Looking for tax advice ..............

shakenbake said:
The CRA has absolute poer over what they want to know regarding business transactions. This is NOT covered under client-lawyer priviledged information. That is the law, as explained by a member of the Justice Department. So, Diogaridan is misleading the public about protection. Yes, there is some priviledged information. However, any and all business transactions are subject to CRA examination, legally, according to the ITA.
What happens in practice is that the tax lawyer states your tax problem
to CRA in general terms without revealing your identity. They
may then negotiate favorable terms on your behalf. So there is some
value to consulting a lawyer when the tax issue is serious. You still
have to submit accurate infos to CRA of course. In the case of blueline
I don't think the case is serious enough for him to consult a lawyer.
 
From the information you have provided, it does not appear that your proceeds on your eBay sales are taxable.

In distinguishing between business income and capital receipts, the following factors are taken into consideration:

1) intention;
2) the relation of the transaction or transactions to the taxpayer's regular business;
3) the nature of the transaction and the type of asset being disposed of;
4) the number and frequency of the transactions.

Under this criterea, the gains you have made on your eBay sales are capital gains and not business income.

Furthermore, for tax purposes the adjusted cost base and proceeds of disposition of an item of personal-use property is deemed to always be at least $1000. Therefore, if you never sold anything for more than $1000, none of your capital gains are taxable.
 
JohnFK said:
Jeepers Jeeperz, who is that babe in your sig pic?
Carri Lee, obscure British babe :p Yummy, eh?

As for the topic at hand, why not call CRA anonymously and ask their opinion? I'm sure you'd get much of the same information as was supplied here but it may give you some peace of mind.
 
capital assets

yippie said:
From the information you have provided, it does not appear that your proceeds on your eBay sales are taxable.

In distinguishing between business income and capital receipts, the following factors are taken into consideration:

1) intention;
2) the relation of the transaction or transactions to the taxpayer's regular business;
3) the nature of the transaction and the type of asset being disposed of;
4) the number and frequency of the transactions.

Under this criterea, the gains you have made on your eBay sales are capital gains and not business income.

Furthermore, for tax purposes the adjusted cost base and proceeds of disposition of an item of personal-use property is deemed to always be at least $1000. Therefore, if you never sold anything for more than $1000, none of your capital gains are taxable.

Firstly let me preface this by saying I'm not that well versed in capital assets but I have a hard time believing a $0.35 hockey card would be considered a capital asset. I'm not sure what class it would fall into but for computer equipment, as an example, an item over $200 would be considered a capital asset.

It seems to me that IF these collectible activities are a business (however you, or CRA interprets it) the cards/coins/comics, whatever, are inventory. I can't see them being considered capital assets. Does Walmart declare capital gains on every item they sell in their stores?

I may be way off on that line of thinking and don't really have the inclination to research capital gains, however based on what Blueline stated about the number and frequency of the transactions I think it would be a toss-up as to how the CRA would treat it. If they take the time to send out an auditor you I'd bet they would assess it. From a corporate point of view they have to recoup those salary dollars some how ;) Could Blueline overturn it on appeal? Could be strike two or he could have it reversed. After that there's still another pitch ... Tax Court and then it's pay a lawyer, take your chances. A costly endevour if, as you say, it wasn't a profitable 'hobby'/business anyway.

That leads me to my final point which is: If you had no reasonable expectation of profit (ie. your costs of goods sold and expenses were as high as you say they were) you weren't in business anyway. What you would have had is a 'hobby'. That just means you won't get to claim a business loss against any other income. This prevents, for example, a shutterbug who sells the odd photo to friends for let's say $100 in a year from writing off thousands of dollars worth of camera equipment in the pursuit of his 'hobby'. That being said, you could again 'argue' you had an expectation of profit, and try to claim a business loss. Then again, based on the facts I have a hard time believing you spent more on these collectibles than you made.

It appears to me your conscience is telling you that you should probably be reporting the income and you're seeking to be talked out of it. Your call. When it comes to the CRA, ask yourself the Dirty Harry question ... do you feel lucky?

Best of luck with your decision.
 
jeeperz said:
Carri Lee, obscure British babe :p Yummy, eh?

As for the topic at hand, why not call CRA anonymously and ask their opinion? I'm sure you'd get much of the same information as was supplied here but it may give you some peace of mind.

Voluntary disclosures can be anonymous or 'no-name', as per Section 220 (3.1) of the Income Tax Act, and Information Circular 00-1R2 (paragraph 28).
 
Fred Zed said:
What happens in practice is that the tax lawyer states your tax problem
to CRA in general terms without revealing your identity. They
may then negotiate favorable terms on your behalf. So there is some
value to consulting a lawyer when the tax issue is serious. You still
have to submit accurate infos to CRA of course. In the case of blueline
I don't think the case is serious enough for him to consult a lawyer.

Fred, you are probably correct, blueline needs only to ask hypothetical questions to a certified accountant. However, once the CRA starts to look at blueline's 'case' there is no negotiation possible. In the eyes of the CRA, he may be just a a 'small fish', compared to big organisations who try to defraud the government of milions of dollars. However, if the CRA determines that they want to audit blueline, and find out about any dialogue between him and an accountant, the information is not priviledged and protected.

Here is what the Justice Department says (from a public Tax Practitioner's Meeting/Presentation) about Client-Lawyer Priviledged information.

You need not disclose material that is subject to solicitor-client privilege. For solicitor-client privilege to apply, the material must be;

a communication between a solicitor and client

which entails the seeking or giving of legal advice, and

which is intended to be confidential by the parties.
Solosky v. The Queen, [1980] 1 SCR 821



For voluntary disclosure;

Voluntary Disclosure: 220(3.1)

Tax prosecution and penalties may be avoided in certain circumstances where a voluntary disclosure is made.

To be “voluntary” it must not be made with knowledge of existing or pending CRA enforcement action, such as requesting returns or if the CRA is in the process of starting an audit.

The voluntary disclosure must be complete.

“No-name” disclosures are possible as per Paragraph 28 of Information Circular 00-1R2. So, blueline may try to ask a hypothetical questionm anonymously to the CRA.














 
Has anyone here ever been audited and if so, what generally happens?

Does it take place at your residence or place of business, or do you meet at their office? During the process, does the taxpayer have the opportunity to explain his/her situation to the CRA rep and is there any discussion as far as coming to an agreement what is taxable and what is not? Or will the taxperson just come armed and fire away with all the numbers and he/she has the final say?

I keep referring to a former taxman who posts on ebay discussion boards and he seems to know the process very well. He has often stated that an auditor will use common sense and if he/she sees a ton of garage sale-like items among my sales invoices, and if it can be shown that I pretty much have been selling personal possessions, it won't take long to determine that I did nothing illegal. They will be looking at bank statements and credit card statements, paypal, etc looking for expenses paid out to purchase stock. Again, in my case, there will be nothing since most of the items were acquired well before 2000, many were given to me (as in inherited following my brother's passing), etc. The guy who sells programs at the hockey games won't give me a receipt for my $5 book, nor can my neighbour provide documentation for that box of hockey cards I puchased from him a few years back, so I have nothing of that sorts either. The program vendor won't take VISA or a personal cheque, neither will yard sale people, so it was a cash purchase. I didn't need to take out a line of credit to purchase a few items, usually the 15-20 bucks in my pocket would cover whatever I wanted to purchase. So there will not be a skid of dvd players or a trailer full of plasma tv's in my driveway that cannot be explained to CRA. If the taxperson were to come here, they can see all my stock up on several shelves in my basement, or in dozens of 3-ring binders and still in some cases, packed away in cartons because there is no room for them anywhere else.

For what it's worth .......As further proof that I was in possession of a large collection of memorabilia, I have a letter that I wrote way back after the time of my brother's passing in 1999. Before he died, my brother gave me his entire collection just prior to his moving out of province. I had it here in the house for nearly one year up until the time of his passing. Right afterwards, his son (my nephew) came calling to pick up all the items, saying that they now belonged to him, he was the son and he gets everything. Since the items were given to me, while my brother was alive and the son even helped us load up the truck to move the items to my residence, he had no right to them. After several unpleasant telephone calls back and forth, I sought out some legal advice, told him the story and it was determined that unless the son could prove the items were his, he has no right to them. I then wrote a nice letter to the son and his mother advising them to back off, that they will have to contact an attorney if they want to get the items back, end of story. That was the end of it. But in the letter it specifically references 'the large collection of memorabilia'. If the taxman were to come here, I would be able to present that, along with significant documentation such as a death certificates, invoices from his cremation and burial of ashes since I paid for it all, including dates that coincide with when I started selling on ebay.

Any input on the actual audit process?
 
hey blueline;

An audit would take place anywhere it is mutually convenient. However, if the auditor needs to see first-hand evidence, then the auditor would have legally every right to come to your place of business. If that place is a residence, the owner's permission would be required. In any event, the CRA is bound to act in a reasonable manner.

fwiw, I think that you will have no problems with the CRA, based on what you would show them, should they ever come knocking at your door. So, just relax. Canada isn't a police state (..........yet!).
 
Blueline the audit will be very businesslike and courteous and you will have an opportunity to present your side of the sory. The problem for you is that in explaining your situation "ignorance of the law" would not be a defense so the following would not help you:

-- "I didn't know that these transactions were taxable"
-- "Since I didn't think it was a business I didn't keep any records"

Neither of those explanations will save you from penalties if you get audited. However at this point you are NOT being audited and so the voluntary disclosure avenue is still open to you.

That process is there just for people like you who did not realize that they owed tax and now, having realized it, want to come clean. Via that process you will be able to file a proper return and pay just the tax you owe as well as interest on it, rather than face any penalties or charges.

All of this is assuming that you do owe any tax--go talk to an accountant and find out.
 
If you're selling thousands of items on Ebay, you should be paying the taxes and I have no problem with the CRA coming after such people.

Even if it's not a "business" (which I'm skeptical it's not), it's too hard for the taxman to distinguish between someone who is selling that many items to "clean out the garage" vs. someone selling that many items as a business. Better to just tax it. Otherwise every business will be claiming to be "cleaning out the garage."
 
fuji said:
All of this is assuming that you do owe any tax--go talk to an accountant and find out.

That is most likely what I am going to do, at least so I will have peace of mind. I suppose I could even arrange to see both an accountant as well as a tax lawyer? Both would most likely offer a free half hour consultation right?

All I really want to know is - will selling personal property be subject to taxes. Do I have anything to worry about, should the taxman come calling. I would hope that could be determined within a half hour consultation. If so, fine, then I will do what I have to do to clear this up asap.

Anyways, it is not like we are talking about a huge amount of money. I added up all my sales from 2004-05 from the invoices ebay sent to me and I was under $8,500 each year. It just took a few good months to put me into the PS status during that time period. There were several months I took in less than $600.

I have actually kept record from 2007-08, since I knew all this was about to shake down. I wanted to have some numbers on hand in case there was a problem. My total from the last two years combined is less than $5,000.
 
blueline said:
That is most likely what I am going to do, at least so I will have peace of mind. I suppose I could even arrange to see both an accountant as well as a tax lawyer? Both would most likely offer a free half hour consultation right?

All I really want to know is - will selling personal property be subject to taxes. Do I have anything to worry about, should the taxman come calling. I would hope that could be determined within a half hour consultation. If so, fine, then I will do what I have to do to clear this up asap.

Anyways, it is not like we are talking about a huge amount of money. I added up all my sales from 2004-05 from the invoices ebay sent to me and I was under $8,500 each year. It just took a few good months to put me into the PS status during that time period. There were several months I took in less than $600.

I have actually kept record from 2007-08, since I knew all this was about to shake down. I wanted to have some numbers on hand in case there was a problem. My total from the last two years combined is less than $5,000.

You could probably claim that amount in 'expenses' and get away with not owing anything! But, talk to an accountant to get a better idea.

Don't worry so much!
 
shakenbake said:
You could probably claim that amount in 'expenses' and get away with not owing anything! But, talk to an accountant to get a better idea.

Don't worry so much!

That's what I said earlier. If I was operating this like a business, I would be out of business .....lol

Hence my reaction to this as being a total waste of time and effort. If they want to come after small time sellers, I will have already done my homework and go to them first. If I have to declare this as a business, and I can write off a lot of expenses, most likely it will all amount to nothing.
 
What makes this even more frustrating for me, is that I was turned down for government funding a few years back when I wanted to start a small business.

I have gone through a few job losses since 2002 and was having difficulty getting back into my engineering profession. I went to a government run agency and started the process of requesting funding so I could start up a business. After a few months of consultations, they figured I was still employable so they decided for me that running a business was not the right answer. Even though I kept bringing in lists and lists of Companies I had contacted, all with no reply, no interest, not as much as an interview. I kept going back and telling them I can't find work in my profession, I went to workshops to improve my interviewing skills and to upgrade my resumes, cover letters, went to job search work shops, all at their request and still nothing.

But they felt that I shouldn't consider starting up a small business so I gave up on it. It didn't matter that I wanted to pursue this, they had to decide for me if I was going to do it. Now what a kick in the ass it would be if CRA comes to me and says, oh you have been running a business, but you haven't been running it properly. Well if they would have helped me learn how to run a freaking business, all this nonsense wouldn't be going on. Incredible.
 
Well I just ran your 'case' by a person I know who actually works in the CRA's call centre. They said that yes technically you should have been reporting it as income. Likely however the amount that you've told us you've sold is low enough that you won't get 'red-flagged' for an audit as CRA would be looking for bigger fish.

Should you be audited however, your lack of documentation is going to screw you, as CRA could claim that it was self-employment income and then the onus would be upon you to prove otherwise. Which you likely can't since you don't have any documentation.

As for going back claiming business expenses, my contact doesn't think you'd be able to since you didn't claim them back at the time.

They also suggest calling the CRA and ask them (they would have access to more resources to answer your questions than my friend does sitting at home on their day off <grin>), you can make a "non-account specific general inquiry" and won't have to give them any id.

As for being audited, while I haven't had that 'pleasure', my father (self-employed) did and fortunately he kept excellent books as the auditor came back with a report that my father owed a ridiculous amount of money. Took going to the CRA office along with 2 accountants (Dad's accountant didn't have the right credentials or something to that effect) to get it all straightened out. Without the books my dad would have had virtually no defense.
 
Sukdeep said:
Again, I haven't read this whole thread, so I don't know if some beancounter has already mentioned this :) But, there is an exemption from taxation for the sale of "personal use property" under certain thresholds. (I think it's $1,000). (There's some other rules of limited personal property - don't ask me. It's been a long time since I was tortured in tax lectures.)

This is intended to cover yard sales, the sale of personal collectibles, etc.

This exception works if you are occassionally selling. If it is your primary source of income, sorry, but you're SOL.

Also keep in mind that they may ding you for GST. If you are selling more than $30,000 a year and shipping to Canadian addresses, you may also get separately assessed for GST.

The GST wouldn't apply to me. In the two years CRA will be looking at, 2004 and 2005, my total sales were less than $8,500 in each year and since then (at least for 2007-2008) my combined total for both years is roughly $5,000. I don't have anything available for 2006 but I know it would not be any higher than my totals for 2004-2005 because I know that I lost my Power Seller status and you have to maintain sales of $1,000/month in order to have it.

As for individual items and what they would sell for, many were in the $5-10 dollar range with the odd high end hockey card etc that would be a couple hundred dollars.

Now there was one transaction that I noticed on one of my invoices. I met a guy who was running a Hockey Fantasy Camp in 2005. I recall it was in Toronto, maybe Steelback Brewery was a sponsor IIRC. Anyways he got in touch with me, wanted to know if I could sell a package for him online, so we agreed on a commission fee and I listed it for him on ebay. It sold for $1500 but it was a one time thing, the only package I sold and the only item over or anywhere near $1,000. I would most likely have to explain that if it ever came up and that's fine.
 
one other thing I thought of, don't know if it is true or would apply, but if you all of a sudden went back and claimed you had a business in your home and your insurance and mortgage companies caught wind, could they make your life even more difficult? Pretty sure one of the questions on my mortgage was whether or not there would be a business on the premises.
 
Something I have always wondered. What happens when a person sells a vehicle, say he/she gets $10,000 for it and banks it. Also what if a person sells a house and comes away with say $150,000, just banks it, doesn't buy another home, moves into an apartment or with a SO.

Is this money taxable? If CRA were to get wind of it, check into it and wonder where $150,000 came from, what would happen?
 
blueline said:
Something I have always wondered. What happens when a person sells a vehicle, say he/she gets $10,000 for it and banks it. Also what if a person sells a house and comes away with say $150,000, just banks it, doesn't buy another home, moves into an apartment or with a SO.

Is this money taxable? If CRA were to get wind of it, check into it and wonder where $150,000 came from, what would happen?

If the items were for personal use, only, ten it is not taxable, especially the home if it was the principal residence. That was a no-brainer, as I have been involved in many home changes. :)