Monday December 8

slowpoke said:
The GG won't be able to take her cue from the public opinion polls. According to the morning news, 55% are against Harper being ousted and 45% want him to walk the plank. I'm not sure about the polling company or the methodology but a 5% difference is hardly compelling - especially since the coalition has quite a few more seats than Harper.

.

slowpoke you're right into the Liberal spin-doctoring aren't you. Only a Liberal could turn a 10% deficit into 5 % :D

The other bit of spin-doctoring which is highly questionable is to blame an election on the Conservatives. Everyone had their little showdown and the Conservatives backed down. If there is an election you have no one to blame but the coalition for not stopping the power grab when the issue had been resolved.

An election, however is far more palatable than having the 3 stooges running the country until the Liberals can find a leader. They need a leader desperately ( and arguably the Conservatives do as well) as everyone in this sordid mess appears to have lost their moral compass. I know, I know Duceppe and Layton never had one to begin with.
 
More stuff on the news this morning about dissention within the ranks of the butt-f*ck trios gang of theives.

Manley says he won't play in the "economic" think group. Ignats people are asking questions.



This lib ploy and soap box sanctimony might hold more sway if celine were to state before the nation that all his libs are free of party shackles and can vote as they see fit. He should openly allow any lib MP that wants to avoid the separatist stench of death to cross the floor and back the Tories. That would be fun to see. Conversely Harper should let any Tory who feels in a particularly traiterous mood to go with the pond scum and get fisted by red jack and the traitors from the blockheads.



.
 
LancsLad said:
This lib ploy and soap box sanctimony might hold more sway if celine were to state before the nation that all his libs are free of party shackles and can vote as they see fit. He should openly allow any lib MP that wants to avoid the separatist stench of death to cross the floor and back the Tories. That would be fun to see. Conversely Harper should let any Tory who feels in a particularly traiterous mood to go with the pond scum and get fisted by red jack and the traitors from the blockheads.


I'm sure those who feel a coalition government is democratic will have no problem with your proposal.
 
The really amusing thing will be if the GG dissolves parliment and calls an election . The coalition will be running for cover so fast you won't see anything but the hairpins flying ( bonus points if anybody knows where the reference comes from).

The issue for the GG is whether she thinks the coalition can govern effectivly. If she does not she can have the P.M. call an election, given the noise coming from the liberal backbenchers and constituancy staffers and volenteers that will be an issue. A lot of the backbenchers are thinking about their futures if this does go through they will get destroyed in any upcoming election. The NDP folks are mad that there election platform has been basically discarded in a blatant power grab by Smiling Jack, they are wondering who is going to believe anything they say in the future. ( See bob Rea and Rea days)

The hardline separatists are going berserk the front office is digging out Jacques PArizeau to back them up.

This is going to be fun Jacques Parizeau supporting Stephane Dion, whats left of my mind boggles .
 
train said:
slowpoke you're right into the Liberal spin-doctoring aren't you. Only a Liberal could turn a 10% deficit into 5 % :D

It is also significantly higher than the number of people who voted for Harper. I think that says something good about the number of people who think this issue is more important than partisan politics.

BTW, I am not impressed with the 1926 precedent. In that case, the governor general handed the government over to a single party that actually had more seats. In that case, the liberals had lost to the conservatives the year before, in terms of the number of seats they had won. However, they retained power with the support of the progressive party, despite their fewer seats. All the Governor General did was hand over power to the party that had won the most seats, which normally would have happened the year before after the election anyway.
 
someone said:
BTW, I am not impressed with the 1926 precedent. In that case, the governor general handed the government over to a single party that actually had more seats. In that case, the liberals had lost to the conservatives the year before, in terms of the number of seats they had won. However, they retained power with the support of the progressive party, despite their fewer seats. All the Governor General did was hand over power to the party that had won the most seats, which normally would have happened the year before after the election anyway.

We need to get rid of the Governor General post altogether. There is no need for a Queen's representative, we are supposed to be an autonomous nation.

The position is nothing more than an unnecessary expense that possesses the dangerous potential to undo the will of an electorate.
 
slowpoke said:
She may prorogue parliament for a while but that also wastes valuable time and won't necessarily change the outcome.

I am not a fan of Harper but I am starting to think that a prorogue of parliament may be the best option. It will give everyone a chance to step back and cool off. It will give the Cons a chance to develope their stimulus package, assuming they see the need, and it will give the Libs a chance to pick a new leader before May. In late January when the budget comes down the opposition can vote no confidence and we go to the polls. IMHO it's the best way out of this mess.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
We need to get rid of the Governor General post altogether. There is no need for a Queen's representative, we are supposed to be an autonomous nation.

The position is nothing more than an unnecessary expense that possesses the dangerous potential to undo the will of an electorate.

Or it's the position required to carry out the constitution of the country. I suppose its all in the way you look at it. :cool:
 
dcbogey said:
I am not a fan of Harper but I am starting to think that a prorogue of parliament may be the best option. It will give everyone a chance to step back and cool off. It will give the Cons a chance to develope their stimulus package, assuming they see the need, and it will give the Libs a chance to pick a new leader before May. In late January when the budget comes down the opposition can vote no confidence and we go to the polls. IMHO it's the best way out of this mess.

Given the way this coalition is appears to be coming appart at the seams ( at least from news reports) a delay is the last thing the coalition wants. The tories will come up with a budget that will make them look like the power hungry idiots they are if they vote it down and if they don't vote it down they look like they folded their tent and ran away.
 
dcbogey said:
Or it's the position required to carry out the constitution of the country. I suppose its all in the way you look at it. :cool:

Do you believe a position with this much importance should be held by a single, unelected official? I prefer we let our elected officials carry out the constitution.

The Governor General is the Queen's representitive, not yours and mine.
 
I may be mistaken but I do not believe the GG can refuse the PM if he requests a 'prorogue'. She has no legal authority to deny the request from a sitting PM.
 
Quest4Less said:
I may be mistaken but I do not believe the GG can refuse the PM if he requests a 'prorogue'. She has no legal authority to deny the request from a sitting PM.


You may be right, I don't know, but it is troublesome to me that a sitting
government can send parliament home for an unspecified time period
in order to avoid a non confidence vote.

Imagine the uproar if Hugo Chavez tried to pull a stunt like that.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
We need to get rid of the Governor General post altogether. There is no need for a Queen's representative, we are supposed to be an autonomous nation.

The position is nothing more than an unnecessary expense that possesses the dangerous potential to undo the will of an electorate.



On this we will differ.

The thing is that recent governments have deliberately gone out of their way to denigrate the position of GG by filling it with vizmin socially correct nobodies.


We need a distinguished older retired gentleman such as myself in that position. The thing is none of the PM's will pass my name along to Liz.


.
 
LancsLad said:
We need a distinguished older retired gentleman such as myself in that position. The thing is none of the PM's will pass my name along to Liz.

.

You realize that you don't get an elephant rifle and a pithe helmet with the position don't you ?
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Do you believe a position with this much importance should be held by a single, unelected official? I prefer we let our elected officials carry out the constitution.

The Governor General is the Queen's representitive, not yours and mine.

getting rid of the GG would lead to a constitutional situation that would make Meech Lake, Quebec "sovereignty" etc look like a walk in the park. I'm not saying the idea doesn't have merit but it wouldn't be easy.
 
train said:
You realize that you don't get an elephant rifle and a pithe helmet with the position don't you ?



No need, already kitted up, just need the green light.




.
 
LancsLad said:
No need, already kitted up, just need the green light.

Seldom do people get permission to hold a revolution.:)
 
LancsLad said:
On this we will differ.

The thing is that recent governments have deliberately gone out of their way to denigrate the position of GG by filling it with vizmin socially correct nobodies.

The GG post was kept to appease the crown allowing us to gain independence without a bloody revolution.

Since the inception of responsible government and the federation, the duties and responsibilities of the GG are primarily symbolic in nature.
 
dcbogey said:
getting rid of the GG would lead to a constitutional situation that would make Meech Lake, Quebec "sovereignty" etc look like a walk in the park. I'm not saying the idea doesn't have merit but it wouldn't be easy.

Positive reform is seldom easy. That doesn't mean it shouldn't be done.