Well...
zydeco said:
So - if you could pick 5 players only, from throughout NBA history to man a squad - What 5 players do you think would be all but impossible to beat in a 7 game series. I'm interested to see who some of our resident Basketball Jones' (homonger,MLAM,slowandeasy,icedog,thebig-e,etc.)will choose.
...somehow for 3 days I missed that you actually had asked for my input directly...sorry
It is difficult for me to judge players I never saw, but there is simply no denying the career Chamberlain had. Wilt is my center, and the easiest choice. 100 points in a game. 50 per game for a season. Did you guys know he once led the league in ASSIST just to prove he could?
From there...the next easiest choice is Jordan. The man has been called by many other great players (essentially everyone except Kareem and Wilt) as the greatest of all time. I trust Larry Bird and Magic Johnson judgment over mine. Jordan is my 2 guard, for all the reason stated by others. I mean, how often in history has the league's best offensive and defensive player been the same man??
Point guard...Magic...Robertson...Stockton. It isn't like I could go wrong with any of them, but Stockton is the least versatile. Not to slight the man - arguably the greatest pure point to have ever played, plus he could supply that outside shot need that I am going to have to address at some point. But he just isn't as much of a pure force of nature as the other two. Stockton needs a teammate to do great things - neither Magic nor Robertson do.
Ok...Magic versus Robertson. I've only seen one play. And I only have confidence in the numbers one put up (comparing eras and all that). Plus, I KNOW Magic has the ego to run this team of mega stars...Magic is a POINT GUARD. Robertson was “The Man” when he played, and reportedly didn't have the best relationship with Kareem when forced to share the spotlight, even though Kareem got him the ring he craved. I've seen interviews of the man - he appears to be angry about something (probably with good reason given that he was a black man who grew up in the 40's and played in the 60's, but still...). Magic is my point guard – not saying Big O wasn’t a hell of a player, but he isn’t the best for THIS team.
Now it gets tough…
Power Forward. I don’t care what you guys say, on paper Karl Malone is the greatest power forward in history. Inside game. Mid range jumper. Underrated passer. Even more underrated defender (quickest hands for a man his size in history) And in his prime ran he the floor like a deer. Fairly ego-less (“a soldier”, as described by Magic Johnson) who should get along just fine with his high profile teammates on this squad. Karl Malone should be my PF.
And yet…
One of the things I am going to use as criteria for decision making is that every member of this team has to have won a championship. My team, my rules. Karl has no rings. Neither does Barkley, arguably to best player in history to not have one. You know who has one though? Elvin Hayes. The Big E. First non-center to go 20K and 10K (actually he was 2nd behind Bob Petit, but I never saw Petit play, plus comparing eras and all that stuff). Defensive genius – he often guarded the other team’s best front court player. And he has a ring. Plus nobody mentioned him yet. The only downside is that he was reputedly as asshole, but hey, we gotta have one. Jordan and Wilt will keep him inline.
The 3 spot. The most talented players in history have played small forward. Wilkins, Havlicek, Alex English (nobody mentioned him), Adrian Dantley (ditto), Baylor, Bird. Of these, Baylor was the best, IMHO (it isn’t as much of an open shut case as Malone), but alas, no ring. Wilkins, English and Dantley were all great players but a tad one dimensional. That leaves Hondo and Bird (and a lot of other guys who just missed deserving mention). Bird. Havlicek. Both have rings. Both were well rounded players…good outside shooters (great in Bird’s case), good rebounders (Bird was better). Bird the better passer (though Hondo has over 6,000 career assist), Havlicek the better defender (though Bird was underrated). Both were incredibly clutch players. Both tireless workers. Both great teammates. Hmmm.
I’m going with Hondo just because no one else did. And also because he was so self-less, which is a quality in need on this team of stars. As with Stockton, this isn’t a slight against Bird – I just think Havlicek is a better fit for this team, which will need at least one guy who is willing to dive for loose balls and keep his mouth shut in the locker room. Bird MIGHT do the former, but no way would he do the later. Plus he and Hayes would never get along, and I’m keeping Hayes.
There you have it. And I will take my 5 over the ones you guys picked any day of the week.
