Cool! Grit delegates to mull legalizing prostitution

I don't understand this bizarre obsession that seems to exist in Canada with public solicitation and red light districts.

The bawdy house and living off the avails laws are the ones that need to be changed to allow the business to operate safely and completely legally behind closed doors. If the police and politicians were honest with the public, they would acknowledge what should be plainly evident to everyone anyway - they already knowingly let almost all the agencies, incalls, and MPs operate when they could be charging all of them with violating the criminal code. Changing these laws would only be a change on paper, not a change in practice. It would not be some kind of radical experiment creating something new that doesn't already exist, that frightens people into thinking part of the city would be ruined.

I don't think public communicating deserves to be a criminal offence, but I don't believe there's a huge number of SPs or guys demanding the right to be able to participate in street prostitution. And who is asking that all the MPs, incalls, etc. be forced to close down where they now exist, so that they could all be forced into some pointless red light district? I doubt anyone in the business wants that. And certainly no one in the general public wants their neighbourhood to be the area designated for this. So, who wants this?
 
HaywoodJabloemy said:
I don't understand this bizarre obsession that seems to exist in Canada with public solicitation and red light districts.

The bawdy house and living off the avails laws are the ones that need to be changed to allow the business to operate safely and completely legally behind closed doors. If the police and politicians were honest with the public, they would acknowledge what should be plainly evident to everyone anyway - they already knowingly let almost all the agencies, incalls, and MPs operate when they could be charging all of them with violating the criminal code. Changing these laws would only be a change on paper, not a change in practice. It would not be some kind of radical experiment creating something new that doesn't already exist, that frightens people into thinking part of the city would be ruined.

I don't think public communicating deserves to be a criminal offence, but I don't believe there's a huge number of SPs or guys demanding the right to be able to participate in street prostitution. And who is asking that all the MPs, incalls, etc. be forced to close down where they now exist, so that they could all be forced into some pointless red light district? I doubt anyone in the business wants that. And certainly no one in the general public wants their neighbourhood to be the area designated for this. So, who wants this?

I agree that creating a red light district is sleezy solution but to argue that the current status quo is the best situation is ignoring some important facts.

If bawdy house & living off the avails laws were eliminated, incalls would be legal and subject to licensing and zoning rules. This would result in more administrative work for legitimate SPs but would reduce the incidence of workers who are exploited.
Proper licensing & regulation should reduce the incidence of STDs, B&S and other problems that result from an industry that operates on the edge of the law.
"Red light districts' are not the only model for legalized sex trade. Our current laws allow for licencing of MPs and they operate in commercial zones (as they should). No residential resident wants a business with constant customer traffic operating next door be it SP, MP or a burger joint. That doesn't mean all SPs & MPs need to be segregated & corraled into their special district.
Real progress will require major changes in the laws, significant education of the general public (voters) and development of an infastructure to regulate & monitor the industry. I doubt any politicians have the balls to take on that task.
 
Living off the avails

The "living off the avails" part of the law has always puzzled me. Does that mean that a woman who does *legal* outcalls can be charged with living off the avails if she uses that money to buy groceries? Can the bank who takes her mortgage money out of her bank account every month or whatever also be charged? Does the newspaper that advertises legal outcall services run the risk of living off the avails? And (I love this one) is the government, who taxes her on her income, liable to be charged with living off the avails? :eek:
 
I don't have a problem with legalizing by any means,infact I'm for it, but to allow street walkers in residential neighborhoods is wrong IMO, no one should have to be subjected to SW's and the traffic they bring, now if there was a designated section like in Amsterdam, where the SW's could do business, that may be different.
The problem I see with Politicians is fear of backlash from "normal citizens" ,in their eyes, all "prostitution is lumped in together and has the same problems , it's dirty ,filthy, diseased girls, Pimps, drugs, crime.
 
It would be nice if one day a cop was pissed off at an incall SP because she didn't have her paperwork/license etc in order and he had to do paperwork to write her a ticket and not because he thought she was "a HO".

The only thing I care about is the workers being safe and that means calling the cops if they are in danger at their "Home Office" (Hey that can be a better definition of HO!) :-)

-F out
 
Bad Idea

You just know if they legalize it they will Tax and regulate the practice. if it's a government job then will they have a public union? Remember in a union you will have to see the service providers in order of seinority

Better it's off the Gov't radar screen. Else the providers and the clients will be the ones getting screwed while the gov't gets all the money
 
The idea of legalizing brothels has been kicking around for many years. It seems that every few years, some politician brings it up, conducts an expensive inquiry, produces a glossy report and then shelves the idea.
Since it is a Liberal idea, I cannot see it getting past Mr. Dithers and the various femi-nazi groups.
 
IMHO, of course!

And, in my way of thinking, the laws are fine just the way they are now except for one: Sections 197(1) (defining common bawdy house) 210 (keeping bawdy house) 211 (transporting to a bawdy house) should be repealed.

Why would anyone want to legalize pimping? These are the "living on the avails" and "procuring" sections (please see many previous threads for discussions as to what they mean!) and are there to protect SP's from abuse. They are entitled to it!

And what is the great social benefit of streetwalkers that we should allow SP's to market themselves in our residential neighbourhoods and public places? There is a place and a time for everything, but this is not it for the profession...

Perry
 
You're the lawyer, so maybe you can explain where I'm wrong.

As I understand "living off the avails", it doesn't necessarily just involve coercion and what we would think of as pimping. Anyone operating an escort agency could be charged with living off the avails. Even the drivers and secretaries who work for the agencies can also be charged.

I think what everyone probably agrees on is that coercion should remain a crime, but the laws should be modified so that it's possible to avoid violating the Criminal Code when operating businesses such as agencies, incalls, and MPs (or legal bordellos if there's no bawdy house law).
 
HaywoodJabloemy said:
As I understand "living off the avails", it doesn't necessarily just involve coercion and what we would think of as pimping. Anyone operating an escort agency could be charged with living off the avails. Even the drivers and secretaries who work for the agencies can also be charged.
As I have said before, it depends on whether the agency, drivers or secretaries are taking a piece of the action -- that is, a cut or percentage of the actual earnings or fees of the SP -- or just providing, at resonable market rates, necessary or reasonable services to or for her (I guess that could be "him," too!) as they would for any other person in an "ordinary" situation.

The Courts have defined this issue in terms of whether or not the relationship between the SP and her "agent," secretary, etc. is parasitic.

These subjects have been discussed several times, in great detail, so please do a search for further clarification, if you want it.

Perry
 
The Brus said:
The idea of legalizing brothels has been kicking around for many years. It seems that every few years, some politician brings it up, conducts an expensive inquiry, produces a glossy report and then shelves the idea.
Since it is a Liberal idea, I cannot see it getting past Mr. Dithers...
Unfortunately you're probably right. I read and heard about his answers this weekend. He wasn't dithering. He was pretty clear that he's going to ignore the subject, no matter what motions were passed at the Liberal convention, so he would be likely to also ignore the all-party subcommittee when they produce their report. Maybe some of those Bishops mentioning the possibility of excommunicating Martin over supporting same sex marriage are scaring him away from what they would call another morality issue.