Mindy McCready an apparent suicide

Suicide never the right answer when you have children. I don't care how depressed you are. You live for your children.
 
Thank goodness not in this case but sometimes the mother murders her children first and then commits suicide.

She murdered her dog. Pointless.
 
I'm sure some members of this board at one time or another have thought about this act of suicide. Just look at every suicide story like this one and realize, who this selfish act hurts in the end. Learn from it.

Do i feel sorry for Mindy. NO. i feel sorry for her kids and everyone else she's impacted with this stupid act.
 
what i cant understand is.

its in every mothers primal instinct to look after their children first and foremost. they draw purpose and happiness thro ugh theor childrens existence and wasnt she happy that she had two beautiful children in her life? that wasnt enough for her to go on?

she actually decided to leave them behind and abandon them to fend for themselves in a cold cruel world? what mother woth her maternal instinct does that?
 
what you can't understand is mental illness. And it is hard to understand and can manifest itself in different ways for different people. This is a terrible story all the way around.


what i cant understand is.

its in every mothers primal instinct to look after their children first and foremost. they draw purpose and happiness thro ugh theor childrens existence and wasnt she happy that she had two beautiful children in her life? that wasnt enough for her to go on?

she actually decided to leave them behind and abandon them to fend for themselves in a cold cruel world? what mother woth her maternal instinct does that?
 
There are over 54 million Americans with mental disorders!!

http://www.mentalhealthamerica.net/go/history

http://www.nami.org/Template.cfm?Se...Management/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=53155

This is a scary, huge number, that's one in four adults in the US. What is even more scary is the open gun culture being advocated by some knowing the number of people walking around with a mental disorder.

I just recently came back from spending a few weeks in the mid/southern states, the governments over the years have really let the people down by not investing and researching more in mental illness.
 
Depression is a real illness which I myself suffer from! Last summer I was put on antidepressants, these drugs caused me to go into a deeper depression and I could not go Five minutes without thinking of killing myself! I had a detailed plan! Depression I always suffered from but before the drugs had never thought suicide the answer, I am a single mother of two boys! These drugs took ALL my emotion away, I was unable to laugh, cry, or love, I was a walking zombie!! What many people do not know is this is a huge problem in the medical community that the media will not cover, Antidepressants are big big money, they are killing millions! I believe this woman was a victim, stop judging, THINGS ARE NOT WHAT THEY ALWAYS SEEM TO BE, sometimes they is more to the story!! Antiphychotic medication is a ma jor problem and to blame for many suicides and murders!!!!
 
Depression is a real illness which I myself suffer from! Last summer I was put on antidepressants, these drugs caused me to go into a deeper depression and I could not go Five minutes without thinking of killing myself! I had a detailed plan! Depression I always suffered from but before the drugs had never thought suicide the answer, I am a single mother of two boys! These drugs took ALL my emotion away, I was unable to laugh, cry, or love, I was a walking zombie!! What many people do not know is this is a huge problem in the medical community that the media will not cover, Antidepressants are big big money, they are killing millions! I believe this woman was a victim, stop judging, THINGS ARE NOT WHAT THEY ALWAYS SEEM TO BE, sometimes they is more to the story!! Antiphychotic medication is a ma jor problem and to blame for many suicides and murders!!!!

Not everyone reacts to anti depressants the way you did! For many people, they do work. Just because they didn't work for you doesn't mean they won't work for someone else. It's at least worth trying them. It's often a question of finding the right anti depressant for you and the correct dosage. We all react differently to different medications.
 
Depression is a real illness which I myself suffer from! Last summer I was put on antidepressants, these drugs caused me to go into a deeper depression and I could not go Five minutes without thinking of killing myself! I had a detailed plan! Depression I always suffered from but before the drugs had never thought suicide the answer, I am a single mother of two boys! These drugs took ALL my emotion away, I was unable to laugh, cry, or love, I was a walking zombie!! What many people do not know is this is a huge problem in the medical community that the media will not cover, Antidepressants are big big money, they are killing millions! I believe this woman was a victim, stop judging, THINGS ARE NOT WHAT THEY ALWAYS SEEM TO BE, sometimes they is more to the story!! Antiphychotic medication is a ma jor problem and to blame for many suicides and murders!!!!

The problem is not always the drug but the wrong diagnosis that gives you the wrong medication.

If a person suffering from bi-polar disorder goes in while depressed a doctor will think it is simply depression and order antidepressants. Except that is not the right diagnosis so the doctor is giving the wrong med. Giving a bi polar person an antidepressant can and usually does send them into a huge manic phase and the patient ends up even worse.

Many mental illnesses are difficult to diagnose and to get right on the first try. Also as stated there are many different kinds of medications and sometimes it takes finding the right ones. Plus with these types of meds, you really really need to stick to the proper time line and take them exactly as directed which many people do not.
 
Last edited:
Ignorance of mental illness and the toll it can take on the person suffering from it does not give anyone the right to say the person taking their own life is selfish, inconsiderate or lazy.

I lost a very good friend to suicide last summer. He was a rock, the kind of person that people gravitated to, looked to for guidance. He was very successful financially, surrounded by friends, had a wonderful relationship with his family. He was 'the guy', connected to hundreds of people. He was a volunteer for many wonderful causes, active in the community. He was about the most honourable, decent, honest man I've ever been friends with.

What we did not know (virtually none of us) was that he dealt with severe depression. He masked it incredibly well, put on a brave face, and pushed on with his life for many years. When he came to the decision to end his life, it wasn't a spur of the moment thing. He took a week to organize his papers, his financial affairs, wrote letters & notes to many people explaining his decision. He gave instructions on where to find various things that would be needed to tidy up his estate. He wanted things to be simple, uncomplicated, didn't want to make extra work for anyone.

Then, only then, he took his own life.

Was I angry with him (were the 100's of people he was friends with....truly friends with) angry?
Frustrated that he didn't feel he could reach out when he had issues the way so many had looked and depended upon him when they had troubles in their lives?
Yes, but we weren't living with the illness he was.


He did not choose to take his own life on a whim. He sincerely felt it was the only way to end his pain.
 
Your story, gcostanza, is interesting. I know of a guy like that who has said he is simply "tired" of living and wants to wrap things up neatly to minimize the pain to his friends and family. He has asked for my help in the past and I have given it to him without condition. He makes lucid, rational arguments supporting his position and it is hard to argue with him. It is his life to with as he pleases after he considers all the implications and seeks the appropriate counselling.

Sad? For us, yes.
 
Ignorance of mental illness and the toll it can take on the person suffering from it does not give anyone the right to say the person taking their own life is selfish, inconsiderate or lazy.

I lost a very good friend to suicide last summer. He was a rock, the kind of person that people gravitated to, looked to for guidance. He was very successful financially, surrounded by friends, had a wonderful relationship with his family. He was 'the guy', connected to hundreds of people. He was a volunteer for many wonderful causes, active in the community. He was about the most honourable, decent, honest man I've ever been friends with.

What we did not know (virtually none of us) was that he dealt with severe depression. He masked it incredibly well, put on a brave face, and pushed on with his life for many years. When he came to the decision to end his life, it wasn't a spur of the moment thing. He took a week to organize his papers, his financial affairs, wrote letters & notes to many people explaining his decision. He gave instructions on where to find various things that would be needed to tidy up his estate. He wanted things to be simple, uncomplicated, didn't want to make extra work for anyone.

Then, only then, he took his own life.

Was I angry with him (were the 100's of people he was friends with....truly friends with) angry?
Frustrated that he didn't feel he could reach out when he had issues the way so many had looked and depended upon him when they had troubles in their lives?
Yes, but we weren't living with the illness he was.

He did not choose to take his own life on a whim. He sincerely felt it was the only way to end his pain.

Often people are angry and do not understand.

For your friend, he couldn't come to any of you. Not because of you but because of him. He was "the guy" after all. I can completely see where and how he made the choice he did. He was tired. Plain and simple. An engine, even properly maintained, only has a certain amount of running time. People too. We need to be refuelling all the time. Those who suffer from depression often can not refuel themselves and they simply get tired. It is sad but it is the reality. They get tired of the fight to put on that face everyday. They get tired of being "the guy". They can not give up the title though either because that sets in ideas of failure etc. making the depression worse.

It sounds as though you had an amazing friend. He knew what he had to do for him and was very thoughtful of others the best he could be. Often it is the people who suffer silence that are the least selfish people in the world.

I am sorry for your lose but am happy to see you can look past his choice and your upset and see the truth of his life as he saw it. Not like an outsider looking in.
 
Last edited:
I am deeply saddened to her of this. She was so troubled, you could see it in her eyes and I always felt for her. It seems she has lost her long battle with the afflictions that she was fighting. I lost a brother to suicide and I can promise you her family will never truly recover from this trauma. It's always hard to understand why the person couldn't be helped. I'm not the most spiritual person, but I hope she is at rest...
 
Depression is a real illness which I myself suffer from! Last summer I was put on antidepressants, these drugs caused me to go into a deeper depression and I could not go Five minutes without thinking of killing myself! I had a detailed plan! Depression I always suffered from but before the drugs had never thought suicide the answer, I am a single mother of two boys! These drugs took ALL my emotion away, I was unable to laugh, cry, or love, I was a walking zombie!! What many people do not know is this is a huge problem in the medical community that the media will not cover, Antidepressants are big big money, they are killing millions! I believe this woman was a victim, stop judging, THINGS ARE NOT WHAT THEY ALWAYS SEEM TO BE, sometimes they is more to the story!! Antiphychotic medication is a ma jor problem and to blame for many suicides and murders!!!!
The movie "Side Effects", which started about a week ago, deals with these issues. It's a murder/thriller with some interesting twists, but the medication issue is front and centre. It was well done.
 
Often people are angry and do not understand.

For your friend, he couldn't come to any of you. Not because of you but because of him. He was "the guy" after all. I can completely see where and how he made the choice he did. He was tired. Plain and simple. An engine, even properly maintained, only has a certain amount of running time. People too. We need to be refuelling all the time. Those who suffer from depression often can not refuel themselves and they simply get tired. It is sad but it is the reality. They get tired of the fight to put on that face everyday. They get tired of being "the guy". They can not give up the title though either because that sets in ideas of failure etc. making the depression worse.

It sounds as though you had an amazing friend. He knew what he had to do for him and was very thoughtful of others the best he could be. Often it is the people who suffer silence that are the least selfish people in the world.

I am sorry for your lose but am happy to see you can look past his choice and your upset and see the truth of his life as he saw it. Not like an outsider looking in.

Thank you.

Not that he needs/needed it, but I have come to be at peace with his decision.
Until someone has walked a kilometre in another's shoes, you don't know the pain, the anguish that they are experiencing.
Do I miss him? Yes, as does everyone whose life he touched.
He is not suffering any more, and this is a very good thing.
 
So she murdered a dog and then killed herself leaving her children behind.

If "she" was a "he" or a non-celebrity lots of folks would be singing a different tune.