Modi scolds Trudeau over Sikh protests in Canada against India

[DesRicardo]

Is it the - Front de libération du Québec? Apparently it was designated a terrorist group as well. But looks like they were only active for a few years in the 60s.

Time to designate Khalistanis as terrorists as well.

But in any case, if the Canadian government is not being efficient with calling terror groups, terror groups, then I have nothing to say. Except that I am not going to lose sleep over some terrorist dirtbag being gunned down either by India or by someone else.

Also I think this is one of those things countries routinely put on the agenda and go back and forth about, without it blowing up too much (pun not intended lol). It's not like people in India care that much about the Khalistani movement either. It doesn't have enough support even within the Sikh community.

I just think it's funny that you spent the whole month defending Trudeau only for him to spit on you and your home country.

No doubt in my mind The Indian Gov played a part in this, but as a world leader something you open your mouth on publicly.

Xi tried to explain it to him awhile back.

 

[Not getting younger]

I need to try and understand something. Without offering opinion on Modi or agents.

1) BC Sikh murdered. Immediate outrage and condemnation over allegations.

2) Chinese agents threaten Canadian politicians…zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

3)China takes 2 Canadian citizens hostage.zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

 

[DesRicardo]

I need to try and understand something. Without offering opinion on Modi or agents.

1) BC Sikh murdered. Immediate outrage and condemnation over allegations.

2) Chinese agents threaten Canadian politicians…zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

3)China takes 2 Canadian citizens hostage.zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

4) China sets up police stations in Canada...zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

 

[Kautilya]

I just think it's funny that you spent the whole month defending Trudeau only for him to spit on you and your home country.

No doubt in my mind The Indian Gov played a part in this, but as a world leader something you open your mouth on publicly.

Xi tried to explain it to him awhile back.

I am still pro-Trudeau. I dont think this is really a big issue and the whole diplomatic dance is just overtly dramatic nonsense that neither Canadians nor Indians care that much about.

And as a Canadian citizen, my home country is Canada.

 

[Not getting younger]

That’s fine, you’re allowed to be.

Im drawing attention to the blatantly different stances and public responses.

1) he cares about China in ways he doesn’t India. Despite both being significant trading partners and having teeth.

2) he desperately needs to be seen as someone serious with backbone that cares about Canadians given mute dumb silence over China

3) He desperately needs to change the channel, given he is getting pummeled by Pierre and in polls.

4) all of the above

 

[Frankfooter]

That’s fine, you’re allowed to be.

Im drawing attention to the blatantly different stances and public responses.

1) he cares about China in ways he doesn’t India. Despite both being significant trading partners and having teeth.

2) he desperately needs to be seen as someone serious with backbone that cares about Canadians given mute dumb silence over China

3) He desperately needs to change the channel, given he is getting pummeled by Pierre and in polls.

4) all of the above

JT tried to investigate foreign electoral interference but PeePee shut it down.
PeePee is campaigning hard right now but its still too early.
You just have to say PeePee voted against CERB, child benefits, dental, housing and went out and backed the anti vaxxer convoy and bitcoin. When you need to he'll be an easy target.

 

[Knuckle Ball]

This is a video from the CBC that describes the history of the conflict in India over the idea of a Sikh state:

The video made a point at the end that the idea of a Khalistani state is an issue amongst the Sikh diaspora community in Canada, the US, the UK, Australia, etc. but that back in India (even in the Punjab region) it is not a particularly big issue.

 

[Butler1000]

Is it the - Front de libération du Québec? Apparently it was designated a terrorist group as well. But looks like they were only active for a few years in the 60s.

Time to designate Khalistanis as terrorists as well.

But in any case, if the Canadian government is not being efficient with calling terror groups, terror groups, then I have nothing to say. Except that I am not going to lose sleep over some terrorist dirtbag being gunned down either by India or by someone else.

Also I think this is one of those things countries routinely put on the agenda and go back and forth about, without it blowing up too much (pun not intended lol). It's not like people in India care that much about the Khalistani movement either. It doesn't have enough support even within the Sikh community.

I think that any nation committing a political assassination on Canadian soil needs to be called out. Period. Or fan Canada do the same and you would be good with that? How about the USA? Or Russia?

Sorry but as a canadian citizen to not denounce this marks you as maybe not as Canadian as you claim.

 

[Kautilya]

I think that any nation committing a political assassination on Canadian soil needs to be called out. Period. Or fan Canada do the same and you would be good with that? How about the USA? Or Russia?

Sorry but as a canadian citizen to not denounce this marks you as maybe not as Canadian as you claim.

Firstly, we don't know if India did it. We dont have evidence and India has denied responsibility.

Secondly, I would condemn it wholeheartedly if it was infact a political assassination. But it is not.

It is just another dirtbag terrorist. I am not going to feel sorry for him, or consider it a huge violation of Canadian sovereignty even if India did it, the same way I did not care that the US went into Pakistan to kill Bin Laden. These terrorists commit war against the state. There is also the fact that Nijjar was most likely not even Canadian and was living here illegally and conspiring to kill people and attack other countries.

I am also surprised you would consider a guy who claims to be Canadian, and belongs to a terrorist organization that killed Canadians as being more Canadian than me. I dont think you thought that through.

 

[Darts]

but that back in India (even in the Punjab region) it is not a particularly big issue.

It is not a "big" issue back in India because people who advocate Khalistan are killed or worse.

"The movement was suppressed by an Indian government crackdown that saw thousands of people killed, including prominent Sikh leaders."
Murder of B.C. Sikh leader puts Khalistan movement in spotlight. What is it? (msn.com)

 

[oil&gas]

Why Canadians Should be Worried by Trudeau's Claim.

 

[MRBJX]

Do you stand with Modi or Trudeau on this issue, darts?

why would you stand with either of those two at all

 

[Kautilya]

It is not a "big" issue back in India because people who advocate Khalistan are killed or worse.

"The movement was suppressed by an Indian government crackdown that saw thousands of people killed, including prominent Sikh leaders."
Murder of B.C. Sikh leader puts Khalistan movement in spotlight. What is it? (msn.com)

The majority of Sikhs in India neither care about the Khalistan movement nor support it.

BTW you said "killed or worse". What could be worse than killing?

 

[MRBJX]

This smells like trudeau doing a favor for his lap dog.

 

[DesRicardo]

Why Canadians Should be Worried by Trudeau's Claim.

Jagmeet is a khalistani leader? Can someone verify this?

I'd want my own separate country too so I can avoid this annoying witch.

 

[Darts]

The majority of Sikhs in India neither care about the Khalistan movement nor support it.
Did they ever have a secret ballot referendum like we did in Quebec? Would it be a free and fair referendum if they had one?

Scotland has had at least one (maybe two) referendum.

BTW you said "killed or worse". What could be worse than killing?
Gallow humour.

 

[Kautilya]

Jagmeet is a khalistani leader? Can someone verify this?

I'd want my own separate country too so I can avoid this annoying witch.

I agree with your last statement. With her smugness and her scoffing. She is what we call Godi media in India. God (prounounced Godh), means lap. Godi media means lapdog media and it is also a play on Modi. lol.

But as she says, the majority of Canadian or Indian Sikhs do not care for Khalistan.

As for Jagmeet, I know he has tweeted in favour of Khalistanis before. I would consider him a sympathizer because it is very difficult to tie him directly to the movement. He is careful that way. Remember a lot of the Sikhs in Canada, especially the ones who came here in the 60s, 70s and 80s were all primarily Khalistanis fleeing India.

 

[Kautilya]

he majority of Sikhs in India neither care about the Khalistan movement nor support it.
Did they ever have a secret ballot referendum like we did in Quebec? Would it be a free and fair referendum if they had one?

Scotland has had at least one (maybe two) referendum.

BTW you said "killed or worse". What could be worse than killing?
Gallow humour.

There is no need for a referendum. It would be 1.4B people vs 25M Sikhs the majority of whom don't and won't support Khalistan, because they see no need for it. Sikhs are already highly regarded, respected, successful and well liked in India, so the only ones who support these types of things are the conservative and overtly religious ones sitting in Gurudwaras without a proper job lol. And of course the Canadian ones stuck either in a time warp or in a terrorist organization.

 

[Butler1000]

Firstly, we don't know if India did it. We dont have evidence and India has denied responsibility.

Secondly, I would condemn it wholeheartedly if it was infact a political assassination. But it is not.

It is just another dirtbag terrorist. I am not going to feel sorry for him, or consider it a huge violation of Canadian sovereignty even if India did it, the same way I did not care that the US went into Pakistan to kill Bin Laden. These terrorists commit war against the state. There is also the fact that Nijjar was most likely not even Canadian and was living here illegally and conspiring to kill people and attack other countries.

I am also surprised you would consider a guy who claims to be Canadian, and belongs to a terrorist organization that killed Canadians as being more Canadian than me. I dont think you thought that through.

So you would support killing every Iranian working against the regime killed by Iran on Canadian soil if it happened. Because they were terrorists? How about Russians killing Ukrainians? Chinese killing dissidents?

 

[Kautilya]

So you would support killing every Iranian working against the regime killed by Iran on Canadian soil if it happened. Because they were terrorists? How about Russians killing Ukrainians? Chinese killing dissidents?

All of those would be political assassinations. So I wouldn't support it.

OTOH the Khalistan movement is a Sikh separatist, militant terrorist group who have killed 288 Canadians.

They aren't remotely the same.