MVP's

ScottyJop

New member
Oct 18, 2004
41
0
0
Mississauga
Hello all.

Relatively new Terbite who just recently started posting.

Just wondering your thoughts on who should win MVP of the American and National Leagues?
 
LOL Yeah, it's all covered there.
My votes would be for Bonds (duh) and Suzuki, but I wouldn't be surprised if Guerrero (or Sheffield, or even Ramirez ... Santana?) won in the AL.
 
re: Santana. do they give the MVP to pitchers? I cant remember that happening. With there being the CY Young for pitchers Im not sure. Fill me in will ya? My picks would be Guerrero and Bonds though
 
Sure. Eckersley won in 92, Clemens in 86, Hernandez in 84, ...
 
hmmm never knew that. Brings up a good argument though. Should they be eligible for MVP? Why not just have the Cy Young for pitchers?
 
Personally, I don't like the thought of giving a pitcher both. One for pitchers, one for players.
I'd never vote for a pitcher.
 
Gotta agree with that logic Ranger. It just doesn't seem right to me to give a pitcher the MVP. Starters only play in 20 - 30% of the teams games.

Most people think i'm insane when I say this, but what about Pudge (Ivan) Rodriguez as a possible MVP candidate.

I mean he is the only real difference between this years Tigers and last years Tigers. He hit over .340, yeah his power numbers were down, but he also missed thirty some odd games, but the work he did with Detroit's young pitching staff was pretty amazing. Especially when you consider that this team lost 119 games last year, and they only lost 90 this year, a difference of 29 wins, pretty impressive, to me anyway.

I know it's a big stretch, but makes for good discussion about other aspects that some players bring to a team.

What do you think?
 
Rodriguez? Meh. He's in there.
It just wasn't a good year for MVP seasons in the AL, so everybody's in the pool.

However, to suggest that Ivan is responsible for the Tigers being 29 games better is probably stretching the argument. Just a bit. ;) Especially since, yes, he did miss a wack of games. There are lots of reasons the Tigers got better. Pudge was one of them. They've got a long way to go.