More on: Why I hate McCain

DonQuixote said:
The only practical solution to the problem is to not let either party
control all branches of government. If the Ds were in control as
the Rs now are we would most likely have the same 'culture'. It's
not an R problem, its our problem

This was my point exactly.

DonQuixote said:
Your position is plausable but for the fact that this administration
has been very unilateral in its dealing with the legislature for some
time. The Rs have stayed in formation and presented a unified front
for the past 5 years. Only recently have they decided to stand up
and protect their institutions. The Bybee torture memo and other
major policy decisions by this administration have been overstepping
their constitutional authority.

Yes, the Rs are feeling the voter backlash and that is a very strong
motivator especially if you want to get reelected. But, they are
also duty-bound to protect the integrity of their branch of government.
They've been late in stepping forward and may very well be doing
it out of self-interest rather than protecting their branch of government,
but they must do so lest the USA does become a fascist state with
an all-powerful president.

Recall the 'Unitary Executive Theory' of recent past. Though
this site is biased it does a fair job of presenting this presidential
theory that is consistent with this administration's conduct

http://rawstory.com/news/2005/CanExecutive_Branch_Decide_0923.html


DQ, help me here, is it really plausible that Congress is immune to search by court order because the Justice Department reports to the POTUS. At a high level I can understand the opportunity for harassment here but I would think the court order part would mitigate this. Does Congress really pass laws that only apply to the rest of us?

Thanks

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
The situation is one of first impression, OTB. The crux of the matter
came out this morning on NPR. The chief counsel for the House stated
she wanted to be present while the FBI was conducting its search and
seize. The FBI denied her request. I think the problem has to do with
the way the administration is trying to bully the House and they're
fighting back. The House is separate and apart from both the POTUS
and the Courts. I'm sure there are ways of protecting the activity
of the House members without trampeling their Costitutional role.

Would I have the same right to have my counsel present while the FBI searched my home or place of work? I don't really see this as a partisan issue, I see it as a seperation of powers issue but given that the third branch (courts) would have oversight I don't see the issue.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Its different, OTB. The executive branch doesn't have the
right to go where it is barred from going.

What bares them from going there? Is there law or just precedent?

DonQuixote said:
When they searched
and seized all of his records they interfered in a member of the
House conducting his business. If they actually took all the records
he had in his office, as reported, then the search warrent was far
too broad. It should have limited the search for the records they
were looking for rather than going on a fishing expedition.

Their search has a chilling effect on the congress and should never
have been authorized. In your or my case we could always request
the Court to strike documents from evidence in a court. But, what
remedy does a member of the House have once the documents are
seized? Do they have a right to all documents or only the ones that
are related to their case.

Tough questions, OTB. That's why this is a case of first impression.
It goes well beyond this congressman and his legal problems. This
could very well be precident setting and who knows where that might
end up.

I don't have any experience with search orders (I'm going to try and keep it that way) so I don't know how typical this broad a search warrant is. I would say that Congress should have to play by the same rules the rest of us do - although having said that I think the Clinton's did push back on finding Ms. Clinton's billing records for a period of time - I guess that was executive privilege.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
There's good reason for treating this matter differently
than it would for you or me.

Just as the executive branch has refused to provide
documents under a Senate subpoena - which this
POTUS has done claiming executive privilege - so
too should the Congress be able to refuse to provide
documents under a court subpoena.

The fishing expedition approach doesn't work in this
situation

Can I categorize this as a political separation of powers battle or is there explicit law underlying it?

Thanks for your patience with me on this.

OTB
 
GlennQuagmire said:
"More on: Why I hate McCain"

should be

"Moron: Why I hate McCain"

Carry on.

Hey Glenn, baby.

Maybe you can tell us what it is like to walk around with your head buried up your butt. On second thought, ask the laddie. He'd be glad to tell you.
 
TOVisitor said:
Hey Glenn, baby.

Maybe you can tell us what it is like to walk around with your head buried up your butt. On second thought, ask the laddie. He'd be glad to tell you.



Hey scroll wannabe, you really did join the moronic thought of the day club. So really how is that Heinz war effort research going. After that you might want to ask Hillary about her affair with Michael Moore.
 
LancsLad said:
Hey scroll wannabe, you really did join the moronic thought of the day club. So really how is that Heinz war effort research going. After that you might want to ask Hillary about her affair with Michael Moore.

Too funny laddie,
You just blew your cover with the above post!
Now we know you have to be pops twin brother.........:eek:

Dam, Dubya likes pops,
we both drink Limbaugh's
lemming-aid together !!!
 
LancsLad said:
So really how is that Heinz war effort research going. After that you might want to ask Hillary about her affair with Michael Moore.

I was about to award papa the "Dumbest Post of the Year" so far, but your continued idiocy has given me great pause.

Is this the best that a second-rate wingnut wannabe can do? I suppose so.

C'mon, maybe it will make you feel better to threaten me with a sniper rifle.
 
DonQuixote said:
Now, now boys. These tit-for-tat repartees may be
a release for you but it's getting a bit dull out here
for the rest of us.

What DQ said.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Now, now boys. These tit-for-tat repartees may be
a release for you but it's getting a bit dull out here
for the rest of us.



I'll play nice ( for now) and say that inspite of tov's wish I will not threaten him with the .50 sniper rifle. A threat gives warning, a surprise is so much more entertaining, and besides the .5 rounds are too expensive to waste on tov. His calibre is more a .22short.
 
LancsLad said:
I'll play nice ( for now) and say that inspite of tov's wish I will not threaten him with the .50 sniper rifle. A threat gives warning, a surprise is so much more entertaining, and besides the .5 rounds are too expensive to waste on tov. His calibre is more a .22short.

Yup, more eliminationist fantasies. Soooooooooo tiresome. Yawn.
 
..I dont trust McCain for 2 reasons

1) His enthusiatic support of this war
McCain has been an ardent supporter of the" democratization of the Middle East.
In my opinion, pure BS.
2) His mantra of "serving a cause greater then yourself".
The stuff Fascism is based on.
as well I would add his actively seeking the support of Bushs evanagelical
base, gives me the creeps.
When things get bad in the Middle East, and they will only get worse.
After perhaps a miltary disaster in Iran.
The public would turn to McCain, just becuase of what he did in Nam.
Unfortunately, that would be it for Democracy.
 
onthebottom said:
Anytime a single party has control of the Whitehouse and both houses of congress the pork will flow - money trumps political philosophies of both parties.

It pains me to say this but the Ds getting control of one of the houses in November and the resulting gridlock might be the best thing for us...... they can beat the shit out of each other and leave us to go make a living and raise our kids. That's why, IMO the tax cuts were locked in thru 08, if nothing happens for the next 2 years we should be fine.

OTB

Even though the phrase "Speaker Pelosi" causes me to dry heave.....

Anohter with the above view:

The Case for, and Against, Gridlock
What if the free-spending GOP loses the House?

By Phil Kerpen

Does the House GOP majority — after delivering a record number of pork-barrel earmarks, an enormous new entitlement program, and most recently a giant minimum-wage increase — deserve to become a minority this November? This question, once unthinkable among fiscal conservatives, is now a common topic of conversation in gatherings of limited-government analysts and activists in Washington.

In his excellent new book, Buck Wild, which details how the House GOP degenerated from the Contract With America to its present state, Stephen Slivinski of the Cato Institute concludes a chapter with this provocative question: “Even if you don’t agree that a divided government would make us better off, can you really argue — based on the evidence here — that it would make us worse off?” I’m not so sure.

Slivinski’s data show that the growth of government is far more rapid under periods of united control, with one party running the House, Senate, and White House, than when the House is controlled by the party not in the White House. Real per capita federal spending, which is adjusted for inflation and population growth, has increased at a 3.1 percent annual rate under Bush, faster than every president since Lyndon Johnson. This spending spree fits a larger historical trend with respect to divided government: Surveying more than forty years of data, Slivinski found that per capita government spending grows at an average inflation-adjusted rate of 3.4 percent under united government, versus only 1.5 percent under divided government.

There is reason to doubt that divided government, specifically in the next Congress, will limit spending. Bush, simply, has shown no appetite for cutting spending, and his cooperation with Democrats on landmark legislation like the No Child Left Behind Act suggests partisanship may not be the reason. When Bush did have a Democratic Senate to contend with, spending grew considerably faster at 4.3 percent annually than his overall 3.1 percent average. While Bush’s spending priorities would be largely at odds with a Democratic House, it’s possible that a Democratic House takeover would be a quid pro quo in which everyone’s pet projects grow.

The bigger question is the future of spending on entitlements, where the impending demographic shift in Congress will create skyrocketing federal spending absent reform. This potentially turns the rationale for divided government on its head: Gridlock is good when it prevents Congress from creating and expanding programs, but gridlock could be disastrous when doing nothing equates to leaving intact massive spending obligations.

Slivinski notes that federal spending went from 20.7 percent of GDP when the Republicans took over Congress to 18.4 percent of GDP when Clinton left office, but that it climbed back to 20.8 percent of GDP in 2006. That’s a big increase, and an embarrassing reversal. But it is dwarfed by the coming demographics-driven explosion in entitlement spending. The Congressional Budget Office projected last year that without reform, spending will be between 38 and 55 percent of GDP by 2050.

During Bush’s most recent State of the Union Address, Democrats congratulated themselves for blocking entitlement reform. Today, many of the same Democrats are campaigning on a platform of blocking any reform, and controlling the House would give them the absolute ability to do so. But united Republican control hasn’t yet delivered reform, while it did give us a gigantic new entitlement — the prescription drug benefit. If Democrats controlled one of the levers of power, would it make them less reactionary and more open to meaningful reform?

Spending is only half the equation for fiscal conservatives, and the GOP is light years better on taxes than spending. The 2003 tax bill was a stunning supply-side success, restoring investor confidence and fueling a dramatic economic expansion. The expansion has, ironically, filled federal coffers and enabled the spending binge, but it also has created millions of jobs and trillions of dollars of shareholder wealth. Because major tax hikes are scheduled to occur automatically on January 1, 2011 — increasing the capital-gains tax rate by 33 percent, the dividend rate by 133 percent, and the top marginal income-tax rate by 13 percent — a prolonged period of gridlock, lasting through the next two Congresses, could cause real economic damage on the tax side.

It’s clear from the fact that this discussion is even occurring that the Republican majority has a dismal record on limiting spending. The party has lost its fiscal compass. If the Republicans do lose the House this cycle, it will be hard to argue, based on spending policy, that they deserved otherwise. The ideal scenario for fiscal conservatives would probably be a brief period in the wilderness, a single cycle in which the GOP could regroup and refocus on the core fiscal issues that powered the Reagan revolution, led by a presidential candidate with a genuine commitment to spending restraint. But there are no guarantees in politics, and the Democrats could instead hold onto control, starting an era of even bigger government.

It’s quite a quandary. Almost makes me glad to be a disfranchised D.C. voter

OTB
 
The Mugger said:
Actually no he didn't and what cost him Florida (Gore) was an unusually high Hispanic vote that went to the Republicans.

Unusual? Remember that Miami has, by far, the largest Cuban-American population and they vote as an unified block for Republican (or whichever candidiate is more strongly against a communist Cuba)
 
assoholic said:
..I dont trust McCain for 2 reasons
2) His mantra of "serving a cause greater then yourself".

Is why I served in the military.

It is actually quite a noble attitude if you ask me. Otherwise why take the time to assist others in need if it doesn't benefit you?

I will dread the day where no one follows that mantra and everyone's only priority is to further their own gain.
 
I don't know about "hate," but there is something about McCain I just don't like.

It may just be the way he is always ready to show up on a Sunday morning talk show and start saying things that contradict his party, knowing it will get him some headlines and attention. Nothing wrong with speaking out on principle, but I get the sense with McCain that he is driven more by ego than principle.

As for Hillary, well, that's a whole different thread. I don't like her, either, but I wouldn't be too quick to dismiss her chances.
 
The primary schedule is being jiggled around and may have some effect.

early Prediction:

GOP Romney

DNC Feingold
 
In today's National Post, columnist David Frum has an interesting take on John McCain, suggesting he could end up being a Republican version of Joe Lieberman.

Unfortunately, I can't find the link to the article, but essentially Frum argued that McCain may have alienated so many Republicans that it has hurt his chances of becoming president. He also says that politicians seeking the presidency tend to be more successful when they have achievements as governor (Clinton, Dubya, etc.), rather than in the Senate (Kerry, etc.).

Frankly, I still find McCain to be annoying. Even when he says something that might sound sensible, it is annoying when it comes from him, spoken in that smarmy way he talks about everything. And I don't like the way he is always the favored Republican of choice for interviewers like George Stephanopoulos. McCain always seems a bit too eager to make headlines by crapping on his own party.
 
McCain's Straight Talk Express got de-railed a long time ago. He lost a lot of credibiity because of his rubberstamping of BushCo.

Another Republican I used to admire was Chuck Hagel. If he gets nominated, I'd consider voting for him but again, he was also a rubberstamp for the GOP.

This WH runs the most efficient muscle operation to be able to muzzle old timers like McCain, Hagel and Lugar like they did for 6 years.

But Mr.36% can't do much damage to them now.