Minivan Recommendations/Horror stories?

homer

Well-known member
Aug 18, 2001
16,326
107
63
guys!

My situation is such that it is time for me enter the minivan years. First of all, there is no way I can afford a Japanese one, and keep up the hobbying, so the Oddesey/Sienna/MPV are off the list. Basically, it's up the the big 3, with their employee discount deal on. Anyone have any experiences, good or bad with a GM/Chrysler/Ford minivan product?
Thanks for your input,

Homer
 
homer said:
First of all, there is no way I can afford a Japanese one, and keep up the hobbying, so the Oddesey/Sienna/MPV are off the list.
I thought the same thing last year, but I decided to at least talk to the Honda/Toyota/Mazda dealers. I found that with re-sale values and low lease rates, the actual cost of the Japanese models wasn't much more per month. I ended up leasing an Odyssey.

If you are sure that you can't get into a Japanese model, for the love of Pete please don't drive a Japanese minivan. You'll be ruined. The Big 3 minivans are bulky, slow, and handle like crap compared to their Japanese cousins.

Good luck. I'd go for a Chrysler if I was in your shoes.
 
Time for the "life stage" instead of "life style"

Welcome to the family pack

I have had both a Ford Windstar and Dodge Caravan. I would not really recommend either one. The Windstar blew a rad hose, left me high and dry, and Ford spent 4 days before they got a replacement (and they refused to pay for a rental even though was under the warranty period). The Caravan which I still have (can't afford to replace yet) has gone through 3 sets of brake pads in just over 90,000 km even though I am not a lead foot driver. Also the transmision interlock refused to disengage one afternoon which needed a tow to the dealer and an entire day to fix (they did cover the tow and repair under warranty). Both the Ford and Dodge are pretty thirsty on gas.

A friend has a Pontiac Montana and seems happy with it, another has a 2000 MPV with over 160.000 KM an had no issues.
 
2006 Mazda 5

Check out this smaller take on the minivan. Seats 7, under 20K base price. No brainer unless you need a ton of space. Google "2006 Mazda 5 review" and you should find some info.
 
Why are cars cheaper in Canada?

DATYdude said:
Check out this smaller take on the minivan. Seats 7, under 20K base price. No brainer unless you need a ton of space. Google "2006 Mazda 5 review" and you should find some info.

Less than 20K CAD? I saw cheap prices at CDN dealers the last time I was there, as well.

In the US, the Mazda MPV begins at $22K USD.

Anyone know what's involved with buying a car in Canada and bringing it to the US?
 
I don't drive a minivan but I just wanted to add that just like dutch too, everyone I know that has had a Chrysler van had transmition problems.
 
Depends on the car...

baltimoron said:
Less than 20K CAD? I saw cheap prices at CDN dealers the last time I was there, as well.

In the US, the Mazda MPV begins at $22K USD.

Anyone know what's involved with buying a car in Canada and bringing it to the US?

...for the high volume cars, or the strippers at the low end of the model line up (especially the North American models), yes they are cheaper. This is partially because many of the cars are manufactured here and partially because the automakers want to "wedge" into families just as they do in the US and offer their low end models at a loss in order to build brand loyalty. They realize that on average Canadians have both lower family incomes and less disposable income than Americans, hence the cars are priced cheaper in SOME instances (the one I have noticed personally is the Dodge Caravan).

On the other hand...as you go up the automotive food chain things reverse. Canadians auto prices are HIGHER for high end models and imports, even when you include the exchange rate.

This wasn't always the case - when I first arrived in Canada I happened to be walking by an Infiniti dealership one day and saw the sticker price on an I30. I did some quick math in my head (at the time the Canadian dollar was 62 cents US) and ran into the dealership. I came thisclose to buying one cash - the only thing stopping me was that I had no idea how long it would be before I was able to work in Canada, so I thought it would be best to not make such a large purchase without knowing when my cash flow would again go positive.

By comparison, a few months ago I purchased a luxury SUV and STILL can't get over how much I paid. I got a great price (Large SUVs aren't selling real well here either), but still, I had never even considered paying that much for a car before, let alone actually doing it. I looked into purchasing one in the United States, as with the exchange rate that would have significantly cheaper, but some investigation revealed that financing and insurance would have been a real hassle.

Bottom line - all cars are not necessarily cheaper here. Do your homework...and keep in mind registering a car purchased in another country is not the easiest thing in the world (from either side of the border).
 
I had a Chevy Astro van for business purposes. Drove it for 375,000Kms without any major cost for repairs. The only downside was that it is built on a truck chasis, therefore the ride is not very comfortable.

Currently have a Dodge Caravan. Very smooth ride, almost car like. But as someone else mentioned, very heavy on gas and the wear and tear of the brake pads is a big problem.

Best advise, spend a little more and get an import. The Odyssey and Sienna are beautiful.

Good luck.
 
mini vans

I have been driving astro vans for years and I highly recommend them. With regular oil changes and proper maintenance they will go on forever. It is not unheard of for these vans to log well over 500,000 kms. and still be going strong. The one thing I really like about them (but to others it may be a drawback) is they are the largest mini van on the market. So if you intend to carry bulky items these vans are the way to go. My van is mainly used for my business, with the rear seats removed, but I have used it extensively for personal use as well and I am very happy with the ride and comfort factor and the head room. The body is holding up very well even though I have been very lax on the exterior maintenance.
 
Believe it or not, I have had a dodge caravan for 5 years now, and it has never been in the shop. The only thing I have replaced is oil and 1 lightbulb.

It has been the most reliable car I have ever had.

BTW, It is for sale.
 
I'll second and third the astro van. I am not currently on the road. But years a go when I was a couier driver for a few years I always had an astro van. Only break down I ever had was the starter... that I thought was completely understandable considering how many times a day I parked to make a delivery and had to start again.
 
Have a friend,associate,that sells used cars.His motherinlaw was in the market for a used mini-van.He went on her behalf to a gm dealer and got her an 05 demo with entertainment centre,after all deals were applied he paid 13k plus taxes.He said he could not have come close to that price at an auction.He buys these from gm and still makes as much or more by passing the savings on.Her only complaint,what was she going to do with the entertainment centre,lol,he said forget it,it was thrown in!
Have personally owned 3 ventures,the 02 needed a head gasket,100% covered by dealer.They have aparently rectified this problem.Owned 3 astro vans,bullet proof.
 
wow!

Thanks for all the responses! They kind of confirm what I was leaning towards. Either a Montana, or whatever their GM cousin is. Thanks again for everyones input!

Homer
 
no problems with my shaggin wagon

I mean windstar
 
Go with the Honda Van,.,..

Chrysler if money is important.... go with the stow seating.

Ford is not a good deal, its more expensive and after the first year the thing rattles... dealer cant answer why, but talking to others in service dept, they all have same issues, lots of noise, not well built actually... Chrysler is not a disposable, actually well built, but must get the 3.8 litre, never the 3.0 it used to be korean built I think? Anyway wasnt a reliable product, the trannys were bad in the late 1990's, but now good shape...

so honda or chrysler... depends on your budget, honda bit better, chrysler less expensive, always get the grand with chrysler and the 3.8 best advice I can give, its sound advice.
 
Dutch too said:
The Caravan which I still have (can't afford to replace yet) has gone through 3 sets of brake pads in just over 90,000 km even though I am not a lead foot driver.

Get ceramic brakes.
 
Right now GM is trying to get rid of the last generation of the montana and venture while the new models are entering the market (the chevy uplander / pontiac SV6 / saturn relay / buick terraza). These new vans offer various trim levels and different pricing but are all pretty much the same mechanically.

Also the Astro and safari are currently in their last year of production, the factory is already closed so whatever is left in GM's inventory is all you will get in terms of choice. The features on the Astro are also very different from other minivans things like dual sliding doors and DVD entertainment systems were never available on the astros.

Best advice is to shop around and if you really like the imports go in and see what sort of deal they can give you, now is the time that the 2006 models will start hitting showrooms and there will be a push to get rid of left over 2005's so there may be added incentives or better rates.
 
I am amazed at how many of you own minivans!

I thought all you guys were swinging bachelors and drove around in 6 series BMW's and M Class Mercedes.
 
poorboy said:
I am amazed at how many of you own minivans!

I thought all you guys were swinging bachelors and drove around in 6 series BMW's and M Class Mercedes.

Doesn't everyone have 2 or more vehicles?lol