Monday December 8

lookingforitallthetime said:
The GG post was kept to appease the crown allowing us to gain independence without a bloody revolution.

Since the inception of responsible government and the federation, the duties and responsibilities of the GG are primarily symbolic in nature.



But we clearly face a situation now where we may not have a "responsible" government.


If only we had a proper GG.


.
 
LancsLad said:
But we clearly face a situation now where we may not have a "responsible" government.

I am surprised you agree with that.
 
LancsLad said:
But we clearly face a situation now where we may not have a "responsible" government.


If only we had a proper GG.


.

We live in a democracy. If we have an irresponsible government, that is the fault of the electorate. The people made that choice.

The people didn't choose the GG and we should not expect (nor allow) an appointed official to face ANY situations regarding our national future.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
We live in a democracy. If we have an irresponsible government, that is the fault of the electorate. The people made that choice.

The people didn't choose the GG and we should not expect (or allow) an appointed official to face ANY situations regarding our national future.



I can understand that you would hold that view given the demographic of the populace today. But lets not forget that the Dominion of Canada was fortunately founded and structured along the lines of the traditional Mother Country. People with Common values and laws. Our civilized form of parliament always accepted the concept of the sober second thought provided by the older, and hopefully wiser men of reason, not swayed by current hysteria.

We now have a haitan separatist deciding if another citizen of france should lead our country.


Yes we need a proper GG and we need one now.


Sgt. call the men to rank.



.
 
danmand said:
I am surprised you agree with that.



I didn't agree that we don't need a Governer General, I pointed out that if the gaytrio get their way we will have irresponsible government.




.
 
LancsLad said:
I can understand that you would hold that view given the demographic of the populace today. But lets not forget that the Dominion of Canada was fortunately founded and structured along the lines of the traditional Mother Country. People with Common values and laws. Our civilized form of parliament always accepted the concept of the sober second thought provided by the older, and hopefully wiser men of reason, not swayed by current hysteria.

We now have a haitan separatist deciding if another citizen of france should lead our country.


Yes we need a proper GG and we need one now.


Sgt. call the men to rank.



.

I'll concede the wisdom of modelling our democracy along the lines of our mother country if you will concede the political situation in Canada as unique, requiring a unique approach to making the system work in the best interests of our country.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Positive reform is seldom easy. That doesn't mean it shouldn't be done.

agreed. But in the here and now we have to work with what we've got, as flawed as it may be. If one good thing comes out of this clusterfuck, it will be that the country takes a good, long hard look at the funding of political parties, and the role of the GG. At least one can hope....
 
dcbogey said:
agreed. But in the here and now we have to work with what we've got, as flawed as it may be.

Of course.

Until we take that all imortant first step though, the future of Canadian politics will forever my mired in the crap we've had to witness this week.
 
LancsLad said:
I didn't agree that we don't need a Governer General, I pointed out that if the gaytrio get their way we will have irresponsible government.
Oh, my mistake, I thought you agreed that we have an irresponsible government.
I was a bit sceptical, mind you.
 
landscaper said:
The really amusing thing will be if the GG dissolves parliment and calls an election . The coalition will be running for cover so fast you won't see anything but the hairpins flying ( bonus points if anybody knows where the reference comes from).

I'm not so sure about that. Flaherty handed the opposition some GOLDEN opportunities in that "economic update":

-- Eliminating the right to strike
-- Cracking down against women's rights

Plainly the new more gentler Conservative party that ran in the last election was a sham. YOU may support the above policies but very, very few Canadians do.

Many Canadians believed that the Conservatives had left that sort of nonsense behind and had moved towards the middle of the political spectrum under Harper but now know it ain't so.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
We need to get rid of the Governor General post altogether. There is no need for a Queen's representative, we are supposed to be an autonomous nation.

We ARE an autonomous nation. The GG is the representative of the QUEEN OF CANADA. Note the word "CANADA" in that. Not the Queen of England.

It happens that the same individual fills both roles but it need not be--the Privy Council of Canada, a bunch of Canadians, can change the rules so that the next Queen/King of Canada is not the same individual.

The GG is performing an important role in our society at this point and if we eliminate that role we can't just eliminate the associated functions and expenses, we would have to create some alternative.

You just can't have out of control Prime Ministers running rough shod over Parliament--somewhere somebody has to have the power to dismiss an errant PM.
 
fuji said:
We ARE an autonomous nation. The GG is the representative of the QUEEN OF CANADA. Note the word "CANADA" in that. Not the Queen of England.

It happens that the same individual fills both roles but it need not be--the Privy Council of Canada, a bunch of Canadians, can change the rules so that the next Queen/King of Canada is not the same individual.

The GG is performing an important role in our society at this point and if we eliminate that role we can't just eliminate the associated functions and expenses, we would have to create some alternative.

You just can't have out of control Prime Ministers running rough shod over Parliament--somewhere somebody has to have the power to dismiss an errant PM.
lancs is the queen of canada I believe
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I'll concede the wisdom of modelling our democracy along the lines of our mother country if you will concede the political situation in Canada as unique, requiring a unique approach to making the system work in the best interests of our country.



It is very unique. In any other country those traitorous yellow bellied blockheads would be tried for treason, here in politically neutered Canada they get paid a lot, with our money, to do it and get to hold the balance of power.


Sgt. call roll, ammo check.


.
 
fuji said:
We ARE an autonomous nation. The GG is the representative of the QUEEN OF CANADA. Note the word "CANADA" in that. Not the Queen of England.

It happens that the same individual fills both roles but it need not be--the Privy Council of Canada, a bunch of Canadians, can change the rules so that the next Queen/King of Canada is not the same individual.

The GG is performing an important role in our society at this point and if we eliminate that role we can't just eliminate the associated functions and expenses, we would have to create some alternative.

You just can't have out of control Prime Ministers running rough shod over Parliament--somewhere somebody has to have the power to dismiss an errant PM.

fuji, spare me the grade 12 civics lecture, I understand how it works.

What you fail to understand about the role of the GG is it has been primarily a symbolic role since confederation. When I talk about getting rid of the position I'm also talking about a complete overhaul of the system including a separation of powers and a clean break from the monarchy.

Under those conditions we would no longer require a Queen's representative. Neither for the Queen of England, nor the Queen of Canada. I'm assuming you realize they are the same person.
 
LancsLad said:
It is very unique. In any other country those traitorous yellow bellied blockheads would be tried for treason, here in politically neutered Canada they get paid a lot, with our money, to do it and get to hold the balance of power.

Yes, there is no Quebec problem for the mother country. ;)
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Yes, there is no Quebec problem for the mother country. ;)



We were taught how to handle froggy. The same method used to handle the real ones would work with the metis lot that Canadians must contend with.



.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
There is something terribly wrong with a democracy that gives one appointed official this much authority. It should be voters and not an appointed official that determines if Harper's actions are worthy of dismissal.

The Governor General is the Queen's representative, not ours.

Canada is NOT a democracy. It is a constitutional monarchy. End of discussion.
 
danmand said:
The queen has no
discressionary powers, acts effectively as a calculating machine.

I think you need to take a constitutional law course. The Crown has vast reserve powers in our system. By tradition, the Crown does not use them.
 
Quest4Less said:
I may be mistaken but I do not believe the GG can refuse the PM if he requests a 'prorogue'. She has no legal authority to deny the request from a sitting PM.

You're mistaken. Not only can she deny his request, she has the power to dismiss him.