No it is not.
You want to create a chicken-egg argument and go in circles.
That is your mental gymnastics at play trying to move goalposts because otherwise you'd have to no excuse than to admit the truth.
The government facilitates the environment in which the private sector exists.
It is the public sector that provides all essential services and infrastructure, and laws that allow the private sector to succeed.
But keep up with your mental gymnastics.
This isn't my first rodeo taking apart your twisted narratives.
this is so wrong
The government facilitates the environment in which the private sector exists.
the reality in a capitalist democracy is
The government attempts to regulate the environment in which the private sector exists. and they are not always effective and definitely never efficient in their regulation efforts
govt is entirely dependant on the private sector
A parasite dies if it kills the host
It is the public sector that provides all essential services and infrastructure, and laws that allow the private sector to succeed.
there would not be a need for food banks if this were true
there would not be an affordability crisis if this were true
there would not be boil water advisories if this were true
there would not be skilled labor shortages if this were true
there would not be access to capital issue for start up business ventures if this were true
there would not be traffic jams & sardine subways if this were true
there would not be health care wait times > 1 month if this were true
there would not be an increase in Canadians seeking private health care in the US if this were true
there would not be inter provincial trade barriers if this were true
there would not be any govt subsidies if this were true
there would be armed forces ready to defend our country if this were true
there would be 4 brand new privately own pipelines if this were true
there would be secure boarders if this were true
there would not be a need for a GST tax holiday if this were true
there would not be a carbon tax if this were true
there would not be frozen bank accounts for protestors if this were true
there would not be enormous public debt if this were true
there would not be enormous and restrictive public debt interest payments if this were true
your entire argument is based upon the utopian socialist ideal
And this is a failed ideal
good lord man , we tried the socialist experiment in Canada and now everything is a mess
Do you think yo will get it right next time ? NO !
The very best thing our govt can do is shrink and let the private sector create wealth for the country
