Negotiating a Severance Package

The employer tried to argue it had given the employee 6 months notice. The court found that the employer had given 3 months notice. The court found that the employee was entitled to 18 months notice. So I think the "added value" is actually pretty clear.

Anyone who cares enough go read the document. It is two lawyers launching appeals to a higher court. Both appeals are thrown out.



It is funny that you do not even realize how completely ignorant you are.

Anyone who cares enough go read the document. It has nothing to do with a layoff. They went after a woman and it was BS. Woman was a Chief Administrator. I wonder if that is middle management.

These cases that you mock are the exact same ones, or very similar to what your precious database is going to kick out. It will not distinguish between cases where a person was told they were being "laid off" and cases where an employer fired someone alleging they had just cause to do so, and were later found not to have just cause - the distinction, for the purposes of determining the notice period the employee is entitled to, is irrelevant.

Wow lots of words. Anyone who cares just go to the web site and find out what people in your situation are getting :) .

My point, as it has been all along, is that everything you have said about employment law in Canada, with the exception of the Thomson Reuters database (i.e., minimum notice period one week per year of service for hourly employees, one month per year of service for management, no one below middle managment gets more than one month per year of service in notice, senior executives might get more than 2 years reasonable notice) has been complete crap and could not have been uttered by anyone even remotely familiar with Canadian employment law - particularly a US HR executive - trust me, they know Canadian employment law and whenever the topic comes up they accuse us of being a bunch of communists because it is so completely different than what they are used to dealing with in the US.


Whatever you say. ya ya. Bottom line. How the fuck am I supposed to know the laws and why would I care? I was told by someone in the industry that when they had a layoff, (regardless of what words you like a layoff is a layoff and most people here know what it means) that what you would get was pretty standard. Hourly rate guys get screwed and do not get much. 1 week a year worked was his ball park. Staff should about a month per year.

Executives get what they get. Simple. If the OP thinks I am way off he can check on the web site they use to set the packages.

Of course if they lured someone away from another company it gets complicated. Lots of things make it complicated. But there are general guidelines and anyone with $50 can get an estimate of what they can expect in THEIR situation.

So what is your point? Am I a lawyer? Dahhhhhh no. Am I capable of reporting comments to the board from someone who worked in the HR universe? Dahhhhh yes. Do I choose to even try and use legal jargon? Of course not who cares?

If you get caught stealing and they fire you you get next to nothing (ya I know unions can appeal etc). If it is proven you were not steeling you get a lot :).

Everyone knows that.

What is it with you? Do you have any point at all other than confirming I am not a lawyer? Did I ever claim to be a lawyer. I am also not a hairdresser, painter, mechanic, etc. Who gives a fuck? Why are you working so hard creating straw men so you can prove they are wrong? Why do you want me to say things I did not?
 
OK, just for shits and giggles lets do some more - now it might take a while to find them, because you know, they are very "rare":

Brown v. OK Builders Suppliers Ltd. - 10 year systems analyst, voluntarily left mgmt team before termination, 10 years service, 12 months notice
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1985/1985canlii688/1985canlii688.html

Davidson v. Worthing - 3 yr p/t book keeper, 5 months notice awarded
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1986/1986canlii850/1986canlii850.html

Lacroix v Eso Resources Canada Ltd. - superintendent, 12 year employee, 18 month notice period assessed but not awarded
http://canlii.ca/en/ab/abqb/doc/1988/1988canlii3821/1988canlii3821.html

Koren v White Spot Ltd - purchasing manager, 8 years employment, 10 months notice awarded
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1988/1988canlii2913/1988canlii2913.html

McIntyre v Atlantic Hardchrome Ltd. et al. - chromium electro-plater, 2.5 years of employment, 4 months of notice (reversed on other grounds by the Nova Scotial Court of Appeal)
http://canlii.ca/en/ns/nssc/doc/1991/1991canlii4445/1991canlii4445.html

Sorry, go find a lawyer to argue with. last 3 were BS and I am not getting payed enough to bother reading stuff from other provinces.

I withdraw from trying to understand you
 
What is it with you? Do you have any point at all other than confirming I am not a lawyer? Did I ever claim to be a lawyer. I am also not a hairdresser, painter, mechanic, etc. Who gives a fuck? Why are you working so hard creating straw men so you can prove they are wrong? Why do you want me to say things I did not?

Thanks for proving Simon right.

To be crystal clear - my point is that everything you have said about employment law, beyond finding a commercially available database, has been complete crap. No one, with even the faintest idea about Canadian employment law would have said those things. My point is that "HR' dinner companion is a figment of your imagination and yet another fairly pathetic attempt on your part to convince people that you inhabit this fabulous world, where you socialize with fabulous people and anything you might ever want, or need, to know is no more than a table setting away.
 
Thanks for proving Simon right.

To be crystal clear - my point is that everything you have said about employment law, beyond finding a commercially available database, has been complete crap. No one, with even the faintest idea about Canadian employment law would have said those things. My point is that "HR' dinner companion is a figment of your imagination and yet another fairly pathetic attempt on your part to convince people that you inhabit this fabulous world, where you socialize with fabulous people and anything you might ever want, or need, to know is no more than a table setting away.


Oh I get it, you are jealous of my lifestyle and the fact that I can get a bit of information on most topics easily. OK now I understand. It should have been obvious.
 
Loki's fake wife character, a med school dropout turned prostitute turned trophy wife (ie, someone who would have ZERO experience or knowledge of labour law), sure learned a lot about severance packages from eavesdropping on a dinner conversation a bunch of old retired guys were having. And quite a technical (and awfully boring) conversation it must have been!!

Here's a hint for a new story line, dude - go back to posting as Loki. Either say you kicked your 'wife' off the internet because it was causing her too much stress and that was affecting the 'baby', or say you broke up with her. Both options are face-saving ways of ending this farce.
 
Loki's fake wife character, a med school dropout turned prostitute turned trophy wife (ie, someone who would have ZERO experience or knowledge of labour law), sure learned a lot about severance packages from eavesdropping on a dinner conversation a bunch of old retired guys were having. And quite a technical (and awfully boring) conversation it must have been!!

Here's a hint for a new story line, dude - go back to posting as Loki. Either say you kicked your 'wife' off the internet because it was causing her too much stress and that was affecting the 'baby', or say you broke up with her. Both options are face-saving ways of ending this farce.

Wow you really love to attack me at every importunity don't you.

A tiny course just for you on social interaction.....

If you have a few couples sitting at the same table for dinner you should try to engage the people in conversation. Men love to talk about themselves and the things they do. If you read a question like the one posted by the OP, and are sitting next to a retired HR guy all you need to do is ask the question and the guy will happily respond and give you a lot of information :).

I like to learn things so it was not boring.

You might try it sometime. You might like it. JUst use a crow bar and open your mind to reality and other people.

Oh and I have no intention of leaving LL. He makes me happy.
 
Well hun,

I bet you associate with gas station attendants and truck drivers socially :) We associate with retired people from corporations.


Qui se resemble, s’assemble.



Seems like your friends consort with prostitutes and men who shop for their wives by test driving them one by one?

Not that there is anything wrong with that.. so why don't you refer your friend to TERB and have him join the conversation? :eyebrows:
 
Seems like your friends consort with prostitutes and men who shop for their wives by test driving them one by one?

Not that there is anything wrong with that.. so why don't you refer your friend to TERB and have him join the conversation? :eyebrows:

Whatever.
 
After a layoff, what's the best technique for negotiating a severance package? If you were there 10 years, how much should you be asking for?

Get a labour lawyer!

But before you chat with them, sit down and summarize all the facts with timelines. Start date, last date worked, how long you were there, why you joined (did they recruit you away from another employer), your roles and responsibilities, number of people that you may have supervised, size of budget you managed, various promotions and overall career path. Did they give you any warning before this happened? Any issues with changes in supervisor and possible constructuve dismissal events before it happened (cutting your responsibilities essentially resulting in a demotion versus what you had done although your title may have stayed the same). Anyway there's probably a dozen more things to consider that I'm not thinking of right now, but the more that you summarize and jot down the less you will be thinking out loud when you talk with the lawyer while the meter is running. It may even make sense to type out the summary in bullet point format and email it to the lawyer before you chat. As long as it's a half page and no more than one page and succinct, you might save yourself $100-$200 because they can read it quickly and focus on specific questions to ask you instead of starting from scratch. And give serious thought about the likelihood that you will find a similar role soon...it will give your lawyer ammo to consider getting a lump sum or having the severance paid out over time. Lump sums are always smaller, but if you get a job right away you're better off. Whereas if you get a package paid over time (and they might have a clause that if you find work before the end of the schedule of payments they have the right to recoup say 50% of the outstanding amount to be paid to you) it's usually larger. So if you doubt you can find something quickly, or just feel like kicking up your feet for a bit (but of course make some effort to appear that you are in fact looking for work) then the non-lump sum might be the way to go. Again, the more you think about such things the less time you are thinking out loud when the meter is running so when the actual expert lawyer raises them you can say what you are thinking and get some direction based on your actual situation and spend less $$$ on legal fees.

Be sure to ask the lawyer how much they think your case will cost you. They should have a general idea based on your scenario (and any possible complexities) how many hours it "should" take and can give you an estimate. Don't go in blindly and let them run up the bill. If there are no addditional complexities (and you didn't do anything to cause some delay or increase the work on their end) then you can always say "but you told me this would cost $XXX-$XXXX and the lawyer might be willing to eat some time and reduce their fees if they can't justify why it took more time than they estimated. It's not as simple as this, but you can try to cover yourself and appear to be better informed if you try to get some sort of an idea. And always try to get the former employer to pay all or some of the legal fees!

Good luck
 
The biggest mistake people - employees and employers alike - make in Employment law is thinking that the Employment Standards Act is the last word on an employers obligations to its employees upon termination of employment. The ESA is where the (wrong) notion that a terminated employee is only entitled to one week notice (or pay in lieu of notice) per year of service derives from. The ESA is the statutory minimum that an employee is owed - however a court will also take into account the "common law", which usually results in a much longer period of notice being awarded to the employee.

Size of company per se is not a factor I have ever seen considered in a wrongful termination decision. it becomes a secondary factor inasmuch as the duties and responsibilities of a 'vice-president" of a small, family owned business might not be in any way comparable to the duties and responsibiltiies of a v.p. of a multi-national and might, in fact, be more analagous to the duties and responsibilities of an intermediate manager of the multi-national. However I have never seen where a Court has said that just because a company is small it owe its employees a shorter notice period.

thats right
 
Wow you really love to attack me at every importunity don't you.

A tiny course just for you on social interaction.....

If you have a few couples sitting at the same table for dinner you should try to engage the people in conversation. Men love to talk about themselves and the things they do. If you read a question like the one posted by the OP, and are sitting next to a retired HR guy all you need to do is ask the question and the guy will happily respond and give you a lot of information :).

I like to learn things so it was not boring.

You might try it sometime. You might like it. JUst use a crow bar and open your mind to reality and other people.

Oh and I have no intention of leaving LL. He makes me happy.

I'm not attacking you I am trying to help you navigate the mental illness that is causing you to pretend to be a woman on the Internet. Maybe one day you will be healthy again and see that. Good luck, mister. Seriously. I hope you get better.
 
I'm not attacking you I am trying to help you navigate the mental illness that is causing you to pretend to be a woman on the Internet. Maybe one day you will be healthy again and see that. Good luck, mister. Seriously. I hope you get better.

I do so hope you get a life someday and stop feeling driven to get involved in mine.
 
Fixed that for you. You're welcome.

Somehow your skill at forging other peoples statements is just so you!

None the less I stand by my original words:

"I do so hope you get a life someday and stop feeling driven to get involved in mine."
 
The biggest mistake people - employees and employers alike - make in Employment law is thinking that the Employment Standards Act is the last word on an employers obligations to its employees upon termination of employment. The ESA is where the (wrong) notion that a terminated employee is only entitled to one week notice (or pay in lieu of notice) per year of service derives from. The ESA is the statutory minimum that an employee is owed - however a court will also take into account the "common law", which usually results in a much longer period of notice being awarded to the employee.

Size of company per se is not a factor I have ever seen considered in a wrongful termination decision. it becomes a secondary factor inasmuch as the duties and responsibilities of a 'vice-president" of a small, family owned business might not be in any way comparable to the duties and responsibiltiies of a v.p. of a multi-national and might, in fact, be more analagous to the duties and responsibilities of an intermediate manager of the multi-national. However I have never seen where a Court has said that just because a company is small it owe its employees a shorter notice period.


I have not seen where a court has ordered less notice/severance when dealing with a small company but I have seen where a wrongly terminated person has been given less then what a court wanted to order based on its financials. Now mind you this was a "non-profit" organization. I know it probably should not make a difference and this was a top ranking position. It was very complicated to me and really sad all the way around based on the position, the reason for termination, and type of non-profit.

Very Very true about the ESA however. I would recommend anyone who is truly wrongfully terminated to seek out a lawyer and fight for everything you think you can get and more. Wrongful termination is just that, wrong. Although, don't be stupid and let entitlement take over where logic should be. A lot of people feel "wrongly terminated" when fact is you truly should be let go. Getting fired because you have cancer and have to take time off for treatment is not right. Getting fired when you are late 4 out 5 days a week for the last 10 years, is not wrongful termination.
 
Thanks for proving Simon right.

To be crystal clear - my point is that everything you have said about employment law, beyond finding a commercially available database, has been complete crap. No one, with even the faintest idea about Canadian employment law would have said those things. My point is that "HR' dinner companion is a figment of your imagination and yet another fairly pathetic attempt on your part to convince people that you inhabit this fabulous world, where you socialize with fabulous people and anything you might ever want, or need, to know is no more than a table setting away.

LOL.

Hun, do you really think retired business people are "fabulous people"? You must have an incredibly boring life. It is just part of a normal person's socializing.

I actually took the time to read your "examples" of real world court decisions proving I was wrong. Somehow I feel you either did not read the decisions or your concept of typical middle management settlement does not match mine. An executive vice president? A Controller? A woman who moved in with the President ? A guy who had issues with breathing Poisson fumes? etc etc. Any one who takes you seriously just needs to go read your examples LOL.

I hope you manage to do better research for your clients.

Oh well, at least we did discover why you seem driven to create straw men to knock down :)

Have a relatively good life, and start socializing !
 
LOL.

Hun, do you really think retired business people are "fabulous people"? You must have an incredibly boring life. It is just part of a normal person's socializing.

I actually took the time to read your "examples" of real world court decisions proving I was wrong. Somehow I feel you either did not read the decisions or your concept of typical middle management settlement does not match mine. An executive vice president? A Controller? A woman who moved in with the President ? A guy who had issues with breathing Poisson fumes? etc etc. Any one who takes you seriously just needs to go read your examples LOL.

I hope you manage to do better research for your clients.

Oh well, at least we did discover why you seem driven to create straw men to knock down :)

Have a relatively good life, and start socializing !

You read the first set of decisions I posted, none of the second set. For the record, the "controller" was no longer a controller when his employment ended and the judge found, as a matter of fact, that he was not a part of the management team when his employment ended. The fact that one plaintiff was in a relationship with the President of the company was irrelevant when it came time for the judge to determine her entitlement for wrongful dismissal purposes - for wrongful dismissal purposes, she was a part-time book keeper.

To be clear - are you still insisting that, in Canada, no one above middle management recieves a notice period in excess of one month per year of service?

On one hand you want to accuse me of creating "straw men" (a phrase you must have just learned judging from your enthusiasm for using it) and on the other hand you want to continue to insist that you are correct. So the minute I disagree with you and point out that you are wrong, I am creating straw men. What exactly then is it that you are doing when you start trying to argue that the plaintiffs in the cases I cited are, in fact, middle management? When I (or anyone else) argue facts and disagree with you we are jealous, petty, creators of straw men and generally small people. When you argue facts and disagree people you are .... what? A diety from on high ... condescending to lower herself to our level in order that we may share in your glory?

Simon called you from the minute this thread started - anyone that disagrees with you gets insulted and told they are a fool - you refuse to actually argue an issue on its merits and you refuse to admit that someone else might know alot more about a given subject than you do. Its curious that you are so invested in defending the opinion of this American HR exec you had dinner with - he was wrong, why is it so hard for you to concede that?

Finally, what, precisely, is the "straw man" argument I have created? Where have I misrepresented your opinion or taken your comments out of context?

1) You start by saying your HR friend suggested that the notice period is one week per year of service for hourly employees, 1 month per year of service for salaried employees, companies might bridge a year, or two to get someone to a pension and that senior management are entitled to much more;

2) I suggest that your HR person is not likely Canadian because none of what you suggested is an accurate representation of the state of Canadian law;

3) You say he is American and then say that he might be way off when it comes to Canada

4) I then say that you are full of crap because there is no single standard that is applicable in the US given the number of different regimes that operate in the US;

5) You then say he is an American but had to lay off people in Canada, that he said anyone at middle management level asking for more than one month per year of service is just letting a lawyer take money out of their pocket and, despite previously having said he might be "way off" when it comes to Canada, you prefer your HR friend's opinoin to mine

6) I say the comment that anyone at middle management or lower will not get more than a month per year of service as a notice period (Admittedly after having to edit my post) is nonsense and produce two sets of cases to substaniate my position - you read the first set of cases and try to argue that there is a difference between "wrongful dismissal" cases and "layoffs"

Where exactly is the "Straw man" I have created?

As for which of us loves to argue - you have over 4000 posts, the vast majority of which are argumentative. I have 241 in about 10 years. Give your head a shake.
 
You read the first set of decisions I posted, none of the second set. For the record, the "controller" was no longer a controller when his employment ended and the judge found, as a matter of fact, that he was not a part of the management team when his employment ended. The fact that one plaintiff was in a relationship with the President of the company was irrelevant when it came time for the judge to determine her entitlement for wrongful dismissal purposes - for wrongful dismissal purposes, she was a part-time book keeper.

Actually I have a cold and am bored, so read the second set of 'examples' you posted. Rather than argue with you, I invite anyone who cares to just go read them for themselves.

In case anyone wants to here are the examples he provided re middle management settlements:

http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1985...canlii688.html A controller? And the demotion is not significant to you? I thought you got the point that middle management was the topic and not executives?

http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1986...canlii850.html Are you joking? She was living with the boss and he dumped her? Don’t you read the shit you post as proof?

http://canlii.ca/en/ab/abqb/doc/1988...anlii3821.html Did you even read this guy’s job duties? And you consider him middle management?

http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1988...anlii2913.html wow worked 8 years and got 10 months. I wonder if the maternity leave issues or the fact that she had worked there before and they had previously agreed to bridge the seniority was a factor. Hardly a clear cut typical situation is it?

http://canlii.ca/en/ns/nssc/doc/1991...anlii4445.html WOW poison gas exposure? No wonder the judge said “I have come to the conclusion that The Workers' Compensation Act does not and should not give total protection to the employer who treats an employee with such cavalier contempt that, but for The Workers' Compensation Act, the employee would be entitled to damages.”

To be clear - are you still insisting that, in Canada, no one above middle management recieves a notice period in excess of one month per year of service?

No, that is just another example of your desire to make up stories and than defend yourself claiming that the other person is silly for claiming that. (aka the straw man defense). I only reported what I was told when I asked some one who had worked in HR the OP,s question. What I said was....

I asked an HR guy we had dinner with.

He said hourly employees typically get at least 1 week / year worked for a company.

Management / salaried employees typically get 1 month / year with a company.

If the employee is near retirement they might bridge them a year or two to a pension.

Anyone in senior management / mahogany row can reasonably expect much more.

Hope that helps.

My comments seem to not even match your tirade at all. So I can only assume the jealousy and dislike are fueling this. You provided a bunch of special cases that proved that poison gas or a President who moves you in you can get a bit more than 1 month per year. Ok so what?

I really am finding trying to have an intelligent discussion with you difficult when you arbitrarily change what I said and go off on a tangent to prove that what I did NOT say is false.

You need to learn to stick to the facts.


.. When I (or anyone else) argue facts and disagree with you we are jealous, petty, creators of straw men and generally small people.

Well :D. You are the one misquoting me and trying to prove I am whatever it is you are trying to prove with a complete disregard to the bloody comment I did make. What you think people here are too stupid to read my statement and will assume your attacks are based on anything other than your emotions?

Simon called you from the minute this thread started - anyone that disagrees with you gets insulted and told they are a fool - you refuse to actually argue an issue on its merits and you refuse to admit that someone else might know alot more about a given subject than you do. Its curious that you are so invested in defending the opinion of this American HR exec you had dinner with - he was wrong, why is it so hard for you to concede that?

Yes Simon hates my not pretending he is always right. Does anyone really take him seriously?

Oh I have no idea if the HR guy was right or wrong. I just know you seem to love attacking me and are not even polite enough to do your basic homework to check the BS you are spewing.

Why do you care so much?



If the OP still cares....... use the link below and based on your personal situation the data base will tell you what to expect. If it i more than you are offered look into seeing a lawyer :)

Simple. For $50 you get piece of mind. If you are kind and caring, come back and tell us how many months you got per year :).


http://www.wrongfuldismissaldatabase.com/Home.aspx


and DO NOT open THIS LINK........ http://www.ilo.org/dyn/eplex/termdisplay.severancePay?p_lang=en&p_country=CA&p_all_years=Y