MsCain divorce ruling

Weird that the FIL wouldn't have figured out the risk earlier on. Maybe things took a turn for the worse in the family dynamics.

Oh well, the son should just get himself a 20-year old hottie and flaunt her in his ex-wife's face. So the ex-wife got half. It's still so much that he's able to enjoy his half more than she can enjoy hers.
 
As a general rule pre-nuptial agreements are designed to protect assets from marriages which "go all to Hell" in the first few years of a marriage, they are not designed to somehow protect all of "your money" from your spouse after a Thirty year long marriage and five children!. Not to mention a post-nuptial agreement entered into 15 years into the marriage.



Oagre will correct me if this does not apply in Canada, but typically pre-marital assets and inheritances are excluded from marital property in any event. However, if you make them into marital property - that is a different situation.*

You bought a thousand shares of Apple back in 1980. You married in 1982 you haven't done anything with the stock except let it grow and cash the dividend cheques - that stock is yours. Now you sold 500 shares of it in 1990 and put that money towards the purchase a house - certainly marital property for the house (and the value of the 500 shares) and there is going to be dispute as to whether the remaining shares are a pre-marital asset or marital property. The same applies if instead of purchasing it, you had inherited it in 1989.
 
As a general rule pre-nuptial agreements are designed to protect assets from marriages which "go all to Hell" in the first few years of a marriage, they are not designed to somehow protect all of "your money" from your spouse after a Thirty year long marriage and five children!. Not to mention a post-nuptial agreement entered into 15 years into the marriage.



Oagre will correct me if this does not apply in Canada, but typically pre-marital assets and inheritances are excluded from marital property in any event. However, if you make them into marital property - that is a different situation.*

You bought a thousand shares of Apple back in 1980. You married in 1982 you haven't done anything with the stock except let it grow and cash the dividend cheques - that stock is yours. Now you sold 500 shares of it in 1990 and put that money towards the purchase a house - certainly marital property for the house (and the value of the 500 shares) and there is going to be dispute as to whether the remaining shares are a pre-marital asset or marital property. The same applies if instead of purchasing it, you had inherited it in 1989.

Well, the money you put into purchasing the house is certainly mat property. The rest I would have to check on.

the intriguing thing is - indeed - that the husband's inheritance would have been protected from equalization anyway, if kept separate from the jointly owned family assets. Of course, it's not protected from being taken into account re his capacity to pay spousal support - which may have been why Greer J was hitting him so hard re alimony.
 
Michael's father and uncle; Wallace and Harrison built the company and their wealth from scratch.

They built McCain Foods from scratch.
They had a falling out and Wallace got $1 BILLION dollars from the Ontario Teachers Pension Fund and bought Maple Leaf Foods. They then went about destroying the unionized labour force and killed 17 people with a listeria outbreak from unsanitary processing conditions. They have so much money and clout that they got a pass on everything.

Karma's a bitch.