Machado Extension

black booty lover

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2007
9,769
1,751
113
How anyone can think this is good for baseball is beyond me. You have a game that is struggling to attract younger viewers, and paying guys like Machado just ends up trickling down to the price to go see a game. They raise ticket prices, food...etc. Second, the Mets have two players that both make more then the entire Oakland A's payroll. How are teams like Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, and Baltimore ever going to have hope? This is killing the small market teams that don't have deep pockets like San Diego. If Machado plays 162 games, he will earn $28,000 per game. So at the back end of that deal when he's sitting on the bench or not even playing taking up a roster spot, he'll still earn that much for sitting on the bench. I'm not even going discuss how ludicrous it is when they get injured. It's totally unfair to the other guys on the team or young pitchers that do well early in their contract and don't get paid, and then blow their arm out before they hit FA. I can't see how this is sustainable.
 
As long as the players union refuses to accept a salary cap these types of contracts will continue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roadhog
How anyone can think this is good for baseball is beyond me. You have a game that is struggling to attract younger viewers, and paying guys like Machado just ends up trickling down to the price to go see a game. They raise ticket prices, food...etc. Second, the Mets have two players that both make more then the entire Oakland A's payroll. How are teams like Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, and Baltimore ever going to have hope? This is killing the small market teams that don't have deep pockets like San Diego. If Machado plays 162 games, he will earn $28,000 per game. So at the back end of that deal when he's sitting on the bench or not even playing taking up a roster spot, he'll still earn that much for sitting on the bench. I'm not even going discuss how ludicrous it is when they get injured. It's totally unfair to the other guys on the team or young pitchers that do well early in their contract and don't get paid, and then blow their arm out before they hit FA. I can't see how this is sustainable.
The Padres also have Fernando Tatis, Xander Bogaerts, Joe Musgrove, Yu Darvish on monstrous contracts. And Juan Soto is due one after 2024. I guess its all worth it to them since they dethroned the Dodgers last season
 
MLB doesn't allow teams to trade draft picks. So all the bottom teams will always get a chance to draft decent players, and teams won't get screwed over by a GM trading away the future. Even if you trade all your good prospects for a couple stars, you'll still have all your picks in each upcoming draft. When you hit on a player or two and find success, they often get traded for more prospects or several lesser players. Look at the Rays the last decade or so to prove that massive payroll means nothing in MLB.

They also have picks called competitive balance picks, which are additional picks awarded to the bottom teams each year (these can be traded). Every pro sport has top teams and bottom feeding teams. Smart management can always find and develop talent in any sport, but the correct mix of players and personnel is key. Superstar players alone won't do it. I think baseball does it better than NHL. The salary cap makes it boring for fans (especially fans of rich teams)
 
Last edited:
How anyone can think this is good for baseball is beyond me. You have a game that is struggling to attract younger viewers, and paying guys like Machado just ends up trickling down to the price to go see a game. They raise ticket prices, food...etc. Second, the Mets have two players that both make more then the entire Oakland A's payroll. How are teams like Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, and Baltimore ever going to have hope? This is killing the small market teams that don't have deep pockets like San Diego. If Machado plays 162 games, he will earn $28,000 per game. So at the back end of that deal when he's sitting on the bench or not even playing taking up a roster spot, he'll still earn that much for sitting on the bench. I'm not even going discuss how ludicrous it is when they get injured. It's totally unfair to the other guys on the team or young pitchers that do well early in their contract and don't get paid, and then blow their arm out before they hit FA. I can't see how this is sustainable.

Wait until this prick ops out of his current contract and renegotiates something more in favour of the last couple of years. Third basemen like Matt Chapman are going to love him.

Philip
 
Wait until this prick ops out of his current contract and renegotiates something more in favour of the last couple of years. Third basemen like Matt Chapman are going to love him.

Philip
This new deal contains no opt out option but does include a no trade clause.
 
This new deal contains no opt out option but does include a no trade clause.

oh lol I just saw his name and started posting. I didn't realize he actually signed an extension.

good luck Blue Jays w Chapman. Chapman the billion dollar man :)

Philip
 
As long as the players union refuses to accept a salary cap these types of contracts will continue.


There's already rumblings that the owners are divided in half. All the smaller market teams (except San Diego) are pissed off.
 
Look at the Rays the last decade or so to prove that massive payroll means nothing in MLB.

This just isn't true at all. Yes the Rays have done an amazing job wile keeping a low payroll, but they were never able to get over the hump.

Now look at most of the other teams with low payrolls, and look at the teams with high payrolls. The teams in the past with high payrolls are always the teams make it in way more. Just ask the Pirates, the Reds or Orioles to name a few. How much success have they had with their tiny payrolls?