fuji said:To be a power seller you have to sell >1200 items per year and consisntly more than 100 per month. That's a lot of garage sales.
Fred Zed said:More on this topic here:
http://www.redflagdeals.com/forums/showthread.php?t=658676
fuji said:Well in that case it does look a lot more like you cleared out your basement, so maybe you're OK. Still check with an accountant.
squash500 said:"accountants aren't under attorney-client privilege, therefore if audited accountants have to give full disclosure to the CRA about their clients. Whereas tax lawyers like MR. D. don't have to because all conversations are covered under attorney-client privilege."
agree, I would not go the lawyer route on this one. Check with an accountantfuji said:Well in that case it does look a lot more like you cleared out your basement, so maybe you're OK. Still check with an accountant.
fuji said:The key is if you were acquiring this stuff with the intention of selling it, I think that would make it a business. That's quite different than if you just had stuff you'd forgotten about lying around in the basement and one day decided to unload it all.
JohnFK said:As another poster said, if they treat it as business income, and THAT is subject to interpretation, you can deduct reasonable expenses incurred to earn that income or make those transactions, i.e, computer, online accounts, perhaps a share of the home costs related to the room that you conduct your business, etc., etc.
fuji said:You shouldn't need an attorney until you get to the point where you're disputing something with CRA. At this point you just need to know whether or nto what you were doing is taxable, and an accountant should be able to tell you.
JohnFK said:Yes albeit a bit of a gimmick since the taxpayer still has to fully disclose their income or furnish their books and records which they are generally obliged to maintain for 6 years from the end of the taxation year in question.
If not, they can use the info from EBay and assess accordingly, even if it is an estimate.
fuji said:Any CA or even CGA should be able to give you advice on this. It's just that they'll be a lot cheaper than a tax lawyer and at this point you simply need to understand whether the transactions are taxable or not.