Mini ice age about to start...

Why are places like Canada so worry if sea levels rise and temps increase / seems like places such as the Florida Keys would be gone but most of Canada is just too darn cold most the time to live there. (talking about for humans)

There very well might be vast oil reserves under all the ice of Antarctic. That ice is not forecast to melt as fast.

Sad the polar bears might be gone but does that effect 99% of us??

Just cause major changes may happen doesn't mean for sure it be for the worst. Yeah if I owned some homes in the Florida Keys I be worried but I don't.

The rise will cause problems in Canada, perhaps not as much as Florida or New York State, but it will effect tidal pools and spawning grounds, Richmond BC would go under as would a lot of the coastal Maritimes. Where does almost everyone live in the Maritimes, along the coast. On the world stage, we don't matter as much with less than 3% of the worlds economy coming from us, but we do hold an amazing amount of fresh water inside our borders and that will become valuable in time.

There is a lot of oil, albeit finite, but so much of it now is prohibitively expensive to extract or unreachable with todays technology.
 
Mini Ice Age? Interesting theory.... but just that. A theory.

Fact is, Polar Ice Caps are melting at an alarming rate. Ice caps that have been around for centuries don't melt when the temps get colder. Sorry they don't.

Another fact.... Climate change is not going to be solved on this board. Everyone has an agenda and only looks for the evidence that supports their own theories or agendas. Same in the real world. It won't be solved their either. Face it, we're just along for the ride at this point.


cheers!
 
Mini ice age about to start...


LOL. I thought you were going to tell us your wife found out about your hobbying.

Thank God this is only a climatic cataclysm .


.
 
Nope- tongue, brain & scientific backup NOT in cheek

Thanks for you contribution. I don't know where to begin, so I'll say this, if your tongue was not in your cheek, don't let the door hit you on the way out.

So, why dont you begin?
 
from your previous post;


OMG! Just saw on CNN, we have THREE big volcanoes..

Originally Posted by Yoga Face
What I do not understand is that the CO2 we put ionto the stratosphere is a tiny fraction compared to a good volcanic eruption

Yet hard to argue with scientists
..warming up! But because of the DUST they toss up high, they are major chillers.

It only takes ONE big one (Krakatoa, Tambora, Yellowstone caldera) to shield the sun and make an Ice Age.
---------------------------------------------

So, why dont you begin?

Fair enough.

I'm not a volcanologist, and I'm only familiar with two of the above eruptions Krakatoa and Tambora, but it would seem to be case of you comparing what are considered extremely large eruptions with what are going on now. The present ones are nowhere near as big, but will have an effect, count on it. The ones you referred to did effect weather for years after. You're really comparing apples and oranges. t he Yellowstone eruption(s) occurred over 600,00 years ago and were larger, by volume, than your noted Tambora eruption by a factor of 10, the Mt Pinatubo by a factor of 100, and Mt St Helen, a factor of 1000. The sizes of eruptions in the Mono Inyo range of volcanos along the California mountain chains over the last 5000 years were 1/10,000th to 1/10,000,000th the size of your noted Yellowstone; comparisons made using the Volcano Eruption Index. Kind of like the Richter Scale for earthquakes.

I don't know where the 3 eruptions are happening now compare, but let's get real. They're not in the same ball park.
Let have a far comparison
 
Last edited:
I don't know if anyone has read superfreakanomics. They discuss an easy cheap solution to global warming - pumping sulphur dioxide into the stratosphere. Take a fraction of what factories already put out but pump it 18 miles up and we will have a continual controlled version of volcanic global cooling.
 
I don't know if anyone has read superfreakanomics. They discuss an easy cheap solution to global warming - pumping sulphur dioxide into the stratosphere. Take a fraction of what factories already put out but pump it 18 miles up and we will have a continual controlled version of volcanic global cooling.

People like you scare the s**t out of me. There is not one proven model out there that says "If we do this, we KNOW that this will happen". Yet you are willing to to do something like this.

Let me ask you.... If I put you in a vehicle, whose controls were 100 unlabeled buttons, surrounded the vehicle with your loved ones with only a single, convoluted path through them, how quickly would you be willing to push a button? Oh and by the way, just because button #1 did a specific thing the last time you pushed it, it might do something different because each button press can affect what all the other buttons do.
 
christ I hope its a global warming, hard to grow crops in snow.

don't know what to think of all the 'science' claims (the science doesn't this, doesn't that...). Science can be a funny thing. For 40 some years the big tobacco companies was able to claim that the science did not support a link between smoking and cancer. Seems to me that science isn't all that free from bias that many people think it is.

in my view the 'green' movement will be arrested unless we come out of this recession in a hurry. people start to lose interest in being green when they have to worry about putting food on the table. same thing happened in the early 90s. I do hope that the economics make people motivated to continue to pursue green living, we just need to realize that we can't depend on oil forever.

as a final component of my rant I have to say I am so sick of watching all this nostradamus (sp?) doomsday shit on TV (and seeing it in other media as well). I just get so fucking depressed when I watch that crap.
 
christ I hope its a global warming, hard to grow crops in snow.

don't know what to think of all the 'science' claims (the science doesn't this, doesn't that...). Science can be a funny thing. For 40 some years the big tobacco companies was able to claim that the science did not support a link between smoking and cancer. Seems to me that science isn't all that free from bias that many people think it is.

in my view the 'green' movement will be arrested unless we come out of this recession in a hurry. people start to lose interest in being green when they have to worry about putting food on the table. same thing happened in the early 90s. I do hope that the economics make people motivated to continue to pursue green living, we just need to realize that we can't depend on oil forever.

as a final component of my rant I have to say I am so sick of watching all this nostradamus (sp?) doomsday shit on TV (and seeing it in other media as well). I just get so fucking depressed when I watch that crap.

You're right on a number of points.

the tobacco science was flawed for political and economic reasons, but it didn't take long before it was challenged and that's the important point.

Green is still moving forward. With help of government programs and a shovel to the side of the head of the powers to be, Germany now employs more people in Green Industries than in the auto sector. Did you ever think you'd hear that statement?

Constant Doomsday news can be a downer. what needs to be done is information about what can be done by Joe Public to help in the solution. If the News Casts would stop all 15 second previews and just report the news they'd be able tin form you instead of titillate or bore you by hearing the same preview 4 times an hour. They'd be able to broadcast 25% more news and information. Isn't that what they're supposed to do?
 
It’s a perfectly acceptable for the scientific community to say, “We don’t know,” when asked about the climate change debate.

Yet, many of them claim to know the answer. Worse, political activists with an agenda jump on the global warming bandwagon and tell us that the sky is falling, the ice caps are melting stuff.

The politicians are using this hysteria and feeding on our fear to push through “carbon” taxes and redistribute wealth based on fear.

I think this global warming “cult” of fear and paranoia seems to have run its course and perhaps common sense and real scientific method can return.

This is exactly why I have a healthy doubts about the validity of all the mumbo jumbo that's out there. There are billions of dollars at stake and the professional activists are all about re-distributing wealth.

Why did Copenhagen fail? The third world wanted billions more than the first world wanted to give them.
 
This is exactly why I have a healthy doubts about the validity of all the mumbo jumbo that's out there. There are billions of dollars at stake and the professional activists are all about re-distributing wealth.

Why did Copenhagen fail? The third world wanted billions more than the first world wanted to give them.


Very close but not quite. It's also a matter of control/influence. The west has it and doesn't want to loose it.
 
Geez, is that all? Of course EVERYTHING on CNN must be taken with a..

from your previous post;


OMG! Just saw on CNN, we have THREE big volcanoes..

Originally Posted by Yoga Face
What I do not understand is that the CO2 we put ionto the stratosphere is a tiny fraction compared to a good volcanic eruption

Yet hard to argue with scientists
..warming up! But because of the DUST they toss up high, they are major chillers.

It only takes ONE big one (Krakatoa, Tambora, Yellowstone caldera) to shield the sun and make an Ice Age.
---------------------------------------------



Fair enough.

I'm not a volcanologist, and I'm only familiar with two of the above eruptions Krakatoa and Tambora, but it would seem to be case of you comparing what are considered extremely large eruptions with what are going on now. The present ones are nowhere near as big, but will have an effect, count on it. The ones you referred to did effect weather for years after. You're really comparing apples and oranges. t he Yellowstone eruption(s) occurred over 600,00 years ago and were larger, by volume, than your noted Tambora eruption by a factor of 10, the Mt Pinatubo by a factor of 100, and Mt St Helen, a factor of 1000. The sizes of eruptions in the Mono Inyo range of volcanos along the California mountain chains over the last 5000 years were 1/10,000th to 1/10,000,000th the size of your noted Yellowstone; comparisons made using the Volcano Eruption Index. Kind of like the Richter Scale for earthquakes.

I don't know where the 3 eruptions are happening now compare, but let's get real. They're not in the same ball park.
Let have a far comparison



..bucket of salt. But I made the hyperbolic comparison, not CNN.

NO dispute with your facts as stated. but
1) Yellowstone was a looooong time ago- to a human. In geological terms no big deal. some experts suggest the world is overdue for a caldera.
2) The 3 newly steaming volcanos on CNN are UNLIKELY to be another Krakatoa, but we dont know YET do we?
3) Who says we will get ANY warning? The next monster could burst out of the Canary Islands tomorrow.
 
..bucket of salt. But I made the hyperbolic comparison, not CNN.

NO dispute with your facts as stated. but
1) Yellowstone was a looooong time ago- to a human. In geological terms no big deal. some experts suggest the world is overdue for a caldera.
2) The 3 newly steaming volcanos on CNN are UNLIKELY to be another Krakatoa, but we dont know YET do we?
3) Who says we will get ANY warning? The next monster could burst out of the Canary Islands tomorrow.

2) Ya, we do.
3) It's not absolutely certainly but it's pretty good chance we will. Enough time to bend over and kiss our collective asses goodbye.
 
I don't know if anyone has read superfreakanomics. They discuss an easy cheap solution to global warming - pumping sulphur dioxide into the stratosphere. Take a fraction of what factories already put out but pump it 18 miles up and we will have a continual controlled version of volcanic global cooling.

Interesting concept pump sulfer dioxide into teh stratosphere to control temperature.

HMMM let me see

Sulfur dioxide SO2

Water H2O

Combined H2SO4 Sulfuric acid if I am not mistaken

What was the phrase I am trying to think of..........


OH YA ACID RAIN
 
AS far as volcanos go even a small one will emitt far more COs , methan and water vapour than human contributions over its life span. A mega volcano such as Yellowstone would give us other worries beyond gloibal warming, like the end of north american civilization that sort of problem.

The ash from a volcano does cause weather effects in some cases world wide effects, both Pinatubo and Krakatoa caused cooler weather and poor crop seasons for a couple of years, that is generally how long it takes the particulates to get rained out of the atmosphere.