Motorcycle Death Arrest

Be careful what you ask for. Would you prefer a system like the one in Japan with a 99.9% conviction rate?

My perception is that the 35% are not wrongly charged, they are wrongly prosecuted. By that I mean that in most of those cases the accused is probably guilty, but the police or prosecution abused their rights, or failed to follow process, and some key evidence is tossed out and they walk. Letting that 35% go is the price we pay to make sure the 2-3% of them who are probably innocent get a fair shake and are not jailed. It is how we keep a leash on the police and ensure that we don't wind up with a system like the one in Japan where, despite that the rules may say there's a presumption of innocence, it would appear the courts presume anyone charged by the police is guilty.

I would much rather a system like ours that lets a bunch of apparently guilty people go free in order to ensure that due process is followed.

Well at least we know how you think... everyone arrested is guilty, and those acquitted get off on technicalities. You probably think Robert Dziekanski deserved to be tazered and was the author of his own death..
 
Anyways, let this thread die, the guy is guilty and now it's up to the courts to punish him.
 
Well at least we know how you think... everyone arrested is guilty, and those acquitted get off on technicalities. You probably think Robert Dziekanski deserved to be tazered and was the author of his own death..

In other words I think our system works pretty well most of the time. Not every time, but most of the time.

No, I don't think Robert Dziekanski deserved to be tasered. I agree with the opinions of Thomas Braidwood on that matter.
 
Well at least we know how you think... everyone arrested is guilty, and those acquitted get off on technicalities. You probably think Robert Dziekanski deserved to be tazered and was the author of his own death..

i would say that dziekanski is partly if not significantly repsonsible for his own death,and i am certain t-boy, that you would have no difficulties creating some lame-brained argument to that efffect,
 
Ah, but can you PROVE that he wasn't doing wheelies?

It is up to the prosecution to prove he did what they alledge, and it is up to his defence to attack and discredit any evidence they offer. That is the system we have, as idiotic as it is. If the defence can discredit the prosecutions version of events, he should walk. If they cannot, or the lawyers he can afford or legal aid can afford are too incompetent and unwilling to do so, he will be convicted. What actually happened is secondary to that fact.
 
In other words I think our system works pretty well most of the time. Not every time, but most of the time.

No, I don't think Robert Dziekanski deserved to be tasered. I agree with the opinions of Thomas Braidwood on that matter.

One of the foundations of our system is a presumption of innocence. So for you to make statement like that shows what a hypocrite you really are.
 
One of the foundations of our system is a presumption of innocence. So for you to make statement like that shows what a hypocrite you really are.

I have no idea what you think you're talking about, but it's been apparent on this thread for awhile that you don't know what you're talking about either, so that comforts me.

A system which has a healthy rate of acquittals indicates just how seriously we do take the presumption of innocence--but it's based on reasonable doubt not the unreasonable doubts you repeatedly raised throughout this thread.
 
It is up to the prosecution to prove he did what they alledge, and it is up to his defence to attack and discredit any evidence they offer. That is the system we have, as idiotic as it is. If the defence can discredit the prosecutions version of events, he should walk. If they cannot, or the lawyers he can afford or legal aid can afford are too incompetent and unwilling to do so, he will be convicted. What actually happened is secondary to that fact.
I was heeding Cobster's wise advice. But this is too much.

Are you actually implying that the job of the defence is to basically manufacture a case or engage in character assassination of witnesses? Talk of a route to swift disbarment.

And then the Pièce de résistance that being unwilling to engage in such bad practice is a sign of incompetence.

Forget about Law and Order - too many reruns of L.A. Law or Boston Legal.
 
But just a smidgen.... and then add your own speculation. Like say... the cop caught up to the superbike and knocked the passenger off.

It is a speculation, and I was quite clear about that. But the fact is, no one knows for sure, the cop has clammed up SIU is investigating, and yet the angry mob on this board is ready to convict because of this limited info and the fact that the guy looks like a twit. Man.. it's like an online version of 12 angry men.
 
I was heeding Cobster's wise advice. But this is too much.

Are you actually implying that the job of the defence is to basically manufacture a case or engage in character assassination of witnesses? Talk of a route to swift disbarment.

And then the Pièce de résistance that being unwilling to engage in such bad practice is a sign of incompetence.

Forget about Law and Order - too many reruns of L.A. Law or Boston Legal.

Don't be an idiot, of course there are courtroom rules they need to abide by, but essentially that is how it works. Do your best to destroy the credibility of the prosecution witnesses and their testimony.
 
I have no idea what you think you're talking about, but it's been apparent on this thread for awhile that you don't know what you're talking about either, so that comforts me.

A system which has a healthy rate of acquittals indicates just how seriously we do take the presumption of innocence--but it's based on reasonable doubt not the unreasonable doubts you repeatedly raised throughout this thread.

You speak as though you believe in the system... then you state quite clearly that the 35% acquitted were probably only freed due to prosecution error or lack of adequate evidence. So much for that presumption. Which is why I think you are a hypocrite. Reasonable doubt needs to meet a certain test. That test is not uniform and is based on all kinds of bias and how various arguments are framed and presented. Facts in many cases are at best murky.
 
that picture above was taken in lebanon, where it is legal to have a gun, any where any time any place & yes this is the guy ! I'm sure Justice will Prevail.