Honourable members and ladies of the night
5 MPs to tour Canada's seediest districts as part of a review of prostitution laws
By BILL CURRY
Thursday, February 24, 2005
OTTAWA -- Is there sex in the champagne room?
What exactly gets massaged in a massage parlour?
Should Canada add the legalization of prostitution to the list of hot button topics on the national agenda?
These are just some of the questions a committee of five MPs hope to answer as they head out next month on a tour of the country's seediest districts, embarking on the first public review of Canada's prostitution laws in 20 years.
A subcommittee of the House of Commons justice committee recently received more than $157,000 to travel with nine staff members to Toronto, Montreal, Halifax, Vancouver, Edmonton and Winnipeg in March as part of a wide-ranging study on the adequacy of current Criminal Code provisions relating to prostitution.
Chaired by Ontario Liberal MP John Maloney and vice-chaired by Vancouver NDP MP Libby Davies, who long campaigned for the study, the five MPs are planning to meet with police, city councillors and community groups that have offered to set up confidential meetings with current and former participants in Canada's sex trade.
Mr. Maloney has set a June deadline for a first report on possible changes to prostitution laws.
"Society has tended to take the ostrich approach to this and it's not going away," he said.
New Zealand, Australia and the Netherlands have legalized prostitution, while Sweden eased penalties for prostitutes in exchange for tough laws for johns and pimps.
MPs on the committee say they hope to visit some of those countries, as well as Las Vegas, Nevada, which has legalized prostitution, but Mr. Maloney said it is unlikely the Commons would finance such trips.
Justice Minister Irwin Cotler is "very interested" in what the MPs will recommend, Mr. Cotler's spokeswoman, Mylène Dupéré, said. She added that Mr. Cotler will wait for the report before deciding whether to update the Criminal Code.
A Justice Department official said more than 20 internal studies have been done in as many years related to prostitution, primarily focused on youth. The subcommittee has heard from Paul Fraser, who in 1985 chaired the last public study on prostitution. Mr. Fraser's report called for decriminalization and allowing prostitutes to set up small private businesses.
Ms. Davies, who represents Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, where nearly 60 female prostitutes have disappeared in recent years, said the study is inspired by the case of the missing women.
Ms. Davies said she hopes to take her colleagues on a walking tour of the neighbourhood.
While the problems of street prostitution in Vancouver are well known and many possible remedies have been debated, Ms. Davies and other MPs on the subcommittee expressed an interest in the hidden side of prostitution. Specifically, they hope to get a sense of the prevalence of sex for money in places such as massage parlours, escort services and strip clubs' champagne rooms, which some MPs say is viewed with a blind eye.
The MPs also hope to learn more about the relationship between prostitution and organized crime, including human trafficking.
Prostitution is not illegal in Canada, but the Criminal Code bans solicitation. Further provisions outlaw bawdy houses, or prostitutes organizing their own businesses.
Ms. Davies has urged the Justice Minister to drop the solicitation part of the law, saying it forces street prostitutes to make dangerously rushed decisions on whether to get into a customer's car.
"These laws were designed to protect women and to protect society, and they've failed on both fronts," said Ms. Davies, adding that prostitution is the top concern in her riding.
The New Democrat MP said the committee hopes to explore why prostitution laws tend to accept sex acts conducted through massage parlours and escort services.
© Copyright 2005 Bell Globemedia Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5 MPs to tour Canada's seediest districts as part of a review of prostitution laws
By BILL CURRY
Thursday, February 24, 2005
OTTAWA -- Is there sex in the champagne room?
What exactly gets massaged in a massage parlour?
Should Canada add the legalization of prostitution to the list of hot button topics on the national agenda?
These are just some of the questions a committee of five MPs hope to answer as they head out next month on a tour of the country's seediest districts, embarking on the first public review of Canada's prostitution laws in 20 years.
A subcommittee of the House of Commons justice committee recently received more than $157,000 to travel with nine staff members to Toronto, Montreal, Halifax, Vancouver, Edmonton and Winnipeg in March as part of a wide-ranging study on the adequacy of current Criminal Code provisions relating to prostitution.
Chaired by Ontario Liberal MP John Maloney and vice-chaired by Vancouver NDP MP Libby Davies, who long campaigned for the study, the five MPs are planning to meet with police, city councillors and community groups that have offered to set up confidential meetings with current and former participants in Canada's sex trade.
Mr. Maloney has set a June deadline for a first report on possible changes to prostitution laws.
"Society has tended to take the ostrich approach to this and it's not going away," he said.
New Zealand, Australia and the Netherlands have legalized prostitution, while Sweden eased penalties for prostitutes in exchange for tough laws for johns and pimps.
MPs on the committee say they hope to visit some of those countries, as well as Las Vegas, Nevada, which has legalized prostitution, but Mr. Maloney said it is unlikely the Commons would finance such trips.
Justice Minister Irwin Cotler is "very interested" in what the MPs will recommend, Mr. Cotler's spokeswoman, Mylène Dupéré, said. She added that Mr. Cotler will wait for the report before deciding whether to update the Criminal Code.
A Justice Department official said more than 20 internal studies have been done in as many years related to prostitution, primarily focused on youth. The subcommittee has heard from Paul Fraser, who in 1985 chaired the last public study on prostitution. Mr. Fraser's report called for decriminalization and allowing prostitutes to set up small private businesses.
Ms. Davies, who represents Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, where nearly 60 female prostitutes have disappeared in recent years, said the study is inspired by the case of the missing women.
Ms. Davies said she hopes to take her colleagues on a walking tour of the neighbourhood.
While the problems of street prostitution in Vancouver are well known and many possible remedies have been debated, Ms. Davies and other MPs on the subcommittee expressed an interest in the hidden side of prostitution. Specifically, they hope to get a sense of the prevalence of sex for money in places such as massage parlours, escort services and strip clubs' champagne rooms, which some MPs say is viewed with a blind eye.
The MPs also hope to learn more about the relationship between prostitution and organized crime, including human trafficking.
Prostitution is not illegal in Canada, but the Criminal Code bans solicitation. Further provisions outlaw bawdy houses, or prostitutes organizing their own businesses.
Ms. Davies has urged the Justice Minister to drop the solicitation part of the law, saying it forces street prostitutes to make dangerously rushed decisions on whether to get into a customer's car.
"These laws were designed to protect women and to protect society, and they've failed on both fronts," said Ms. Davies, adding that prostitution is the top concern in her riding.
The New Democrat MP said the committee hopes to explore why prostitution laws tend to accept sex acts conducted through massage parlours and escort services.
© Copyright 2005 Bell Globemedia Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.

