Negotiating a Severance Package

except you are the only person trying to argue here and i wouldn't have to go that far back to find quotes from you saying you missed me and i am one of your favorite posters here. remember all this started from me saying you were wrong about something and you flying off the handle. just cuz someone says you are wrong doesn't mean that they are insulting your as a person. i am not the only person here you have done this with. anyone you are fighting with here is because you take it as a personal attack when someone says you are wrong about something. remember the time not to long ago when i was one of the last people here that actually defended you and we talked normally quite a bit.

don't bring up the tires again. you were wrong about what you said and i wasn't. canadian tire does not sell studded tires, they sell tires that can be studded. that never changed and is still true. several phone calls proved that and just because you don't believe it doesn't make it less true.


LOL tires was the straw that broke the camels back. You were to much of an ass to even check the reality. I lost all respect I had for you at that point. Canadian Tire up North sell tires that can be studded. They sell studs. They put the studs in the tires for a fee. So you drive out with nice new studded tires. LOL

You really do not get how silly you sound saying "they do not sell studded tires" ?

Where do the studded tires you drive out of the shop come from in your mind? The stud tooth fairy?

Your phone calls to Southern stores where studs cannot be used on the roads is relevant in your mind? God you are so stubborn and naive.

Please leave me alone. I find conversations with you to be circular and meaningless.
 
LOL tires was the straw that broke the camels back. You were to much of an ass to even check the reality. I lost all respect I had for you at that point. Canadian Tire up North sell tires that can be studded. They sell studs. They put the studs in the tires for a fee. So you drive out with nice new studded tires. LOL

You really do not get how silly you sound saying "they do not sell studded tires" ?

Where do the studded tires you drive out of the shop come from in your mind? The stud tooth fairy?

Your phone calls to Southern stores where studs cannot be used on the roads is relevant in your mind? God you are so stubborn and naive.

Please leave me alone. I find conversations with you to be circular and meaningless.

called the head office and sudbury store. they sell tires that can be studded, not studded tires. they don't sell studs. i also don't drive with studded tires since i know how to drive and don't need them. when i called the head office they said they don't sell them since they are illegal in southern ontario and it is easier to have one policy for all stores. the sudbury store said they don't sell them completed but if you show up with studs they will put them in the tires you buy from them after they check to make sure you live up north. sorry but your wrong again, you haven't actually ever been right in an argument with me.

it's funny that i say you were wrong about something in a normal way instead of responding like a person you attacked like a juvenile. if you could manage to drop your child like attitude you could be better off. you start every post to just about everyone here in a condescending and insulting way and finish it with i don't want to talk to you anymore. you do that with everyone. perhaps when 15 or so people here are all saying the same thing about you, we are not the ones that are wrong.
 
Well mostly because you have proven on several occasions that you love to try to lay imaginary traps to prove something or another you believe about me, and I really did not want to get involved in a long discussion with you. You seem to like playing the lawyer game that "I HAVE PROVEN SOMETHING OR ANOTHER"

It is funny how you think you're so superior to Simon and yet he can read and predict your responses pretty much to a "T". Of course, before Simon's ego gets too inflated I would also say that it is not like you are parcticularly clever or complex. I know my dog is going to want to go outside at 7:00 a.m. every morning - that doesn't mean I am a genius (just kidding Simon).

It is particularly funny that at this high powered Algonquin round-table you were at a senior executive said that a month per year of service was the maximum notice period when, it is more than common, for employees of all levels to get well in excess of one month per year of service (in Canada) - depending on other relevant factors. It is also nearly impossible for anyone, senior executive, "C" Suite, mahogany row or otherwise to get more than 24 months in a post-termination negotiation - something you earlier suggested was possible.

Of course was he talking about his U.S. experience or his experience laying off Canadian workers? I noticed you have tried to cover all your bases by adding in that little caveat.

I tell you what, you go ahead and rely upon Snuffalufagus the US multi-national, HR executive. I will just have to make due with actual court reported decisions:

Irrcher v MI Developments Inc. - 14 year employee awarded notice period of 18 months,
http://canlii.ca/en/on/onca/doc/2003/2003canlii27685/2003canlii27685.html

Wright v. The young and Rubicam Group of Companies (Wunderman) - 5 year employee awarded notice period of 12 months, after being given 13 weeks pay in lieu by his employer (I'm sure he regretted hiring a lawyer)
http://canlii.ca/en/on/onsc/doc/2011/2011onsc4720/2011onsc4720.html

Langan v. Kootenay Region Metis Association - 9 year employee awarded notice period of 15 months
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2008/2008bcsc1169/2008bcsc1169.html

Go ahead and keep thinking you're not a complete moron.
 
It is funny how you think you're so superior to Simon and yet he can read and predict your responses pretty much to a "T". Of course, before Simon's ego gets too inflated I would also say that it is not like you are parcticularly clever or complex. I know my dog is going to want to go outside at 7:00 a.m. every morning - that doesn't mean I am a genius (just kidding Simon).

It is particularly funny that at this high powered Algonquin round-table you were at a senior executive said that a month per year of service was the maximum notice period when, it is more than common, for senior executives to get well in excess of one month per year of service.

Of course was he talking about his U.S. experience or his experience laying off Canadian workers? I noticed you have tried to cover all your bases by adding in that little caveat.

I tell you what, you go ahead and rely upon Snuffalufagus the US multi-national, HR executive. I will just have to make due with actual court reported decisions:

Irrcher v MI Developments Inc. - 14 year employee awarded notice period of 18 months,
http://canlii.ca/en/on/onca/doc/2003/2003canlii27685/2003canlii27685.html

Wright v. The young and Rubicam Group of Companies (Wunderman) - 5 year employee awarded notice period of 12 months, after being given 13 weeks pay in lieu by his employer (I'm sure he regretted hiring a lawyer)
http://canlii.ca/en/on/onsc/doc/2011/2011onsc4720/2011onsc4720.html

Langan v. Kootenay Region Metis Association - 9 year employee awarded notice period of 15 months
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2008/2008bcsc1169/2008bcsc1169.html

Go ahead and keep thinking you're not a complete moron.

i am a reformed troll. i know how they think still.
 
It is particularly funny that at this high powered Algonquin round-table you were at a senior executive said that a month per year of service was the maximum notice period when, it is more than common, for senior executives to get well in excess of one month per year of service.

Wow you do like to create straw men to knock them down ! I think I made it clear enough he was talking about management people LOL. Do you know you do that and just ignore the evidence to win an argument or are you such a careless reader?

Of course was he talking about his U.S. experience or his experience laying off Canadian workers? I noticed you have tried to cover all your bases by adding in that little caveat.

Well hun, seems many parent companies brief their executives about layoffs. Even when the parent company is US and the branch plants are in Canada. Who would have guessed? I mentioned layoffs in Ontario in thequestion

I tell you what, you go ahead and rely upon Snuffalufagus the US multi-national, HR executive. I will just have to make due with actual court reported decisions:

LOL silly man. Or the OP could just go to: http://www.wrongfuldismissaldatabase.com/Home.aspx
and look up the the settlements for different jobs :). Or are you claiming that you are just a better resource than the team that put it together?

Go ahead and keep thinking you're not a complete moron.

Well, perhaps I am not a COMPLETE moron :). LOL but I know when someone is just being bombastic and quoting rare exceptions with special cases.

Are you going to continue going on and on with the same results as last time?

Did you actually read the court reported decision? Since when is an "executive vice president" in the same category as the settlements for middle management? Or getting caught trying for a bogus "with cause" is the same as a layoff?

You really must be fun to watch in court. I guess the judges in Canada are less strict about behaviors :). Other wise RELEVANCE would certainly echo through the halls a lot.
 
Wow you do like to create straw men to knock them down ! I think I made it clear enough he was talking about management people LOL. Do you know you do that and just ignore the evidence to win an argument or are you such a careless reader?
LOL but I know when someone is just being bombastic and quoting rare exceptions with special cases.

You will see I edited my comment - notice periods in excess of one month per year of service are common for all levels of employment - not just senior executives. Of the three cases I cited I think maybe one of them could be described as a senior executive.

"Rare cases"??? How rare do you think they are - I did a Westlaw search using and it took me about 5 minutes to find them. I didn't even get of the first page of the results.

There is nothing wrong with the database your Google search engine skills led you to. It is a compilation of Canadian case law. Most employment lawyers probably use it as a useful starting point in advising their clients. In a relatively cordial negotiation it may very well be all that is needed. But in a truly contested situation it is nothign more than a starting point. But what the database is going to give you is a list of cases, the ages of the plaintiffs (if available), a description of their position and the length of their tenure with the defendant company (if avaialble) - then it is going to give you the notice period each plaintiff was awarded. There could be quite a range of notice periods that the OP is still going to have to decide which one is most analagous to the case at hand. He can easily go to CanLii and read all the cases himself and make that determination or he could hire an emloyment laywer, who has already read the cases and knows the cases, to assist you.

And don't kid yourself - you are a complete moron.
 
You will see I edited my comment -.


I think most would agree your love of altering the past makes having a conversation with you rather difficult, don't you think?
 
Since when is an "executive vice president" in the same category as the settlements for middle management? Or getting caught trying for a bogus "with cause" is the same as a layoff?

You really must be fun to watch in court. I guess the judges in Canada are less strict about behaviors :). Other wise RELEVANCE would certainly echo through the halls a lot.

The other two cases did not involve anyone near a senior executive level position. Also a "bogus just cause" allegation has zero relevance to the length of reasonable notice a person is entitled to. There was a time when it might have been a factor in what were called "Wallace damages" but those were over and above the "reasonable notice period" awarded to a terminated employee, and have since been abolished by the Supreme Court. When you read what the Court awarded as a period of reasonabel notice the "bogus just cause" allegation was not a factor considered.
 
I think most would agree your love of altering the past makes having a conversation with you rather difficult, don't you think?

I edit one post and now I have a "love of altering the past"?
 
I edit one post and now I have a "love of altering the past"?

allow me to interpret. "you have proven me wrong and i cannot think of a valid retort so i will create a new story and insult you as a way of continuing this tryst."

savvy ?
 
allow me to interpret. "you have proven me wrong and i cannot think of a valid retort so i will create a new story and insult you as a way of continuing this tryst."

savvy ?

Do you work with housepets as well or are your skills limited only to trolls?
 
Ok lets check your decisions

Irrcher v. MI Developments Inc., 2003 CanLII 27685 (ON CA) dahhhhh I think only the lawyers made money on this one. Where do you see added value?

http://canlii.ca/en/on/onsc/doc/2011...1onsc4720.html geeeee an executive VP ????

http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2008...8bcsc1169.html wow interesting case of wrongful dismissal. Chief administrator officer ???? Not exactly middle management? And does sound like wrongful dismissal to me.

So not one related to the topic, a layoff. I am sorry, if you are not going to even do your homework I really see no reason to have this discussion :)


The OP asked for advice. I provided a link that you admitted was the starting point for at least some lawyers. So if he is being laid off, it would give him a great idea what he should be able to get. He can then elect to seek help if he wishes. Do you have a point at all other than creating straw dogs to try and prove beyond any doubt that one of us is a moron? :)
 
Do you work with housepets as well or are your skills limited only to trolls?

i have never met a dog i didn't get along with. even when people say my dog hates everyone and will rip your face off, 30 seconds later they are my best friend. fuck cats.
 
I edit one post and now I have a "love of altering the past"?

I answered you post and you changed it. I refuse to play that silly game. Sort of a thing adults do. They live by their statements.
 
You will see I edited my comment - notice periods in excess of one month per year of service are common for all levels of employment - not just senior executives. Of the three cases I cited I think maybe one of them could be described as a senior executive.

The one month per year is consistent with settlement packages I've seen from staff up to middle-management, in large Canadian corporations.

Seeing an employment lawyer is recommended no matter what - even if you don't get an increase, you get peace of mind that you are being treated fairly. There are complications like pension bridging, bonus treatment, etc that a lawyer can advise you on, and the consultation fee is small relative to the amounts at stake. No brainer to consult a lawyer.
 
truck drivers in the tier 1 part of the transport union get a bonus every year. 1 day pay for every month worked. the retirement pension works out to 3500$ a month.
 
Ok lets check your decisions

Irrcher v. MI Developments Inc., 2003 CanLII 27685 (ON CA) dahhhhh I think only the lawyers made money on this one. Where do you see added value?

The employer tried to argue it had given the employee 6 months notice. The court found that the employer had given 3 months notice. The court found that the employee was entitled to 18 months notice. So I think the "added value" is actually pretty clear.

http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2008...8bcsc1169.html wow interesting case of wrongful dismissal. Chief administrator officer ???? Not exactly middle management? And does sound like wrongful dismissal to me.

So not one related to the topic, a layoff. I am sorry, if you are not going to even do your homework I really see no reason to have this discussion

The OP asked for advice. I provided a link that you admitted was the starting point for at least some lawyers. So if he is being laid off, it would give him a great idea what he should be able to get. He can then elect to seek help if he wishes. Do you have a point at all other than creating straw dogs to try and prove beyond any doubt that one of us is a moron? :)

It is funny that you do not even realize how completely ignorant you are. There is no such thing, in Canadian employment law, in a non-unionized environment, as a "layoff" - unless the right to layoff has been negotiated before the employment commences. Do you know what makes a case a "wrongful dismissal" case? A "wrongful dismissal", in Canadian law, is when one is terminated without first being given adequate notice by their employer - the failure to provide reasonable notice, or pay in lieur of notice is what makes the dismissal "wrongful". Whether an employer alleges cause or not is largely irrelevant in determining the period of notice the terminated employer is entitled to. Of course, if the employer can prove they possessed "just cause" than the employee is not entitled to any notice or pay in lieu of notice.

These cases that you mock are the exact same ones, or very similar to what your precious database is going to kick out. It will not distinguish between cases where a person was told they were being "laid off" and cases where an employer fired someone alleging they had just cause to do so, and were later found not to have just cause - the distinction, for the purposes of determining the notice period the employee is entitled to, is irrelevant.

My point, as it has been all along, is that everything you have said about employment law in Canada, with the exception of the Thomson Reuters database (i.e., notice period one week per year of service for hourly employees, one month per year of service for management, no one below middle managment gets more than one month per year of service in notice, senior executives might get more than 2 years reasonable notice) has been complete crap and could not have been uttered by anyone even remotely familiar with Canadian employment law - particularly a US HR executive - trust me, they know Canadian employment law and whenever the topic comes up they accuse us of being a bunch of communists because it is so completely different than what they are used to dealing with in the US.
 
Ok lets check your decisions

OK, just for shits and giggles lets do some more - now it might take a while to find them, because you know, they are very "rare":

Brown v. OK Builders Suppliers Ltd. - 10 year systems analyst, voluntarily left mgmt team before termination, 10 years service, 12 months notice
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1985/1985canlii688/1985canlii688.html

Davidson v. Worthing - 3 yr p/t book keeper, 5 months notice awarded
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1986/1986canlii850/1986canlii850.html

Lacroix v Eso Resources Canada Ltd. - superintendent, 12 year employee, 18 month notice period assessed but not awarded
http://canlii.ca/en/ab/abqb/doc/1988/1988canlii3821/1988canlii3821.html

Koren v White Spot Ltd - purchasing manager, 8 years employment, 10 months notice awarded
http://canlii.ca/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1988/1988canlii2913/1988canlii2913.html

McIntyre v Atlantic Hardchrome Ltd. et al. - chromium electro-plater, 2.5 years of employment, 4 months of notice (reversed on other grounds by the Nova Scotial Court of Appeal)
http://canlii.ca/en/ns/nssc/doc/1991/1991canlii4445/1991canlii4445.html