Michael Vick Is Toast

Well, I'm pretty sure the Falcons aren't remotely considering taking him back, and are only keeping him on the roster to see if they can recover any of his 20 Million plus signing bonus. Ironic that he is being replaced by the ultimate nice guy, though of questionable NFL talent, Joey Harrington. The guy plays the piano for Christ's sake.
 
frankcastle said:
I'm seeing a lot of hate for Vick and deservedly so. But to say that he is replacable is a bit of a stretch.


Frank..this is Foot Ball in the United States of America. Do you have any idea how many kids there are out there that could be the next great player but just havent had a chance yet?

He was a good QB, yes...but hes not god and he is CERTAINLY replaceable
 
BottomsUp said:
Isn't it amazing how when something as despicable as this is done by a well known personality and done in our own back yard (usa), everyone is aghast with shock and outrage. Well animal abuses are happening all over the world, and not confined to dog fights, (which are prevalent in many countries).

Consider bull fights. The poor bull gets his shoulder muscles systematically sliced apart and dies a slow painful death. Purely for entertainment. Where's the outrage with that.

Rhinos slaughtered so their horn can be sold as aphrodisiacs.

Sharks having their dorsal fins sliced off to be sold as aphrodisiacs, and left to die.

Gorillas killed for body parts to be sold.

Elephants slaughtered for their tusks.

Killing animals for trophy horns, heads, rugs, etc.

The list goes on.

So it seems we've elevated dogs, horses, cats, monkeys, dolphins above the rest of the animal world, likely due to their level of intelligence and their ability to relate to humans in a non threatening manner. I guess the non threatening manner of the cow is offset by their lack of brain power. What happened to the poor pig? Both smart and non threatening, (but doesn't relate well to humans). But if they're non threatening and cute, but not smart, all hell breaks loose. I'm sure you've figured this one out...the baby seal. But, if you're smart, don't relate to humans and considered a nuisance, you're toast. Witness the ant. Nobody going to jail for wiping out an ant colony, as far as I know.

I guess all of the animal atrocities that happen around the world just don't spark the same level of concern as when man (especially a famous man) messes with mans best friend. After all it's not in our back yard. And, yes I know there are animal rights groups that are trying to prevent these abuses, and I applaud their efforts. Many species of animals have been saved by their efforts.

Michael Vick, you're finding out the meaning of the law of unintended consequences. The focus however, should not be on MV, it should be on all the sickening animal abuses being committed globally, dog fighting being just one of many.

What are you talking about there is outcry over that other stuff mentioned as well..been so for years.

Yeah Michael Vick is making the news but thats because hes rich and famous...but that doesnt change the punishment he deserves to get and his punishment wont be any worse than some joe blow doing the same thing
 
Mongrel4u said:
Frank..this is Foot Ball in the United States of America. Do you have any idea how many kids there are out there that could be the next great player but just havent had a chance yet?

He was a good QB, yes...but hes not god and he is CERTAINLY replaceable

This point makes absolutely ZERO sense. Sure there are alot of football players... but elite level players who can start in the NFL, cannot be replaced by Jimmy and Johnny down the street just because they played at a good college.

If there are so many "replacement" types, how do you explain Joey Freaking Harrington getting another chance to start in the NFL. Once again, Joey Harrington.
 
maurice93 said:
If there are so many "replacement" types, how do you explain Joey Freaking Harrington getting another chance to start in the NFL. Once again, Joey Harrington.


Uggg, everytime I hear/see this guys name it makes me depressed.
This fool lost me 100's of dollars the last 3 years....100's I tell you
 
Mongrel4u said:
He was a good QB, yes...but hes not god and he is CERTAINLY replaceable


Sayin Vick is replaceable is like sayin Kobe is replaceable. Can you get rid of Vick, surre but...

- You will not sell out allot of games if any = money loss
- The most sold jersey in the league = money loss
- Vick can single handedly change a game which means get use to losing
- He gives defensive cord's fitz and is one of the best running backs in the league.
- Also has IMO the strongest arm in the NFL and can cut to the side and still throw a 40 yd pass WITH VELOCITY
- The allure to attract future key players in hopes of a ring (I doubt Joey H will lure any superstars to ATL)

So he is replaceable like anyone is even MJ but your franchise will be back to square one losing games and losing tons of money for years to come.
 
John_E_Depth said:
Uggg, everytime I hear/see this guys name it makes me depressed.
This fool lost me 100's of dollars the last 3 years....100's I tell you

You don't know about football my friend if you kept betting on the Lions. I am a fan of the Lions and I wouldn't have bet on them!!!

Harrington sucks more than Vick did, but for all the hype, Vick never got the Falcons where they needed to be come playoff time, and often never even got them there. He is more hype than substance, and in his conduct this last 6 months, in his lies, and tap dancing, he doesn't deserve another shot in the NFL. This commish wont give him the chance I suspect. There is a new Sheriff in town....and he isn't into idiots who lie to him. Look no further than Pacman being booted out.....for just being near a crime. Vick actually is going to be a convicted abuser of dogs, and in case you forgot, he was involved with illegal bettors on the fights as well. Illegal gambling? Pro sports? Oh ya, even if Vick so much as not looked at a dog he could be looking at a life substance.

The guy had it all...and he threw it away.....
 
maurice93 said:
This point makes absolutely ZERO sense. Sure there are alot of football players... but elite level players who can start in the NFL, cannot be replaced by Jimmy and Johnny down the street just because they played at a good college.


What the hell are you talking about? Where do you think a guy like Michael Vick came from??? Where do you think they ALL come from??? Lemme guess you think they come down from heaven at the age of 19 for the sole purpose of playing ball :rolleyes:

Theres always some new kid in the works, 300 million people down there; a good deal of these people (young people) beleive that sports is their only way out and will do anything to get there. Dont beleive me? go to any inner city in the Us and tell me what you see? If they are not slinging dope and busting caps they are playing ball and there are a lot of kids that could hold their own at a pro level but for whatever reason didn't thier chance yet. You're delusional if you think this guy is the be all and end all of football.
 
John_E_Depth said:
So he is replaceable like anyone is even MJ but your franchise will be back to square one losing games and losing tons of money for years to come.

you cant be on top for ever...sports franchises go through cycles, they all do..every last one of them.

I just find it really silly to hear people say that some kid that dribbles a ball, or throws or runs is irreplaceable...give me a break
 
Mongrel,

Sure there are plenty of kids that play football but he is a very unique talent. No QB has ever rushed for over 1000 yards and he does have a good arm. IF you look at the new QBs each year very few of them excel in the league even after a few years of experience.

This has nothing to do with whether I like the guy. I have no respect for him as a person for allowing dog fights to occur. I think as a football player he was a great physical talent on a mediocre to subpar team who would probably benefit from being a bit more of a student of the game (i.e. using his teammates instead of relying on risky scrambles to bail himself out). In other words a good player with very unique skills who could have been great.

If there are so many great QBs out there why do certain mid to low level QBs just bounce from team to team rather than dipping into this so called deep pool of talent that you suggest is out there?

I mean Charlie Batch, Joey Harrington, Kerry Collings, Tim Couch, Gus Ferrotte just to name a few guys who have been around for ages but are not exactly Fantasy Football material.
 
Actually...

Mongrel4u said:
What the hell are you talking about? Where do you think a guy like Michael Vick came from??? Lemme guesss you think he can down from heaven at the age of 19 for the sole purpose of playing football :rolleyes:

...you are closer to the truth than you know.

I am guessing you never played organized sports.

HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of kids play High school football. Maybe 1 in 100 is good enough to get a scholarship to a NCAA Div I school. I played on a good (not great) team...one guy got a scholarship. At some football factory (say in Texas), that number might would be 4 or 5. On the other hand...lots of schools have none.

THOUSANDS of kids play college football at the highest level in college...NCAA Div I...thousands. Only a few hundred get drafted into the NFL.

Of the hundreds that get, perhaps a third each year actually make it to the first day of the season. About 100.

Of that 100...2/3 will never amount to ANYTHING. They will be cut within 3 years.

Of the remaining 30...20 are guys you have never heard of if you aren't a huge NFL fan.

The other 10....of HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS...are the 10 or so guys from each NFL draft that make it to the long time vet or Pro Bowl level. of those 10...perhaps one or two are actually superstars.

Now...Michael Vick...in my opinion...was a mediocre NFL quarterback. That said, he is a INCREDIBLE talent / athlete. A once in a lifetime type guy. He single handily lifted a franchise...the Atlanta Falcons were NOWHERE before Michael Vick...now they sell out every game. His presence led to a new stadium being built. As others have said, he made them "respectable", playoff contenders, consistently .500, after years of them being a laughing stock franchise. He did this at times winning games by himself.

Was he as good as all they hype? That depends on your perspective.

Would the Patriots, Eagles, Bengals, Chargers, Saints, or Colts jettison their current starting quarterback for Vick? No.

But of the remaining teams, half would do it, and half would at least think about it.

I don't think you can win a Superbowl with Michael Vick as your quarterback...at least not the current Michael Vick.

But would he make the Oakland Raiders, Kansas City Chiefs, Tampa Bay Bucanners, Houston Texans, Washington Redskins, Cleveland Browns, or Minnesota Vikings, Chicago Bears, Miami Dolphins or Atlanta Falcons better? Absolutely.

Michael Vick instantly becomes the starting QB for 1/3 of the teams in the NFL. Not because he is a great QB...but because he is a great talent, and better than the current QB.

So yeah...depending how you define "irreplaceable", he qualifies...because the Falcons are fucked as a franchise for the foreseeable future. Half the people who went to those games went to see Michael Vick...
 
MLAM said:
...you are closer to the truth than you know.

I am guessing you never played organized sports.

HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of kids play High school football. Maybe 1 in 100 is good enough to get a scholarship to a NCAA Div I school. I played on a good (not great) team...one guy got a scholarship. At some football factory (say in Texas), that number might would be 4 or 5. On the other hand...lots of schools have none.

THOUSANDS of kids play college football at the highest level in college...NCAA Div I...thousands. Only a few hundred get drafted into the NFL.

Of the hundreds that get, perhaps a third each year actually make it to the first day of the season. About 100.

Of that 100...2/3 will never amount to ANYTHING. They will be cut within 3 years.

Of the remaining 30...20 are guys you have never heard of if you aren't a huge NFL fan.

The other 10....of HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS...are the 10 or so guys from each NFL draft that make it to the long time vet or Pro Bowl level. of those 10...perhaps one or two are actually superstars.

Now...Michael Vick...in my opinion...was a mediocre NFL quarterback. That said, he is a INCREDIBLE talent / athlete. A once in a lifetime type guy. He single handily lifted a franchise...the Atlanta Falcons were NOWHERE before Michael Vick...now they sell out every game. His presence led to a new stadium being built. As others have said, he made them "respectable", playoff contenders, consistently .500, after years of them being a laughing stock franchise. He did this at times winning games by himself.

Was he as good as all they hype? That depends on your perspective.

Would the Patriots, Eagles, Bengals, Chargers, Saints, or Colts jettison their current starting quarterback for Vick? No.

But of the remaining teams, half would do it, and half would at least think about it.

I don't think you can win a Superbowl with Michael Vick as your quarterback...at least not the current Michael Vick.

But would he make the Oakland Raiders, Kansas City Chiefs, Tampa Bay Bucanners, Houston Texans, Washington Redskins, Cleveland Browns, or Minnesota Vikings, Chicago Bears, Miami Dolphins or Atlanta Falcons better? Absolutely.

Michael Vick instantly becomes the starting QB for 1/3 of the teams in the NFL. Not because he is a great QB...but because he is a great talent, and better than the current QB.

So yeah...depending how you define "irreplaceable", he qualifies...because the Falcons are fucked as a franchise for the foreseeable future. Half the people who went to those games went to see Michael Vick...

I actually did play organized sports

My point is .....the game goes on. How long has the NFL, NHL, NBA, MBL been around? And how many great players were there..a lot there are greats player for every era...and franchises go into slumps and come out of slumps.

You can quote all the numbers you want but history dont lie... they are all replacable...theres always a new great players in the works...always have been always will be.

In the grand scheme of things MLAM... he IS replaceable

and people should stop saying things like "oh he is irreplaceable" regarding athletes...because:

a) Its not true

and

b) They are otherwise simply guys (generally speaking) and all you end op doing is adding fuel to the fire..these guys end up thinking they are untouchable and start to act as such (I'm not just talking with respects to MV); this isnt good when so many look up to them.
 
In that context....

Mongrel4u said:
I actually did play organized sports

My point is .....the game goes on. How long has the NFL, NHL, NBA, MBL been around? And how many great players were there..a lot there are greats player for every era...and franchises go into slumps and come out of slumps.

You can quote all the numbers you want but history dont lie... they are all replacable...theres always a new great players in the works...always have been always will be.

In the grand scheme of things MLAM... he IS replaceable

and people should stop saying things like "oh he is irreplaceable" regarding athletes...because:

a) Its not true

and

b) They are otherwise simply guys (generally speaking) and all you end op doing is adding fuel to the fire..these guys end up thinking they are untouchable and start to act as such (I'm not just talking with respects to MV); this isnt good when so many look up to them.

I agree.

I thought you were saying that he was just like "any other" QB, and there would be someone somewhere who could step right in.
 
I love football

Mongrel4u said:
I actually did play organized sports

My point is .....the game goes on. How long has the NFL, NHL, NBA, MBL been around? And how many great players were there..a lot there are greats player for every era...and franchises go into slumps and come out of slumps.

You can quote all the numbers you want but history dont lie... they are all replacable...theres always a new great players in the works...always have been always will be.

In the grand scheme of things MLAM... he IS replaceable

and people should stop saying things like "oh he is irreplaceable" regarding athletes...because:

a) Its not true

and

b) They are otherwise simply guys (generally speaking) and all you end op doing is adding fuel to the fire..these guys end up thinking they are untouchable and start to act as such (I'm not just talking with respects to MV); this isnt good when so many look up to them.
Could not agree with more. And as far as Vic goes at QB does the word choke come to mind. Does all the rushing yards add up to his arm at best is half ass. Give me a break Falcons built on Vic lmfao. Stadium was in works before they even drafted him. Has there not been speculation that they where going to shop Vic around due to him not coming through when it counts, calling his own plays etc. Bottom line football and Atlanta better off without his big dumb ass. Sure it will hurt this season but Atlanta got deep pockets and be reaching in MV’s pocket soon to take back a big chunk. He going to be a broke, big dumb bitch to boot soon. Maybe he can open hot dog cart back in those hills where he was fighting dogs. My opinion at NFL level his hype and ego where bigger then his game.
 
Puff puff pass

John_E_Depth said:
Sayin Vick is replaceable is like sayin Kobe is replaceable. Can you get rid of Vick, surre but...

- You will not sell out allot of games if any = money loss
- The most sold jersey in the league = money loss
- Vick can single handedly change a game which means get use to losing
- He gives defensive cord's fitz and is one of the best running backs in the league.
- Also has IMO the strongest arm in the NFL and can cut to the side and still throw a 40 yd pass WITH VELOCITY
- The allure to attract future key players in hopes of a ring (I doubt Joey H will lure any superstars to ATL)

So he is replaceable like anyone is even MJ but your franchise will be back to square one losing games and losing tons of money for years to come.

And what are you smoking share plz where your facts coming from
Most sold jersey in league?
I give you the gives def cord fits.
Strongest arm in league? throw with volocity ya but can not hit reciever so hit the bong again!
Allure to attract future talent your way off he does not use what around him very well as it is, and talent goes where the doe flows this the NFL where athletes have shortest career then any other sport.
losing $$$ well you got a point but it like I stated before deep pockets in Falcons camp.

We going have some fun on these boards this season I can tell already all you arm chair quarter backs. No disrespect I am one too, Sun and MONDAY nights you can catch me calling plays from bar stool at Tail Gate Charles. We must get those proline football pool picks up by Friday so I can have a look each week.
 
Bearlythere said:
You don't know about football my friend if you kept betting on the Lions. I am a fan of the Lions and I wouldn't have bet on them!!!

I didnt bet allot of times on them just certain games in which they should win/cover against not so great teams. You'd figure they would have to put together a decent home game sooner or later...I took the points @ home against bad teams and still lost but oh well, thats sports betting.
 
Hooked on phonics

Tiffany_69 said:
And what are you smoking share plz where your facts coming from Most sold jersey in league?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, I was guessing his jersey's at the top maybe after Bush's but here's some stats.

USA today Aug 26, 2005

http://www.usatoday.com/sports/football/nfl/2005-08-26-nfl-jerseys_x.htm


Top-selling jerseys
1. Randy Moss, WR, Raiders
2. Michael Vick, QB, Falcons
3. Tom Brady, QB, Patriots
4. Donovan McNabb, QB, Eagles
5. Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers
6. LaDainian Tomlinson, RB, Chargers
7. Byron Leftwich, QB, Jaguars
8. Carnell Williams, RB, Bucs
9. Jeremy Shockey, TE, Giants
10. Tiki Barber, RB, Giants

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

USA Today May 11, 2006

The NFL's top 10-selling jerseys for 2005:

1. Randy Moss Oakland
2. Ben Roethlisberger Pittsburgh
3. Peyton Manning Indianapolis
4. Michael Vick Atlanta
5. Troy Polamalu Pittsburgh
6. Donovan McNabb Philadelphia
7. Terrell Owens Philadelphia
8. Tom Brady New England
9. Hines Ward Pittsburgh
10. Brett Favre Green Bay

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.a1-throwback-jerseys.net/Article - NFL Jersey.htm

Let’s take a look at this year's list of top selling NFL jerseys

1 B. Roethlisberger QB Steelers
2 Michael Vick QB Falcons
3 Terrence Owens WR Eagles
4 Donovan McNabb QB Eagles
5 Warren Sapp DL Oakland
6 Priest Holmes RB Chiefs
7 Tom Brady QB Patriots
8 Brett Favre QB Packers
9 Clinton Portis RB Redskins
10 Peyton Manning QB Colts

The Top 10 Selling NFL jerseys list is prepared by Reebok, the NFL’s official licensee for football jerseys and other NFL team wear.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
As for your.... "Allure to attract future talent your way off he does not use what around him very well as it is, and talent goes where the doe flows this the NFL where athletes have shortest career then any other sport"

I'd say you were the one smoking the hydro cause I can't even decipher what you're saying...
 
So much wrong with this thread it makes me wonder if people watch football or even know the sport. Don't have time to quote everyone but....

Yes Vick has had one of the highest selling Jersey's. No need to publish any stats, it's been known for years. He's been called the most exciting player and graced many magazines and video games. He's brings in the cash.

Now, comparing Vick to Kobe is insane. Kobe is easily top 3 in the NBA, while Vick isn't even in the top 3 for his position. (but I assume you meant off the field?)

Vick is an average QB at best with natural talent. At anytime he can make a great play or break a tackle for a gain or even touchdown. The problem is his lack of consistency in the pocket. I was thinking that this would be his break out season but I guess not.

The thing that I ask; if he had Manning numbers, would Atlanta be so quick to drop him? If he was on the vurge of winning the Superbowl, would the Falcons be standing behind their man? I think they would. Winning is a cure for forgivness.
 
Mongrel4u said:
What the hell are you talking about? Where do you think a guy like Michael Vick came from??? Where do you think they ALL come from??? Lemme guess you think they come down from heaven at the age of 19 for the sole purpose of playing ball :rolleyes:

Theres always some new kid in the works, 300 million people down there; a good deal of these people (young people) beleive that sports is their only way out and will do anything to get there. Dont beleive me? go to any inner city in the Us and tell me what you see? If they are not slinging dope and busting caps they are playing ball and there are a lot of kids that could hold their own at a pro level but for whatever reason didn't thier chance yet. You're delusional if you think this guy is the be all and end all of football.

I think we are talking about entirely different concepts here, so we both think we are delusional.

Your talking about whether elite players will still cme along. Yes. (although Vick may be more elite talent then elite achiever)

Can the Falcons easily replace Vick now. No.
 
Back Burner said:
So much wrong with this thread it makes me wonder if people watch football or even know the sport. Don't have time to quote everyone but....

Yes Vick has had one of the highest selling Jersey's. No need to publish any stats, it's been known for years. He's been called the most exciting player and graced many magazines and video games. He's brings in the cash.

Now, comparing Vick to Kobe is insane. Kobe is easily top 3 in the NBA, while Vick isn't even in the top 3 for his position. (but I assume you meant off the field?)

Vick is an average QB at best with natural talent. At anytime he can make a great play or break a tackle for a gain or even touchdown. The problem is his lack of consistency in the pocket. I was thinking that this would be his break out season but I guess not.

The thing that I ask; if he had Manning numbers, would Atlanta be so quick to drop him? If he was on the vurge of winning the Superbowl, would the Falcons be standing behind their man? I think they would. Winning is a cure for forgivness.



Sorry BB, I only posted the jersey stats when someone didn't believe me when I said his jersey is a top seller. I thought everyone who watches the NFL knew that but apparently not. I agree that he isn't one of the best QB's in the league maybe not even top 10. My comparing him to Kobe was regarding them being the most exciting players of their sport.... IMO
IMO the last few seasons Kobe was the best player in the league, maybe even this season as well (King James is alllmost there and might be this season)
You cant say one player is the best in football since theres off & def and the positions are more singled out. I would never say he is the best in the NFL but I would say he's the most exciting to watch like Kobe.
I thought last season was going to be Vicks break out season but I was wrong. I do wonder if he would've been a better QB if he was under a different system and coach?
As for if Vick had PM numbers would they cut him I'd say yes. This shit he's in brings sooo much bad press to the Falcons that even with great numbers they'd have to cut him. Its amazing how much people hate him now and allot of the Falcon fans tossed his jersey. I think he was the most exciting player in the NFL but what he did was cruel and stupid and its a shame cause his talent was such a rarity.

He is the most hated athlete at the moment