be very fitting.

The D's plattform today is a long way from Truman's, or the past D's plattforms. What has changed?
 
langeweile said:
I am trying to read and finish David Mcculloughs biography of Truman.
By most standards today he would be considered a neo-con or a conservative, but he was a Democrat??
The term neo-con today is being almost used in demeaning way. If I compare Truman, to todays democratic party, the term neo-lib would be very fitting.

The D's plattform today is a long way from Truman's, or the past D's plattforms. What has changed?

The Democrats have moved so far to the left that they have isolated themselves from many of their traditional sources of power. In my home state of Minnesota the Democratic party is called the DFL (Democratic Farmer Labor), how many farmers do you think vote for Democrats these days.

OTB
 
Where can I find the platform for neo-moderates, liberal conservatives, or conservative liberals? What ever happened to "consensus building"?
 
langeweile,

As I'm sure you're aware, in 1949 Truman proposed the "Fair Deal", including among other things his plan for national health insurance, increased minimum wage and equal rights in employment. If you consider this would make him a neo-con by today's standards, I must be missing something.
 
Many neo-Con's are former Dem's or ex-Marxists. One of the main differences, at least in theory, between the neo-Con's and unreconstructed Conservatives or Libertarians is that the NCs acknowledge the need for a baseline level of social government.
 
Asterix said:
langeweile,

As I'm sure you're aware, in 1949 Truman proposed the "Fair Deal", including among other things his plan for national health insurance, increased minimum wage and equal rights in employment. If you consider this would make him a neo-con by today's standards, I must be missing something.

Ok so you found one point where he qualifies as a liberal, and there might be a few more.
This however iginores that he believed in hard work, self reliance and was a morally strong person.
It is true that he believed that if you are in need that you should be helped, but not to the point where it created a dependency on the goverment.This is very much in line with my thinking and defies everything the D's stand for today.

The term neo-con in my opinion does not define anyhting of any consequence. Personally I reject this whole classification. It is being used in a way that describes a "wannabe" conservative. Very much an attempt to discredit those that are in power.
On second thought maybe Truman doesn't deserve that term, he was to great of a man, that acted on principle rather than on polls.
So maybe he was more of a true conservative. In this case the question still remains, how can a party like the democrats, devolve in to shadow of their former principles.
The current administration is much closer to the roots of conservatism, than the democrats are to their former plattform.
They sound more and more like European socialists than democratic Americans.
 
That is a useful observation. It is symptomatic of a general being of uselessness, the helpless cries of the shunned hysteric. The American left adopted this path during the Reagan years, when it became evident that he would destroy the evil empire regardless of the level of screaming. Ditto for the left under Bush - the ME is being reformed regardless of the left's antics.

The antics of Europe's left are driven by the same helplessness - it is the elites that make most of the decisions and quite naturally elites tend to be contemptuous of the masses.

It is instructive to look at the approaches of the left towards the ME: Nada, zip, squat. Same with the evil empire under Reagan. This utter lack of any positive suggestions makes one question what their true agenda contains.

langeweile said:
[...] than the democrats are to their former plattform.
They sound more and more like European socialists than democratic Americans.
 
Peeping Tom said:
That is a useful observation. It is symptomatic of a general being of uselessness, the helpless cries of the shunned hysteric. The American left adopted this path during the Reagan years, when it became evident that he would destroy the evil empire regardless of the level of screaming. Ditto for the left under Bush - the ME is being reformed regardless of the left's antics.

Both Reagan and Bush have the heroic quality of being able to stay the course without faltering or self-doubt in the face of a vast ocean of screamers trying to jinx them. Not Bush Sr. though- that wimp was so afraid of a renewed anti-war movement that he couldn't even muster enough resolve to just get rid of the Sultan when the opportunity presented itself, leaving his son to finish what he started...
 
Truncador said:
Both Reagan and Bush have the heroic quality of being able to stay the course without faltering or self-doubt...

Heroic? These same qualities could just as easily describe someone who is pig-headed, lacks imagination, and has no ability to examine their own motives.
 
Americanson is a hero
 
Asterix said:
Heroic? These same qualities could just as easily describe someone who is pig-headed, lacks imagination, and has no ability to examine their own motives.

Can we at least agree that, whatever the personal faults of Reagan and Bush Jr., lack of imagination isn't one of them ?

Reagan was predicting the immanent demise of the Soviet at a time when the big question being debated wasn't whether or not the East would crumble as a result of its own internal contradictions, but whether or not the West would.

Time will tell whether or not the Bush doctrine will bear fruit, but you can't fault it for being unambitious or short-sighted.
 
Karl Rove and co. didn't exactly do their thing in a vacuum; at least one American pollster already saw the split coming in the early 1960s, and the Dem's- as they are now beginning to acknowledge- brought it on themselves. The Dem's of old were first and foremost champions of the working class at a time when most people worked at industrial jobs. By the end of the 60s, the Dem's and/or the Left more generally abandoned the working-class cause in favour of more trendy issues like civil rights, feminism, abortion, environment, affirmative action, etc. The old focus had been primarily economic; the new one raised culture and lifestyle issues to the fore, and it was here that things began to unravel. It turned out that the "little guy" in America is, in many ways, a rather conservative fellow who flies a flag, wants to see criminals severely punished, and favours at least some social standards of modesty. This same individual distrusts Big Government as much or more than he does Big Business, and insists on his freedom to drive fast cars, to smoke, to raise his kids as he sees fit, and above all, to keep and bear arms (one of the biggest mistakes the postmodern Dem's made was to attempt to trespass upon the latter).

Furthermore, as many of the little guys moved up into the middle classes, Republican tax cuts became more and more appealing; where the Dem's saw in tax cuts only an excuse for the rich to get richer at the expense of the little guy, the little guy himself saw an opportunity to become more independent- and in this respect stopped seeing Big Business as his natural enemy, but rather as an ally in the fight against the nanny-State (another central nail in the Dem coffin).

With increasing individualism and economic independence, the elitist and patrician style of the Dem's became more and more intolerable. The Dem's had inherited an old aristocratic tradition whereby they just sort of saw themselves as the natural spokesmen and protectors of the Commons, appointing themselves as the leadership of constituencies from which they expected obedience and allegiance as their rightful due (something that is still true with respect to Blacks). This was a lot easier back when most people belonged to unions and lived under machine politics (especially in urban areas and the South), and obedience could be secured with patronage or even the threat of violence. Along with declining union membership and less corrupt municipal politics came greater individualism, under which people are both less likely to vote the way local bosses tell them to and to believe they need someone to protect them from being exploited by the rich.

Aggravating the situation even further is that, following the Civil Rights movement, urban liberals from the North came to view working-class, rural, and/or Southern Whites with undisguised contempt as "Archie Bunker slobs", "rednecks", "trailer park trash", etc. This had the effect of turning traditional anti-elitism away from resentment of the rich and towards resentment of "cultural elites" and "East Coast Liberals", who were hated not for their wealth, but for their attitudes. In the South in particular, this cost the Dem's what were once hereditary seats, and comprised the final nail in the party's coffin.

Right now, the insane campaign being waged by ACLU-types (indelibly associated with the Dem's in the public mind) to outlaw public expression of religious faith, the baffling, truly incomprehensible refusal of the party to give ground on 2nd Amendment issues, and the tendency of many outspoken Dem supporters to despise their opponents as intellectually and even genetically inferior barbarians and usurpers- among others- all end up doing Karl Rove's job for him. He could base Republican press releases and speeches on stuff he plagiarized from restaurant place-mats and baseball cards, and the Rep's would still come out on top.
 
Truncador said:
Can we at least agree that, whatever the personal faults of Reagan and Bush Jr., lack of imagination isn't one of them ?

Depends on how you would define imagination. If defined as child-like imagination, the ability to go beyond perceived reality into a world of our own making, I might agree. Child-like imagination also has a strong tendency to fantasy based on the desires of the ego, and in issues of conflict, an attraction to identifying sides in black and white, or good and evil. In this, GW has in abundance.

Adult-like imagination has the ability to go beyond the self, and consider the possibilities and moral consequences not only of our own actions, but what others may do in response, or simply, to put ourselves in anothers shoes. As a symbol, the game of chess offers a perfect example, whereas the truly successful player is not merely concerned with their next move, but is able to see four or five moves ahead. To be fair to Reagan, he possessed this quality sufficiently to be able to get inside the heads of other leaders, like Gorbachev, long enough to figure out how they would react. I've seen very little of this ability in GW. Watching him in press conferences and in the debates, his confusion when anyone suggests an alternative view appears genuine, as if he can't understand any other assumption than his own. On the international stage this translates into his tendency to go it alone when frustrated by his inability to get what he wants.

Truncador said:
Time will tell whether or not the Bush doctrine will bear fruit, but you can't fault it for being unambitious or short-sighted.

As far as faulting him for not being ambitious, you're probably right. As far as faulting him for being short-sighted, sure I can.
 
Asterix said:
Adult-like imagination has the ability to go beyond the self, and consider the possibilities and moral consequences not only of our own actions, but what others may do in response, or simply, to put ourselves in anothers shoes. As a symbol, the game of chess offers a perfect example, whereas the truly successful player is not merely concerned with their next move, but is able to see four or five moves ahead. To be fair to Reagan, he possessed this quality sufficiently to be able to get inside the heads of other leaders, like Gorbachev, long enough to figure out how they would react. I've seen very little of this ability in GW. Watching him in press conferences and in the debates, his confusion when anyone suggests an alternative view appears genuine, as if he can't understand any other assumption than his own. On the international stage this translates into his tendency to go it alone when frustrated by his inability to get what he wants.

Bush might answer, on the basis of a sound appreciation of French history and manners, that it might have been an extremely bad idea to fuel the fires of French vanity by allowing them to think that America can't go to war without their say-so at a time when the French were beginning to openly fancy themselves as "rivals" of America. Four or five moves ahead of that particular move would possibly have been a war with France...
 
The problem that will keep the Democrats down for a long time to come is one of their own making: the hubris of belief that their ideology is the correct one. Liberalism subconciously equates God with government and replaces the former with the latter. The effect of this is to transcend religion from the ethereal, where liberalism detests it, into the real, as a form of practical idealism. Thus, the recent secularist extremism of the movement (both here and Europe) makes perfect sense, after all it is merely attempting to stamp out the competing religious movements. It is not just a set of appearances similar to religion - it is the real thing. See the State religions of the 20th century (National Socialism, Soviet communism, Maoism etc.) as examples of attempting to bring these types of belief to perfection.

bbk's post shows all too clearly that a faith in dogma can have adverse side effects. The reply by Truncador was excellent; detailing all the relevant sociological data, yet he didn't approach one thing explicitly: that the dogma of the Democrats is sealed, a done deal. That is the reason such dogma lost two recent elections - it was old and tired and the people were weary of hearing it. In contrast, the Republican dogma is a dynamic, constantly under construction. Karl Rove didn't flip anything: He delivered the message that was relevant to the day.

bbk said:
Bottom line is that the Dems will have to find a way to make this work for them and they are going to have to do it without these hi-sounding bites of info. It can be done, but first the Dems have to communicate better than they are doing today.

bbk, that is wrong - it wasn't the packaging, it was the product that couldn't sell That product was the result of a system of beliefs. Those beliefs focused on a core theme: That President Bush was wrong because he was a moron. Yet, because he won elections, he was not only a moron but an evil genious as well. bbk: Can you note the problem in this? It doesn't matter who packages this product - be it Dean, Kerry or some squeegy kid on the block - the product itself just plain stinks.
 
Peeping Tom said:
The effect of this is to transcend religion from the ethereal, where liberalism detests it, into the real, as a form of practical idealism.

In this respect, the revival of the medieval, theocratic notion of a "just war" (shorn of the theological reference) on the part of the anti-Bush anti-war activists is highly suggestive. Indeed, neither the concept of "international law" nor "human rights" even make sense outside of a theological, Judeo-Christian frame of reference. Explicit references to God may drop out, but remain in the background as an unstated assumption- one which can remain unstated precisely to the extent that it is utterly foundational, e.g. can simply be taken as a given.


It is not just a set of appearances similar to religion - it is the real thing.

In the 80s and 90s, the uber-elite "Communitarian" intellectual movement within the Democratic Party (which was roughly to the Dem's of the Clinton era what Neo-Con is to the Rep's today) was not only tracing its own origins to the utopian, theocratic vision of the Puritans, Quakers, and other fanatical Protestant sects, but celebrating that heritage and holding it up as the sole and unique authentically American political tradition. For some reason, they don't like to talk about this anymore lately :p
 
Truncador said:
Bush might answer, on the basis of a sound appreciation of French history and manners, that it might have been an extremely bad idea to fuel the fires of French vanity by allowing them to think that America can't go to war without their say-so at a time when the French were beginning to openly fancy themselves as "rivals" of America. Four or five moves ahead of that particular move would possibly have been a war with France...

War with France? I wouldn't have expected this level of silliness from even americanson. My point was that President George W. Bush Jr. has no real ability, or even a desire, to think critically. Less charitable folks would simply say that he's a dumbass.
 
Asterix said:
War with France? I wouldn't have expected this level of silliness from even americanson.

So much for the question of lack of imagination...


Less charitable folks would simply say that he's a dumbass.

Who nonetheless managed to become the most powerful and influential person in human history to date...
 
Truncador said:
Who nonetheless managed to become the most powerful and influential person in human history to date...

Well maybe most powerful.....but only by default, his access to the nuke button is scary though! Lets just hope Uncle Dickie restrains him......

As far as influential in human history....no way, not even a blip on the radar screen unless he does as feared and hits that nuke button launching 'armageddon' as some fear.......:eek:

FYI: the late Pope John Paul II, had it all over W on both of the above counts.

Blessed are the peacemakers for they shall be called the children of God.
Matthew 5:9
...Thanks for the quote Blitz.