Lockdown - Is there Death Rate Modelling available yet?

Some interesting info there Valcazar.

On the one hand, people who lose their jobs are much more likely to die than had they not lost their jobs.

But for the whole population, there is less death due to factors like less traffic, less pollution, and less money to blow on unhealthy vices.

This is relevant for the net effect on the population size, but I think this is just a bonus side effect, and it is still possible to independently consider the deaths that are the result of the job losses.
We can shut down and save lives in this manner without a virus.

This virus is killing people.
It wouldn`t make sense to say, yeah but now there is less traffic and pollution, less CO2, less drain on resources, more wealth to inherit, etc...

The virus has killed X number of people.
The shutdown has killed Y number of people.

The issue here is how do we quantify Y.

You see my thoughts - just imagine how complex the modelling would need to be to calculate death rates for lockdown activities. It's mind boggling to think about and yet I'm absolutely certain a bunch of really smart people with a whole bunch of compute power are doing it right now for all major governments, hopefully all governments, around the world.
 
For those doing so much more research and sharing in this forum, thank you.

I was watching a movie last night again, the Big Short. In the movie Brad Pitt's character makes a troubling statement:

“Every 1 percent unemployment goes up, 40,000 people die. Did you know that?”


Curious if there was any reality to this or just hollywood attempt to drive home a point, I did a bit of Google searching and found this article from just a few days ago.

https://nypost.com/2020/04/20/explaining-the-link-between-unemployment-deaths-amid-coronavirus/


According to this article, the real academic study number is 37,000 deaths per percent just in the U.S. based on the studies performed in the 1980's.


The math then shows (for example) a 15% increase in unemployment in the U.S. would result in 555,000 deaths based on this modelling from years ago.
*Qualifier - this math is from 50 years ago and we should all be aware of this.

This perspective however does demonstrates a lot of the battle we see in the threads here - the lockdown is saving deaths from COVID-19 and I fully agree with the steps taken - but what is the data and modelling showing for deaths we are going to experience elsewhere from the actions we have taken? There is always a trade off in these difficult situations and I wanted to bring what little I have found so far to a thread for discussion.


Has anyone found more current/recent modelling related to the actions the world is taking for fight against COVID-19 and can share links in this thread perhaps? Please share if you do.

Take care everyone.

It has been know for a long time that eventually we all die, as we are only mortal men. For any younger generation to show apathy for the pursuit of longevity for those older than them is an abomination. What the fuck is going, the calculated kneecapping of elders who will die in their own time.
 
...It's not perhaps how many people have died so much as 'how' they died, compared to being an accident, cancer, etc. It's all about perspective I suppose.

Are you saying cancer is a pleasant way to die versus that of C19...? Keep in mind the vast majority that have died from C19 world wide have been the elderly with pre-existing medical conditions, the virus merely accelerated their finals days. When you are 95, does it really matter if you live to be 96...I don't think it does when you are in poor health. You also need to keep in mind many that tested positive for C19 report the mildest of symptoms...

To me, a car accident is similar to catching C19 as the "incident" was caused by someone else's action.
 
Without reading the original source information myself, I can only speculate there are thresholds and the 37,000 per 1 percent went up to a XX percent level and then increased there above.

It probably grows exponentially ("snowballing effect").

========================================================================================

The antibodies in some/many people could be because they caught a mild or very mild dose of the virus and their immune system was able to quickly and completely overcome the disease.
 
Percentage wise, yes.

2,300+ Canadians and 200,000 people world wide have died already because someone coughed near them. It's not perhaps how many people have died so much as 'how' they died, compared to being an accident, cancer, etc. It's all about perspective I suppose.

Latest results from Florida suggest that for every 10k infected and tested there are 160k with antibodies. In NY State the latest estimate is(if I heard correctly) at 15% of the population with the covid19 antibodies. These are massive infection numbers that severely decrease the mortality statistics. I'm not being cavalier about the deaths. I'm just saying that the mortality rates are over estimated by a huge amount. Doug Ford should really direct the Ministry of Health to start wholesale tests for antibodies so we can put the end to the guessing games and the endless speculations.
 
Are you saying cancer is a pleasant way to die versus that of C19...? Keep in mind the vast majority that have died from C19 world wide have been the elderly with pre-existing medical conditions, the virus merely accelerated their finals days. When you are 95, does it really matter if you live to be 96...I don't think it does when you are in poor health. You also need to keep in mind many that tested positive for C19 report the mildest of symptoms...

To me, a car accident is similar to catching C19 as the "incident" was caused by someone else's action.

Ah, I apologize bebe, I choose poorly in my wording.

We have come to accept the reality of possibly dying of cancer (my mother had it and runs in my family for generations), car accident (all had our close calls we could share) and so on. The idea that the person simply coughing near us could lead to our eventual death is a new form of terror we are all dealing with.

The isolation requirements of those in hospital before they pass is also particularly jarring. I read the story about a father who stayed on his cell phone with his wife and children for 30 hours before he passed - knowing he was critical condition in a hospital and the family had absolutely no opportunity to say their good-byes in person - can bring tears to your eyes just thinking about it.

Just some thoughts on these new and difficult times we all are living through.

Take care.
 
Latest results from Florida suggest that for every 10k infected and tested there are 160k with antibodies. In NY State the latest estimate is(if I heard correctly) at 15% of the population with the covid19 antibodies. These are massive infection numbers that severely decrease the mortality statistics. I'm not being cavalier about the deaths. I'm just saying that the mortality rates are over estimated by a huge amount. Doug Ford should really direct the Ministry of Health to start wholesale tests for antibodies so we can put the end to the guessing games and the endless speculations.

If the suggested 15% of New York's population has the anti-bodies now is eventually proven correct, that's 2.9 million infected of their 19.5 million population. Their current death tally of 15,740 as of today would work out to be a death rate of those infected of 0.5%.

But yes we are all speculating and will be for months to come (or even longer) until at least anti-bodies testing has done wide spread per region/country to better understand what really has been happening all around us.
 
, that's 2.9 million infected of their 19.5 million population.
I still think we need to assess the level of infection say on a scale of 1 (extremely mild) to 10 (super massive). For example, you or I might have been very mildly infected because of a very brief exposure to the virus (say you touched a doorknob). Our immune system quickly and efficiently got rid of the virus. Hence, we now have antibodies.
 
I still think we need to assess the level of infection say on a scale of 1 (extremely mild) to 10 (super massive). For example, you or I might have been very mildly infected because of a very brief exposure to the virus (say you touched a doorknob). Our immune system quickly and efficiently got rid of the virus. Hence, we now have antibodies.

Agreed - again lots of good input in this thread.

I realize this thread will likely taper off soon as there are so many threads in motion right now. I do hope someday someone here finds some interesting modelling about 'what we have done to our society' performing the lockdowns in so many countries as I feel it will be both conversation worthy and also something we will need to prepare for as it will give us insight to what our 'new normal' as a society will look like.
 
The New York numbers were ~21% with antibodies for the city, ~14% for the state. (note: We don't have details on the methodology, so I don't know if there are any problems there. )

That works out to about 2.7 million infected.

At the time this came out (2 days ago) there were basically 15,500 deaths in the state. That would put an IFR of about 0.57%
(Remember that deaths are a lagging indicator so this crude calculation isn't necessarily great.)

That's better than some earlier numbers. If we use 14.75 million as the estimated Ontario population (not perfect) then we would get a little over 84,000 dead from COVID-19 if we just gave it to everyone.

However, we don't know how solid those New York numbers are. We also know there is evidence from just about everywhere that COVID-19 deaths are being undercounted, so that IFR may be higher.
It is also worth remembering that IFR isn't some kind of magic constant, but will respond to treatments available, resource allocation, and other factors.

Still, we are starting to see numbers from a bunch of places, which can allow for more serious work on deciding how to proceed.
 
The New York numbers were ~21% with antibodies for the city, ~14% for the state. (note: We don't have details on the methodology, so I don't know if there are any problems there. )

That works out to about 2.7 million infected.

At the time this came out (2 days ago) there were basically 15,500 deaths in the state. That would put an IFR of about 0.57%
(Remember that deaths are a lagging indicator so this crude calculation isn't necessarily great.)

That's better than some earlier numbers. If we use 14.75 million as the estimated Ontario population (not perfect) then we would get a little over 84,000 dead from COVID-19 if we just gave it to everyone.

However, we don't know how solid those New York numbers are. We also know there is evidence from just about everywhere that COVID-19 deaths are being undercounted, so that IFR may be higher.
It is also worth remembering that IFR isn't some kind of magic constant, but will respond to treatments available, resource allocation, and other factors.

Still, we are starting to see numbers from a bunch of places, which can allow for more serious work on deciding how to proceed.

This is a very important point that a lot of people seem to either not understand or trying to undermine. I've said it numerous times the current death rates aka IFR (Instant case fatality rate) will move up and will move down on the tail end of the fight in the Coronavirus it's an educated guess that it will come down.

The report on antibodies that had tested people from New York City as well as the state is based on 3000 tests, unfortunately some people think that 2.7 Mln people from the state of New York showed they had antibodies which is not true. The antibodies test is based on 3000 people sample tested and 21% in New York city as well 14% in the state of New York showing they had the antibodies. I couldn't come across the demographics of the sample if anyone has a link to it please post it as that is very important to the sample and the outcome.
That sample size is a far lower number than something that could be useful, there needs to be a larger sample size and the demographics of testing need to be wide.

In comparison the state of New York has tested over 775 000 people for the Coronavirus with 37% testing positive.
 
The virus has killed X number of people.
The shutdown has killed Y number of people.

The issue here is how do we quantify Y.

The problem is that kind of quantification is extremely difficult.
It's also rarely a linear relationship (which is why the Big Short stat immediately struck me as probably wrong).

At best you will get some models with some broad ranges because of the uncertainty involved. If the ranges are very separate, maybe you have a clean answer. If they overlap a lot (which I suspect they do) you end up in the range of difficult judgment calls.
 
The problem is that kind of quantification is extremely difficult.
It's also rarely a linear relationship (which is why the Big Short stat immediately struck me as probably wrong).

At best you will get some models with some broad ranges because of the uncertainty involved. If the ranges are very separate, maybe you have a clean answer. If they overlap a lot (which I suspect they do) you end up in the range of difficult judgment calls.

That's why I'm not celebrating, yet. The latest from Florida is that the mortality rate is at .01%
 
The death rate or IFR at the moment in Florida is 3.4%
1055 deaths 30 839 confirmed cases.

Not if you include the people with the antibodies into the equation. GRANTED, that number is far from tight. Confirmed cases is not the same as the level of exposure. The LA County is seeing similar disparity.
 
I've said it numerous times the current death rates aka IFR (Instant case fatality rate) will move up and will move down on the tail end of the fight in the Coronavirus it's an educated guess that it will come down.

Just to clarify the acronyms. (These acronyms aren't as much fun as the ones in your sig, unfortunately. :) )

IFR = Infection fatality rate
CFR = Case fatality rate

They aren't the same (this is something that the video guy smallcock keeps spamming actually has right and does a decent job with).

CFR is the proportion of deaths among the total number of people diagnosed with the disease.
IFR is the proportion of deaths among the total number of people infected with the disease.

What that means is that IFR includes all those people who were asymptomatic and never knew they had the disease because it was so mild. That means IFR is always lower than CFR.
Say 1,000 people are infected, but only 300 of them are sick enough that they ever get diagnosed. The other 600 think they have a mild cold or never get symptoms.
Then 30 of the diagnosed people die from the disease.

That means that the CFR is 30 people out of 300 cases or 10%
However, when the total number infected is later found out (say by antibody testing), the IFR will be 30 people out of 1000 cases or 3%.
(Yes, this would be an absolutely fucking horrible disease if it had rates like this.)

One thing to keep in mind is that when people talk about how this is "just like the flu" they might be screwing up which numbers they are referring to.
Take https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2016-2017.html. They estimate 29 million cases and 38,000 influenza-associated deaths. That's an IFR of 0.13% (although the confidence interval could make it as low as 0.07%).

The report on antibodies that had tested people from New York City as well as the state is based on 3000 tests, unfortunately some people think that 2.7 Mln people from the state of New York showed they had antibodies which is not true. The antibodies test is based on 3000 people sample tested and 21% in New York city as well 14% in the state of New York showing they had the antibodies. I couldn't come across the demographics of the sample if anyone has a link to it please post it as that is very important to the sample and the outcome.

I don't think the details are out yet on the specifics of the sample. It does seem to be a better random sample than the ones gathered in California, though.

In comparison the state of New York has tested over 775 000 people for the Coronavirus with 37% testing positive.

Yes, but those were tests of people who were suspected of having the disease. You would expect higher numbers there.
 
Not if you include the people with the antibodies into the equation. GRANTED, that number is far from tight. Confirmed cases is not the same as the level of exposure. The LA County is seeing similar disparity.

Do you have a link for the people in Florida being tested for antibodies?