Congratulations on several years on 4 or 5 years of relative sobriety Nitehwk.
Glad that you found the 12 steps helpful. Most people don’t.
I frankly suspect that it is the religious or “spiritual” component of AA and other 12 step programs that ultimately accounts for its dismal success rate. AA is careful not to publicly acknowledge this, but they privately admit that 50% of attendees quit within the first 3 months, and only 5% hang in to permanently quit drinking for good.
Sorry, but 5 percent blows. If I were to market a sugar pill for alcoholics, or some phony herbal concoction, I would be guaranteed of at least a 10 to 20 percent success rate based on the well known scientific principle of the placebo effect.
Most people don’t know what the “12 steps” of a 12 step program really are.
http://www.aacanada.com/12s.html
Well, it’s short and sweet and God is mentioned in six of them.
Step 2. Believe that a power greater than ourselves can restore us to sanity. Step 3. Turn our will and our lives over to God. 5. Admit to God our failings. 6. Be ready to have God remove these defects of character. 7. Humbly ask God to remove our shortcomings. 12. Having had our spiritual awakening, carry the message to others.
Is it any wonder why more than half the planet gives up on it within weeks? Remember, not everyone who “doubts” about the God question, actually self-identifies as a skeptic, or an agnostic or an atheist. Many still tick off RC, or United Church, or whatever as far as religious affiliation goes on the forms, but just gradually stop going to church, live perfectly moral lives, and forget all about it. If they happen find themselves in an AA meeting, they pretty quickly stop going.
Too bad, because they give up on the networking, the hearing of the stories of people whose lives are, or once were, worse off than their own because of alcohol, and the sponsor to talk to when they feel like breaking down and having a drink, which is unfortunate, because these elements of treatment might actually help someone’s recovery.
I suspect that this is what Nitehwk means by the “fellowship” aspect. But for many, its all the “Praise God,” crap, and the “I’m helpless and only God can save me” drivel, is what gives them the creeping willies and what drives them out before they get to the useful stuff.
Fortunately, there are other alternatives to religious or “spiritual” programs.
Penn and Teller had a TV show called “Bullshit” awhile back. The show did expose features on stuff like spiritualism, (the talking to ghosts stuff) Feng Shui, and even mundane stuff like store-bought bottled water, and called it like they saw it – as bullshit. They happened to do a show on 12 step Programs, and being uncompromising atheists, they called bullshit on AA.
The whole show is available on youtube, with link to part one here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8tPNgHrIkgo&feature=related
Despite the fact that people in AA can supposedly can turn their lives over to anything, to “God as they understand him” or to a non-God concept, “even a tree or a rock.” it still presupposes that an individual has no personal control over their lives. Penn makes light of this nonsense by substituting the word rock for God in reading the 12 steps, to emphasize how fallacious this idea is.
P and T also have a problem with AA from a constitutional perspective, because US courts often sentence people to attend AA meetings as a condition of probation, and since AA is God based organization, then people can be sentenced to attend religious meetings.
AA loves to say that alcoholism is a disease. Why then do we see addiction as the only medical condition that the ONLY solution is a spiritual solution?
As I said, there are other alternatives. Along with the ones Nitehwk linked to, look into SOS, Managed Maintenance, Assisted Recovery, among others, and the medically supervised use of naltrexone, and GHB, (yes, that GHB, at least in treatment programs in Europe) and of course, the old fashioned expedient of individuals taking personal control of their lives, which is proven to be as every bit as effective as AA.
By the way, I had no problem with your posts Angela. Good job. Don’t ever back down from the Goddies. We’re supposed to pretend to respect their beliefs. They can bloody well pretend to respect ours.