Luke Schenn

new2game said:
http://www.canada.com/windsorstar/news/story.html?id=72b0f2cd-04b1-485c-b35a-3c24ab68489a

"First-round draft pick Luke Schenn faced a number of players that competed in the Stanley Cup final last spring, and he looked shakier than he did against Buffalo's patchwork lineup. The Pittsburgh forwards - notably, Talbot - pressured him in the corners and Schenn coughed up the puck several times. Schenn, of course, is still just 18".




....seems to back up my view of his play...

Yea 21pro....I know you used to "play the game"...and seem to be connected with some NHL guys....but us so called "dumb fans" sometimes watch too much sports..and actually catch on to the nuances of the game...lol


N2G

you are assuming that what 21pro says about himself (that he played and knows some nhl plays and now coaches at some level he feels is impressive) is for real. Take all this with a grain or truck load of salt. anyone can get a subscription to the Hockey News. I love what the Leafs have in Schenn but he is not ready nor should they rush him. he is the one good thing they have done recently and putting him in this losing environment will not be good for him or the Leafs. he is playing well but he should not be in the NHL yet
 
21pro said:
my role as a jr A head coach perhaps leads me to have an understanding of hockey that is a little better than average.

I'm telling you- he's ready.

Please, whatever "jr A" team you're "coaching" is probably in the cellar, because the kid isn't ready yet.
 
Send him back to the WHL. This is a tank year. It's about picking high in a deep draft, and moving players at the trade deadline for prospects and picks to ensure that happens. Nothing to be gained by keeping Schenn around.
 
Cut 21 Pro some slack here, he actually does have an impressive background in hockey, both junior and minor pro. Having said that I look back at all the defensemen the leafs over the years damaged by playing them too soon. Exhibition season is not the time to forecast greatness.
 
lawyerman said:
Cliff Fletcher said it would be a miracle if Schenn makes the team.

Let the kid try and dominate the other kids in junior (he was very good but not dominant). This would (hopefully) help his offensive game to be a better all-around defenceman.

I don't understand what the rush is to bring him up ot the big club.

When the year is over in junior hockey, he will be able to play with the Marlies and upgrade his game even further.

Leafs management is doing the right thing with this kid.
Yup. Close thread...
 
one small problem with the 'dominate in the O' philosophy.

you aren't supposed to do that with Defensive Defencemen. It doesn't work.

Marc Moro on Leafs TV should know that. I agree, put him back to the O, only because you are the leafs, and in the hockey mecca... but not to dominate the O. If this were LA, St. Louis, Nashville, or even Chicago- he should stay. he's ready to develop at the nhl level.
 
no problem. happens all the time. i eat my words alot, too. so is life.

I can totally see how Schenn is going to be a much better player than any of Colaiacovo, Strahlman, White, Frogen, and whoever will make the lineup under the top 2. It will happen, and it COULD happen sooner than realized. he is the future Captain of your TMLs.

though, after tonight's game (which I did not see) ... heard the after game thingy on 640am, it sounds like he's slotted to play another 2 more seasons in the O!

better be careful... did you know that most players that go back to the juniors digress? truth is, very few improve with another season of junior (goalies excluded).
 
Last edited:
no kidding...I do it too...

21pro said:
no problem. happens all the time. i eat my words alot, too. so is life


...after that less than stellar performance last game...Schenn played quite well against the Blues. His passes looked sharp. He seemed to get better body position when battling for the puck along the boards. And you gotta gvie Wilson some credit for not taking this preseason too serious, and allowing Schenn to be the 4th shooter in the shootout...regardless of how he looked in practice..

I think Wilson has it right..the real test will be when the end of the presaosn is near, and teams are icing their close to opening night rosters...but for tonight...Schenn looked like he belonged...

N2G
 
21pro said:
did you know that most players that go back to the juniors digress? truth is, very few improve with another season of junior (goalies excluded).

I respect your posts 21pro and have enjoyed them and would like to hear what you would recommend for this young defenceman.

Here is my take on the situation:

There are many young players that aren't ready at 18 years old and the minors is not the place for them. If they are dominant in juniors then I could see that going back to the junior club would be a bad idea and his game would most likely suffer. Schenn was not dominant in juniors (and few are) and although he was very good, he can improve. The kid has a good head on his shoulders and will see this as a chance to enhance his skills further.
 
21pro said:
one small problem with the 'dominate in the O' philosophy.

you aren't supposed to do that with Defensive Defencemen. It doesn't work.

Marc Moro on Leafs TV should know that. I agree, put him back to the O, only because you are the leafs, and in the hockey mecca... but not to dominate the O. If this were LA, St. Louis, Nashville, or even Chicago- he should stay. he's ready to develop at the nhl level.

What I am saying is that he does have the tools to become a very good two-way defenceman and if he does stay with the junior club, this will help him develop at a slower pace. At the moment, he is too inconsistent (as expected from an 18 year old) to be looked at as a solid NHL defeneman.
That's what he is expected to be. Give him the ice time that he deserves and he should prosper.
 
I agree completely

lawyerman said:
What I am saying is that he does have the tools to become a very good two-way defenceman and if he does stay with the junior club, this will help him develop at a slower pace. At the moment, he is too inconsistent (as expected from an 18 year old) to be looked at as a solid NHL defeneman.
That's what he is expected to be. Give him the ice time that he deserves and he should prosper.


Wow you are "highly intelligent" You most certainly are going to hell ;)
 
He's done well so far....why not give him a couple regular season games, but tell him upfront he will be going down.

Gives him a taste and some experience without exposing him to a year of losses.

Only thing that matters is getting him better.....the cupoboard looks pretty bare otherwise
 
MojoRisin' said:
Wow you are "highly intelligent"

I certainly don't think I'm not intelligent.

Am I supposed to think that I am stupid? :confused:

This is hell and I'm doing the best I can.
 
the leafs have up to 9 NHL games to keep schenn, and that is exactly what they should do. give him a regular shift for those games as well, do not put the kid's gloves on with him. when those 9 games are up, send him back to junior, let him play regularly, give him his last chance to play in the WJC's. if his junior team does not make the playoffs, call him back up for the remaining few games on the leafs sked. he will improve and mature immensely going through this process. he will also being playing in "winning" environments, not the long, losing season the leafs will endure this upcoming year. the media vultures surrounding the leafs will pick him apart daily as well, is he ready for that? his game will be dissected every nite.

he is nowhere near being "NHL ready" as were guys like dion phaneuf and shea weber, so the leafs definitely need to give him the time to mature. he also, as has been pointed out, did not exactly set the world on fire last year in junior. phaneuf and weber were men amongst boys by the time their respective junior career's were coming to an end. these two guys are also exceptions, rather than the norm. the leafs should know quite a bit about rushing and ruining promising careers...gary nylund, jim benning? both very promising prospects, reduced through injuries and playing for losing teams, when they should have been apprenticing in the AHL, to just avergae players. there are others!

Plyrs99
 
blueline said:
Perhaps he is. Or maybe he just has a subscription to The Hockey News like all of us coaches .......lol

I watch the games and I have my own analysis. I'm not saying I'm right about everything but Schenn needs more time. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it. :)
 
lawyerman said:
I certainly don't think I'm not intelligent.

Am I supposed to think that I am stupid? :confused:

This is hell and I'm doing the best I can.

that was just in reference to the other thread out there.."the god one" lol
 
MojoRisin' said:
that was just in reference to the other thread out there.."the god one" lol

Hey bro,

I understand that I put it out there but I do believe in my self and my capabilities.

Anyways, back to Schenn. This kid has impressed me and I believe will be a Maple Leaf for a very long time. He shoould be an anchor on this defence in the years to come.
 
lawyerman said:
Hey bro,

I understand that I put it out there but I do believe in my self and my capabilities.

Anyways, back to Schenn. This kid has impressed me and I believe will be a Maple Leaf for a very long time. He shoould be an anchor on this defence in the years to come.


hey man it wasnt at all meant as a shot. Nothing wrong with feeling good about your intelligence. It was just an attempt at humour there. Nothing meant by it. I agree completely with your assessment of Schenn and what to do with him so i was agreeing with your comments/intelligence.

anyway I have a good buddy in Kelowna that hates the Leafs but has raved about Schenn for the past couple of years. He selfishly wants Schenn back as Kelowna has a good shot at the Memorial Cup with him. He also said he might have to become a Leaf fan now he likes this Schenn kid so much. I dont know what all that means but he's a good one for sure but just not with the Leafs this year.