Nba All-time Top 5 Team

zydeco

Active member
Aug 16, 2003
1,493
1
38
I've always thought that it's difficult, if not futile, to compare players and teams from different eras. However, for the purpose of debate/discussion it can definitely be interesting. So - if you could pick 5 players only, from throughout NBA history to man a squad - What 5 players do you think would be all but impossible to beat in a 7 game series. I'm interested to see who some of our resident Basketball Jones' (homonger,MLAM,slowandeasy,icedog,thebig-e,etc.)will choose.
Here's my squad:
Wilt
Bird
Malone(as in Karl)
The Big O
Michael
Can you beat them?
 
As great as Karl was, he NEVER won the big one so i wouldn't put him on the list. He also had the luxury of playing with one of the top 5 point guards of all time (1st in steals and 1st assists all time) threading him the ball to a tee for over 20 years which actually made him better than he actually was.

I would replace Karl with Denis Rodman.
-5 time NBA champion with 2 teams
-Best rebounder in his era (averaged 16 a game from '91-'98) with a great "nose" for the ball at BOTH ends of the court
-Timely hard fouls
-Got under opponent's skin unlike no other
-One of the best "role" players ever
-Outstanding defender

He doesn't score but with your chosen talent around him...he wouldn't need to. Magic needs to be there....sorry Oscar.
 
Last edited:
to-guy69 - I actually considered Rodman, pretty much for the reasons you point out - but opted for Malone(hard to ignore a bona fide iron man like him). As far as Oscar goes, I don't know how old you are - but I think some of the older folks are going to have a harder time leaving Oscar out. No doubt some tough choices - I mean think about it - I named a team WITHOUT Magic Johnson!
 
Very nice list although for the ULTIMATE team I would put Kareem at centre and move Wilt over to power forward!!! Can you image the Stilt pushing around 6"10 PFs to score 100 easy?? Also Magic at point, he had too much champion quality about him to bench

C- Kareem (Alcindor) and his unstoppable sky hook
PF - Wilt Chamberlain
SF - Bird
SG - Michael Jordan
PG - Magic Johnson

The only thing this team loses is fast break speed cause theres no fast running forward like James WOrthy to take Magic's passes, but i think Jordan could probably fill in a few times! :D
 
C- Shaq (the most electrifying man in sports entertainment today...sorry wrong sport)
PF - Wilt Chamberlain
SF - Bird
SG - Michael Jordan
PG - Oscar Robertson

I started watching b-ball the year that Indiana State played Michigan State for the NCAA final. At that time I really thought that Magic would not be as good of a pro as Bird (mainly because of his ugly shot)

Bird and Magic are my favorite players of all time (although I would never have adimitted that when Magic was still playing). I could not believe what this guy did with that body... and the shorts of that era were not flattering on him either...

Honorable mention to Karl Malone, Magic Johnson, Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Worthy, Rick Barry, Scottie Pippen etc...
 
I'll pick a team of players not mentioned yet.

Center- Bill Russell
Forward- Dr. J
Forward- Elgin Baylor
Guard- Jerry West
Guard- Pistol Pete

I plan on running the floor. :)
 
Magic -PG
Jordan -SG
Bird -SF
Mailman -PF
Wilt - C


This team has everything - the ability to score, play defense, rebound, shoot, run and the ability to rise above the rest in the critical moments of the game
 
slowandeasy said:
C- Shaq (the most electrifying man in sports entertainment today...sorry wrong sport)

Shaq does not deserve to make this list.

Back when the league had alot more top centers (Ewing, Olajuwon, Robinson, ect.), Shaq DIDN'T dominate until the quality of talent at the center position took a nose dive. I can remember the countless times Hakeem took him to school and back.

Shaq's free throw ability is a joke, his foot work is poor, he doesn't even have a jump shot and only dominates because he is that much bigger than everyone (size over talent).

Zydeco,
No disrespect to Oscar who was one of the all time greats but you cannot take him over Magic who lead the NBA all time in assists per game with 11.2. No one will ever top that...ever. Magic revolutionized the position, made all of the players around him better and was a great leader during the dynasty years.
 
Hang on

I noticed that a few people put Wilt as a power forward. If we're picking teams and players, we have to stick by position; shouldn't we?

Center - Bill Russell - defensive juggernaut, an uncanny shot blocker (in an era where this stat wasn't even formally counted), A 5 time MVP (look at the talent then as well), 22.5 rebounds per game (51 boards in one game, 49 twice in his career), Olympic Gold medalist (1956 - pre dream team days), 12 time all star, defensive player of the year 1969, 12 seasons with 1000 or more rebounds (less games then too), and 11 rings in 13 years.

backed up by - The Stilt - 2 time NBA champ, Finals MVP in 72, league MVP 4 times, 10 time all star, defensive player of the year twice, rookie of the year....and a scoring machine (nobody has come close to 100 in one game).

I like Kareem and Chocolate Thunder - but if these two can't make this list - Shaq won't....ever.

Power Forward - Sir Charles (I know, I know.lol) - 6'4" power forward - in the NBAs history there are 4 players to score 20k points, 10k rebounds and 4 k assists - CB is one of the 4. NBA MVP,11 time all star, AllStar MVP, 2 time olympic gold medallist. Quick, agile, outspoken and a team player - I'd want him first.

backed up by - Elgin Baylor - athletic, strong and mean. 27 ppg and 13.5 rpg, in the playoffs he's at 27 and 13. 11 time all star, played against the stilts best years, for a big man - he should be ranked with the Dictor, his Airness and the Hawk for acrobatics - television never captured his moves...a shame. Not only did he have to put up with the Stilt, Bob Pettit, Rick Barry and the 1970 Knicks. Another "small" power forward who played big.

I like Big Karl and Wes Unseld as well, but not here; not today.

3 Spot - this is a tough one - there are so many - but, given one choice...... I choose - Larry Bird - never mind the scoring, the rebounding, the assists, the hustle, the work ethic (which is legendary), Bird was MONEY. Best clutch shooter of all time. He used to predict 40 point games to his opponents all the time...and delivered. In practise he shot 3 balls with his eyes closed. 3 time NBA champ, finals MVP 2 times, 3 times league MVP, rookie of the year, all defensive team 3 times, olympic gold medallist, 24 ppg, 10 rpg and 6 apg career. He shpt .496 from the floor and 88% from the line.

backed up by - pick one - The Doctor, The Glide, Nique and the Iceman - running the floor and acrobatics these four were the best.

But how I long for the sweet shot of a Bernard King or World B Free.

Shooting Guard - a 500 field goal shooter, 84% from the line, 30ppg, 6 rpg and 5.3 apg - MJ. 6 time champion, 5 time MVP, Defensive player of the year, 9 all defensive team awards, 2 time Olympic gold medallist, rookie of the year, 14 time all star, 3 time all star MVP, 10 scoring titles - 7 of them in a row - matching Wilt.

backed up by - Jerry West - obsessive winner, perfectionist ,confident. 27ppg, 5.8 rpg and 6.7 apg. 14 time all star - a player called "Mr. Clutch" by non other than John Havlichek - that should be enough.lol.

For a defensive specialist - I'd go with Sidney Moncrief.

Point - The Big O - his numbers are better than Magic but Magic is a bigger presence. Era and style determine the point guard for this team. A run and gun West coast or Traingle offense - I'll go with Magic but a hard zone defense, I'll take Oscar. I'll take the Big O as my starter with Magic as my backup.

A backcourt with Stockton and Nate wouldn't be bad either.
 
Last edited:
to-guy69 - I don't think anyone can accuse you of disrespecting Oscar when the player you take ahead of him is Magic Johnson. However, if you really want to see some mind blowing stats - check out www.bigo.com(specifically look under "About The Big O" and then under "Triple Double Season").

healer - I'm surprised that it has taken this long for someone to select Bill Russell - that's a hard choice to argue with - although I'd take Wilt ahead of him.

hdog - I can see how some might not take Malone among their ultimate Top 5 - in fact in the team I selected, I would agree that he is "weakest link in the chain" if there really is one - however, I totally disagree with you. The man is arguably among the best PF's of all time.
 
healer677 said:
I noticed that a few people put Wilt as a power forward. If we're picking teams and players, we have to stick by position; shouldn't we?

I read the first post a few times and decided that it didnt specify that, especially if we were going to make the ultimate team anyways, as explained in my reply post. With different eras and people like 7'1" Dirk Norwitzky playing shooting guard nowadays, i picked the best team i thought would be impossible to beat in a 7 game series.

That being said, I still hated having to leave the Big O off the list. Man, what a great player he was!
 
I agree newguy - for my money, Big O stays in. But a lot of it depends on a few things. Era, type of competition, offense first or defense first style etc, etc.

Zydeco for me there's really only 3 great centers (if you're only allowed 3) - mine is Russell or Wilt (interchangable depending on style) and Kareem (his stats are hard to argue). And as for Magic and Big O, really it's interchangable.

For this reason Shaq can't make this list for me. He can't shoot free throws, now; injury prone as well. Too bad - could have been, should have been.

With the players listed, in a game 7 (against any team all time), I would play:

First Team - Russell, Barkley, Bird, MJ and the Big O

Second Team - Wilt, Baylor, The Doctor, West, Magic

off the bench - Kareem and 'Nique

The second team is tough too - bench players can be more subjective.

Coached by Red with Jackson as an offensive assistant and Wilkins as the defensive assistant.

Five is tough but, if these 12 were in a game 7; they'd be hard to beat. A team has to have balanced scoring, proper work ethic, a defensive ability to stop the other team (see 2005 Phoenix Suns- for me any team sport - "offense is the sizzle, defense is the steak") and be coached evenly on both sides of the court. Plus there's the intangibles too.
 
thundarr said:
Shaq
Rick Barry
Dave the Rave
MJ
MJ

Who is Dave the Rave?
 
So you wanna play dirty.lol

ok thundarr -

Dave Stallworth, excellent. Dave the Rave.

well, if we're going to play dirty ball.lol. I'll go with The Goat, Boober (from Bedford Stuy and Ruckers) and The Helicopter.

And I thought some of my NBA guys were obscure enough (ie Glide, Iceman) but, Dave the Rave wow - how about Skywalker Thompson (the fight for the scoring title with the Iceman was tight).

Bravo on the Rave though.
 
holden said:
Magic -PG
Jordan -SG
Bird -SF
Mailman -PF
Wilt - C


This team has everything - the ability to score, play defense, rebound, shoot, run and the ability to rise above the rest in the critical moments of the game

Actually I like to change my PF from Mailman to Tim B. Duncan
 
holden said:
Actually I like to change my PF from Mailman to Tim B. Duncan

What do you think this is??? You can't just change your mind??? What are you a girl???? :D
 
PG - Magic
SG - Jordan
SF - Bird
PF - Duncan
C - Wilt

Reserves:

PG - Oscar, Stockton
SG - Lebron, Jesus Shuttlesworth, Kobe
SF - Drexler, Pippen
PF - Barkley, Mailman
C - Kareem, Hakim the Dream, Shaq

Cheers
RF
 
1st: Bird, Havlicek, Chamberlain, Jordan, and Magic Johnson
2nd: Shaq, Olajuwon, Wilkins, Stockton, and Nash
 
Well...

zydeco said:
So - if you could pick 5 players only, from throughout NBA history to man a squad - What 5 players do you think would be all but impossible to beat in a 7 game series. I'm interested to see who some of our resident Basketball Jones' (homonger,MLAM,slowandeasy,icedog,thebig-e,etc.)will choose.

...somehow for 3 days I missed that you actually had asked for my input directly...sorry

It is difficult for me to judge players I never saw, but there is simply no denying the career Chamberlain had. Wilt is my center, and the easiest choice. 100 points in a game. 50 per game for a season. Did you guys know he once led the league in ASSIST just to prove he could?

From there...the next easiest choice is Jordan. The man has been called by many other great players (essentially everyone except Kareem and Wilt) as the greatest of all time. I trust Larry Bird and Magic Johnson judgment over mine. Jordan is my 2 guard, for all the reason stated by others. I mean, how often in history has the league's best offensive and defensive player been the same man??

Point guard...Magic...Robertson...Stockton. It isn't like I could go wrong with any of them, but Stockton is the least versatile. Not to slight the man - arguably the greatest pure point to have ever played, plus he could supply that outside shot need that I am going to have to address at some point. But he just isn't as much of a pure force of nature as the other two. Stockton needs a teammate to do great things - neither Magic nor Robertson do.

Ok...Magic versus Robertson. I've only seen one play. And I only have confidence in the numbers one put up (comparing eras and all that). Plus, I KNOW Magic has the ego to run this team of mega stars...Magic is a POINT GUARD. Robertson was “The Man” when he played, and reportedly didn't have the best relationship with Kareem when forced to share the spotlight, even though Kareem got him the ring he craved. I've seen interviews of the man - he appears to be angry about something (probably with good reason given that he was a black man who grew up in the 40's and played in the 60's, but still...). Magic is my point guard – not saying Big O wasn’t a hell of a player, but he isn’t the best for THIS team.

Now it gets tough…

Power Forward. I don’t care what you guys say, on paper Karl Malone is the greatest power forward in history. Inside game. Mid range jumper. Underrated passer. Even more underrated defender (quickest hands for a man his size in history) And in his prime ran he the floor like a deer. Fairly ego-less (“a soldier”, as described by Magic Johnson) who should get along just fine with his high profile teammates on this squad. Karl Malone should be my PF.

And yet…

One of the things I am going to use as criteria for decision making is that every member of this team has to have won a championship. My team, my rules. Karl has no rings. Neither does Barkley, arguably to best player in history to not have one. You know who has one though? Elvin Hayes. The Big E. First non-center to go 20K and 10K (actually he was 2nd behind Bob Petit, but I never saw Petit play, plus comparing eras and all that stuff). Defensive genius – he often guarded the other team’s best front court player. And he has a ring. Plus nobody mentioned him yet. The only downside is that he was reputedly as asshole, but hey, we gotta have one. Jordan and Wilt will keep him inline.

The 3 spot. The most talented players in history have played small forward. Wilkins, Havlicek, Alex English (nobody mentioned him), Adrian Dantley (ditto), Baylor, Bird. Of these, Baylor was the best, IMHO (it isn’t as much of an open shut case as Malone), but alas, no ring. Wilkins, English and Dantley were all great players but a tad one dimensional. That leaves Hondo and Bird (and a lot of other guys who just missed deserving mention). Bird. Havlicek. Both have rings. Both were well rounded players…good outside shooters (great in Bird’s case), good rebounders (Bird was better). Bird the better passer (though Hondo has over 6,000 career assist), Havlicek the better defender (though Bird was underrated). Both were incredibly clutch players. Both tireless workers. Both great teammates. Hmmm.

I’m going with Hondo just because no one else did. And also because he was so self-less, which is a quality in need on this team of stars. As with Stockton, this isn’t a slight against Bird – I just think Havlicek is a better fit for this team, which will need at least one guy who is willing to dive for loose balls and keep his mouth shut in the locker room. Bird MIGHT do the former, but no way would he do the later. Plus he and Hayes would never get along, and I’m keeping Hayes.

There you have it. And I will take my 5 over the ones you guys picked any day of the week. ;)