MsCain divorce ruling

Worf

Well-known member
Sep 26, 2001
1,890
28
48
In a house somewhere
Here is an interesting case.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/record-breaking-divorce-ruling-against-maple-leafs-foods-president/article7284629/

Ex-wife of Harrison McCain gets record breaking support judgement. I guess there is no such thing as a contract anymore. I also suppose that a lot of wealthy people will now just not pass their fortunes to the children. If their marriages fail then the aggrieved spouse will just go to courts and take the family money regardless of whether a contract exists.
 
Here's your answer:


The support decision by Madam Justice Susan Greer of Ontario Superior Court dealt only with Ms. McCain’s spousal support claim. More than $500-million in assets will be divided at a future trial.
 
I have to side with the Judge on this one, having read the article.

The post nuptual 'contract' was really signed under duress, and in fact in my opinion borders on extortion.

Yes, it is extravagant, but the rich live differently!
 
Here's your answer:


The support decision by Madam Justice Susan Greer of Ontario Superior Court dealt only with Ms. McCain’s spousal support claim. More than $500-million in assets will be divided at a future trial.

Captain Kirk is spot on.

If you think the family courts in Canada treat men fairly, you're a fucking idiot.
 
Captain Kirk is spot on.

If you think the family courts in Canada treat men fairly, you're a fucking idiot.

Trust me, I KNOW they don't treat men fairly. And the remaining $500 million? Who knows what will happen to this. But while I agree that the contract was not fair, it appears that the older McCain only gave the younger McCain the inheritance was only if the contract was signed. If it wasn`t signed, then there would be no inheritance to argue about.
 
$500 million? If someone had 10% of that they'd be filthy rich, if they had 1% of that they'd be very rich, it must be nice to be a McCain.
 
The magic word from Justice Greer “unconscionable” marriage contract.

Bottom line don't threaten to disinherit your child unless their fiancé(e) signs a prenuptial agreement.
 
The magic word from Justice Greer “unconscionable” marriage contract.

Bottom line don't threaten to disinherit your child unless their fiancé(e) signs a prenuptial agreement.

Bottom line threaten to disinherit your male children if they are stupid enough to get married in Canada.
 
When I tell men they will get fleeced if they get married, I usually hear: "don't worry, I will get a pre-nup."

I always laugh hysterically.
 
The magic word from Justice Greer “unconscionable” marriage contract.

Bottom line don't threaten to disinherit your child unless their fiancé(e) signs a prenuptial agreement.

In return, if the marriage dissolved, Ms. McCain was to receive a lump sum of about $7-million and title to the family home.

Sounds absolutely unconscionable to me. A ten million dollar home and seven million in cash.

Even after the separation, Ms. McCain paid a pilates/yoga instructor $2,600 per month. She listed her personal entertainment expenses as $5,562 per month; travel expenses as $16,395 per month; and basic household expenses – including for food, pet care, dry cleaning and meals – as $12,812 per month.
 
I never feel sorry for men getting divorced. They made the decision to get married. No one had a gun to his head.
 
In return, if the marriage dissolved, Ms. McCain was to receive a lump sum of about $7-million and title to the family home.

Sounds absolutely unconscionable to me. A ten million dollar home and seven million in cash.

Even after the separation, Ms. McCain paid a pilates/yoga instructor $2,600 per month. She listed her personal entertainment expenses as $5,562 per month; travel expenses as $16,395 per month; and basic household expenses – including for food, pet care, dry cleaning and meals – as $12,812 per month.

How do you have travel expenses of over $16,000 per month? Is she flying on a plane every single day of her life? How does she eat almost $13,000 of food every month? That's over $400 every single day, granted some of that is for pet care and dry cleaning, but if she eats that much in a day maybe Mr. McCain just couldn't handle her obesity anymore?
 
When I tell men they will get fleeced if they get married, I usually hear: "don't worry, I will get a pre-nup."

I always laugh hysterically.
Prenuptials work perfectly fine, however, a prenuptial will not allow you to "screw over" your spouse. Reasonable agreements made with the advise of independent counsel and without coercion will be enforced.
 
Prenuptials work perfectly fine, however, a prenuptial will not allow you to "screw over" your spouse. Reasonable agreements made with the advise of independent counsel and without coercion will be enforced.

Do you have experience with the court system? I suspect not.
 
Do you have experience with the court system? I suspect not.

Actually, Aardvark is a practising attorney in the USA.

Perfectly sound judgment by Greer J. The wife was pressured into signing away a VAST entitlement to spousal support and equalization for a mere pittance because she was told she would be legally blocked from getting a dime if she did not. Clear unconscionability - and unconscionability voids any contract and most especially a domestic contract which is uberrimae fideis.

A first year law student could have written that judgment.
 
Actually, Aardvark is a practising attorney in the USA.

Perfectly sound judgment by Greer J. The wife was pressured into signing away a VAST entitlement to spousal support and equalization for a mere pittance because she was told she would be legally blocked from getting a dime if she did not. Clear unconscionability - and unconscionability voids any contract and most especially a domestic contract which is uberrimae fideis.

A first year law student could have written that judgment.

17 million is a mere pittance? lol I love you lawyers. I guess these types of judgements will bring more asset protection trust business?
 
17 million is a mere pittance? lol I love you lawyers. I guess these types of judgements will bring more asset protection trust business?

Asset protection trusts are a US legal idea. They don't work up here.

Listen: All McCain had to do was get his wife to sign a legit pre nup before marrying her. Then, he was covered. The idiot pressured his wife into signing a clearly bogus marriage contract for no consideration towards the end of the marriage when no reasonable wife would willingly agree to it. Any contract that one signs under pressure from someone with far greater bargaining power is liable to be voided.

That's legally-speaking all that happened here. The inflated figures do not alter the basic contracts 101 legal principles.