Martin's Gun Control Proposal

slowpoke

New member
Oct 22, 2004
2,899
0
0
Toronto
"..a new 250 officer unit from the RCMP dedicated solely to fighting gun-related crimes, as well as other organized crime and drug trafficking;

75 new officers at Canada Border Services to combat illegal importation of handguns from the U.S.;

tougher sentences for gun-related crimes, by changing the Criminal Code to double the mandatory minimum sentences for such crimes;

encouraging community-based gun prevention, with help from a $50-million Gun Violence and Gang Prevention Fund to focus on youth at risk;

waving the re-registration fees for owners of long guns in order to encourage compliance with the Canada Firearms Program; and

a gun amnesty and buy-back program that draws from an Australian model, including a gun stoppers initiative aimed at ensuring the turn-in of illegal weapons...."
http://sympaticomsn.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20051207/elxn_martin_handguns_051208

The one good thing about election campaigns is that all the parties are forced to propose solutions to popular issues like gun violence. This proposal looks pretty ambitious. Should be interesting to see how Harper responds.
 
75 guys for a border that's 2000+ miles long..UHUHUHUHUH..wow, that should make all the difference.

I propose to keep guns legal and force you to have a license if you want one. Take classes on how to handle them should be part of the requirement.
 
langeweile said:
75 guys for a border that's 2000+ miles long..UHUHUHUHUH..wow, that should make all the difference.

I propose to keep guns legal and force you to have a license if you want one. Take classes on how to handle them should be part of the requirement.

That's 75 NEW [ie: additional] guys, not 75 in total. Believe it or not, we have had Border Services personnel for many years. I think our border is more like 3000 miles long but there aren't 3000 border crossing points. If there was one every 30 miles that would mean 100 access points. There are many places in Canada where there isn't a crossing every 30 miles so my guess is he's added an extra guy to many or most border crossings. Probably wrong but at least I've ballparked it in a rational fashion....
 
relax dude.
I knew they were additional.
My point is, that no matter how many agents you put on, the border is way too long to protect.
Ever been to Montana? A good friend of mine works at a remote border station on the US side. if you really wanted to, you can bring just about anything across the border.
The additional agents make for good campaigning, but to little in reality.

Maybe MCL can chime in on this. I believe he works for immigration.
 
I'm all for minimum sentences and community based initiatives to help the stem the violence but the ban on handguns has me confused.

You can't own a handgun in Canada without applying for a permit in the first place. If you do, you already have the gun illegally. Even those that use handguns for target practice need a permit for them. Criminals don't apply for permits to have handguns. So how does banning them keep them out of the hands of criminals when the majority of guns are smuggled across the boarder?
 
Cardinal Fang said:
I'm all for minimum sentences and community based initiatives to help the stem the violence but the ban on handguns has me confused.

You can't own a handgun in Canada without applying for a permit in the first place. If you do, you already have the gun illegally. Even those that use handguns for target practice need a permit for them. Criminals don't apply for permits to have handguns. So how does banning them keep them out of the hands of criminals when the majority of guns are smuggled across the boarder?

My read on this is that just slightly over half the incidents of gun violence in Toronto involved illegal handguns of US origin. That still leaves quite a few shootings involving handguns stolen from local collectors, target shooters, gun stores etc. Martin's ban will probably just make it much harder to have a legal handgun and apparently some of the legally registered handguns will no longer qualify. IMHO, this part of the legislation is more about catering to those law and order types who've been screaming for "government measures". I can't see this making a huge difference in the short term but it might slowly reduce the number of guns out there.
 
langeweile said:
relax dude.
I knew they were additional.
My point is, that no matter how many agents you put on, the border is way too long to protect.
Ever been to Montana? A good friend of mine works at a remote border station on the US side. if you really wanted to, you can bring just about anything across the border.
The additional agents make for good campaigning, but to little in reality.

Maybe MCL can chime in on this. I believe he works for immigration.

I have been to Montana and I imagine there are plenty of places where you could probably just stroll across the border. But there are sensors and surveillance so there is still a chance of getting caught. I agree that 75 guys doesn't seem like much but an extra guy at each crossing will mean quite a few extra inspections so the odds of getting caught smuggling just got a bit higher. If these 75 are focussing strictly on firearms, they'll catch a few and the publicity might deter a few more.
 
slowpoke said:
I have been to Montana and I imagine there are plenty of places where you could probably just stroll across the border. But there are sensors and surveillance so there is still a chance of getting caught. I agree that 75 guys doesn't seem like much but an extra guy at each crossing will mean quite a few extra inspections so the odds of getting caught smuggling just got a bit higher. If these 75 are focussing strictly on firearms, they'll catch a few and the publicity might deter a few more.

I would like to see the comparissons in numbers of that effort vs the effort to stop the flow of illegal drugs?
We all know our success rate there.
 
I have long hated the Liberals and resented also the Progressive Conservatives for the four rounds of gun control over the last twenty-eight years.

As a owner of both long guns and handguns, I resent having to take the blame for crime and criminal activity by the smegma of society. Taking guns away from law-abiding citizens is the prime mantra of the Liberals and other socialists who believe that the criminals are really nice people and we should help them.

Unfortunately, I am so pissed off that I cannot continue my rant.

Vote anyone except Liberals and NDP.
 
I thought only the criminals had guns in Canada.....

OTB
 
slowpoke said:
"...75 new officers at Canada Border Services to combat illegal importation of handguns from the U.S...

didn't the liberals say it was the U.S. that should eliminate the problem of guns coming into canada? aren't they backpeddling again?

75 officers is probably only enough to cover 2 entry points 24/7 with shift rotations! hardly enough to do anything!
 
langeweile said:
Ever been to Montana? A good friend of mine works at a remote border station on the US side. if you really wanted to, you can bring just about anything across the border.
The additional agents make for good campaigning, but to little in reality.
I have. and there is atleast one private road that I know of that crosses into Canada that is not patrolled at all! ... on a farm and is in very treacherous terrain...
 
langeweile said:
relax dude.
I knew they were additional.
My point is, that no matter how many agents you put on, the border is way too long to protect.
Ever been to Montana? A good friend of mine works at a remote border station on the US side. if you really wanted to, you can bring just about anything across the border.
The additional agents make for good campaigning, but to little in reality.

Maybe MCL can chime in on this. I believe he works for immigration.


I have been thru that border check. I think there might be a lone gas station on the US side, if I recall. I would say you are probably right. Although these days, I think profiling is probably in effect. Like if your wife was wearing a veil, they'd probably notice...
 
21pro said:
didn't the liberals say it was the U.S. that should eliminate the problem of guns coming into canada? aren't they backpeddling again?

You're probably alluding to this:

"...Government sources told the Star yesterday that Canada will be looking into "every legal option" to stem a tide of crimes involving weapons that make their way into this country illegally from the United States, whether they're sold through the Internet or smuggled across the border.

That includes possible suits against U.S. manufacturers, launched either in the United States or in this country if the firm has assets here as well, the sources said. Though no precise estimates are available, Toronto police have said repeatedly that almost half the gun crimes committed in Canada involved illegal, U.S. weapons...."

http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/Co...cle_PrintFriendly&c=Article&cid=1129931411914

I want our government to pursue every available means to stem gun violence. If there is even a remote possibility that we can use the threat of a lawsuit to reduce the availability of illegal US guns, I fully expect them to at least give that option a hard look. This, by the way, does not constitute our government saying that the US "should eliminate the problem of guns coming into canada". It simply means that we will sue the US gun manufacturers if we can show that they've been negligent or even partially responsible for the illegal importation of handguns into our country. We should prosecute anyone who is contributing to this problem, including gun manufacturers & distributors etc.

You make it sound like we expect the US to solve our illegal handgun problem. Nothing could be further from the truth. The US can't even solve their own problems with gun violence so where is the logic of your contention? We have simply demonstrated our resolve to explore a variety of paths as we wrestle with this problem.
 
If this criminal gang manages to form a majority, and Al-Qaida trashes the House of Commons while it's in session, I will shout "Allahu Akbar" from my rooftop and convert to Islam on the spot:mad:
 
Truncador said:
If this criminal gang manages to form a majority, and Al-Qaida trashes the House of Commons while it's in session, I will shout "Allahu Akbar" from my rooftop and convert to Islam on the spot:mad:

The irony of that statement, coming from the extreme right side of your mouth is that it probably just got you honorable mention in the carni*vore data base. Of course, they will know your only joking... won't they...
 
Truncador said:
If this criminal gang manages to form a majority, and Al-Qaida trashes the House of Commons while it's in session, I will shout "Allahu Akbar" from my rooftop and convert to Islam on the spot:mad:

Know thy enemy, say the wise men.

Allah U Akbar is what you shout just before you blow yourself up.
 
Mcluhan said:
The irony of that statement, coming from the extreme right side of your mouth is that it probably just got you honorable mention in the carni*vore data base. Of course, they will know your only joking... won't they...

Meh. If I get arrested and interrogated by some FBI agent, I'll just ask him what he's doing lurking on TERB, and if his wife knows.

Back on topic, happily this little Liberal stunt seems to have fallen flat on its face. Amongst the public at large gun control is selling about as well as used Michael Jackson LPs these days- even on the Left. The normally psychotically anti-gun left-wing news outlets- badly embarassed by their erstwhile fervent support for the gun registry- greeted the proposal with indifference and even open skepticism. The NDP, which is further to the Left than the Libs, publicly called out the proposal for what it is, namely a smokescreen to disguise the Liberals' deviation from the true socialist path. By bundling the handgun ban up with mandatory minimum sentences, the Libs even managed to alientate the professional criminal-coddlers and community activists who ordinarily support anti-gun measures unconditionally, and upon whose support they were counting heavily. Meanwhile, on the Right the Conservatives suavely declined to walk into the trap the Liberals laid out for them, while the nation's gun-rights groups are educating the firearms community that the handgun ban is the first step towards a total ban on guns, which can only be avoided if the nation's many, many rifle and shotgun owners throw the Liberals out of office.


:D