Looking for tax advice ..............

shakenbake said:
If the items were for personal use, only, ten it is not taxable, especially the home if it was the principal residence. That was a no-brainer, as I have been involved in many home changes.

I gotta put the freaking hockey cards away and get out more. ;)
 
Fred Zed said:
What happens in practice is that the tax lawyer states your tax problem
to CRA in general terms without revealing your identity. They
may then negotiate favorable terms on your behalf. So there is some
value to consulting a lawyer when the tax issue is serious. You still
have to submit accurate infos to CRA of course. In the case of blueline
I don't think the case is serious enough for him to consult a lawyer.


Wouldn't a voluntary disclosure more then likely lead to an audit?
 
girlyboy said:
Wouldn't a voluntary disclosure more then likely lead to an audit?

No, although it could. In practice people making voluntary disclosures tend to be so afraid of an audit that they really do come clean. CRA knows this and so audits only a few of them. It is though a good idea to make sure your voluntary disclosure really is full and honest so that if you do get audited you have absolutely nothing to fear.

Also almost by definition those making voluntry disclosures are people who are trying to be good citizens and pay their taxes, and who until now haven't done that only due to reasons of ignorance, error, or financial hardship.

So in a way targetting the voluntary disclosure filers is targetting the wrong people--the auditors would rather go after the guys who think they're going to get away with it.
 
blueline said:
Something I have always wondered. What happens when a person sells a vehicle, say he/she gets $10,000 for it and banks it. Also what if a person sells a house and comes away with say $150,000, just banks it, doesn't buy another home, moves into an apartment or with a SO.

Is this money taxable? If CRA were to get wind of it, check into it and wonder where $150,000 came from, what would happen?

I think I already answered the vehicle question earlier.

As to the house thing there is a capital gains exemption for your primary residence so unless you flip and move as often as you sold hockey cards ... no worries and nothing to declare.

P.S. I believe there is a pamphlet available on the CRA website called, What You Should Know About Audits, Blueline, in response to your earlier curiousity.
 
jeeperz said:
P.S. I believe there is a pamphlet available on the CRA website called, What You Should Know About Audits, Blueline, in response to your earlier curiousity.

Got it - thanks. It is actually a topic right on the CRA website for anyone to access and to read. (maybe that's what you meant, but thanks again).
 
shakenbake said:
If the items were for personal use, only, ten it is not taxable, especially the home if it was the principal residence. That was a no-brainer, as I have been involved in many home changes. :)

You have it wrong. Capital gains on personal use property (absent a specific exemption such as that for principal residence) are taxable. Capital losses on same are deemed nil.

To the OP - this is really not the right forum to ask such tax questions. For a freebie, have you considered calling into the tax show on BNN? You should ask tax advisors for this type of stuff, even if you pay for an hour for say $250-$300.
 
scrooge said:
You have it wrong. Capital gains on personal use property (absent a specific exemption such as that for principal residence) are taxable. Capital losses on same are deemed nil.

To the OP - this is really not the right forum to ask such tax questions. For a freebie, have you considered calling into the tax show on BNN? You should ask tax advisors for this type of stuff, even if you pay for an hour for say $250-$300.

You are probably right, in view of T4037-07. However, the lifetime capital gains exemption is so high (upto $375,000), and the ACB of $1000 per item, if I read it correctly, puts the OP in possibly non-taxable waters.
 
Blueline,
If what is in this thread is basically true,I don't understand what you are worried about?
It sounds like you were an eBay member as long as I was.I think I joined about 10 years ago.
There was no eBay.ca then!
I am STILL a member of eBay.com,so you should be too!
Didn't someone say that only Power Sellers from eBay.ca are being looked into?
 
JohnFK said:
As of March 19th, 2007, the amount of the lifetime capital gains exemption rose to $750,000 from $500,000 but it only applies to certain small business shares and farm and fishing property.

It does not apply to personal-use property or listed personal property.

If you change a property from personal use to income-earning use, you are normally deemed to have sold it at its fair market value, requiring you to recognize for tax purposes any accrued capital gain.

In the case of property sold for resale as an adventure or concern in the nature of trade, that property would be considered inventory and subject to no capital gains and the profit would be taxable as ordinary or business income.

Sorry, but that was the number in the tax form that I cited T4037-07, page 20.

As for personal property, are you saying that a capital gain is not taxableÉ


Under proposed changes, the capital gains deduction limit
will be increased to $375,000 on capital gains arising from
dispositions of qualified property after March 18, 2007. For
more information, see “Claiming a capital gains deduction”
​

on page 12."`

Also, from Page 19, an example of personal property sale says,

"Jane sold the following personal-use properties in 2007.

Property​

sold
Proceeds
of
disposition
Adjusted
cost
base
Outlays
and
expenses
​


China cabinet $ 900 $ 500 $ 0
Boat $ 1,200 $ 850 $ 50
Personal
computer
$ 1,500
$ 3,200
$ 30
​


Jane calculates the capital gain or loss for each transaction
as follows:
​


Calculation of capital​

gain (or loss)
China
cabinet
($)
Boat
($)
Personal
computer
($)
​


Proceeds of disposition
(
​
greater of selling price
and $1,000)
1,000
1,200
1,500

​


Minus​
:
ACB (
greater of cost
and $1,000)
plus outlays
and expenses –
1,000
– 1,050
– 3,230
Capital gain (loss) = 0 = 150 = (1,730)

​


China cabinet​
– For the proceeds of disposition and the
ACB, Jane uses $1,000, as both were less than that amount.
As a result, there is no capital gain or loss for this
transaction and Jane
does not have to report it on
Schedule 3.

​


Boat​
– Because the cost of the boat is less than $1,000, the
ACB is considered to be $1,000. Jane reports $150 as a
capital gain.

​


Personal computer​
– Jane’s capital loss is not deductible.
She also cannot use the loss to decrease any other capital

​

gains realized in the year."
 
shakenbake said:
Sorry, but that was the number in the tax form that I cited T4037-07, page 20.

As for personal property, are you saying that a capital gain is not taxableÉ


Under proposed changes, the capital gains deduction limit
will be increased to $375,000 on capital gains arising from
dispositions of qualified property after March 18, 2007. For
more information, see “Claiming a capital gains deduction”
​

on page 12.```

Also, from Page 19, an example of personal property sale says,

``Jane sold the following personal-use properties in 2007.

Property​

sold
Proceeds
of
disposition
Adjusted
cost
base
Outlays
and
expenses
​


China cabinet $ 900 $ 500 $ 0
Boat $ 1,200 $ 850 $ 50
Personal
computer
$ 1,500
$ 3,200
$ 30
​


Jane calculates the capital gain or loss for each transaction
as follows:
​


Calculation of capital​

gain (or loss)
China
cabinet
($)
Boat
($)
Personal
computer
($)
​


Proceeds of disposition
(
​
greater of selling price
and $1,000)
1,000
1,200
1,500

​


Minus​
:
ACB (
greater of cost
and $1,000)
plus outlays
and expenses –
1,000
– 1,050
– 3,230
Capital gain (loss) = 0 = 150 = (1,730)

​


China cabinet​
– For the proceeds of disposition and the
ACB, Jane uses $1,000, as both were less than that amount.
As a result, there is no capital gain or loss for this
transaction and Jane
does not have to report it on
Schedule 3.

​


Boat​
– Because the cost of the boat is less than $1,000, the
ACB is considered to be $1,000. Jane reports $150 as a
capital gain.

​


Personal computer​
– Jane’s capital loss is not deductible.
She also cannot use the loss to decrease any other capital

​

gains realized in the year.``


I do not see anything on any of pages 12, 19 and 20 which contradicts anything JohnFK or I said. The bottom line is that, absent a specific rule, capital gains are taxable on personal use property (i.e., CRA's boat example) while capital losses on same are deemed nil (i.e., CRA's computer example). The only type of personal use property which provide for even some relief of capital losses is "listed personal property" - such losses can be offset against only capital gains from LPP.

In the case of a capital gain, the capital gains exemption is loooooooooooong gone for "general" properties (properties other than small business corp shares and qualified farm property). That repeal has been effective for over ten years now.

I agree with you, though, that because of the $1,000 rule for personal use property, the items are probably not taxable to the OP. However, that is assuming that such items were capital property to him to begin with.
 
TheShadow said:
Blueline,
If what is in this thread is basically true,I don't understand what you are worried about?
It sounds like you were an eBay member as long as I was.I think I joined about 10 years ago.
There was no eBay.ca then!
I am STILL a member of eBay.com,so you should be too!
Didn't someone say that only Power Sellers from eBay.ca are being looked into?

Hey Shadow - yes I also started on ebay.com and I did reach Power Seller status for a short time during 2004-2005, which are the years CRA is investigating now. As I stated earlier and as I am sure you will attest to, it doesn't take a lot of effort to reach the $1000/month minimum requirement for three consecutive months. If one has a lot of high end collectibles, it is very easy to do.

But Power Sellers from Canada are being investigated, even if you registered on ebay.com or not. My info will be (or already has been sent) to CRA and I was informend of this via email from ebay.ca. If you did not receive the email, then you are not on their list of Power Sellers from 2004-2005.

Anyways, I have taked to a few people and as it sits right now, I am not going to worry about it. It can very easily be determined that I had been selling personal items from the reports ebay has sent to me and to CRA. If by chance I do get audited, I will be able to explain everything.

Thanks everyone for your input, links, suggestions, etc.
 
blueline said:
But Power Sellers from Canada are being investigated, even if you registered on ebay.com or not.

Pretty certain only eBay.ca was mentioned in this thread,so I wasn't aware it was all Canadiens,not just .ca members.


If you did not receive the email, then you are not on their list of Power Sellers from 2004-2005.

Actually,whenever they bugged me to become a Power Seller,I deleted the email,as they do ask you first.You are not automatically made a PS because of sales.Since I was only selling off my collection,and it wasn't a business for me,there was no point in joining.

See above.
TheShadow
 
scrooge said:
I do not see anything on any of pages 12, 19 and 20 which contradicts anything JohnFK or I said. The bottom line is that, absent a specific rule, capital gains are taxable on personal use property (i.e., CRA's boat example) while capital losses on same are deemed nil (i.e., CRA's computer example). The only type of personal use property which provide for even some relief of capital losses is "listed personal property" - such losses can be offset against only capital gains from LPP.

In the case of a capital gain, the capital gains exemption is loooooooooooong gone for "general" properties (properties other than small business corp shares and qualified farm property). That repeal has been effective for over ten years now.

I agree with you, though, that because of the $1,000 rule for personal use property, the items are probably not taxable to the OP. However, that is assuming that such items were capital property to him to begin with.

We are all saying the same thing. :) It's just that we are saying it a bit differently.