My Secular Christmas Rant (well, sort of...)

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
I dunno what all the fuss is about when it comes to the issue of Happy Holidays vs. Merry Christmas and/or having a "Holiday Tree" instead of a Christmas Tree. For me, Christmas isn't at all religious. Maybe it once was, but it isn't anymore (at least IMO). It's about giving and receiving gifts (I guess greater emphasis should be placed on the former rather than the latter), being with family, celebrating, and having a holiday from work.

I have no problem if someone else (e.g. a minority group) wants to celebrate Kwanza or whatever at Christmas; heck, it might be interesting to hear about what other people do. But FUCK YOU if you think I'm not going to celebrate Christmas b/c you don't celebrate it, or if you think I'm going to rename things to be more "inclusive".

That being said, I'd be equally appalled if some hardcore Christian tried to preach his faith about Christmas in the office. There's no place for religion at work, IMHO. So long as Christmas remains secular, I don't have a problem with it.

I think all the Christians who lament what Christmas has become are deluding themselves. If I had to choose between having a traditional Christian Christmas or nothing at all, I'd choose the latter.

So put that in your pipe and smoke it. :p
 
December 25 is Christmas Day, as in Christ's birthday, the day to celeberate His birth. December 25 is not Season's Greetings Day, nor is it Happy Holidays day.
You can celebrate as you see fit, however you see fit. The fact remains it is a holiday to celebrate Jesus' birth. Merry Christmas.
 
Coach said:
You can celebrate as you see fit, however you see fit. The fact remains it is a holiday to celebrate Jesus' birth.

Actually, it's a statutory holiday. Nothing more, nothing less. The legislation says nothing about Jesus. Whatever other significance you want to attach to it is fine by me. But don't try shoving it down my throat.
 
Keebler Elf said:
So long as Christmas remains secular, I don't have a problem with it.

I think all the Christians who lament what Christmas has become are deluding themselves. If I had to choose between having a traditional Christian Christmas or nothing at all, I'd choose the latter.

Christmas is Christ's Mass. A celebration of the birth of Christ.

You don't want to celebrate? Not a problem. But it is not, nor should it ever be a "secular" holiday. Oh and BTW, holiday comes from Holy Day.

And Good bye comes from "God be with you"

You don't want to celebrate Christmas, that is your right. But don't deny the right for Christians to celebrate what the day is about. And it is NOT about exchanging presents.
 
you are entitled to your opinion as are the majority. So just say MERY CHRISTMAS and forget that happy hoilday horsesh@t
 
Notsniw said:
You don't want to celebrate Christmas, that is your right. But don't deny the right for Christians to celebrate what the day is about. And it is NOT about exchanging presents.

Wah-wah. Wah-wah, wah-wah-wah, wah-wah. No wonder the churches are empty.

I don't deny the right for Christians to celebrate the origins of Christmas. Unless it's at work or in the schools (with the exception of Catholic schools). Then I absolutely oppose it and will deny employees the right to express their faiths during working hours. It has no place at work or in the classroom.

And I see you kinda missed the point of my original post. No surprise there, given your last blathering post. :rolleyes:
 
Keebler Elf said:
Then I absolutely oppose it and will deny employees the right to express their faiths during working hours. It has no place at work or in the classroom.

QUOTE]

why do you oppose allowing individuals to express their faith at work?
 
Are there no workhouses? Are there no prisons?
 
red said:
why do you oppose allowing individuals to express their faith at work?

It's shocking that anyone still asks this question today.

Let me start by saying I think religion can be a positive thing. Any institution that helps people behave better than they might otherwise is okay with with me. Frankly, I don't care what someone wants to believe, as long as it encourages socially positive behaviour.

Having said that, I am in no way religious. I'm trying to apply my own set of values. So far, so good. I haven't started any wars, killed anyone for heresy, or emotionally repressed any children.

Many people who are trying to be good by following the teachings of a religion simply cannot tolerate the thought that there may be more than one way to do things right. It confuses them. These people feel the need to have everyone around them adopt the same beliefs in order to avoid this confusion. People who "celebrate" their religious beliefs at work are really trying to sell those beliefs to others, or at least create a "beach head" around themselves to avoid hearing conflicting beliefs. Worse yet, some people feel that following their particular set of beliefs makes them morally "superior" to others. This point of view is a way of rewarding yourself for the difficulty of staying good.

These realities about religious observance are a proven recipe for conflict. I don't know why any employer (who pays people to work, not fight) should have to put up with this nonsense. Similarly, I can't understand any theory of religion which prevents a person from waiting until you get home to worship your god(s). If your faith really is inconsistent with a job, just don't take the job, or quit, as the case may be!
 
Bud Plug said:
It's shocking that anyone still asks this question today.

Let me start by saying I think religion can be a positive thing. Any institution that helps people behave better than they might otherwise is okay with with me. Frankly, I don't care what someone wants to believe, as long as it encourages socially positive behaviour.

Having said that, I am in no way religious. I'm trying to apply my own set of values. So far, so good. I haven't started any wars, killed anyone for heresy, or emotionally repressed any children.

Many people who are trying to be good by following the teachings of a religion simply cannot tolerate the thought that there may be more than one way to do things right. It confuses them. These people feel the need to have everyone around them adopt the same beliefs in order to avoid this confusion. People who "celebrate" their religious beliefs at work are really trying to sell those beliefs to others, or at least create a "beach head" around themselves to avoid hearing conflicting beliefs. Worse yet, some people feel that following their particular set of beliefs makes them morally "superior" to others. This point of view is a way of rewarding yourself for the difficulty of staying good.

These realities about religious observance are a proven recipe for conflict. I don't know why any employer (who pays people to work, not fight) should have to put up with this nonsense. Similarly, I can't understand any theory of religion which prevents a person from waiting until you get home to worship your god(s). If your faith really is inconsistent with a job, just don't take the job, or quit, as the case may be!
you are agnostic or atheistic. great. but why prevent others from celebrating their religious beliefs. How does it impact you?
 
Keebler Elf said:
Actually, it's a statutory holiday. Nothing more, nothing less. The legislation says nothing about Jesus. Whatever other significance you want to attach to it is fine by me. But don't try shoving it down my throat.
wow, you're more ignorant than I thought.
I'm no christian by any means but the whole NAME of the holiday which is to come is called CHRISTMAS. Christ's birthday.
You can't argue that and if you do, well then you're an idiot.
 
Bud Plug said:
It's shocking that anyone still asks this question today.

Let me start by saying I think religion can be a positive thing. Any institution that helps people behave better than they might otherwise is okay with with me. Frankly, I don't care what someone wants to believe, as long as it encourages socially positive behaviour.

Having said that, I am in no way religious. I'm trying to apply my own set of values. So far, so good. I haven't started any wars, killed anyone for heresy, or emotionally repressed any children.

Many people who are trying to be good by following the teachings of a religion simply cannot tolerate the thought that there may be more than one way to do things right. It confuses them. These people feel the need to have everyone around them adopt the same beliefs in order to avoid this confusion. People who "celebrate" their religious beliefs at work are really trying to sell those beliefs to others, or at least create a "beach head" around themselves to avoid hearing conflicting beliefs. Worse yet, some people feel that following their particular set of beliefs makes them morally "superior" to others. This point of view is a way of rewarding yourself for the difficulty of staying good.

These realities about religious observance are a proven recipe for conflict. I don't know why any employer (who pays people to work, not fight) should have to put up with this nonsense. Similarly, I can't understand any theory of religion which prevents a person from waiting until you get home to worship your god(s). If your faith really is inconsistent with a job, just don't take the job, or quit, as the case may be!


I am agnostic and am an employer. I absolutely do not oppose my employees who want to worship their god, whichever one it may be. This country supports freedom of expression, speech and religion. This freedom should be allowed in ANY circumstance. Just because a person is at work doesn't mean that their religious ideologies should stay home. NEVER has it caused any problems in my work place because for the most part, decent people understand an individuals want or need to worship their god.

Here I thought we lived in a free country, but what I'm hearing is such closeted communistic views.

Basically, you don't care if they practice religion, just not in public. :rolleyes:
 
ruck said:
wow, you're more ignorant than I thought.
I'm no christian by any means but the whole NAME of the holiday which is to come is called CHRISTMAS. Christ's birthday.
You can't argue that and if you do, well then you're an idiot.

You're right, you can't argue the name. However, most people don't realize that ol' JC isn't as "original" as they think....check out the following:

http://www.taivaansusi.net/historia/mithraism.html

Mithraism had many similarities to Christianity. Mithras was born of a virgin, remained celibate, his worship involving baptism, the partaking of bread marked with a cross and wine as sacrificial blood, held Sundays sacred and Mithras was born on 25th of December. Mithraists called themselves 'brother' and were led by a priest called 'father' (Pater). The symbol of the father were a staff, a hooked swored, a ring and hat.

These similarities frightened the early Christian leaders - that almost 500 years before arrival of Christ all of the Christian mysteries were already known.
IMO, the debate over whether or not to wish someone "Merry Christmas" is just representative of the paranoia inherent in organized religion; ie. not saying "Merry Christmas" is deemed to be disrespectful to Christianity at least, an attack on it at worst. They always seem to leave out that they stole some of the tenets of their faith from another religion. By doing so, they're just as inflexible as Muslim extremists.
 
Bobzilla said:
You're right, you can't argue the name. However, most people don't realize that ol' JC isn't as "original" as they think....check out the following:

http://www.taivaansusi.net/historia/mithraism.html

Mithraism had many similarities to Christianity. Mithras was born of a virgin, remained celibate, his worship involving baptism, the partaking of bread marked with a cross and wine as sacrificial blood, held Sundays sacred and Mithras was born on 25th of December. Mithraists called themselves 'brother' and were led by a priest called 'father' (Pater). The symbol of the father were a staff, a hooked swored, a ring and hat.

These similarities frightened the early Christian leaders - that almost 500 years before arrival of Christ all of the Christian mysteries were already known.
IMO, the debate over whether or not to wish someone "Merry Christmas" is just representative of the paranoia inherent in organized religion; ie. not saying "Merry Christmas" is deemed to be disrespectful to Christianity at least, an attack on it at worst. They always seem to leave out that they stole some of the tenets of their faith from another religion. By doing so, they're just as inflexible as Muslim extremists.

yeah those damn merry christmas terrorists
 
red said:
you are agnostic or atheistic. great. but why prevent others from celebrating their religious beliefs. How does it impact you?

I already answered that question. Re-read my post.

(An interesting and enduring phenomenon around TERB, responding to posts without reading them).
 
red said:
yeah those damn merry christmas terrorists

Are you really that unlettered? Why don't you ask a Muslim about the Crusades? Or about GWB's war?:rolleyes:

The point, which BTW you seem to have missed completely, is that people defending beliefs of any religion will go to some messy extremes.